Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on July 28, 2010, 02:29:30 PM
-
The more I like a tune the harder it is to play.
Explain?
-
Well it might mean you are musical character and prefer complicated tunes (:)
-
Well it might mean you are musical character and prefer complicated tunes (:)
champagne outlook with orange juice talent ;)
-
Is the inverse of your statement also true? Therefore ladytemps likes difficult tunes.
If you dislike a tune, do you find it easy? :o
-
Is the inverse of your statement also true? Therefore ladytemps likes difficult tunes.
If you dislike a tune, do you find it easy? :o
As a listener I like to hear complicated tunes...but as a player i'd prefer to like simple tunes so I could play what I liked.
Plus easy tunes get over-played. ;)
-
champagne outlook with orange juice talent ;)
Now that, I like. Quote of the Week, easily.
John (:)
-
Aye it is! :D
-
The more I like a tune the harder it is to play.
Explain?
Sounds like a normal occurrence of Sod's Law :(
Richard
-
The more I like a tune the harder it is to play.
Explain?
But do you not find that the increased desire balances out the extra difficulty and you end up learning it anyway?
-
The more I like a tune the harder it is to play.
Explain?
You know it better to listen to, so you are more critical as to what it should sound like. You are just setting the bar higher, which of course is a good thing.
G
-
But the real challenge to your musicianship is to take a simple tune and play it so well that it captures the attention of your audience
-
I have the same experience! I find that when I learn a new tune that I really like I learn the bits I find easiest (which often these days means having a familiar pattern) first and then work hard on the bits that don't come so easily. Then, lo and behold, when I think that I have 'got it', the parts that I first thought easy to learn are the parts I mess up and the parts I worked hard on stay with me. I suppose there is something obvious about this but it took a bit of time for the penny to drop (....orange juice talent!).
Love that saying by the way ;D
-
i thought the dorset four hand reel was boring untill i heard a recording of one of the rice brothers playing it on the gob iron!
-
However, the harder it is to play the easier it is to remember it off by heart due to the countless hours spent practising it, so worth the effort?
Well at least that is my experience. What about you LdT?
-
The worse critic of a tune and your own playing is always yourself! .... the tune always sounds better to those listening usually and equally have you noticed your own box when played by someone else always sounds better than you think it does!.... (and its not the better playing .... getting distance from the instrument ..shows its full glory!)
DTN
-
armed ( or should it be eared?) with two of the latest (NHS) digital hearing aids I can now not only turn my box up or down but can vary the volume between bass and treble! For some strange reason it also sounds as Derek points out as if its furthur away. Presumably it just sounds like itself to the punters.
Just to clarify the reason for two hearing aids, I am not profoundly deaf, just 'normal' loss of high frequencies as part of the aging process. However the audiologist said do you want one or two. I replied that one would be adeqate & she said why not have two you use a pair of specs not a monacle & also you will get it in stereo! For anybody in need of a bit of a hearing boost I would definately recommend going for a matching pair!
george
-
Years ago, playing guitar in folk clubs, I longed to play open tuning picked accompaniaments, but couldn't get it. I played finger-picked ragtime, etc and the guy who played the open tunings wanted to do that! sod's law again.
The ceilidh band picked a new tune which I dislike intensely, too simple, too repetitive - but the dancers love it! I guess it'll grow on me.
Rob.
-
The ceilidh band picked a new tune which I dislike intensely, too simple, too repetitive - but the dancers love it! I guess it'll grow on me.
Rob.
And the tune is?
-
The ceilidh band picked a new tune which I dislike intensely, too simple, too repetitive - but the dancers love it! I guess it'll grow on me.
Rob.
Perfect opportunity for some improv/embellishment/variations. (:)
-
What Rot! ;D
-
Maybe its just boredom for me....I'm having trouble seeing much improvement. Its like I've hit a talent wall.
Might try and make practice more interesting try playing down squeeky/dusty end of the keyboard and maybe try standing up when I play.
-
And the tune is?
"Four Seasons" - damn its a 48 bar, so i never had a chance of vetoing it!
Rob.
-
And the tune is?
"Four Seasons" - damn its a 48 bar, so i never had a chance of vetoing it!
Rob.
Oh........
The Four Seasons is one of my favourite tunes of all. It is so very hypnotic in the way it goes round and round (just like the seasons I guess).
Play it quietly at first, and not too lumpily, and let it build and build. There is a lot of scope for variations in it too. If you get a chance to hear Brian Peters play it on his CD "Beast in the Box", you'll see what I mean.
One notable time I played this was at Barry Callaghan's wake-session after his funeral. There must have been 30 of us in the room all different instruments, but including quite a lot of melodeons. I remember being sat next to Pete Coe and being completely bowled over by the tune and Pete's playing of it. We must have played the tune continuously for at least ten minutes and we all just went into a trance. Barry would have been proud of us, I'm sure.
-
Thanks for the PM, Steve. I'm glad you're happily one of the majority - all our band like the tune - but even played that well, I JUST DON'T LIKE IT! On the plus side, I always love watching the dancers enjoying themselves, so I can live with it.
Rob.
-
Oh........
The Four Seasons is one of my favourite tunes of all. It is so very hypnotic in the way it goes round and round (just like the seasons I guess).
Steve - is this the one?
http://www.folktunefinder.com/tune/159070/
Your description of it makes it sound very worth learning ....
-
Steve - is this the one?
http://www.folktunefinder.com/tune/159070/
Your description of it makes it sound very worth learning ....
Yes, it's similar, but a bit garbled, I think. Not quite how it's generally played (around here anyway).
I've started a new thread in the 'Tunes' section here: The Four Seasons (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4659.msg59022.html#msg59022)
I love the tune, although sorry that Rob and maybe others don't like it, but never mind. We all have our preferences and it would be a boring old world if we all liked the same thing! (:)
-
Now that's just why I didn't name the tune! I didn't want to offend anyone's sensibilities, nor arouse such interest that I'll be hearing it everywhere I go!
Rob.
-
Steve - thanks.
Rob - sorry! (Still ... I haven't heard it yet ... >:E)
-
Now that's just why I didn't name the tune! I didn't want to offend anyone's sensibilities, nor arouse such interest that I'll be hearing it everywhere I go!
Rob.
Yep! .. sounds like a load of 'Old Bowlocks' to me! >:E