Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: SylviaUK on April 17, 2008, 12:03:58 PM
-
Hello there
I am hoping some of you might be able to help me with a couple of queries about starting to learn how to play Klezmer or "Balkan/Italian" style music.
Firstly, is this type of music best learnt on a melodeon, or an accordion? Or does it really matter which instrument I choose?
If a melodeon is suitable, what type or style of instrument? 24-48 bass keys have been suggested, plus something which covers all the sharps & flats I'd need on melody & chords.
Lastly - suggestions on reasonable price ranges & makes please. I would have a budget of around £200 (i.e. obviously in the UK), and not much beyond that, so perhaps second-hand is the way to go?
Any help or suggestions gratefully received, thanks.
Regards,
Sylvia
-
Hi Sylvia and welcome.
I don't know much about the styles you are interested in, but enough to suggest that there are big differences between the three you have mentioned, and even within Italian music there are lots of regional variations. For example in Southern Italy the Organetto is king and is used for playing relatively simple very fast, repetitive dance tunes. If you search the forum you will find quite a range of information on the Oranetto and its repertoire. My limited knowledge of the other two styles is that they are quite chromatic, and use distinctive modes which are probably quite difficult to play on the melodeon.
I suggest you look for examples of your kind of music on youtube and see what instruments are being used.
-
how to play Klezmer
The problem with Klezmer on melodeon is that most songs use the 'klezmer' scales. In particular the 1st, 4th and 5th mode of the harmonic minor, requiring notes that aren't on the standard melodeon.
-
Klezmer scales make some very nice patterns on a half-step box, just a matter of choosing the right one so they come out in the right key!
That music is very chromatic and often played in flat keys. Some of George's comments about B/C/C# boxes in that discussion here might be helpful.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=176.0
I think Jax Delaguerre plays Klezmer etc on the Club style box. He has a wonderful site at
http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/index.html
All that said, and I hate to say it here, but I suspect this music is usually piano accordion territory. No doubt there are exceptions, but a quick google images search on klezmer accordion tends to confirm that.
Within your budget a PA is probably more realistic too.
Tom
-
Klezmer scales make some very nice patterns on a half-step box...
De Dannan recorded two blazing Klezmer pieces under the title "Two Jewish Reels" on the album Ballroom, with Mairtin O Connor on C#/D box. You should be able to listen a bit of them on this page http://www.amazon.com/Ballroom-Dannan/dp/B000005CSD - except I couldn't make the clip play.
But it will take you an awful long time to learn to play like Mairtin O Connor. Like Tom, I think you'd be far better off with a piano accordion, quite common in Klezmer, or a continental chromatic.
-
I think Jax Delaguerre plays Klezmer etc on the Club style box. He has a wonderful site at
http://www.delaguerre.com/delaguerre/pedagogy/club/index.html
Club is more than adequate to play Klezmer music given the Club player's choice of the tonic.
Klezmer is not so much "chromatic" as "scale-oriented" like Middle Eastern and Hindustani and Irish music. It's just that some of the scales have 12 tones in them. Or more :-)
One cliché chord change for Klez is Im-IVm-V(7 or m7). You could do that rooted in D on a Club C/F. Another is I-VIIbm. You could do that in F on a C/F.
-
Interesting discussion here. I myself was drawn to the Box by way of Klezmer and Balkan music, I've been an avid listener of eastern European folk since my childhood. (Anything from Roma laments to Bartók.)
I played a little guitar and harmonica before, mostly by ear - Pretending to be Woody Guthrie and what not. ;)
What little music theory I know isn't worth mentioning. But as far as I know a G/C/F diatonic box would be suitable for Klezmer and Russian modes. I've seen Russian folk-song books written for G/C/F and G/C 2.5 step so I deducted the obvious.
Maybe I'm assuming too much here. Luckily I also enjoy valse musette's & tarantella's, which I know is definitely box territory so I won't regret picking up a Melodeon. But if I have to buy a Bayan one day and grind away at learning that too, so be it. ;D