Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: strad on August 21, 2010, 08:27:26 PM
-
The selection of bass/chords on the bass buttons of a B/C box are mostly fairly unusable.
What would people consider would be a more sensible set of notes for the lefthand side.
Most music played on these boxes seem to be in C, G, D, and A. For instance, tunes played in D frequently have a prominent F# which is on the push but the D chord on the left is on the pull.
Of course you can always ignore the lefthand and just waggle the bellows.
Nigel
-
Do you have the version squeezy posted:
http://info.melodeon.net/files/site/BC23modernbass.gif
-
Nigel,
Changing the inside C and C chord to a D and D chord, the bass layout that nfldbox has pointed you to, is the simplest and cheapest way of getting a push D on your Paolo Soprani, and is probably the most usual arrangement on BC boxes today.
Even better is the "Joe Burke" arrangement shown on Han Speek's page, (http://www.xs4all.nl/~hspeek/irishbox/basses.html) which gives the Gs and Ds as push/pull pairs. I had my Paolo Soprani 2-row (like yours) modified to this layout, and it worked pretty well.
Better by far was when I replaced the Paolo Soprani with a 2-row Notturni - identical right hand side, but with a 50 (10x5) Stradella bass.
Bill
-
I have the McComiskey basses but like most Irish players I don't use the basses much. When I play waltzes and such I tend to play the Hohner, with the 12 stradella.
I'm sure many will disagree with me but it seems to me the diatonic basses work best when you are playing up the row. If you play BC Irish then you seldom play up the row and so if you are using the basses you are constantly working against the system. Thus the McComiskey basses make more sense than the original but nothing really makes sense on a normal 8 bass if you are constantly in D, G and A on an instrument that theoretically is in B and C.
-
Irish style accordion playing is much different than other melodeon styles. The basses are mostly rhythmic in nature, but are not as counterintuitive as one might think. The scale of A on the BC is mostly on the draw and so is the A chord. If you have 2 D's like the McComiskey setup, there is always a D chord when you need it. Ditto with the G. E chord sometimes acts as a passing chord leading to an A. The basses are set up so that the majority of times when you need to accent a melody note, there is a bass available. Granted there are limitations, but the style has developed so there is no oom=pah bass, but rather a more selective use of strong chords when appropriate and mere tapping when not. Listen to Billy McComiskey play and you'll hear the left hand of a BC box used to a very musical effect.
-
So far I play very little Irish music on my box, and chose the B/C 'cos the session where I usually play has a wide range of keys -from Eb up to E and everything in between! It's mainly dance music at rational speeds and I've reached a point in my learning where I'm venturing to use the left hand a bit more, which is the main reason for the post.
Nigel
-
watch this space!
george ;)
-
I'm watching with bated breath.
Nigel
-
Irish style accordion playing is much different than other melodeon styles. The basses are mostly rhythmic in nature, but are not as counterintuitive as one might think. ... The basses are set up so that the majority of times when you need to accent a melody note, there is a bass available. ... the style has developed so there is no oompah bass, but rather a more selective use of strong chords when appropriate and mere tapping when not.
Excellent explanation, Dave. Thank You! John Williams explains a similar thing on his instructional video: "regulator style" of playing the bass.
Dave Hanrahan plays (and teaches) exatly this way on the demo CD of the book The Box. I love this style so much that I try to use, it when playing the stradella bass on my chromatic button accordion.
PJ Hernon teaches a kind of oompah bass (mayba the ceilidh band) style on his instructional videos/DVDs, though.
Dereck Hickey does not touch the bass at all on his madfortrad instructional DVD-ROM.