Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on August 06, 2010, 11:47:58 AM
-
Okay here's my question...
What is the trick to playing at dusty end of the keyboard?
How do you not get lost?
Why do I find it so hard to play a tune that I usually play at the chinward end of the melodeon down the other end?
-
Because you learnt on the well used end. You need to get used to the reverse Polish logic, which I thought was the same as the 'A' end of an anglo concertina. Two tunes to learn to get used to the squeaky end are 'Rose Tree' in D, and 'Barren Rocks of Aden' in D. Rose Tree will probably make your brain hurt, it did mine.
X:51
T:Rose Tree (Bampton)
C:3(1A.3B).1A
M:4/4
L:1/4
K:D
P:A
f/2e/2|"D"dB AF|"D"A/2B/2 "A"A/2F/2 A2|"D"d e/2d/2 "Bm"ed/2e/2|"Em"fe "A"e/2g/2 f/2e/2|
"D"dB AF|"D"A/2B/2 A/2F/2 A2|"Bm"d e/2d/2 "A"ed/2e/2|"D"fd de|]
P:B
"D"f>e fg|"D"a2 gf|"Em"eb b>a|"A"be ef/2e/2|
"D"dB AF|"D"A/2B/2 A/2F/2 A2|"Bm"d e/2d/2 "A"ed/2e/2|"D"fd d2|]
X:2
T:The Barren Rocks of Aden
C:from the Knots of May repertoire
Q:1/4=180
I:abc2nwc
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:D
A2d2|:e2|f3g f2e2|d2f2A3d|c2e2A2de|f2A2d2e2|
f3g f2e2|d2f2A3d|c2e2A2fe|d6:|
|:fg|a3f d2f2|e2g2A4|g3e c2e2|defg a2fg|
a3f d2f2|e2g2A4|g3e c2e2|d6:|
-
Okay here's my question...
What is the trick to playing at dusty end of the keyboard?
You will hate this but it's that old practice thing.
How do you not get lost?
See above
Why do I find it so hard to play a tune that I usually play at the chinward end of the melodeon down the other end?
As you probably already know the push and pull notes are in different places, for example, on the G row, the G nearest your chin is paired with an A, next one down with a F#, and finally with an E. Bit of a bugger really. It may not make you any happier but I am similarly struggling now I have a G/C box which is mostly played in the top octave and the G row is on the outside ???
-
Mind you, I am surprised that you get lost as the fingering is the same as the right hand side of an Anglo concertina at which you are proficient.
-
Mind you, I am surprised that you get lost as the fingering is the same as the right hand side of an Anglo concertina at which you are proficient.
yeah but on the concertina I cross rows to keep the tune on the right hand. Can you do that on a melodeon?
-
Mind you, I am surprised that you get lost as the fingering is the same as the right hand side of an Anglo concertina at which you are proficient.
yeah but on the concertina I cross rows to keep the tune on the right hand. Can you do that on a melodeon?
Yep.
I know I bang on about this and many disagree with me but knowing wot button generates wot note is, too my engineer's head, essential knowledge. Once you have the map it allows you to know what is possible. Mind you if you are, for example, DTN, not doing this may not hold you back. ;D
-
A lot of people find this hard to begin with.
The reason it is strange is that adjacent notes which were on the same button at the chin end, e.g. [G/A] [B/C] [D/E] are now on the next button, thus: [g/f#] [b/a] [d/c]. The push notes are the same but the pull notes are on the next button.
How to get round it? Only one way: practise, practise, practise ..... and it will come.
Think of easy tunes which you are confident with in the lower octave, and try them in the upper octave instead. Use the stop on your Tommy to bring in the low voice, and the dusty end (especially on the G-row) will not sound so squeaky.
-
Mind you, I am surprised that you get lost as the fingering is the same as the right hand side of an Anglo concertina at which you are proficient.
yeah but on the concertina I cross rows to keep the tune on the right hand. Can you do that on a melodeon?
Yep.
I know I bang on about this and many disagree with me but knowing wot button generates wot note is, too my engineer's head, essential knowledge. Once you have the map it allows you to know what is possible. Mind you if you are, for example, DTN, not doing this may not hold you back. ;D
I'm not an engineer...I'm an *dramatic pose* artist.;)
I was trying to do it by ear but my ear and my brain disagreed...I found it really hard to tell the difference between two notes when its that high. Don't know why though.
I also felt I couldn't make it as 'bouncy' as I can usually...its like I didn't have the strength.
-
I believe this is an example where playing simple scales can be a big help. Practice playing the scale of G and D up and down the top octave. Then practice doing a two octave scale on either row. I'd even go so far as to say that if you can't manage the scale in the top octave you will struggle to play a tune.
To my mid the top octave really comes into its own for playing in Em (on a D/G) where you can play all the scale except for D on the pull, and the notes form a very nice pattern that seems to fit easily under the fingers.
-
I believe this is an example where playing simple scales can be a big help. Practice playing the scale of G and D up and down the top octave. Then practice doing a two octave scale on either row. I'd even go so far as to say that if you can't manage the scale in the top octave you will struggle to play a tune.
To my mid the top octave really comes into its own for playing in Em (on a D/G) where you can play all the scale except for D on the pull, and the notes form a very nice pattern that seems to fit easily under the fingers.
Spot on advice, Theo!
-
as others have said the key is to practice scales the full length of the box & to KNOW which note is on which button & bellows direction in the upper octave.
The other thing is to cease to view the top octave as "the dusty end to which few go and many fear to tread!" Use it regularly for the tunes you can already play well ?winster gallop. Av oid having tunes that belong to one or the other octave as you have just the same notes in both octaves & it can vary things nicely to play in upper octave seccond time through a tune.
There are also many tunes that sit accross the two octaves & so many of those that can't play in the top octave already do! Soldiers joy is a good example.
Its also worth keeping in mind that the push pull sequence (on the row) is just the samae in both octaves, i.e blow/suck, blow/suck, blow/suck ,suck/blow. The difference is that in the loiwer octave you do a pair i.e blow/suck on the same button. In the upper octave you move up a button for the second part the 'suck' so its G blow- next button towards feet suck A then blow on same button for B etc. It helps to look at a keybord chart whilst working out how the upper octave is set out.
george
-
This may be a bit extreme, but if you really keep going the wrong direction on a note or two at the high end, maybe a small colored sticky "dot" on the key for a few days as a reminder of the troublesome note?
-
Tip: The cross rowing patterns are the same in the upper octave, just remember that when you change bellows direction you have to shift one button. That made the dusty end a bit easier. Other than that it's just practising scales, arpeggios and exercises I'm afraid.
-
Try playing scales or simple tunes you already know in both octaves at the same time. This makes scales fun ( >:E) as your fingers perform an interesting walk up the keyboard.
-
You need an instrument either in G/C (ideal) or with low voiced reeds (ot the spouse/cat may attack you). When I started that end I just dug in and played the tunes I knew. Yes it's a different push pull pattern - but actually more fluent, especially for minors. In my head I sort of have that end as a 'different instrument'.
Andy Cutting's 'Incontinental Mood/Flatworld' is a really good practice set. Most of the first one can be played both on the push v a G chord or on pull v and Em chord (D/G box). AFAIR Andy originally wrote these tunes for the 'dusty end'.
-
An interesting thread from 10 years ago. I’ve just had my Maestro sorted out by Mike Rowbotham (10/10 service) and he has corrected several high notes. I’ve been learning Simon Ritchie’s ‘Alf Ritchie’s Balanced Incline’ from the Banquet of Boxes album. It’s a thumping tune, huge fun to play. Someone on this forum supplied the abc for me. Anyway, it has a section right up in the high notes and it’s been good to learn how the buttons go up there! Made me realise how rarely I visit the “dusty endâ€.
-
Here's a tune I wrote 2 kettles ago, just for that reason:
The Dusty End (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=px70FCYwAeo)
-
Example of a 'dusty end' reed block
-
Example of a 'dusty end' reed block
Did you find any interesting wildlife in there?
-
Example of a 'dusty end' reed block
Brilliant.
-
Tip: The cross rowing patterns are the same in the upper octave, just remember that when you change bellows direction you have to shift one button. That made the dusty end a bit easier. Other than that it's just practising scales, arpeggios and exercises I'm afraid.
tuition on most instruments involves considerable practice of whatever scales the instrument is capable of. Melodeons of whatever tuning are no different !
george
1
1
-
Example of a 'dusty end' reed block
That’s cobwebby.🧐
-
That looks like one of those places that you know should be vacuumed but it's a two man job to move the wardrobe. Your nearest and dearest think the wardrobe is empty but you know something(s) they don't.
One of the reasons I liked the idea of a 1 row was that to me (a one time serial starter of new instruments) it looked like an instrument I could actually use over it's full range. And so it has proved. Whilst many traditional tunes have a range of 1 octave starting on the fundemental others include a drop down to the leading seventh or the fifth of the octave down and suddenly you find those tunes need to live in the upper octave. and you are up to button ten...at least on the pull. No dusty end.
-
I agree. I only played a one row for the first five years, so got used to playing all the buttons!