Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: oggiesnr on July 30, 2010, 10:29:53 PM
-
I buy and sell on Ebay. My basic approach is that my starting price is the minimum I will accept for what I'm selling. Even when there are 99p listing days etc I stick to this. Likewise my maximum bid is what I'm prepared to pay for what I'm after. I get increasingly frustrated where I bid and I get the "reserve not met" message and then I enter the rigmarole of trying to get their etc etc.
IMHO, if you know what you want either do a "Buy it now" or set a sensible opening bid and go from there. A low starting bid and a high reserve is just a waste of everybodies time!
Steve
Oops, this has ended up in the wrong place, could an Admin move it please?
-
too late, I'm the fourth to see it here and I think GCHQ was just in front of me ;D
-
I use reserves once in a while but I also post a buy it now price. I think that simple logic dictates that a reserve price will be very close to the buy it now price. That said I can see your point about how frustrating it is when there is a reserve but at the same time there is a certain amount of interest that is generated by starting the price out low. Perhaps I'm wrong...when I place a reserve I usually get less interest it seems so you might have something there!
-
"Nobody likes reserves," BUT they can be useful to both sides.
As a seller, if you don't use a reserve and just set a fair starting price, that's fine, but then the first bidder has to jump in high on their own, relying completely on their own judgement of the worth of the item, and may end up buying it on that first bid, ever wondering if they went too high!
When you have a reserve, the bidding up to the reserve does have some use in that it can reassure bidders that others are valuing the item similarly to them. Bidder confidence is good news for sellers.
For secondhand items one of the great things about Ebay is that, so long as you're not out on your own in the bidding, you know that you have a good chance of passing the item on without losing too much if it turns out not what you wanted. (Obviously if it's misdecribed you may end up in a dispute with the seller etc, but that's another matter.)
Reserves a necessary irritation I'd say.
-
Oops, this has ended up in the wrong place, could an Admin move it please?
Done!
-
Reserves are used widely in "live" auctions for precisely the same reason. Sellers want to be sure of getting at least their minimum price, however bidders may be reluctant to start off bidding too high. Starting low breaks the ice and gets the bidding going. Often bidding will quickly go above the reserve. If it doesn't then the vendor isn't committed to sell at a price lower than he's prepared to accept.
Once the reserve is reached the auctioneer will announce "it's in the room" and everyone knows they are now bidding for real.
-
I cannot see what the problem is. If you put your bid in on what you are prepared to pay for the item, the reserve is of no interest to you. If the reserve is more than your bid, stick to your guns, you have reached your maximum so wait until another one comes along. Even if you are just bidding a few quid at a time, once you have reached your limit on what it is worth to you. Stop bidding again and wait for another. If you think you can get a bargain that way, you are sadly mistaken.
I always put what I think is an affordable price depending on scarcity etc on my first bid. If I am outbid so be it I certainly ain't getting into a bidding frenzy and pay more than I want to.
I never bid after a skinful anymore after ending up with a Harley a few years ago. Lucky me got it 4 grand cheaper than I was prepared to pay, But evidently when your missus says 'just do what you effing well like' it means totally the opposite.
-
Let's face it..there are many bargain seekers (ie: cheap folks) who think that just because an item is on ebay that it's not worth a damn! That said "one mans trash is another mans treasure" So if you know that your item is worth a certain amount to you then you place a reserve. If it doesn't sell then it's due to the value you placed on it or some other reason. Another thing about ebay is that one week you might get 300.00 for an old pre-war Hohner and the next week no one will bid. It's all very capricious thus the reason for a reserve.
-
I've done a lot fo buying and selling of different types of items on Ebay, and these are some of my experiences with reserves.
The usefulness of a reserve varies by auction. I generally don't like them (buying or selling), but they have advantages for seller security when an expensive item is on the line. If you want to put something on Ebay and are afraid of the crapshoot nature of the auction, then placing a reasonable reserve allows you to sell with confidence as much as it allows the bidders to bid with confidence. If the reserve isn't met then you only lose a few dollars for listing the auction, but you maintained the advantage of selling the item for more than the reserve price if interest was high.
Reserves can be overkill for less expensive items (say less than $100, depending on what it is). The availability of the item also plays a role. If the item is widely available, like a knackered Pokerwork, then any reserve will just steer buyers to other auctions where there is no hassle and the tempting possibility that the final price will be lower. There are bargains everywhere on Ebay and personally, I'd rather shop around than deal with the hassle of negotiating reserves. I've even had sellers keep the reserve to themselves when I've inquired about it, and a few who became borderline hostile in discussing the details of the reserve. Such people are obviously in the dark about the purpose of a reserve -- it's not some secret surprise that the seller lords over his bidders, it's a practical tool for saving time and making money, and keeping it from me does not help me to bid.
I frequently watch old chisels and other tools on Ebay, which sell for $5-$30 depending on the maker, year, and condition. Bidding typically starts in the $1-$10 range, and results for similar or identical items often vary by a wide margin. In such a case where an informed seller doesn't expect more than $25 (and can jack up the shipping if the item sells at the low end :-X), a reserve frightens off bidders who can find a comparable tool in another auction with no reserve.
I avoid placing reserves. When I sell, I always start the bidding at a point reasonably below what I'd like for the item (50-75% less than the value of the item) and offer a simultaneous Buy it Now option for the minimum I would be satisfied to receive. I have never had a bad result with this method, and I have sold expensive items ($300-$500) on Ebay numerous times. It also helps to have detailed shipping information prepared in advance, and also make the auction visible in other countries. The more concrete information there is available to bidders, the more confident they will feel. If you're selling anything with a light, then turn it on in the photographs and watch your numbers double. (:)
-
Fair points made by all.
I think it also depends on how specialised an item is. If it is specialised and there are likely to be very few people bidding, you're unlikely to get up much of a "head of steam" so if you start low, you might sell too low, or fizzle out below the reserve.
If I was listing a D/G Castaganari Lily or Tommy in good nick on Ebay UK I'd feel pretty secure starting quite low knowing that the auction should run well and get to a fair price. Something in Bb/Eb, I'd use a reserve!
It's also a matter of proportion.
List that Lily at 99p and you waste a lot of bid time getting out of the silly area. Start it at something eye catching where it would be a real bargain, but not totally unrealistic...... (Probably the zone cpsmart is talking about.)