Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Jake Middleton (brinwins) on August 10, 2010, 07:21:10 PM
-
So there I was at Sidmouth and I wanted my Bb accidental to be put onto the pull instead of the push and an E major chord made into an E minor one. I went to a melodeon repair man at his stall and he sat down while I watched flipped the offending Bb reedblocks over and gave them a bit of a scrape with a little buzzing tool that looks like something a dentist would use - also scrapes the E minor note that needs changing, he then checks it as he works on an electric tuner. It doesn't take very long and soon enough my box is in my hands set up how i want it and all sounds fine. It looked easy......
Is what this man just did easy or hard? Im not talking about changing a boxes key or anything like that, just stuff like tuning a slightly out of tune reed.
all the best, Jake
-
Not as hard as you think, not as easy as it looks...
-
Well, is it easy or hard to play a melodeon? I mean...
there I was at Sidmouth and there was this bloke sitting there with a squeezebox in his hands and he just pushed and pulled on the bellows and pressed buttons and music came out - it looked easy....
>:E >:E >:E
It's not hard to fix a single reed, but even the process of scraping material off a reed to change its pitch has a right way and a wrong way, and right and wrong tools to do it with... To get a set of reeds performing optimally is a fine skill, and you also have to learn to tune them without damaging them.
-
Good advice, Mr Cool.
I couldn't have put it better myself.
Come to the Devon SqueezeBox Foundation Access All Areas Melodeon Maintenance Day (bit of a mouthful, Mr Rennie!) and find out how easy it is to damage reeds. See relevant thread.
-
I wish I could come to that, but I believe that I am playing with the Gogs that weekend :(
-
Not as hard as you think, not as easy as it looks...
Very unforgiving task! No going back if you make a mistake... Great fun nevertheless. Practice on spare reeds before doing the ones that will go in your box.
-
and practice with hand tools not things that go buzz, a small file or a sharp scriber, little at a time.
-
Hard!
If you have a little dabble with the odd slight fix on a reed here and there with success ... don't let that fool you in to a false sense of security.
There will always be that first time that you do exactly the same thing with a reed and then it doesn't speak, warbles or just sounds weak or wrong in a way you didn't expect. This is followed by a lot of scrabbling around blindly to try and fix the problem without knowing what's causing it and ends with you going sheepishly to a "proper" tuner to fix or replace the reed you buggered up.
There are just so many factors which make a reed speak correctly and sound nice and to the untrained eye - these little factors are almost invisible but make a huge difference. It's the same feeling tuning with the wrong file or using the file incorrectly - you'll think you're being delicate and the reed doesn't shift much in pitch at all and suddenly, you'll make what you think is the same stroke and it will sharpen the reed by 20 cents (much worse on little high reeds!).
I hate tuning and voicing reeds. I am just too impatient / lack the necessary attention to detail. That is certainly not to say don't have a go ... you might be brilliant! But definitely take the advice given here earlier to try it out on beaten up old boxes first.
I think I respect people who become good at tuning more than I do any other craftsman because I have tried it and it is painfully difficult to be brilliant at. Respect to all you tuners out there.
-
Hard!
If you have a little dabble with the odd slight fix on a reed here and there with success ... don't let that fool you in to a false sense of security.
There will always be that first time that you do exactly the same thing with a reed and then it doesn't speak, warbles or just sounds weak or wrong in a way you didn't expect. This is followed by a lot of scrabbling around blindly to try and fix the problem without knowing what's causing it and ends with you going sheepishly to a "proper" tuner to fix or replace the reed you buggered up.
There are just so many factors which make a reed speak correctly and sound nice and to the untrained eye - these little factors are almost invisible but make a huge difference. It's the same feeling tuning with the wrong file or using the file incorrectly - you'll think you're being delicate and the reed doesn't shift much in pitch at all and suddenly, you'll make what you think is the same stroke and it will sharpen the reed by 20 cents (much worse on little high reeds!).
I hate tuning and voicing reeds. I am just too impatient / lack the necessary attention to detail. That is certainly not to say don't have a go ... you might be brilliant! But definitely take the advice given here earlier to try it out on beaten up old boxes first.
I think I respect people who become good at tuning more than I do any other craftsman because I have tried it and it is painfully difficult to be brilliant at. Respect to all you tuners out there.
I agree that a reed can 'not sound right' for a lot of maddenly different reasons. But, on the other hand, an accordion reed is a piece of steel. Very tough and very forgiving of mistakes, in my experience.
-
I agree that a reed can 'not sound right' for a lot of maddenly different reasons. But, on the other hand, an accordion reed is a piece of steel. Very tough and very forgiving of mistakes, in my experience.
Yes - I have to agree with that. However that doesn't make it any easier to diagnose the little adjustments you need to make!
I didn't want to sound like it was witchcraft - although I have felt like it was in the past. Just to point out that when tuning dabbling goes wrong, it becomes a much bigger subject very quickly.
Cheers
Squeezy
-
and practice with hand tools not things that go buzz, a small file or a sharp scriber, little at a time.
Tell that one to Pete Grassby! (:)
-
and practice with hand tools not things that go buzz, a small file or a sharp scriber, little at a time.
Tell that one to Pete Grassby! (:)
I suspect he is the culprit described in the original message.
-
Probably easier if you have all the tools you need, a tuning gig, an oscilliscope, and most important, an experienced person to help out when it all goes wrong.
That's a lot of conditions, so I'd say hard for most people.
I tuned my harmonica reeds, they'd last about a month, then fail.
-
Hi, cheers for the advice people.
About pete, yeah he was the guy who tuned my melodeon - it was a little thing that looked like a dentists tool. Should he not have used that? or do you mean that its a tool you should only use if you really know what your doing?
jake
-
I've tuned and restored a number of concertinas for folk over the last few years - and the pressure not to mess up is pretty acute when you're handling someone's beloved Wheatstone Aeola. When it comes to my own instruments I'm quite cavalier - but when it's someone else's... :Ph
AL
-
Hi, cheers for the advice people.
About pete, yeah he was the guy who tuned my melodeon - it was a little thing that looked like a dentists tool. Should he not have used that? or do you mean that its a tool you should only use if you really know what your doing?
jake
Pete always uses his Dremel for tuning and has done a number of quick fixes for me (for free) at Witney and they have always been successful and there have been ho longer term issues. But other tuners do not recommend the use of such tools.
-
You can make your own dremel tool from a lady's personal fan, and a round bit from a hobby store. Cost me about $4 usd. Works on harmonica reeds.
I always took away steel at a 45 degree angle. Rinse and repeat as necessary, small amounts at a time. Usually top portion of reed to raise pitch. Factory marks did help, where someone else tuned.
I understand a hobby file is much better. Use of the steel of an old 3 1/4 disk under the reed worked well as a support. Thin enough, yet stable.
-
Ah i see, well pete did do a good job on my box its sounding great, and having played it exclusively for a couple of years as i only own one melodeon I really would notice if something was amiss. however I can appreciate many tuners have their own ways and perhaps would use a different approach than pete - If anyone has any very strong views on this do feel free to PM me ;D
I think If I were to tune a set of reeds I would first go to a tuner I know to see how they do it and what tools they would recomend. then get a broken old accordion/ melodeon to practice on.
FYI I am not planning on immediately doing this, it just interests me as something i might do one day for fun
-
DOnt think Im critising small power tools for tuning. In practiced hands a small rotary grind stone can work very well and leave a great finish but they are not for the beginner and take much more practice to be consistent with. On small fine reeds you have to make sure the direction of rotation is towards the tip of the reed or they can crumple - I learnt the hard way.
-
Hi, cheers for the advice people.
About pete, yeah he was the guy who tuned my melodeon - it was a little thing that looked like a dentists tool. Should he not have used that? or do you mean that its a tool you should only use if you really know what your doing?
jake
The latter!
I have a box with a bass conversion that Pete did with a grinder. Still OK twenty years later which must prove something!
Maybe a bit OTT for spot tuning, I get the impression that the use of Dremel type tools is frowned upon more for aesthetic reasons than anything else.
(Sole thing I have against them is that it is the only tool that has managed to put me in hospital.)
-
You can also wreck a small reed with an inexpertly used file. I learned that the hard way!
A sandpaper file made from medium or fine abrasive paper glued to a small stick is a cheap and gentle way of removing metal from reeds.
-
I get the impression that the use of Dremel type tools is frowned upon more for aesthetic reasons than anything else.
There's certainly that but along with the potential for small mistakes quickly ruining a reed some also argue that the way using them at the base to lower the pitch changes the profile at the side is detrimental and removing metal in one fairly concentrated place rather than taking longer strokes with a scratcher potentially shortens the life of the reed and makes it more likely to break. That's the theory anyway but whether or not it actually works like that in practice is a whole different debate that's beyond the scope of this thread.
I have the posh digital Dremel with a zillion bits and accessories and when I bought it I thought it was going to be so useful but I only use it with one bit and one attachment, both specialised and bought elsewhere, for cutting out soundholes and making the channels for soundhole rings. You can use them to do a lot of things but it's rarely the best tool for the job.
-
You can use them to do a lot of things but it's rarely the best tool for the job.
I couldn't agree more! I too bought the lot and yet have only found very limited use for it - and no power tool ever goes anywhere near any of the concertinas I restore.
AL
-
I've been reading this thread with some interest. My own personal feeling, whether it be right or wrong is: Metal is being removed from the reed tongue to reduce mass either at the tip to raise the pitch, or at the base to lower it. However, providing this is carried out with care and an understanding of the tools and materials used either files or powered tools are ok to use. (I think an angle grinder might be pushing it) :o
Personally I will use a file for tuning as much as I can but there is a point where it is far safer to use a very fine engraving tool, particularly on the smaller reeds (I find the amount of pressure needed to 'scratch' them pushes them out of set anyway)
Look at the reeds of a lot of boxes new or old and they will have been tuned by some sort of mechanical means.
Martyn