Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on July 29, 2010, 09:35:03 PM

Title: faster action
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on July 29, 2010, 09:35:03 PM
does any one know of any easy peasy tricks to make the trebble action quicker? i can play repeated notes alot quicker on one box than i can on the other, any ideas?
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Anahata on July 29, 2010, 10:09:36 PM
It could be mechanical (change the spring rating) but the answer's much much more likely to be new, better reeds. If there's one obvious difference between good reeds and not so good reeds it's speed of response.

It's also possible that you can get an improvement by expert tweaking of the reeds and possibly replacing the valves if they aren't performing well. Valves that don't close will certainly slow the action of a reed.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: HallelujahAl on July 29, 2010, 10:16:54 PM
 
Quote
Valves that don't close will certainly slow the action of a reed.
yep - never underestimate the importance of valve performance, in some ways they're critical.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 29, 2010, 10:18:20 PM
Somewhere either on this or the old forum site I found a link to some photos posted by Theo showing the method he uses to restrict button movement on Hohners so they don't vanish down the rabbit hole - may not make the reeds speak any quicker but may assist your speed of using them unless you know you're not over pressing -  Are the springs stronger or quicker acting on the faster box ??

I shall have a go at mine (button restriction) once the current restoration job is finished, unfortunately I suspect this will now include all new bass end springs and (if re leathering the pallets does not improve matters) the treble end too :(

Richard
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on July 29, 2010, 10:47:01 PM
I've come to the conclusion that if you don't down want your fingers disappearing down the "rabbit holes" on a Hohner melodeon, the  following is best method.

Just don't do it.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: rees on July 29, 2010, 10:54:20 PM
I've come to the conclusion that if you don't down want your fingers disappearing down the "rabbit holes" on a Hohner melodeon, the  following is best method.

Just don't do it.

Right on. It never did Tony Hall any harm.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 29, 2010, 11:35:18 PM
I've come to the conclusion that if you don't down want your fingers disappearing down the "rabbit holes" on a Hohner melodeon, the  following is best method.

Just don't do it.

Right on. It never did Tony Hall any harm.

Andrew
I appreciate that finger control is high on the agenda when it comes to the right hand side and that sufficient practice and experience may allow a 'gossamer touch' to develop, as someone with a more agricultural touch, trying to play both one and two row without thumbstrap and generally only a RH shoulderstrap I could see the the buttons bottoming no further down than enough to spill adequate air through the reeds as also being beneficial for holding the keyboard better, on that basis is this something I ought to bother doing?

Rees, as for Tony Hall, yes agreed, but who knows what fragments of old kipper crates and bacca tins lurk under his keyboards - unless of course you are the 'who' who has been there and seen all (I'll understand if this is 'seal of the confessional' stuff)  ???

Good night one and all - Richard (who strangely can't summon to mind an appropriate fish pun, or even an inappropriate one come to that)
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 29, 2010, 11:46:59 PM
Somewhere either on this or the old forum site I found a link to some photos posted by Theo showing the method he uses to restrict button movement on Hohners so they don't vanish down the rabbit hole - may not make the reeds speak any quicker but may assist your speed of using them unless you know you're not over pressing -  Are the springs stronger or quicker acting on the faster box ??

I shall have a go at mine (button restriction) once the current restoration job is finished, unfortunately I suspect this will now include all new bass end springs and (if re leathering the pallets does not improve matters) the treble end too :(

Richard
The link to Theo's method is here:
Regulating Hohner action (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=109685&id=709188166&l=c564b24e38)

Having recently acquired a Hohner Erica which Theo had modified in this way, I can personally vouch for it. It really does make a huge difference to the action and the speed of the box. It also means that the impact velocity of the pallets on release of the buttons is less, and therefore you get much less pallet noise rattle as a result.

The only improvement I would suggest to Theo's method is to add a facing of thin chamois leather to the wood strip, where the pallet lever arms contact it, to act as an additional rattle-reducing buffer. I am about to try this for myself on another Erica. Will report back....
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: stevejay on July 30, 2010, 12:07:51 AM
I have an improved action melodeon and one regular in CF. I don't totally dislike the feel of the unimproved CF. It is somewhat slower, but mostly just requires a different touch. You learn to reduce the clacking by the touch.

Honestly I don't know why Tony Hall recordings clack so much, I think placement near a microphone enhances it even more than it would sound in person, like fret noise in classical guitar recordings.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 30, 2010, 12:18:25 AM
Thanks Steve - based on your comments I will carry on when I get the chance. I've not looked inside yet but if the variation of lever height was not huge I wondered about using a wood strip topped with some rubber or closed cell neoprene strip so that there was a degree of 'crush', if they are all over the place then Theo's method of filing a groove for each lever to come to rest in will obviously be needed but I can certainly see chamois giving just that little bit of cushioning effect as it will conform with the grooves - and it's a traditional material  ;)

I was horrified to see he used RH cross point screws but assumed these were only for convenience while the strip went in and out for filing, shame we didn't see the finished job with those shining brass slot headed countersunk screws in custom sunk countersinks, previously occupied by steel screws to size them so the slots line up and candle waxed against removal in a century's time - then I thought, even if his name was Castagnari I doubt he could charge that much for levelling a few buttons  ;D ;D

Thanks for your 'guides for the incurably interfering and impecunious squeezboxers' Theo, I have downloaded both this and the reed tuning pics for my further education - are there any other hohner related sections of Gibb equivalent of Haynes Car manuals out there ??

Gypsylad, your thread well and truly hi - jacked but hopefully to your enlightenment as well

Richard
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Theo on July 30, 2010, 09:43:42 AM

The only improvement I would suggest to Theo's method is to add a facing of thin chamois leather to the wood strip, where the pallet lever arms contact it, to act as an additional rattle-reducing buffer. I am about to try this for myself on another Erica. Will report back....

In practice you get no audible noise from a wooden strip,  soft material will give a softer more spongy feel to the action and a less precise stop, so its worth doing if you like that kind of feel.

I was horrified to see he used RH cross point screws

Best tool for the job in this situation.  Very light gauge screws needed, brass would be a bit flimsy.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: GeeTee on July 30, 2010, 12:19:03 PM
I've not used Hohners for a long time but we used to use car floor mats cut to the same shape as the finger board and slide it in behind the levers reducing the distance the buttons can travel.If you're going to try this make sure you tighten the two long bolts that hold the finger board on evenly rather than one at a time if that makes sence.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Theo on July 30, 2010, 02:03:23 PM
I've not used Hohners for a long time but we used to use car floor mats cut to the same shape as the finger board and slide it in behind the levers reducing the distance the buttons can travel.If you're going to try this make sure you tighten the two long bolts that hold the finger board on evenly rather than one at a time if that makes sence.

The trouble with this method is that if you use thick enough material to limit the button travel to flush with the fingerboard surface then you can't get the fingerboard back on!
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: GeeTee on July 30, 2010, 02:16:06 PM
Good point it was a long time ago.The mat cannot be flush but then there's no need for it to be.
 
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Theo on July 30, 2010, 02:20:12 PM
does any one know of any easy peasy tricks to make the trebble action quicker? i can play repeated notes alot quicker on one box than i can on the other, any ideas?

Going back to the original question - if there were "easy peasy tricks to make the trebble action quicker" we would all be using them, as would the builders of our instruments!
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 30, 2010, 03:26:38 PM
Thanks for the clarification Theo, as I don't have any Red Cedar, do you think Ash sapwood would give similar results and ignore the rubber strip ? I happen to have lots of ash  (:)

As for the screws, much as I dislike the look of cross points I am guilty of using them but that doesn't stop me pulling the legs of those who do likewise, however, when visible or if replacements for originals I do try to use traditional fixings - one of my main gripes is people using post WW2 Whitworth and BSF nuts / bolts in restorations of earlier machinery (head sizes were reduced for wartime economy and never re enstated)

Richard
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Theo on July 30, 2010, 04:27:21 PM
I would certainly not allow a Philips or pozi head anywhere near my 1943 Indian,  When I have to use modern bolts I even file off the lettering from the blot heads so that they look the part.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on July 30, 2010, 05:46:42 PM
this is on a paolo soprani elite 1 , i can rattle notes, but it seems a bit more sluggish than my gabbanelli, it feels like it could be something to do with springs, i think the reeds in the gabby are "cheaper" than the soprani, so it maynot be that, i will have a check with rees next weekend, if i can find him!
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: rees on July 30, 2010, 05:50:26 PM
I'll be in the Kings.  :|glug
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on July 30, 2010, 06:50:16 PM
me too, and all my clan! better warn em...! :|glug
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on July 31, 2010, 09:03:19 PM
I've come to the conclusion that if you don't down want your fingers disappearing down the "rabbit holes" on a Hohner melodeon, the  following is best method.

Just don't do it.

Right on. It never did Tony Hall any harm.

Andrew
I appreciate that finger control is high on the agenda when it comes to the right hand side and that sufficient practice and experience may allow a 'gossamer touch' to develop, as someone with a more agricultural touch, trying to play both one and two row without thumbstrap and generally only a RH shoulderstrap I could see the the buttons bottoming no further down than enough to spill adequate air through the reeds as also being beneficial for holding the keyboard better, on that basis is this something I ought to bother doing?

Rees, as for Tony Hall, yes agreed, but who knows what fragments of old kipper crates and bacca tins lurk under his keyboards - unless of course you are the 'who' who has been there and seen all (I'll understand if this is 'seal of the confessional' stuff)  ???

Good night one and all - Richard (who strangely can't summon to mind an appropriate fish pun, or even an inappropriate one come to that)


I think that there are two issues to consider. If you want to play with a light touch then practicing for that is the only answer. Getting your finger onto a button is only half the story (less than half actually), getting your finger off again is the thing and learning things like "bouncing" on a key rather than gripping it.

Limiting the key travel may cure one issue (your finger has very slightly less distance to travel on the return) but I strongly suspect that that is the lesser issue anyway. What is really needed is control and the problem isn't the amount of travel on the button but the fact that you're gripping it too hard, relax and get your finger off.

So, second issue. Hohner reeds are better than many give them credit for, but have a little experimentation. To get the "full throated" Hohner roar you need to get a bit of air through them. Limit the key travel and you lose some of it and that is a shame since that is often just what you're after; especially if you're playing outdoors or otherwise unamplified for dancing.

All interesting stuff for me anyway ... I also investigated what I actually do on my other boxes. One has a pretty limited action (on a stepped keyboard) but I noticed that even when stood up (with one strap as ever) I hardly hit the bottom of the travel of the button. The other has much more travel on the buttons and they will disapear under the level of the keyboard (though not as far as on a Hohner) and I generally seem to play them down to the level of the keyboard of just shy of it.

In the end, if having a more limited travel on your Hohner makes if feel nicer to you and you're happy with the sound then why not. I've tried both, having limited the action on one of my first boxes, but coming back to regular Pokerwork Hohner playing years later I now wouldn't do it.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Steve C. on July 31, 2010, 09:49:21 PM
Easy peasy way=
Send to Theo or if in US, to Dancemaster.  Not expensive. Very noticeable improvement. And having had my Pokerwork done, this is good time to get a nice tuning.  Dry it out a wee bit.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Broadland Boy on July 31, 2010, 10:26:31 PM
Thanks Andrew

As one who has struggled to master the melodeon over the years (without putting enough practice in before anyone offers a Mally type comment  ;) ) the chances of me ever becoming a good, let alone subtle player are at best minimal, however I would settle for reasonably competent and I only play for my own enjoyment / frustration. (have there been any truly 'great' box players who started in vengeance the wrong side of 50 with limited musical ability ??)

I can see the relevance of your comments and that button control is an integral part of playing well and yes I should aim for that but there are not enough years left and I spend so much time trying to translate what is in my head onto the keyboard that hitting some of the notes in mostly the right places and being on the right pull or draw is plenty for me at present so suspect that at some point I will put Theo's mod into my D/G, however, as it's reversable should I get frustrated by having inadequate control in the future, 4 x point screws and its out ! 

More importantly another facet of playing has been lodged here in cyberspace for others who may be younger / keener / less lazy than me to read and absorb, the more good and improving box players there are the better  (:)

Someone else recently mentioned elsewhere that the point at which you take your finger off is as, if not more, important than when you put it on, which wholly tallys with my first love in music, JS Bach and particularly in his organ music, where what often marks a stunning, as opposed to competent, performance is the gaps between the notes.

Richard
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on July 31, 2010, 10:44:21 PM
A few years back Daniel Barenboim did the Reith lectures and his first one included his descriptions and thoughts on the nature and the life of a musical note (and silence). It was gripping stuff and something, as you say, that the great composers have understood either intellectually or instinctively.

There's something to be said for your position too, we're meant to be enjoying ourselves as well and too much worrying will just spoil it.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Broadland Boy on August 01, 2010, 12:03:15 AM
A few years back Daniel Barenboim did the Reith lectures and his first one included his descriptions and thoughts on the nature and the life of a musical note (and silence). It was gripping stuff and something, as you say, that the great composers have understood either intellectually or instinctively.

There's something to be said for your position too, we're meant to be enjoying ourselves as well and too much worrying will just spoil it.

Must have missed that Andrew, sounds really interesting, some of those Reith lectures have left me chewing over the content for weeks, while some of the more arty ones have gone right over my head  ::)

I find posts like yours very rewarding to read, sometimes they confirm something known or suspected, sometimes they throw an entirely new light on something vaguely known or show it in a different perspective, sometimes its brand new info.

Horses for courses as they say, I'm under no illusions about my playing but for every member on there seem to be an equal number of 'lurkers' so info such as this is read numerous times and will inevitably help other squeezers who may not have considered it as part of their technique  :|||:

I'll content meself with trying to renovate an old box or two and have enough digital dexterity to get a tune of some description out of it,

To share a smile, I lent an un marked german open pallet 4 stop to a neighbour the other week, he is a very accomplished double bass and bass guitarist and thought he'd 'like a go', he brought it back this afternoon, "however do you play one" he says, "I've had a tune out of just about every instrument I've ever picked up but not that" a little enquiry found that the other instrument he'd failed on was the Gob Iron -  Ah says I they are just like each other  >:E >:E

Richard
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: rees on August 01, 2010, 12:21:44 AM
I bought my first melodeon (dg pokerwork) from a local musician. Extremely talented man, jazz, classical. whatever on piano, clarinet and violin - played in loads of bands,orchestras, etc.
After seeing John K he decided to buy a melodeon. He never managed to get a tune out of it!
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Anahata on August 01, 2010, 09:45:27 AM
Someone else recently mentioned elsewhere that the point at which you take your finger off is as, if not more, important than when you put it on, which wholly tallys with my first love in music, JS Bach and particularly in his organ music, where what often marks a stunning, as opposed to competent, performance is the gaps between the notes.

That's a big open secret of musical melodeon playing.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Gandy on August 01, 2010, 08:15:07 PM
Thanks for the clarification Theo, as I don't have any Red Cedar, do you think Ash sapwood would give similar results and ignore the rubber strip ? I happen to have lots of ash  (:)

It worked OK for me using Ramin (which was what I had to hand).   
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Theo on August 01, 2010, 10:11:00 PM
The exact timber is not important though it helps if it's fairly soft then you can adjust the travel by pressing the levers hard so they crush the wood slightly.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Andrew Culwell on August 02, 2010, 02:03:55 AM
Those of us (not tony Hall) need every assistance in adjusting our Hohners to make them user friendly.  It's all well and good to say "don't do it" but necessity is the mother of invention.  Just because some genius doesn't need to make adjustments doesn't mean the rest of us shouldn't.  Where would we be if people didn't think that something needed modifying.  Let me go get my square wheel. 
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on August 02, 2010, 08:19:48 PM
thanks for all the great responses! im gonna let a few people try it at the weekend and see what they say, then go from there, as ive only been playing for a couple years it might just be me!
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: oggiesnr on August 02, 2010, 10:18:09 PM
For me the issue is noise, I'm trying a sliver of felt on the underside of the button hole to deaden the clack.

Steve
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on August 02, 2010, 10:30:23 PM
i find the bass side on my soprani clacky, its not realy bad, but enough to annoy me! is it best to resurface the pallets or felt around the the sound holes?
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: OwenG on August 03, 2010, 08:47:40 AM

I think that there are two issues to consider. If you want to play with a light touch then practicing for that is the only answer. Getting your finger onto a button is only half the story (less than half actually), getting your finger off again is the thing and learning things like "bouncing" on a key rather than gripping it.

Three tricks:
I was playing an un-reconstructed HA114 like this last night and it definitely makes a difference
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 03, 2010, 12:13:00 PM
Can someone explain something I don't understand - why do Hohner make buttons that vanish, as opposed to many other manufacturers where the buttons stand proud of the keyboard?

It would seem to me obvious that buttons that stand proud give more hitting area, so you can be more flexible.  But perhaps the idea of the Hohner system is that the surround is a sort of resting area that allows your finger to slide around more easily.  (I've always found vanishing buttons a little difficult, because my guitarist fingernails get in the way a bit, but that's not really relevant.)

This isn't really a flat vs stepped issue, I don't think, it's more to do with what the keyboard surround is for - presumably it's there to cut short finger travel.

Title: Re: faster action
Post by: LDbosca on August 03, 2010, 01:26:00 PM

I think that there are two issues to consider. If you want to play with a light touch then practicing for that is the only answer. Getting your finger onto a button is only half the story (less than half actually), getting your finger off again is the thing and learning things like "bouncing" on a key rather than gripping it.

Three tricks:
  • play with 'flat' fingers using the pads of your fingers to play the button rather than curling your fingers and using the tips of your fingers. Quite often you'll see trumpet players playing like this; and
  • play the keyboard not the button. If you aim slightly off-centre and hit both the button and the keyboard with your fingers you can self-limit the travel of the button; and
  • look at your bellows control - if it's not co-ordinated with the button pushing it won't help!
I was playing an un-reconstructed HA114 like this last night and it definitely makes a difference

I always tell students I'm teaching to use the tips of the fingers and natural curl to the fingers as in piano playing. Surely flat fingers make  cross-row fingerings difficult and reduce the snappiness of ornamentation? You'll have to excuse my skepticism but all the good players I'm used to seeing play with the tips of their fingers and solve the keyboard problem by playing instruments with a good keyboard.

Luke.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Theo on August 03, 2010, 01:55:56 PM
Can someone explain something I don't understand - why do Hohner make buttons that vanish, as opposed to many other manufacturers where the buttons stand proud of the keyboard?

I thing it is simply a matter of keeping production costs down. 
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: george garside on August 03, 2010, 04:31:57 PM
[ ]

  I always tell students I'm teaching to use the tips of the fingers and natural curl to the fingers as in piano playing.  .

Luke.
[/quote]

so do I!

george
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Theo on August 03, 2010, 05:31:39 PM
[ ]

  I always tell students I'm teaching to use the tips of the fingers and natural curl to the fingers as in piano playing.  .

Luke.

so do I!

george
[/quote]

Me too.   I don't see how you can play the inside row with flat fingers and avoid the outside row.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Quebecois on August 03, 2010, 07:52:26 PM
Can someone explain something I don't understand - why do Hohner make buttons that vanish, as opposed to many other manufacturers where the buttons stand proud of the keyboard?
Except for the Morgane and similar models, which have mushroom buttons.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: waltzman on August 03, 2010, 08:56:08 PM
I have noticed myself that playing with the flat part of my fingers on the BASS buttons of my Erica reduces the noise substantially.  When I read that earlier post I just assumed he was talking about the bass buttons.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: OwenG on August 04, 2010, 08:44:58 AM
[ ]

  I always tell students I'm teaching to use the tips of the fingers and natural curl to the fingers as in piano playing.  .

Luke.

so do I!

george

Me too.   I don't see how you can play the inside row with flat fingers and avoid the outside row.
[/quote]

Looks like 'flat' was the wrong word! (I did put it in 'quotes'). What I was trying to get at was to suggest not curling the hand too much and ending up with a 'claw'. I know when I started playing a Pokerwork, I would tense up and my fingers would be approaching the buttons at right angles to the keyboard, with a consequence that the buttons would disappear down the holes. The 'flatter' the fingers the more relaxed the hand and consequently the easier it is to play with a lighter touch. Of course the fingers will be curled enough to move over both rows and the position of the wrist is such that fingers will naturally move downwards onto the button rather than up and down if you take the 'claw' approach.

Out of interest, how much curl do you suggest to your pupils?

Apologies for any confusion caused.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: Theo on August 04, 2010, 08:51:24 AM

Out of interest, how much curl do you suggest to your pupils?


Ideally the natural amount of curl that is in your hand when relaxed.
Title: Re: faster action
Post by: george garside on August 04, 2010, 09:34:52 AM
the amouint of 'curl'  that  iis comforable depends to a large degree on what else you are trying to use the rest of the hand for - i.e. is it required to push the keyboard against a single shoulder strap.  Also on what is the role of the thumb - is it pushing/steadying the edge of the keyb oard - is it tucked behind the keyboard, is it resting lightly on the edge of the keyboard (or in the groove provided on some boxes for that purpose).  With the thumb on edge of keyboard or in groove ( and playing no part in anchoring the box to the person) the thumb can slope upwards at an angle away from the keyboard so the playing fingers only require a very small amount of curl  to enable the buttons to be  LIGHTLY tapped with just the finger tips.


Its also worth remembering  that the buttons do not control the volume in any way shape or form.  They work more or less as on off switches & once the pallete is off the board enough air is comin in or out to play loudly or softly, the volume being governed by bellows pressure (or ? pullsure!).    Therefore there is absolutely no reason to attempt to shove the buggers down hohners (or anyabody elses) holes!

george ;D

Title: Re: faster action
Post by: LDbosca on August 04, 2010, 11:28:55 AM

Out of interest, how much curl do you suggest to your pupils?


Ideally the natural amount of curl that is in your hand when relaxed.

I sometimes get kids to let their right arm hang by their side and see how their fingers naturally curl up, it's pretty much exactly that amount (as Theo said).  RIght angles are too much alright. I had a friend who had an unusually flat finger position, his playing was choppy (and not in the desirable way) and he caused a lot of unnecessary clunky noise when playing.

I know it's not the same as piano playing in that we don't need to use anything like the amount of force with the right hand to produce sound, however I reckon that this hand position makes it easiest to get the small amount of force we do need.

Luke.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal