Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on July 28, 2010, 09:31:28 PM
-
EDIT: Sorry, the layout I originally posted was incorrect (G# where G should be). I have now posted what should be the correct version (but it is getting late to be hurrying).
EDIT 2: I have now issued Version 2 in a later post. To avoid confusion I have removed the attachment from this post.
I am currently exploring options for a compact and lightweight melodeon, primarily for playing tunes in D and G, but more versatile than a two-row such as my Castagnari Tommy which is challenged by even slightly wider ranging or more intricate tunes. I decided to see what extra versatility I could achieve by customising a Hohner Liliput, taking advantage of the 4 additional buttons on its accidentals row. After many enjoyable hours of playing, figuring out and analysing (inspired by Bob Ellis's efforts doing the same for his full 3-row layout) I have come up with the layout attached (see version 2 in a later post).
I arrived at this by going through my favourite 200-or-so tunes, all of which I would ideally like to be able to play on the Liliput without any significant compromise on notes, chords, etc (apart from where I need to transpose to D or G to make a tune playable/more playable on the instrument).
I played all the tunes as far as I could on my normal-layout D/G Tommy, figured out (on piano) missing notes or chords, and noted if the bellows direction was to be important.
I have written more, but thought this would do for an initial post.
I would welcome any comments, observations, and in particular if you spot something I might not have thought of.
-
Maybe I'm missing the point but the D row now looks more like an A row as all the G's are G#'s. Can you expand on that choice?
Sorry to any pedants reading this post but the apostrophes are probably wrong but make the reading easier
-
yes, what's going on in that D row, Sandy?
-
I am currently exploring options for a compact and lightweight melodeon, primarily for playing tunes in D and G, but more versatile than a two-row such as my Castagnari Tommy which is challenged by even slightly wider ranging or more intricate tunes. I decided to see what extra versatility I could achieve by customising a Hohner Liliput, taking advantage of the 4 additional buttons on its accidentals row. After many enjoyable hours of playing, figuring out and analysing (inspired by Bob Ellis's efforts doing the same for his full 3-row layout) I have come up with the layout attached.
I arrived at this by going through my favourite 200-or-so tunes, all of which I would ideally like to be able to play on the Liliput without any significant compromise on notes, chords, etc (apart from where I need to transpose to D or G to make a tune playable/more playable on the instrument).
I played all the tunes as far as I could on my normal-layout D/G Tommy, figured out (on piano) missing notes or chords, and noted if the bellows direction was to be important.
I have written more, but thought this would do for an initial post.
I would welcome any comments, observations, and in particular if you spot something I might not have thought of.
Here's what I decided on for my Preciosa, also based on all the non-standard tunes and keys I wanted to play...
-- based on wanting the accidentals where tunes were split 50/50 on direction both ways, and accidentals in both octaves, and keeping the F bass for playing in C and Dmi
-- all basses have thirds swapped for an extra fifth reed which fills out the chords nicely and means no major/minor problem
Ian
-
Why two Eo's on the pull (2nd button on G row, 4th on D row)?
-
The attachment should be okay now. Sorry about the bit of finger trouble, but I did lots of copying and pasting as part of the exercise and as part of my hurry to get it posted I only really double checked the "unconventional" notes.
So G instead of G# to make it a conventional D layout.
Ganderbox - it is a conventional B-push, E-pull on the G-row - which, hopefully, you should see if you view with increased zoom (limits of scanning a print out of an Excel spreadsheet). I have changed the font and made it portrait, so hopefully that will help.
I will reply to other points separately.
-
I'd have thought that any system truely intended to 'maximise versatility' would have to emply the Dutch System trick of swapping the E and D notes in the centre of the G row. Yes, this does sound, in practice, like a scary change, but it will make more notes available that you've currently got.
-
I'd have thought that any system truely intended to 'maximise versatility' would have to emply the Dutch System trick of swapping the E and D notes in the centre of the G row. Yes, this does sound, in practice, like a scary change, but it will make more notes available that you've currently got.
Ah yes, how clever - you get both notes in both directions. But it would mean throwing away all that intuitive D/G playing which is so ingrained now! Perhaps I should call it "optimise" versatility, for my range of tunes.
-
Here's what I decided on for my Preciosa, also based on all the non-standard tunes and keys I wanted to play...
-- based on wanting the accidentals where tunes were split 50/50 on direction both ways, and accidentals in both octaves, and keeping the F bass for playing in C and Dmi
-- all basses have thirds swapped for an extra fifth reed which fills out the chords nicely and means no major/minor problem
Ian
Ian - many thanks for sharing your Preciosa layout; it really got me thinking as to why I have some extras that you do not have and vice versa. I then realised this is because we have different starting criteria, the main difference being that I am trying to maximise the playability of tunes in D and G whereas you were also seeking to enable playing of tunes in other keys such as C and Dmin, thereby truly maximising the versatility of the 2.5 row.
In past years I have spent months at a time trying, but failing, to get past "adequate" capability on a B/C/C#, and therefore have no appetite any more for having to think where the notes in a particular key are when I can play any tune almost completely intuitively in D or G (on a D/G box), and also accurately and expressively. So my objective is to have a 2.5 row layout that will enable me to play even the more challenging tunes to the full in D or G. This also means I am happy to leave the thirds in all the basses (except A).
However, one very important aspect your layout has pointed out to me is the need for repeats of low A and D on the draw, on the D-row and G-row respectively. So with a few minor mods to accommodate that I have come up with Version 2 of the "Flett 2.5 row D-G layout" which I have attached (I have removed the original from my first post to avoid confusion for anyone just coming to this thread).
-
This is something that I've been thinking about recently too.
My (current) preferred set up is as follows:
(Push/Pull)
Half row: (Bb/G#) (F/Eb) (C/D) (Bb/G#)
G row: (G/C) (B/D) (D/F#) (G/A) . . .
D row: (F/Eb) (F#/A) (A/C#) (D/E) . . .
My thinking has been on ensuring that the notes of as many triads as possible - both major and minor - are available in the same bellows direction.
The planned 12 bass end (no thirds in any of the chords) would be:
Head
(A/G) (F/F#)
(D/A) (B/E)
(G/D) (C/C)
Foot
Although I think the system would also work with the eight-bass 'club' layout with a push F.
Cheers,
Owen