Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: hectormc on August 10, 2010, 07:37:51 PM
-
Hi I'm a newby...a harmonica and mandolin player.
Looking to get a Hohner Morgane in B/C how much should I need to pay and where is the best place to get one Im based in Scotland.
Would consider a good second hand one.
Are there any good books on B/C melodeon or should I just figure it out?
regards
-
Depending where you're located, the following accordion shops may be worth a call/visit. They are more likely to stock the Hohner Double Ray than Morgane, but you never know. All have new and second hand stock.
Morag Robertson, The Music Corner, Laurieston, Falkirk 01324 627100
Wilkie's Music House, Perth 01738 623041
John Douglas Accordions, Dumfries 01387 256479
Bruce Miller Music, Aberdeen 01224 577207
Merlin Music, Melrose 01896 822376
Celtic Chords, Stonehaven 01569 763913
Of course, all the main English retailers could supply you by mail order/online.
The only BC book readily available is "The Box" by David Hanrahan (Irish oriented). You'll find a variety of derogatory comments about it on this forum, but it's certainly OK to get you going, and it's cheap. I found it fine to get started with. There are also a number of BC instruction DVDs, Irish/American.
Since you're in Scotland, you'd be able to attend occasional workshops & courses here. They're for Scottish music. Stick around the forum and you'll learn about them. The next one is in September, details here. (http://www.mackaymusic.co.uk/shop/page/8?sessid=VriZycVuPWVdl6Ia8P4k94cN8BhH2bodMOQ0kPyaJi45B2hYgZdaVgJeQMJli08a&shop_param=)
-
Are there any good books on B/C melodeon or should I just figure it out?
Hi Hector - as a harmonica player, you'll take to the box like a duck to water -
-
Are there any good books on B/C melodeon or should I just figure it out?
Hi Hector - as a harmonica player, you'll take to the box like a duck to water -
Very true, however B/C might be a bit different to playing a diatonic harmonica since you'll be using both rows together to play in any key other than B or C, plus, depending on the music you want to play, you might need to learn certain ornamentation techniques. With that in mind a few lessons/pointers etc might be a bit of a help, even tho you're at an advantage as a harmonica player.
Good luck!
Luke
-
I played chromatic harmonica at one point, and have always been curious to try a b/c type system. I don't regret going the quint box route however.
btw is "quint box" a very common term among melodeon players? I learned it here, and it is convenient rather than saying a melodeon with the rows a fifth apart. :P
-
Some say they are a fourth apart! Depends which direction you are looking... D to G or vice-versa!
-
Some say they are a fourth apart! Depends which direction you are looking... D to G or vice-versa!
Musical intervals are quoted from the low note to the high note. In the case of a 2-row D/G melodeon the outer row (D) is the lower pitched row and the inner row (G) is the higher pitched row. So the G-row is pitched a fourth above the D-row. So it is incorrect to call it a 'quint-box'. If you must use such terminology, it ought to be called a 'quad-box'. Similarly for C/F, G/C, etc. instruments.
-
In the case of a 2-row D/G melodeon the outer row (D) is the lower pitched row and the inner row (G) is the higher pitched row. So the G-row is pitched a fourth above the D-row. So it is incorrect to call it a 'quint-box'. If you must use such terminology, it ought to be called a 'quad-box'. Similarly for C/F, G/C, etc. instruments.
Don't quite get the math Steve -
from D to G, in my brain goes
D#/ Eb - E - F- F#-G
i.e D to Eb is one interval, Eb to E is 2, E to F is 3, F to F# is 4, and F# to G is 5
That makes 5 intervals - hence the term quint?
I know I'm probably going to be proved wrong ;) I'm not very good on this technical stuff. But that's how I read it?
Regards
AL
-
Al, in musical terms G is a perfect fourth above D, as it is the fourth note of the diatonic scale. So D to Eb is a minor second, D to E a major second, D to F a minor third, D to F# a major third, D to G a perfect fourth.
-
Al, in musical terms G is a perfect fourth above D, as it is the fourth note of the diatonic scale. So D to Eb is a minor second, D to E a major second, D to F a minor third, D to F# a major third, D to G a perfect fourth.
[/quot
That bit of knowledge must eventually come in handy for something!
george ???
-
D to G a perfect fourth
Or an imperfect 5th then?
;D
But no - still don't really get it actually. Why should whether an interval is a minor second or not have anything to do with how many half-tone intervals there are between notes?
AL
-
Al, in musical terms G is a perfect fourth above D, as it is the fourth note of the diatonic scale. So D to Eb is a minor second, D to E a major second, D to F a minor third, D to F# a major third, D to G a perfect fourth.
That bit of knowledge must eventually come in handy for something!
george ???
Indeed it does. Very very handy.
-
Al, in musical terms G is a perfect fourth above D, as it is the fourth note of the diatonic scale. So D to Eb is a minor second, D to E a major second, D to F a minor third, D to F# a major third, D to G a perfect fourth.
Had time to think - yes makes sense now. Sorry :-[
It's music not maths isn't it?
-
Al, in musical terms G is a perfect fourth above D, as it is the fourth note of the diatonic scale. So D to Eb is a minor second, D to E a major second, D to F a minor third, D to F# a major third, D to G a perfect fourth.
Had time to think - yes makes sense now. Sorry :-[
It's music not maths isn't it?
Yes, it is ;D And it was also invented before we had 12 semitones in a scale, when instead we had 6 church modes (:)
-
It really should be called a "quad box" That's a keeper imo.
-
It really should be called a "quad box" That's a keeper imo.
I hate to jump into a relatively unnecessary musical discussion but Steve's presuming that the G in question is higher than the D. One could often have a D that's higher than a G, which case it's a fifth. I don't play D/G box so I don't know the range of each row but sure there you go.
Another thought is that they're called quint boxes because it makes sense to think of them as boxes with one key and the dominant (5th) related key.
It's also worth mentioning the all of this is of no practical benefit to anyone. Is it? ???
-
One could often have a D that's higher than a G...It's also worth mentioning the all of this is of no practical benefit to anyone. Is it? ???
Possibly, now you know a D row higher than a G row would be unusual. Also, some members were confused by interval relationships. Intervals are probably one of the more useful theory elements compared to other topics.
Actually my question was answered, and quint box distinquishes it from the b/c box well enough in a post for example. Maybe the b/c box is a "semi" box? (:)
-
I hate to jump into a relatively unnecessary musical discussion but Steve's presuming that the G in question is higher than the D. One could often have a D that's higher than a G, which case it's a fifth. I don't play D/G box so I don't know the range of each row but sure there you go.
Watch my lips:
In the case of a 2-row D/G melodeon the outer row (D) is the lower pitched row and the inner row (G) is the higher pitched row. So the G-row is pitched a fourth above the D-row.
;)
Another thought is that they're called quint boxes because it makes sense to think of them as boxes with one key and the dominant (5th) related key.
Actually, that does make some sort of sense. Perhaps you're right ;)
Maybe the b/c box is a "semi" box? (:)
Yes indeed; instruments in B/C, C#/D, C/C# etc., are certainly described as 'semitone boxes' and everyone knows what is meant!
-
It's also worth mentioning the all of this is of no practical benefit to anyone. Is it? ???
I agree - but obviously there are those who get considerable enjoyment out of 'raking the coals' & that fact alone makes such discussion 100% valid!
george ;D
-
OMG what have I gotten into??
Is the predisposition to go off topic in a thread a function of the type of Box you play or is it merely a tendency for all box players...If the former surely its easier if you have a chromatic inclination, or does that only apply to keys?
Thanks for all the advice BTW.
-
OMG what have I gotten into??
Is the predisposition to go off topic in a thread a function of the type of Box you play or is it merely a tendency for all box players...If the former surely its easier if you have a chromatic inclination, or does that only apply to keys?
Thanks for all the advice BTW.
many classically trained piano accordion players seem to view push/pull persons as an undisciplined lot and this makes me proud to be a push/pull man. It may also explain our propensity for and obvious enjoyment of thread drift!
george ;D
-
classically trained piano accordion players seem to view push/pull persons as an undisciplined lot
If only Hohner could produce a Morgane with keys instead of buttons then they'd have a really good instrument on their hands >:E
Btw - I have heard of and seen problems with their [Morgane] treble buttons, - has anyone else experienced this?
-
Btw - I have heard of and seen problems with their [Morgane] treble buttons, - has anyone else experienced this?
Yes. They have a tendency to undo themselves and fly off. A drop of "light" breakable glue when reinstalling them helps to prevent this. Don't use anything strong, because they're mushroom buttons; if you ever need to get under the keyboard you'll have to take them off first before you can remove the cover. Liberal use of Loctite or similar cyanoacrylate glues makes this difficult if not impossible!
-
A question to anyone with sufficient knowledge will eventually lead to a esoteric answers, especially if the answers are presented in the company of others with similar knowledge.
-
Btw - I have heard of and seen problems with their [Morgane] treble buttons, - has anyone else experienced this?
When DTN plays his for the morris, the rest of the band pick up the buttons he has shed - he's normally already off doing something else by then. Makes a change from picking up all manner of bits he used to shed from his Pokerwork, though - bellows pins, bass end, etc. ::)
Rob.
-
When DTN plays his for the morris, the rest of the band pick up the buttons he has shed - he's normally already off doing something else by then. Makes a change from picking up all manner of bits he used to shed from his Pokerwork, though - bellows pins, bass end, etc. ::)
Rob.
I thought DTN had moved on to Castagnari-busting? Or is that a piece of multi-tasking by him?
I find wearing shoes with soft-ish rubber soles helps with the Morgane problem. If you're lucky, the button tops land with the spike uppermost and stick in your soles like drawing pins. You can then do some buck and wing or step dancing and then fish them out with a penknife. A bit of a problem if someone else treads on them and walks off, never to be seen again.
-
Not recommended for accompanying clog dancing; at least, not of you want to reuse the buttons.....Crrrruuunch!!! :M
-
Yes. They have a tendency to undo themselves and fly off. A drop of "light" breakable glue when reinstalling them helps to prevent this.
I used a "gasket maker" product available from auto parts shops. Another solution is the "crafter's goop" which is another rubbery compound that does the trick.
-
I thought i just played a D/G box and a B/C box and now I find that I play a qint/quad box(depending on your oppion) and a semitone box, I wonder if they will sound any better now when I play them, now they have technical names ???? :|||: :|||: :|||:
-
until I joined this forum my boxes thought of themselves as humble- DG,BC etc. devices- I presume my Dg box still thinks its a plain Dg box & similarly by BC & BCC#s remain content with their humble titles . Despite the fact that I have repeatedly told them they are quint quad semitone or whatever they flatly refuse to improve in any way!
How do I get them to act up to their newly found grand titles?
george :(
-
I've been playing my Morgane BC fairly intensively for about 6 months and so far, touch wood, no problems with buttons and box is a delight to play. :Ph
-
Hello Hectormc...The Squeezebox shop near Inverness have a range of new and secondhand two and three row melodeons in stock...tel 01463 741423...