Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: OwenG on August 09, 2010, 04:53:30 PM

Title: Possible 2.5 row layout
Post by: OwenG on August 09, 2010, 04:53:30 PM
I am thinking of commissioning a 12-bass Hohner Club conversion and have come up with the following layout. The thinking behind the layout is to ensure that as many useful major and minor triads are available either on the pull or the push, or if possible, both. I could have gone through loads of tunes and come up with a system to fit them, but I thought that I would try and extend the underlying structure of a 'standard' keyboard layout.

Anyone got any constructive comments?


Treble end

(Push/Pull)

Half-Row: (Bb/G#) (C/D) (F/Eb) (Bb/G#)

G Row: (G/C) (B/D) (D/F#) (G/A) etc etc

D Row: (F/Eb) (F#/A) (A/C#) (D/E) etc etc

Bass end

(Push/Pull)

Head

(A/G) (F/F#)
(D/A) (B/E)
(G/D) (C/C)

Foot

All of the chords would be thirdless, with possibly an extra fifth reed instead of the third.

Title: Re: Possible 2.5 row layout
Post by: GbH on August 09, 2010, 06:52:32 PM
Owen - if you're looking for a definitive answer on this, I very much doubt that you'll get one, as whatever system you choose will inevitably be a compromise of one sort or another.  If someone says that, yes, your system is fine, then I'm sure that there'll be others that will disagree, whichever way you go.

Anyhow, with this in mind, as a 2.5 row player myself, my comments would be as follows:

1.  Going for a 4th row start seems a good idea, particularly so on a D/G.  This is something that I didn't choose when ordering my own instrument and now, on balance, regret.  Certainly, I'd consider that extra G/C button to be most welcome.

2.  If you're intending this to be your main instrument, then the C/D reversal button on the half-row will become invaluable.  The only (tenuous!) reason I can think of for not wanting the pulled D is that you might feel lost without it if you still intend to play a standard 2 row regularly.  The case for pushed C, however, is probably not so clear cut.  Personally, I have a pushed C too and I use it quite frequently.  On the other hand, I'm sure that some people might argue that since a pushed E is useful for both G and D major scales, it's theoretically a better idea.  In practice, I've rarely, if ever, wished I'd put chosen an E instead.  The other option might be for a pushed F (yes, I see you've already specified one, but read below...).  This is something I have missed having, but am still undecided whether it would be better than the C.

3.  The big issue I'd have with your layout is that you've gone with F/Eb buttons, rather than Eb/F - and that, as a consequence, you've put your F bass on the push too.  Despite having said, above, that an F push would be useful on the treble, I still think that foregoing an F pull on the bass is likely to prove a bad idea.  In every situation that I remember, the F bass has needed to be pulled.  So, given this, it seems reasonable that there should be a pulled F on the treble to match.  It's surely no accident that the suggested 2.5 row system on this site all use a pulled F in this manner.  If you're not absolutely sure about what you want and why (I assume you aren't, as you wouldn't have posted the question...), I'd suggest going with experience and switching it to the conventional approach.

4.  Obviously another issue that you've had to think about concerns the basses.  Is it better to have the extra Bb and Eb notes, or the ease of the A/G reversal?  I personally like having the Bb and Eb - I'd certainly miss having them if they weren't there.  But, I understand the reasons why people would choose otherwise.  I guess it comes down to how likely it is that you'll want to be experimenting with less usual keys and modes.


Hope this helps.
Title: Re: Possible 2.5 row layout
Post by: Hasse on August 09, 2010, 08:06:25 PM
... I could have gone through loads of tunes and come up with a system to fit them, but I thought that I would try and extend the underlying structure of a 'standard' keyboard layout.
Anyone got any constructive comments?

Maybe that's just what you ought to do - go through loads of tunes!

I. Is it a certain kind of tunes you want to be able to play. Then go through that kind of tunes, and talk to people about the characteristics of these tunes, (maybe you are lucky to already play these tunes on a different instrument?) Then work out a layout that works for this specific kind of tune/tradition or whatever.
II. Do you simply want to extend your possibilities? Then go with a more standard looking keyboard layout.

I've got this first kind of specialized keyboard layout myself (C/F 2+5 row), and it works OK for me. but there are always room for improvement and that's a never never never ending story.  ::)

Hope this was not too confusing
Title: Re: Possible 2.5 row layout
Post by: NeilA on August 09, 2010, 08:18:12 PM
Don't club models have 8 basses or is it possible to get them with 12 as you've shown?

Sorry - didn't read the post properly. Are you considering a conversion that adds more basses?
Title: Re: Possible 2.5 row layout
Post by: OwenG on August 10, 2010, 08:17:52 AM
Thanks for the responses - I know that there's no definitive answer but I thought it would be useful to test a few ideas out before taking the plunge.

If you're intending this to be your main instrument, then the C/D reversal button on the half-row will become invaluable. 

I've already got a converted C/F Club and would be lost without the push Bb, which I think I use more than the pulled C and certainly more than the pushed D.

Quote
The big issue I'd have with your layout is that you've gone with F/Eb buttons, rather than Eb/F - and that, as a consequence, you've put your F bass on the push too.

The reasoning behind the pushed F is mainly that my C/F box has an un-de-clubbed left hand and so has Eb bass and chord on the push, and so it seemed to feel 'right' to have a similar set-up. One of the reasons for posting was that I wasn't sure about whether this was a sensible move so I may re-consider.

Quote
Is it better to have the extra Bb and Eb notes, or the ease of the A/G reversal?

My C/F box covers the flat keys and so the reason for the A G and F# basses is to facilitate playing in keys with more than two sharps, plus having G, D, C, and A in both directions seemed like a good idea.

Maybe that's just what you ought to do - go through loads of tunes!

I. Is it a certain kind of tunes you want to be able to play. Then go through that kind of tunes, and talk to people about the characteristics of these tunes, (maybe you are lucky to already play these tunes on a different instrument?) Then work out a layout that works for this specific kind of tune/tradition or whatever.
II. Do you simply want to extend your possibilities? Then go with a more standard looking keyboard layout.

I did think about going through loads of tunes, but as any system is just a compromise I thought that the risk of this would be ending up with a box that was only good for those tunes. Instead I've tried to look at the basic set-up of a melodeon, with all of the notes of each chord available in the same direction. I've also tried not to move too far away from the standard club helper row. In this way it's more a question of making the tunes fit the box rather than making the box fit the tunes.

Are you considering a conversion that adds more basses?

Yep.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal