Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on August 21, 2010, 10:27:35 AM
-
Hi All,
I seem to be making a clumsy attempt at Salmon Tails in G, essentially the first bar.
I drop down to the D row for the E and D and pull a C chord and push a G bass. Just seems a bit choppy if you know what I mean!
Just wondering how others play it in 'beginners mode'
Any thoughts much appreciated!
cheers
Q
-
Hi All,
I seem to be making a clumsy attempt at Salmon Tails in G, essentially the first bar.
I drop down to the D row for the E and D and pull a C chord and push a G bass. Just seems a bit choppy if you know what I mean!
Don't get too analytical about it!
It's a mistake to try to micro-manage your chords to fit every note.
My approach is usually to concentrate on the bass notes on the beat, and don't worry too much about what off-beat chords come out. Keep them short and snappy and nobody will notice if they "don't fit".
You could also do
G (C chord) C (C chord) | G or B (G chord)
or
G (D chord) D (Dchord) |
Either way, you're not changing chord on every note, which is probably A Good ThingTM.
I think what I play is:
G (D chord on pull) B A | G
(that's three bass notes in a row!)
Or to be really flashy, only bass notes, no chords at all 1st bar:
G C B A | G
Then go into ordinary bass-chord vamp after that - it's quite effective.
It works especially well on the 2nd or 3rd time, emphasising the restart of the tune.
-
ok....will try and mess around a bit with your suggestions.
I think as a newbie, analytical mode is currently very 'on', as I'm constantly wondering what's happening!!
Interestingly, the last couple of days I realise I'm going into autopilot for a couple of bars of some tunes, which I think means something's happening and I'm progressing. Quite reassuring.
.....then I come too and wonder what's going on ......and inevitably break the moment.
Will dry out from a quick walk and have a go :||:
cheers
Q
-
G (D chord) D (Dchord) |
This is what I do (I think!)
I agree with Anahata not to get too picky about the chords. If you are playing the tune VERY slowly whilst learning it then you will hear if the chord isn't perfect, but once you have it up to speed then neither you nor anybody else will notice.
I'd say incidentally that you are doing a lot better than most beginners (and better than many who are no longer beginners) in actually listening and thinking about your left hand to such an extent. Well done!
-
Or, you could go (all basses) G E D E G E D E >:E ;D
-
ganderbox:
I take your point about about being slow and therefore errors are more significant.
I just would like to get it right!
....comes with a lifetime of muttering about others! :|bl
Ollie:
ok will give that a go.
Earlier i did have a go with some of Anahata's suggestions, and quite liked the bass note approach.
( yawn ) tiered bunny off to bed now.
Will have another go later tomorrow.
Night all
zzzzzzzzzzzz
Q
-
Or, you could go (all basses) G E D E G E D E >:E ;D
Only in the Wilbraham sessions ;D :|glug
-
Bass analysis ... mmm, not often done too deeply here either.
What I seem to play is, G (bass) A (bass), D (bass) Em (chord) at the beginning of the tune, another three bass run there ;)
Though that does seem to change when I muck around with the tune depending on what gets changed. Funny this analysis thing when you start it.
Edited: changed Bm to Em ... berk :D