Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: DoninOhio on August 01, 2010, 04:16:17 AM
-
I am going to ship my Hohner HA 114 for modifications (different bassbox; lighter, less knucklebusting treble spring action and clarinet reeds tremolo reduced. Will make a fine box for taking on trips, etc.. I am looking for a sound closer to Quebecois players, so not sure how much to reduce the stock Hohner tremolo on the 2 clarinet reeds. Down to +5/-5 to +7/-7? Is there a formula that I could provide to a tuner (uses a strobe tuner) to use for the tuning? All I know about tuning is tempered vs. Just (Cajun) tuning.
Don
-
A good technician will use his ear to make final adjustments, even with a general or formulaic guideline. If you tell him to stick to a formula and he does just that then I think it'd sound pretty bad. There's usually a wider tremolo/slower beat at the lower end and a faster beat at the top because this is what the human ear expects to hear. The best thing to do is to provide the technician with some sound samples of other boxes that you want yours to sound like, and have a detailed conversation about the job.
So if it's a "forumla" you're after... you're in the right place. ;D
-
not sure how much to reduce the stock Hohner tremolo on the 2 clarinet reeds. Down to +5/-5 to +7/-7?
If you want to be able to have a totally dry sound with just LMH reeds in play then one of the M reeds must be tuned exactly to pitch. That is the norm for pretty much all 4 stop boxes. So they would need to be 0/+10 or 0/+14 for the amount of tremolo in your examples.
-
I am currently modding my Weltmeister Cajun 4 stop. It came with both MM reeds tuned dry. My first mod was to add a small bit of wetness. I chose a linear increment: C4= +9.0 C5=+7.5 C6=+6.1. (If you interpolate this line thru the remaining notes of the scale, this gives a smooth increase in the beating as the scale ascends. It's very subtle, but I definitely got the "fatness" I wanted without too much tremolo.
How much is too much? You must judge for yourself.
So far, I have only done the push reeds on this block. If it's any help, I can make a recording of dry vs. trem. as it sounds on my instrument. Then you can decide if you want more wetness. If you like the sound, I can easily send you the beating chart for it. Your tuner can take it from there.
Cheers................jwf :||:
Edited to add: Heed Theo's advice. One set of medium reeds must remain at zero pitch (except for the thirds, which might be flattened to some degree, a whole other discussion)