Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on July 27, 2010, 04:59:58 PM
-
i dont realy understand how musical keys work,
for example would a g in the key of d, be exactly the same , as a g in the key of f ???
and are all accidental notes the same for each key???
im very miffed!
hope one of you clever folks on here will be able to help!?!
-
There are 12 notes available:
C, C#, D, D#, E, F, F#, G, G#, A, A# and B
They are all a semitone apart.
Each major key follows the same intervals of:
tone, tone, semitone, tone, tone, tone, semitone
So, for instance C has:
C, C#, D, D#, E, F, F#, G, G#, A, A# B
G has:
G, G#, A, A# B, C, C#, D, D#, E, F, F#
etc etc
Hope this help, easier to explain with a non-computer keyboard ;D
-
thanks lester, so would they actualy sound the same?, ie d in the key of a and d in the key of d? would you be able to hear a difference in sound between the two?
-
Well if, say, you played your box mostly 'on the row' and your instrument wasn't properly in tune with itself, then that might be a reason why a G in one scale (i.e. say, on the inner row) wouldn't sound the same as the G note on a different scale (i.e. on the outer row)!
-
On a melodeon the 'D' on the G row and the 'D' on the D row are the same note. The same principle applies to piano and AFAIR probably started there.
But because other instruments (eg brass) are tuned for 'beauty' (eg brass) or 'to get any note at all' (eg bagpipes) they might not be the same frequencies there. Another difference might be mouthorgan where the note bends differently 'coming down'. It is all still perfectly valid music and we are to some extent the odd ones out.
Lester's tone/semitone explanation of the diatonic scales seems just right. So to play in say Eb "you just start on Eb" (perhaps not conveniently on our instrument though)! And Eb's 7th note 'D' .. will be found either on D or G row as above.
-
many thanks for your replys it would have probaly helped if i told you a little more info....
im looking at converting a box from C/F to D/G the box has a row of accidentals.
do the accidentals have to be different to fit the key of the keys that im changing it to?
i.e are the accidentals for c /f different to d/g?
sorry if my first question was vague!
-
thanks lester, so would they actualy sound the same?, ie d in the key of a and d in the key of d? would you be able to hear a difference in sound between the two?
Just jumping in here (sorry Lester....)
The basic answer is 'yes' they would sound the same. That's why, on a piano keyboard, you have one key for each note, and you can use all those notes available - the 12 that Lester originally mentioned, together with their equivalents in higher and lower octaves - to play a tune in any key you like. The note D is always the same D regardless of whether you are playing in the key of C, G, A, F, etc. This holds true for any instrument where the tuning is 'fixed' and not easily adjustable, e.g a piano, organ, concertina, accordion, and of course a melodeon. Although these instruments can be, and are, tuned from time to time, once that has been done, the tuning is fixed and not alterable by the player whilst playing.
The rather more complex answer is 'no' they might not necessarily sound the same. A singer, or a violinist or other non-fretted string instrument has the capacity to finely and minutely adjust the pitch of every note. Part of the skill of playing such an instrument or singing, is learning how to subconsciously pitch the note you want. But a highly trained and expert player/singer will not play/sing notes of the same letter name, at the same pitch, in different keys. Why?
Here's just one example:
Going back to Lester's pattern of notes in a major scale:
tone, tone, semitone, tone, tone, tone, semitone
In a C-major scale the notes will be
C, D, E, F G, A, B, and top C
The note B is the seventh, penultimate note of the scale. This seventh note is a semitone below the upper keynote C and it is that penultimate semitone interval which gives the scale tremendous 'pulling power' at that point. If you play a scale to an audience but pause dramatically before playing the final note, everyone listening will be silently begging for you to finish the scale, to release the tension. It's to do with the psychology of how we perceive music that it works like that.
However in the key of A major, the notes of the scale are
A, B, C#, D, E, F#, G#, and top A.
This time it is the G# which creates the tension ready to be released. The note B, which did the same job in the scale of C, is now only the second note in the scale of A major, so it doesn't have the same tensional effect.
Now here's the point: Singers and violinists subconsciously seek to increase that tensional effect of the seventh note of the scale, by making that seventh note fractionally sharp, because it sounds better that way!. So they would sing/play the note B in the scale of C major sharper than the note B in the scale of A major, because it sounds better that way.
Fixed-pitch instruments cannot do this, and the way in which the notes are tuned is a compromise about having it tuned so that it will sound OK (but not as good as ultimately possible) in all keys. Generally, these days, this is achieved by making the semitone step between every note an equal distance in pitch - this is known as Equal Temperament tuning. But singers and violinists can, and do, infinitely adjust the pitch of their notes, according to the scale they are in at the time, and is an example of a Just or True Temperament.
There are other reasons why Equal Temperament has developed over the last 300 years or so, to do with the harmony of different chords, but I think that is best left for another day (and another writer!).
Hope all this has (a) answered your question and (b) not confused you more than you were to begin with!
-
Another hapless victim drawn into this thread :|glug
C/F 'accidentals' are F#(=Gb) /Ab and C#(=Db) /Eb
D/G 'accidentals' are Ab/Bb and Eb/F
So you need to sharpen them as per the other reeds
[edit] er, spiders also have eight legs, Steve
-
another hapless victim drawn into this thread :|glug
I know - it's like an octopus. ;)
-
so could i make a c/f box into d/g by using the original reeds???
-
sorry if my first question was vague!
Don't worry, your second is even vaguer!
Rather than having mel.net posters trying to write explanations of basic music theory in posts here, you'd do better to Google "basic music theory". You'll find many (many!) pages where it's all been written down already. Or your local library, or music shop, will have books on the subject. We've mostly all learned some music theory as a basic part of learning to play an instrument. You should be asking yourself, though, whether, with your present level of knowledge, you're ready to undertake the project you describe.
-
many thanks for your replys it would have probaly helped if i told you a little more info....
im looking at converting a box from C/F to D/G the box has a row of accidentals.
do the accidentals have to be different to fit the key of the keys that im changing it to?
i.e are the accidentals for c /f different to d/g?
sorry if my first question was vague!
Yes - the actual notes of the accidentals row will need to be different on a D/G compared with a C/F box. The best guide is to look at the keyboard layouts, here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/CFclub30.gif
and
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DGclub30.gif
-
so could i make a c/f box into d/g by using the original reeds???
No.
There are two reeds on each reed plate, one for the push and one for the pull. The push-pull patterns of the scale do not correspond between C/F and D/G. For example on a D/G box, to play the G-major scale on the G-row with 3rd button start, the reed plates would be [G push, A pull] [B push, C pull] [D push, E pull], etc....... But on a C/F box the notes [G, A], [B, C] [D, E], etc. are not available on the same reed plates, so it would not be a case of just swapping the reed plates into a new position to make the conversion. If you look at the layouts I posted links to earlier, you should be able to see why.
-
[edit] er, spiders also have eight legs, Steve
I know - I'm just automatically revealing my interest in marine biology..... ;)
-
im just trying to work out the cheapest way of doing it!!!!
-
There isn't one. lol.
-
There isn't one. lol.
< Pedantry On>
Sorry Ress but there will be a "cheapest way of doing it" it may well be expensive but still cheaper than even more expensive methods
<Pedantry Off>
-
oh dear... lol im sure it will all work out right in the end :o
-
There isn't one. lol.
< Pedantry On>
Sorry Ress but there will be a "cheapest way of doing it" it may well be expensive but still cheaper than even more expensive methods
<Pedantry Off>
nag, nag, nag
-
Theo and Mike Rowbotham both do these ocnversions, particularly on Club models. I believe the reeds are moved around to minimise the retuning required. I would imagine this means the least change of pitch per reed, rather than the least number of reeds to tune, as it is difficult to maintain the tone and performance of a reed if it is tuned too far from its original pitch. I believe you need to sit down with the layouts for the start and finish configurations to work this out with no moe than a semitone shift on any reed - unless one of the gurus is willing to assist in the plan! It may be neccessary to introduce a couple of new reeds, but I'm sure one of the guys will have some available. There are always a few donor boxes in store which are beyond salvage.
Good luck,
Rob.
-
Yes, Rob has the essence of it. Move the reeds to minimise pitch changes of individual reeds. For a Liliput or any Club box there is not really a magic formula as to what goes where because not everyone want the same note layout for the half row or the first 2 or 3 buttons on the main rows, and there are occasional differences of the original note layout too. In general it is better to go for a 4th button start. There is slightly less retuning required when going from B♭/E♭ to D/G than from C/F to D/G, just because of the way the pairs of notes are on each button. Its a lengthy task and has to be approached with care. If you feel like trying to do it yourself expect to do two or three boxes before you get it right! I still have one badly converted Club that I keep as a reminder of my own fallibility.