Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Steve C. on August 10, 2010, 04:23:14 PM
-
Having just received my new Benny, I was wondering, in the global scheme of things, if this was "normal" and if there are certain retailers, models, etc. that take considerably longer or shorter.
It was often been stated (and probably proven in the laboratory) that this is just "one of those Italian things".
But it seems as if there must be some "accepted" value for various instruments obtained in various ways.
Manufacturing processes have to be under some sort of control, even Italian ones. (Don't they?)
For example, I have been told it's good to use, as a rule of thumb, "4-14 months".
Would be very interested in compiling a little study:
First data point, mine.
Model: (e.g. Benny, 12 bass, cherry)
Location (e.g. US)
Method: (e.g. through Button Box)
Order date/Total time to receipt: (e.g. 4/2009, 69 weeks)
Any other possibly important factors: (e.g. GCF, added stop to remove thirds)
Not really interested in prices. Mostly interested in which models take longest, time to deliver of various shops in various locations, factoring certain time of year, time if ordering direct from Castagnari, etc.
If there is enough data, I will compile and report.
Thanks and regards, Steve
-
Hi Steve,
Did you get your Benny in GCF?
It might be useful data to record the tuning of the boxes in your study.
So:
Model: Jacky
Tuning: GCF dry
Method: Direct from Castagnari
Order date/total time to receipt: early 2000s, 8 months
-
Mori direct Dec 1991 = 6 months
one month delay was due to my odd reed choice
Organetto direct Oct 1992 = about 5 months
-
As the main Castagnari agent for the UK and having dealt with Castagnari for the last 26 years, I can reveal the following:
8)
-
Looks like my little study is going to be VERY little.
Those in the know, "sworn to secrecy". :Ph
-
Sander, late 80s, around 5 months.
-
Sorry, just my little joke.
Currently awaiting Benny, Dinn III and three Hascys - all ordered well over a year ago.
It's very rare these days for an order to be processed in six months.
A friend of mine recently phoned them regarding a potential order and they informed him that they have a three year waiting list!
-
No offense intended.
Sounds like the 4-14 rule is 5 years out of date.
-
Benny: C/F/Accidentals
Ordered direct 1/2001
Received 6/2001
-
Castagnari Dinn II
C#/D
Ordered thru American distributor
8 Months
-
LS/MFT LOL. Haven't heard that one in dogs years.
-
First considered the Big C: 2003.
Presently 2010 and still haven't snagged one. :|glug
Came quite close to a Tommy in D/G that had hardly been touched (only $1900!) but they were packing it up as we spoke over the telephone. So I guess my number is -7. Maybe next year!
-
LS/MFT LOL. Haven't heard that one in dogs years.
My dad used to smoke those....
-
I'm not quite a data point yet, having just placed my order for a Laura on March 23 of this year. That's 5 months so far, I reckon but, hey!, who's counting? Doug (Button Box) tells me that when it finally comes I'll love it so much that I won't even remember how long I had to wait.
-
I ordered a Trilly, it was due for delivery a fortnight later - finally turned up nine months later - but I love it. Not that you'd guess, if you saw me playing it in the rain!
My first Castagnari was a Nik, secondhand from a friend, and my Max came from a local lad who was selling to fund a Paolo Soprani before his wife found out. I've known better Niks and I need longer arms for the Max, but I find them excellent all the same.
Rob.
-
I'm still waiting - tum tee tum.
-
I was hoping to find out the folks like Rees were getting their instruments in just a few months as "old friends of the firm" but that does not look like its happening.
Does anyone know what models are their highest volume?
-
In the UK it must be Tommy and Lily.
-
:D I thought MTBC meant how long before a box player invested in a Castagnari after starting with or using another make box --
ha ha!
-
:D I thought MTBC meant how long before a box player invested in a Castagnari after starting with or using another make box --
ha ha!
Indeed.
-
:D I thought MTBC meant how long before a box player invested in a Castagnari after starting with or using another make box --
ha ha!
A year on a clapped out Pokerwork, and then seven more years on an Erica which had two rows of mine shafts on the keyboard and was wetter than a November day in Llanelli.
Actually, I loved my Erica. It taught me a lot and I was sorry to see it go. But I couldn't afford to run two boxes.....
-
:D I thought MTBC meant how long before a box player invested in a Castagnari after starting with or using another make box --
ha ha!
Nineteen years and counting (:)
Steve
-
Hard to believe, but it looks as though I'm about to become a data point. I just heard from Doug at the Button Box that my Laura has shipped and is expected in Massachusetts sometime before October 15. That would put it just a little less than 7 months from order to delivery. Who should be so lucky?
Note to LdT: We definitely need a new off-the-chart emoticon for birth announcements, don't you think?
-
Yesterday, received a Benny at 16 months and a Dinn III at 11 months.
-
That was quick.
-
I thought I was an outlier but I guess they (mis)treat everyone the same.
-
Castagnari have a huge market in France, the Netherlands and Scandinavia plus the Italian home market.
I'm afraid that the meagre amount of instruments that are sold to the UK and USA places us firmly at the bottom of the pecking order.
Last time I was visiting Castagnari they were completing an order of 40 instruments (all the same model) for one shop in Norway.
Now do you get the picture?
-
Thanks Rees, did not realize this.
It does make sense of this picture I have had in my picture files, always wondered, who gives kids this young instruments this nice?
-
Castagnari have a huge market in France, the Netherlands and Scandinavia plus the Italian home market.
I'm afraid that the meagre amount of instruments that are sold to the UK and USA places us firmly at the bottom of the pecking order.
Yet if you can't get the instruments you are going to have a small market. Which came first, the chicken or the egg?
Steve
-
Castagnari have a huge market in France, the Netherlands and Scandinavia plus the Italian home market.
I'm afraid that the meagre amount of instruments that are sold to the UK and USA places us firmly at the bottom of the pecking order.
Yet if you can't get the instruments you are going to have a small market. Which came first, the chicken or the egg?
Steve
I confirm for France and Casta :
Hardly 3 month's waiting
Cost 2750 € (I bought it in the south of France because the nearest seller's price was 3200 € >:(
If their prices are high they are going to have a small market too..
-
In the UK it must be Tommy and Lily.
Or maybe this year Willie & Katie?
Sorry - I'm really NOT a Royalist, and as I live outside the UK I should be able to avoid any contact with the regal nuptials.......but WHY do Castagnari give their furniture instruments such silly names? I feel I should be able to order a D/G Tinky-Winky or a C/F Bilbo......
-
I feel I should be able to order a D/G Tinky-Winky or a C/F Bilbo......
I believe that Excelsior makes the "Bilbo" (seriously!).
-
Sorry - I'm really NOT a Royalist, and as I live outside the UK I should be able to avoid any contact with the regal nuptials.......but WHY do Castagnari give their furniture instruments such silly names? I feel I should be able to order a D/G Tinky-Winky or a C/F Bilbo......
I understood from them that the models were all named after family members or workers in their workshops....
-
Castagnari Kriss III
B/C swing tuned LMM
8 months wait.
6 months after receiving it i ordered an extra reed block to make it MMM (by removing the L reed block when ever i wanted) and this took 15 MONTHS!!!! It seems they don't want to know unless you're buying the whole box from them.
-
Castagnari Rik A/D/G
American tremolo, bass switches (to remove thirds and/or low bass notes)
Ordered through the Button Box in 1997, 10 months.
-
I feel I should be able to order a D/G Tinky-Winky or a C/F Bilbo......
I believe that Excelsior makes the "Bilbo" (seriously!).
they do. It's a very close box to a castagnari tommy as well
-
I feel I should be able to order a D/G Tinky-Winky or a C/F Bilbo......
I believe that Excelsior makes the "Bilbo" (seriously!).
they do. It's a very close box to a castagnari tommy as well
Please don't tell me they make a "Gollum" as well........ :D
-
Received a Lilly with custom layout in 4 months. Praise be.