Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Huw on August 11, 2010, 04:12:51 PM

Title: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Huw on August 11, 2010, 04:12:51 PM
I have a Saltarelle Nuage with a ""wood" finish grille which doesn't look as attractive as the chrome one to me.
I have emailed Saltarelle to see if I can buy a new chrome one , haven't had a reply as yet.
I doubt very much if anyone has got one spare, but I thought I saw somewhere that there was somebody who was making grilles with all sorts of fancy designs might have been in brass  or aluminium , anyone got any info on who they might be ?
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Prestidigitator on August 12, 2010, 09:01:29 AM
I had the same sort of dilemma with a new box from France (not Salterelle) which arrived with wooden grille (a flat one rather than the curved variety).

I'm in Suffolk, and I made a few enquiries of metal workers who have laser cutting/CNC facilities, and all were able to make me a "tin" one to my design; albeit at a price.

In the end, I decided to try to make my own using a sheet of stainless steel which had formed a part of my outgoing heating boiler. It's not difficult, but there's plenty of room for error and cause for cursing. I have a small session on it when I feel so inclined, and will likely finish it in time to give it to myself as a Christmas present.

The box arrived Autumn 2009, and, adapting an old adage, we don't have an expression in the Suffolk dialect which expresses the urgency contained in the word "mañana"!
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 12, 2010, 09:24:41 AM
The ryallarmouries.co.uk (http://ryallarmouries.co.uk/) have offered to make me a bespoke grille to replace the brass one Gaillard (http://www.accordeonsgaillard.fr/) always puts in (and that no one else seems to like).  I'm temporising just now as 1. I cannot think of a design and 2. Gaillard's is actually starting to grow on me!  

If anyone here wants an artisan bespoke metal grille cut, they could contact Fred Ryall directly.  He's very good at cutouts, having gone bonkers on stencils as a lad. Now works in metal and leather as per his website.  Doesn't use lasers though ...

PS have attached stencil example (once used as my ativar).  Of course the template was rather sharper.

PPS - AFAIK Satarelle don't actually 'make' anything. Their kit is badge engineered from Italy

(I "declare an interest" here  .. Fred being #1 son)
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: ganderbox on August 12, 2010, 09:32:13 AM
I had the same sort of dilemma with a new box from France (not Salterelle) which arrived with wooden grille (a flat one rather than the curved variety).

I've got one of these boxes as well, and I too wondered about the metal grille, but didn't do anything about it.

However, I have just acquired a Saltarelle Pastourelle II which leapt into my arms from the Music Room stand at Sidmouth, and it has a  grille which looks like wood, but is in fact metal. It has the most amazing sound, and I'm now thinking again about a metal grille for my "box from France (not Saltarelle)", so I'd welcome any info on their availability.

I've just read your post, Chris, and I'll have a look at that, thanks.
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Prestidigitator on August 12, 2010, 09:57:17 AM

I've got one of these boxes as well, and I too wondered about the metal grille, but didn't do anything about it.

However, I have just acquired a Saltarelle Pastourelle II which leapt into my arms from the Music Room stand at Sidmouth, and it has a  grille which looks like wood, but is in fact metal. It has the most amazing sound, and I'm now thinking again about a metal grille for my "box from France (not Saltarelle)", so I'd welcome any info on their availability.

I made some more overtures about this after we last corresponded but got no further than before. I formed the impression there just weren't any spare ones to be had, at any price, but I may be quite wrong. Anyway, that's why I went the DIY route, with the added joy of some vanity grillework. Looking at it, Chris Ryall's suggestion is very interesting, and that way I might have a metal grille before Christmas (2010, not 2011 onwards as seems possible) and some uncut fingers.

You seem to have a magnetic attraction for nice melodeons. I can't seem to "pull" anything under 60 years old these days.

Peter
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Huw on August 12, 2010, 10:53:53 AM
Thanks for your replies, a few weeks in the shed with my dremel would probably be one option.
The grille on the Nuage after having a good look at it is infact aluminium with plastic woodgrain finish glued on, first thought was to peel  the finish it off but no going back once you've gone down that route.
Next thought after removing grille simply turn it over remove grille cloth, polish the aluminium and replace cloth to the " wood" side , can always be reversed to put back to original. Away to start polishing!
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Prestidigitator on August 12, 2010, 11:30:05 AM
The grille on the Nuage after having a good look at it is infact aluminium with plastic woodgrain finish glued on, first thought was to peel  the finish it off but no going back once you've gone down that route.
Next thought after removing grille simply turn it over remove grille cloth, polish the aluminium and replace cloth to the " wood" side , can always be reversed to put back to original. Away to start polishing!

Thanks, Huw.
I've got a couple of boxes with the keyboard covers aluminium covered in wood-effect Fablon (or whatever). Having long admired the Briggs keyboards, I've been idly wondering how to achieve the bare metal effect without messing the thing up irrevocably; and now you've given me the answer.
The next best thing to lateral thinking is to have some other clever person do it for you.
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: ganderbox on August 12, 2010, 01:31:47 PM

You seem to have a magnetic attraction for nice melodeons. I can't seem to "pull" anything under 60 years old these days.

Peter


Sadly young virgins come at a price! (although the Music Room have just reduced their Salterelles).

As my collection is now approaching double figures I'm thinking I ought to rationalise them, and just keep the ones that really get played out and about, but I don't want to part with any of them.
Definitely "one in, one out" from now on, though.

 ("Oh, yeah", I hear you say!)
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Huw on August 12, 2010, 01:49:20 PM
Reversed and polished, and it cost nowt.
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Prestidigitator on August 12, 2010, 03:51:15 PM

Sadly young virgins come at a price! (although the Music Room have just reduced their Salterelles).

As my collection is now approaching double figures I'm thinking I ought to rationalise them, and just keep the ones that really get played out and about, but I don't want to part with any of them.
Definitely "one in, one out" from now on, though.

 ("Oh, yeah", I hear you say!)

I should think that the chorus of "Oh, yeah"s from the British Isles and the Rest Of The World have momentarily drowned out any other sounds in Cornwall.
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: ocd on August 12, 2010, 04:54:51 PM
The box arrived Autumn 2009, and, adapting an old adage, we don't have an expression in the Suffolk dialect which expresses the urgency contained in the word "mañana"!

People are often under the mistaken expression that "mañana" means "tomorrow".  Effectively, it means "not today".

ocd
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: ganderbox on August 12, 2010, 05:02:36 PM


I should think that the chorus of "Oh, yeah"s from the British Isles and the Rest Of The World have momentarily drowned out any other sounds in Cornwall.

So that's what frightened the hens.

Oh ye of little faith!  :|||: :|||: :Ph :|glug


The box arrived Autumn 2009, and, adapting an old adage, we don't have an expression in the Suffolk dialect which expresses the urgency contained in the word "mañana"!

People are often under the mistaken expression that "mañana" means "tomorrow".  Effectively, it means "not today".

ocd

You mean like dreckly?
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Lester on August 12, 2010, 05:04:42 PM
The box arrived Autumn 2009, and, adapting an old adage, we don't have an expression in the Suffolk dialect which expresses the urgency contained in the word "mañana"!

But the Cornish have the word "drecly" which almost certainly covers the situation.  ;D
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Mike Averill on August 12, 2010, 08:37:23 PM
You might consider approaching one of the concertina makers with a shorter waiting list. John Connor in Rochford hand frets Stainless concertina ends and is very helpfull for one off,custom jobs.
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: ganderbox on August 12, 2010, 09:33:51 PM
The box arrived Autumn 2009, and, adapting an old adage, we don't have an expression in the Suffolk dialect which expresses the urgency contained in the word "mañana"!

But the Cornish have the word "drecly" which almost certainly covers the situation.  ;D

As I said. But there is definitely a k in dreckly.

You might consider approaching one of the concertina makers with a shorter waiting list. John Connor in Rochford hand frets Stainless concertina ends and is very helpfull for one off,custom jobs.

Thanks for the (on topic) suggestion, Mike.
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: oggiesnr on August 13, 2010, 07:11:03 PM
My day job (one of them) is as a fretworker, ie I cut shapes in wood.  I also can cut shapes in metal and have done a similar job in the past.  As with any job like this price depends on complexity (how long is the cutting line) and thickness of material, it's worth spending some time so as to get maximum effect for the shortest possible line.  Likewise you don't want to make the material so thick that cutting speed is reduced to a crawl and blades blunt every inch or so.

The one advantage of doing one offs the old-fashioned way is that you don't have the set up costs of a laser or plasma cutter, all you need is a full size drawing and the piece of metal.

Steve
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Huw on August 13, 2010, 07:31:25 PM
Thanks for that Steve, in a past life I was a fitter /machinist so understand a bit about the differences and durability in cutting and polishing brass, stainless, aluminium etc.  I was wondering what sort of ball park figure someone would charge for a one off stainless grille, hardest to work I know ,as I really have no idea.
 I stumbled across a website recently, I think it might have been a french box maker who had some fantastic grilles , celtic designs , cobwebs with spider, and believe it or not a donkey! not my cup of tea that one but it made me think of all sorts of possibilities, just wish I could find the site again.  
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Stiamh on August 13, 2010, 09:07:16 PM
Reversed and polished, and it cost nowt.

Now you just need to give the keyboard plate the same treatment and it'll look really spiffy!
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: JohnA on August 13, 2010, 09:50:23 PM
Huw
Is this is the site you are trying to relocate?
http://yvusaccordeons.free.fr/anglais/yvus-accordions.html
Cheers     John
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Broadland Boy on August 13, 2010, 10:59:15 PM
Rather than laser or plasma cutting stainless steel, look for someone who does water jet cutting - this leaves a finish which on thin material like this needs no further treatment for cutting burrs etc. as it leaves none and unlike laser / plasma as there is no heat there is no oxide discolouration or hardening along the cut lines - also works in plastic and can be made to work on wood if sealed before cutting.

Modern CAD/CAM means that if you can produce a drawing of the finished item to scale, the machine can often absorb or convert its cutting path from a DXF (drawing exchange format) file. Unlike CNC lathes / mills there is very little operator involvement needed in setting appropriate tools, tool offsets machining speeds etc. before the toolpath is created.

Richard - who does not have one of these marvels in his workshop  :(
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: oggiesnr on August 13, 2010, 11:14:19 PM
Only problem with a water cutter is the hourly cost.  Even with recent reductions in price (a decade ago they were around a quarter million for one to do this type of work) they are not cheap and that is reflected in the hourly cost.  They (like lasers etc) really come into their own for bulk, repeatable work (100 melodeon grills) not for one offs.

Steve
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Huw on August 14, 2010, 07:24:49 AM
Huw
Is this is the site you are trying to relocate?
http://yvusaccordeons.free.fr/anglais/yvus-accordions.html
Cheers     John]
Well done John , yes thats the site fantastic aren't they, didn't get the Hascy, so what about a Yvus..............
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Prestidigitator on August 14, 2010, 09:52:55 AM
Being more of a metal butcher than worker, I've found some useful insights here. The water cutting method sounds ideal if it weren't for the cost.

I've tried various methods of cutting out my evolving design (i.e it started out far too elaborate) on scrap pieces, including fretsaws and nibblers. The best fretsaw was a very old one with a round (as opposed to flat) blade which, if the kerf was properly allowed for, gave the cleanest and most accurate cut. Naturally I broke the blade and nowhere can I find another. Any recommendations on suitable tools would be gratefully received.

The worst thing is cleaning up the cut edges, as it is very easy to alter the design subtly when filing or stoning, so that it doesn't exactly match the paper template. I've got enough stainless sheet for 5 tries, if I don't despair and hand the job on to someone else.
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Broadland Boy on August 14, 2010, 08:46:13 PM
True Steve, I was forgetting my devious ways might not be so common, you go to the back door during lunch time, take a bu@@ered attempt, a scale drawing of what you want, a blank sheet (and a playable box) look dumb and / or pathetic and find a fabricator, they will not be able to resist improving on your poor attempt and you may even get the job done for nowt - (playing for them would in most cases be an added bonus), if this happens you must insist on them having a fiver / tenner for the tea fund or for a drink for the lads - never know when you might want another.
Universal rule #1 of fabricators, never work for a firm where you can't do 'foreigners'.

I bought some steel tube for bench legs last summer from our local fabricators, it came out of a length which had been badly bent and no real use to them so there was a discount, I next asked for some short bits as runners across the top and was pointed at the offcuts bin - take what you need, when the 'swedish brick' could hold no more I went back to pay 'more trouble than it's worth, glad to see it being used' says the man, so left a fiver for the tea fund. Last week I was filling up with petrol and gets a tap on the shoulder - the same chap "you ought to come and have a look in the offcuts bin as its going to be emptied next week" - another rear suspension straining visit later I have finally run out of undercover space to store steel stock :)


Prestidigitator - I usually get my piercing saw blades from Proops over near Leicester (although off their stand at Model Engineering shows which always has a concertina or two displayed as one of their number is a hexboxenist)

their url - http://www.proopsbrothers.com/acatalog/index.html

Piercing Saw Blades Ref: M0276
72 Assorted Largest Dim 150mm Price: £3.95

Am I right in thinking you a Suffolkist ? do you ever get Norwich way ? in which case you can have a look / try of my stock blades and find a suitable one to send as a sample of what you want - their mixed packs are good unless you have a particular job likely to wreck a number of one size - oh and use a lump of tallow / paraffin / beeswax touched on the blade periodically to keep the blade lubricated - they last longer.....

Richard
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: oggiesnr on August 14, 2010, 10:08:37 PM
For decent metal cutting saw blades try here http://hegner.co.uk/system/index.html (http://hegner.co.uk/system/index.html).  Follow the links the Hegner machines, then scroll saws, then blades.

The spiral blades are not really meant for metal (which is probably why your's broke.

Steve

Typos fixed
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Broadland Boy on August 14, 2010, 11:41:50 PM
I know of Hegner scroll saws by their (excellent) reputation Steve but didn't realise they did a piercing saw size - I'll have to give them a try - and tis true that the Proops blades are not top quality like the Swiss blades which Walsh supply but if they are not forced I find them pretty durable by hand and they even stand up to use in my (cheap, nasty, not Hegner) scroll saw reasonably well if I keep the speed down.

I've had mixed results with spiral cut blades, dry in brass and wet in Ali works reasonably but can't recall ever trying one on stainless - Abrafile used to make a variety of lengths and cuts of about 1mm dia material which worked well on SS in a saw frame but I've not seen them about for years - no doubt someone on the web is selling them but I've not looked - cut down for a fret frame I used about 3 to cut out my weathervane in 2mm stainless (a Fowler BB1 ploughing engine) many moons ago and swore I'd never do another  (:)

Pdigitator, whatever you do in stainless, do it with the tool working slower than for a similar cut in mild steel, especially drilling, rarely do electric hand or pillar drills have a low enough speed and sawing / filing even in thin sheet can still harden it, which then takes the edge off the tool. and if nothing else a rub with a candle on the blade will help ease your way.

Richard
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Prestidigitator on August 15, 2010, 09:50:22 AM

Am I right in thinking you a Suffolkist ? do you ever get Norwich way ? in which case you can have a look / try of my stock blades and find a suitable one to send as a sample of what you want - their mixed packs are good unless you have a particular job likely to wreck a number of one size - oh and use a lump of tallow / paraffin / beeswax touched on the blade periodically to keep the blade lubricated - they last longer.....

Richard
Richard,
That's a very generous offer; and thanks for the advice. I'm Southwold way (one of the few natives, in fact) and I do get to Norwich from time to time. My son lives there, and I like to listen to Tony H whenever I can. It was hearing him (and some of the old Suffolk boys in various pubs hereabouts) play when I was at the art school there in the 60's that persuaded me to give up playing the 5-string banjo very badly and play the melodeon even worse. Might get the hang of it one day, I hope.
Some time after Henham Steam Rally in September is likely best for me, and I'll PM you then, if that's OK.

Thanks,
Peter
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 17, 2010, 09:12:45 AM
It'll be very hard work with a fret saw. They are really for wood, although I've seen a chap fenestrate the old 1d coins with this to make jewelry.  Fred uses a plasma cutter for his thin metal fretwork. I guess lasers are the coming thing industrially - but perhaps not for the artisan.
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: Broadland Boy on August 17, 2010, 03:36:04 PM
Piercing saw is the metal cutting equivalent of a fretsaw Chris, frames are typically not so deep but blades are interchangeable - long and laborious job all the same  :(

@Added 17/08 - Chris, have seen the same done with the old 1/2d with a ship on the reverse having had its rigging etc cut out - a labour of love ! @

Lasers / plasma cutters are fine but especially in stainless the clean up is a real PITA as the edges and burrs harden and discolour the steel hence my suggestion of waterjet (where you can stack the work so could make 10+ at a time and there is little if any cleanup needed) As Steve pointed out the capital cost of these is enormous which is reflected in the 'front door' prices charged, however it is a method of preparation which a lot of model engineers are now using economically compared with milling out of the flat for things like locomotive frame parts and entire wagon part sets, they design in slots and tabs so you can 'kit build' say a set of frames and then weld over the tabs to secure  (:)

The other possibility I'd not considered earlier is someone who does deep engraving on a CNC machine but it still needs a scale drawing as a starting point and hardening rears its ugly head again

Richard
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: boxlad on August 17, 2010, 04:06:13 PM
Here is one that has been redone on a Paolo Soprani. It looks like a nice job and was carried out by Benedict Koehler. Google him for more info.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=290462207418&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT#ht_500wt_1154
Title: Re: Bespoke Grille
Post by: oggiesnr on August 17, 2010, 04:52:09 PM
What thickness of stainless steel are we talking about here?  I've a bit of free-er time coming up so I might have a play.

Steve
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal