Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: melodeon on August 17, 2010, 06:41:48 AM

Title: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: melodeon on August 17, 2010, 06:41:48 AM
I have a new to me 2 row, 3 reed Lmm  single stop for the L,  Castagnari arriving soon; pending tuning to preference.

To date I have preferred dry or a whisper of tremolo similar to Castagnaris "swing" which is by comparisonm to other makes
a rather slow beat.

I am wondering about suitability and preference of tuning for a more recent/modern(e) style of playing
specifically French ... or those playing French style music ...
Yes I realize that is a bit broad  ... but I am considering the sound that players such as Frederic Paris,
they guy from Caruhel.. Yann Dour (sp) ... or as in the sound that Milleret/Pignol
... yes I realize that often they play octave tuned boxes and three rows, but they have been known
to play 2 rows....

What tuning preferences do Brits prefer on 2 row boxes specifically referring to Italian instruments for other than Morris..
when using other than D/G.. ie Blowzabella, Andy Cutting,  or even Tim Eady....

And what Quebec 2 row players such as the folks from Vente du Nord  get.. I believe I have seen them using a 2 row G

Any idea of the tuning on this ( these) video (s)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rMaQdaw-28

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CaoQ22YQCGQ

My intent is to play alone or max with one other stringed instrument such as guitar or fiddle, perhaps the dreaded banjo..
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 17, 2010, 08:28:19 AM
My Oakwood is 2 voice in wide swing (by the sound of it).   My Gaillard is 2 voice in L/M (bandoneón) - as are virtually all the Gaillards played in the Pignol/Milleret orbit. eg last February in Vogüé there was a pile of 8 bandoneon tuned Gaillard Saphires in the middle of the boeuf at about midnight - you might buy a small apartment here in Liverpool for rather less!  AFAIR Frédéric Paris plays swing Castagnari 2-rows

I like very much having the two voicings available. D/G swing for UK sessions and moody bandoneón for introspective contemplative stuff. That low voice C/G is like chocolate!

Have I discovered the cure for MAD? We'll see.  Your LMM would seem to offer the same flexibility albeit usually at a weight penalty. Good luck.
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: Tamba on August 18, 2010, 05:46:12 AM
Chris,
Could you please explain exactly what Bandoneon tuning is? I can see that is 2 voice L/M but how are they tuned in relation to each other. That is to say are they a perfect octave apart or is there some wetness in there? Apologies if this is an obvious and stupid question.

Thanks, from Tim in stormstruck Singapore, really missing his Saltarelle Epsilon!!
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 18, 2010, 06:40:12 AM
I picked up 'bandoneón' as a named tuning style talking to french players and makers. As ever in the free reed world, bandoneón is actually quite a complex mix of instruments, related more to Anglo concertina than our box, and originating from Germany.  

It was very popular in Argentine - classically as a 'salon' instrument (most simply say 'brothel') and came over to Paris early 20th century where it had the same, shall we say louche reputation. It's 'the symbol of the tango'

  This is a good web reference http://www.gardelweb.com/bandoneon.htm

Says there are various tunings, but the one associated with the tango, and later jazz crazes has two reeds per note in strict octave - no vibrato at all. This is the usage I'd picked up on and I think it is a useful one. Certainly the Gaillard in L+M mode enjoys a tango, whereas the Oakwood's swing loses that certain je ne sais quoi

So it is a classic 'French' tuning albeit an imported one .  The other being musette - wet as Nantes in february. The French folkies of our epoch play all manner of tunings though.


[edit] One thing we've not touched on is stability. It seems to me that any form of tremelo seems to stabilise - my Oakwood is rock-like in this regard. The Gaillard in single note mode can be bent noticably.   Even in bandoneón mode "it moves" - but isn't that is what the Tango is all about?  ;)
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: Tamba on August 18, 2010, 07:19:01 AM
Many thanks for explaining that to me Chris.
 
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: ganderbox on August 18, 2010, 08:45:59 AM
The boxes I like to use for French, Breton, Blowzabella etc are (not surprisingly)  my  Loffets - a 2 voice G/C and a 3 voice (LMM) D/G, both swing tuned.
Swing can of course mean different things, but his website gives  definitions, and examples, of the tunings he offers.
http://diato.org/accord.htm

and he says that swing is one he likes best.

The 2 voice G/C sounds great as it is, and I don't miss the third voice, although I think the D/G is better for having the low reed option.



Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: melodeon on August 18, 2010, 04:18:27 PM
True,  Swing can mean almost any degree of wet

Saltarelles "swing" is more like Castagnari's "Americano"

I think I will opt for Castagnari's swing which is a very low beat.

I have a late 1800's 2 row in "bandoneon" tuning on the 4 or 5 lower reeds.
Very nice sound

The Tex Mex 3 row players such as El Parche ( Esteban "Steve" Jordan)
use a form of bandoneon tuning on the lower reeds... octave reeded
and then  dry tuned MM upward.  They call it "jazz" tuning
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: Tyker on August 18, 2010, 04:24:46 PM

http://diato.org/accord.htm

and he says that swing is one he likes best.

The 2 voice G/C sounds great as it is, and I don't miss the third voice, although I think the D/G is better for having the low reed option.



I , too , like his 2-voice swing tuning.
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: rees on August 18, 2010, 04:55:58 PM


The Tex Mex 3 row players such as El Parche ( Esteban "Steve" Jordan)
use a form of bandoneon tuning on the lower reeds... octave reeded
and then  dry tuned MM upward.  They call it "jazz" tuning

Jeff, can you expand on this?
At what point in the scale does it change from LM to MM?
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: EeeJay on August 18, 2010, 05:08:47 PM
The Tex Mex 3 row players such as El Parche ( Esteban "Steve" Jordan)
use a form of bandoneon tuning on the lower reeds... octave reeded
and then  dry tuned MM upward.  They call it "jazz" tuning

Indeed... there's a bit on YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmD5fLV9u4g), where you can see the size/length of the reeds - and thereby, where the modification is made. I'd guess it's a little like the idea with the Bouzouki... where you have that octave strung bottom end to fill the sound out...

This is one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gn6EGZLSXXU) in action... complete with just a smidge of typical Hohner clatter - looks like it might be a seriously re-worked Hohner Panther... 8)

Ed J
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: LDbosca on August 18, 2010, 08:14:31 PM


This is one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gn6EGZLSXXU) in action... complete with just a smidge of typical Hohner clatter - looks like it might be a seriously re-worked Hohner Panther... 8)

Ed J

Go on the lad! Jayzus!
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: rees on August 18, 2010, 11:36:48 PM


This is one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gn6EGZLSXXU) in action... complete with just a smidge of typical Hohner clatter - looks like it might be a seriously re-worked Hohner Panther... 8)

Ed J

Go on the lad! Jayzus!

Mind-blowing!
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: rees on August 19, 2010, 10:47:14 AM
OK  >:( .. but his left hand's crap  :P

What's wrong with 13 air buttons?  ;D
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: LDbosca on August 19, 2010, 12:11:33 PM
OK  >:( .. but his left hand's crap  :P

Do people play the left hand in this type of music??
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: rees on August 19, 2010, 12:37:19 PM
Not really and they very often remove all the reed blocks in the left hand, hence 13 air buttons.

Back in the time of Santiago Jimenez Snr (Flaco's dad) and Narcisso Martinez the standard instrument for Tex-Mex was a two row Hohner and the basses were occasionally employed, but since the advent of the 3 row Corona no basses are used.
The accompaniment in the classic Conjunto band is Bajo Sexto and Double Bass.
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: Steve C. on August 19, 2010, 01:24:56 PM
In San Antonio I have seen 3-row players who can do the MOST AMAZING things with all 5 fingers on the treble but who cannot play ANY bass.  They play with bands and say, who needs it?
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: LDbosca on August 19, 2010, 01:40:59 PM
Not really and they very often remove all the reed blocks in the left hand, hence 13 air buttons.

Back in the time of Santiago Jimenez Snr (Flaco's dad) and Narcisso Martinez the standard instrument for Tex-Mex was a two row Hohner and the basses were occasionally employed, but since the advent of the 3 row Corona no basses are used.
The accompaniment in the classic Conjunto band is Bajo Sexto and Double Bass.

Thought so. When a guy plays like him on the right-hand I don't worry about his left hand too much.

Did anyone click any related links? The voice-overs on some of his videos are really, really funny...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4DwhPuoQz2k&feature=related
"First you get de money, then you get de accordeen, then you get de weemen..."

Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: rees on August 19, 2010, 01:53:50 PM

"First you get de money, then you get de accordeen, then you get de weemen..."



Works every time (in my dreams)  8)
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: EeeJay on August 19, 2010, 02:01:21 PM
Did anyone click any related links? The voice-overs on some of his videos are really, really funny...

Erm, quite. (:) Then again it's just hyperbolic marketing... pulls some punters in...

When a guy plays like him on the right-hand I don't worry about his left hand too much.

Need to check out the right links... (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xg2NKMAX8qM) 8)

'Scuse the thread drift... :|bl

Ed J
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: rees on August 19, 2010, 02:12:23 PM
What a player, so lyrical.

Definitely no bass blocks in that last video as there are a couple of places where the bellows shoots out to full stretch and back in in a fraction of a second - not possible with only one air button.

Someone suggested earlier that this might be a customised Panther. I think not as it has the wooden fingerboard as found on the old Coronas and the new Corona Classic.
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: LDbosca on August 19, 2010, 02:30:59 PM


Erm, quite. (:) Then again it's just hyperbolic marketing... pulls some punters in...


No it's not! This one http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZPuyvFK8LM&feature=related , which is an actual single, has a hilarious spoken intro and a vocoderizer on the chorus!! Amazing!
 :D
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: melodeon on August 19, 2010, 03:28:20 PM
eejay
In you first post with the link to "this one"

I can't bring it up

who is the player and what is the title so I can look it up on youtube

Thanks...

These Tex Mex guys are amazing players

my favorites are  Steve Jordan ( El Parche)  and  Joel Guzman

Steve plays Hohners.. and has an endorsed model
Joel plays Hohners and lately Baffettis.. one with a 48/50 stradella bass set up
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: Anahata on August 19, 2010, 03:59:48 PM
my favorites are  Steve Jordan ( El Parche)  and  Joel Guzman
Steve plays Hohners..

not any more, apparently (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4756.0.html)  :(
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: EeeJay on August 19, 2010, 07:39:11 PM

In you first post with the link to "this one"... I can't bring it up

who is the player and what is the title so I can look it up on youtube

Link is:- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gn6EGZLSXXU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gn6EGZLSXXU)... title is:- 'AJ Castillo Jammin Unplugged'...

Ed J
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: melodeon on August 19, 2010, 09:51:02 PM
Thanks.. excellent video

Steve Jordan had been ill for some time. His death was not unexpected.

His legacy will not only be greatness, but originality.

He took the box into another world.
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: Steve C. on August 19, 2010, 11:19:25 PM
My recently acquired Benny is about 1/2 bps at C on the C row, was wanting more of a French sound than the Hohners I am used to.  It is "almost" too dry.
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: melodeon on August 21, 2010, 03:56:05 AM
Some years back I got a  dry tuned Serenellini C#/D from Chambers.  Excellent box in all respects.. 
however, I felt that this particular accordeon was needing a bit of tremolo... just the character
of the box and the sound of the reeds.

I got another Serenellini 233 deluxe 233 ( Cloud) nuage style.. it was supposed to be "swing" but was more on the order
of what I experiemced in Americano tuned bos]xes

This point to 2 things..
1 different makers tune diffrerently though called the same
and some accordeons are just needing and sound best in a particular degree of wetness/dry.
Title: Re: Modern(e) G/C Tuning Preferences
Post by: ganderbox on August 21, 2010, 07:55:34 AM
I think tuning is much more of a black art than just a case of doing it by numbers.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal