Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Manfrini Accordions on August 22, 2010, 10:47:33 AM

Title: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Manfrini Accordions on August 22, 2010, 10:47:33 AM
I am new to these pages, from reading through many of the questions on bass layout, I would be interested in knowing if a Stradella bass system on a 2 row would be of interest to some players and what layout would be best, bearing in mind the amout of space available.
Look forward to your suggestions. Robert Rolston
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 22, 2010, 11:13:50 AM
YES PLEASE! A Stradella bass system (say 48 bass, either 8 x 6 or 12 x 4 - I'd find the 12 x 4 better personally) on a B/C box would be brilliant.

However, an even better solution as far as many members on this forum are concerned would be to make an affordable three row BCC# with 48 bass - there is a real need and no one seems to be listening out there in accordionland.
Thanks for asking the question Robert.
AL
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: strad on August 22, 2010, 11:15:41 AM
I fully agree with Al.

Nigel
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Manfrini Accordions on August 22, 2010, 11:30:41 AM
How many notes would be required on the treble side ? would 3 voice be suitable 8'8'8' or 16'8'8' can be either or, giving a choice, the same cost to make.
I can have a look at this and see what the price would be. Robert
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Sandy Flett on August 22, 2010, 12:53:08 PM
My dream from about 20 years ago was to have an ADG melodeon treble with Stradella bass. I searched everywhere, and was told more than once that you just cannot get all the reeds in a melodeon sized bass. So I was very interested to read on melnet the other day about Bill's Notturni and now Robert's thread.

To keep the weight and width down to a minimum I would have been happy to settle for 4 rows (or columns) of bass - counter-bass, bass, major chord, minor chord. For playing in A it would have been nice to have the C# at the top, with an F at the bottom as that sometimes comes in to tunes in G - this would result in a 32 button bass. However, I was concerned that the G and C basses were a bit of an off-centre stretch for the left hand for regular playing in G, a problem I had with a 12-bass 3-row melodeon; maybe Bb to F# would be a better compromise.

I have written the above in the past tense as, in more recent years, I have come to the conclusion that it is only worth my while having small, lightweight diatonics (I have gone for Liliput and Tommy) as I can pump their bellows to give me all the wonderful additional expression that you cannot get out of a piano accordion (my other life-long instrument) but which I also cannot get out of larger diatonic melodeons. So my solution is to try to get as much melodeon-type expression as I can out of my piano accordion (which is much wider-ranging and more flexible), and use my compact melodeons for the really "breathy stuff", much of which is characterised and complemented by the quick bass reed changes (the buttons being held down while doing fast bellow changes) which you will not get with Stradella bass.

But for those who want to concentrate on melodeon, the Stradella bass must be a huge development opportunity, and I offer my thoughts above as a contribution.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: DRUMKILBO on August 22, 2010, 12:59:50 PM
As Al and Strad say, there is a need for a 3 row of the size of a Hohner Echo or a Casali, you have to be a big lad to work a Shand Morino. There is nothing for a youngster to play in the 2 or 3 row with a stradella bass, no wonder they nearly all play PA in Scotland.

Ian
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Andrew Culwell on August 22, 2010, 02:00:21 PM
I'd be interested in a light 2 voice BCC# 2 voice,  as for bass side stradella I'd leave those druthers to the BCC#'ers on this forum who know best.  However my preference would be lightweight. 
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Bill Young on August 22, 2010, 03:58:16 PM
The 2-row Notturni B/C (Paolo Notturni, Recanati) that I used to have had 23 treble buttons and 50 bass (5x10, Ab up to B). Playing mostly Scottish music, I could have done with the F# and, occasionally, the C# rows. I'd recommend a 60-bass (5x12), Ab to C#, for either a 2- or 3-row. I can't see any reason for not having the dominant 7th row - there can't be much in it, weight-wise, between 5x12 and 4x12.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: nfldbox on August 22, 2010, 06:04:23 PM
Different strokes for different folks but the 12 stradella BC Double Ray works for me.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: jonm on August 22, 2010, 06:32:02 PM
A friend of mine, on hearing my better half's Fantini four-voice PA, promptly ordered a 4v ADG three-row with stradella bass (60 bass I think) which he manages to play, standing up, without difficulty. Cross-rowing, which he does a lot, helps with bellows changes with all that extra weight. I'm hoping for an opportunity to try it myself soon.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Lester on August 22, 2010, 06:48:09 PM
A friend of mine, on hearing my better half's Fantini four-voice PA, promptly ordered a 4v ADG three-row with stradella bass (60 bass I think) which he manages to play, standing up, without difficulty. Cross-rowing, which he does a lot, helps with bellows changes with all that extra weight. I'm hoping for an opportunity to try it myself soon.

May be a challenge to a Lilly player :o
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Sandy Flett on August 22, 2010, 06:54:17 PM
A friend of mine, on hearing my better half's Fantini four-voice PA, promptly ordered a 4v ADG three-row with stradella bass (60 bass I think) which he manages to play, standing up, without difficulty......

That sounds like one awesome ADG box!

As it is a Fantini, would I be right in assuming your friend got it through Emilio Allodi (if not do you know who)? I know Emilio has a good "folk" range of PAs and CBAs, but I did not realise such a bespoke diatonic configuration could be ordered - presumably ADG reeds inside a 3-row CBA body. Did he get a decent air button for diatonic?
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Anahata on August 22, 2010, 07:23:49 PM
I know someone who has a D/G club with Stradella bass.
With the club tuning, it's possible to avoid quite a lot of bellows wiggling.
I've never seen another box like it, and don't know if it's something Hohner ever made as standard or not.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: melodeon on August 22, 2010, 10:08:50 PM
The  Northern Argentina/Southern Brazilan gauchos play a 2 row and 2 1/2 row with stradella
Gailta punta / punta gaita ?


Joel Guzman of Texas ( you tube videos, sadly none with the Strad bass )  has a custom 3 row Stradella bass 3 row made for him by Dino Baffetti  last year.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fz9Fiq0nKtU&feature=search
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: rees on August 22, 2010, 11:18:21 PM
Ashley Orchard has a ADG four voice 96 bass on the way from Beltrami.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Owen Woods on August 23, 2010, 12:15:04 AM
From my perspective, having tried a few melodeons recently, I see no particular reason why a three row the size and weight of a Benny cannot be made with Stradella Bass. This would give a 2 voice BCC#, C#DG, ADG, CBA, etc. that is light and portable. My Hohner Imperial IIA is the size of a Liliput yet crams in 32 stradella bass. That would be the minimum for me, C# at the top and F at the bottom (as someone else said), counterbass, bass, major, minor. More practically though I suppose (although I can't stand using dominant chords) an 8*6 with that configuration would be more saleable. I don't have the measurements of anything at all to hand, as I am sitting in a small flat in the middle of Edinburgh, but if you could fit it in then a 72 bass 12*6 would be even better (although I have a feeling that this would be pushing it). I agree with others that if such a thing is to be appealing above the second hand market then it needs to be as small as pratical. Of course, equal volume across the rows would be vital but not insurmountable. Although you can hear the difference between the rows on Bob's Benny it isn't something that is noticeable unless you are looking for it specifically and I am sure that Manfrini will be able to design against that.

The other possibility is Free Bass. Not a converter necessarily (I don't know it works, but I have a feeling that it involves another set of reeds [can't think of another way of doing it], making it drastically impractical for a small instrument) but a 48 8*6 would give 2 chromatic octaves of bass/counterbass, 4 row C system. I think anyway, I worked this out on the train up here last week (psychic, eh?) but have only just started learning CBA, so might have got that wrong. Whether there would be a market for that I have no idea, but I would be interested (assuming that I had the money, which I don't).
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Accordion Dave on August 23, 2010, 04:32:12 AM
I just took a look at my many orphan accordions and I see some distinct Frankensteinable possibilities.

The size of the various Hohner one and 2 row melodeons is almost the same as the smaller Hohner 12-bass and 24-bass student models.

Cleveland Ohio musicians Johnny Pecon and Lou Trebar had custom-made half-chromatics... Bisonoric Helikon bass coupled with unisonoric chromatic treble. They used these in their "Janez and Lojze" button box routine.

I can play piano accordion just fine, so I think I will leave the experimental grafting to someone else.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: jonm on August 23, 2010, 07:53:19 AM
A friend of mine, on hearing my better half's Fantini four-voice PA, promptly ordered a 4v ADG three-row with stradella bass (60 bass I think) which he manages to play, standing up, without difficulty......

That sounds like one awesome ADG box!

As it is a Fantini, would I be right in assuming your friend got it through Emilio Allodi (if not do you know who)? I know Emilio has a good "folk" range of PAs and CBAs, but I did not realise such a bespoke diatonic configuration could be ordered - presumably ADG reeds inside a 3-row CBA body. Did he get a decent air button for diatonic?


It did come from Allodi; it appears to have a generous air button.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on August 23, 2010, 01:36:18 PM
My Trichord has 12 strad basses and I would love to have a row of counters too - then the minors woiuld be good, so dream of a 4x12.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Manfrini Accordions on August 23, 2010, 01:49:48 PM
Many good points have been brought up, I will work on the project in September.
It must be small, light and a dream to play and not cost the earth.
Many thanks for all suggestions so far Robert
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Bill Young on August 23, 2010, 02:44:44 PM
My Trichord has 12 strad basses and I would love to have a row of counters too - then the minors woiuld be good, so dream of a 4x12.
Tony,
Could I draw your attention to this 48-bass La Divina PA (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=330463656636&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT) on eBay UK? This is exactly the model I used to fit a 48-bass end on a Trichord.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: squeezenplease on August 23, 2010, 04:19:45 PM
HI Bill...was the Divina bass a good fit with little adjustment...we have a trichord for sale up here in Inverness which might be worth adapting...would then only have to change the colour...TomC
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Bill Young on August 23, 2010, 04:40:12 PM
HI Bill...was the Divina bass a good fit with little adjustment...we have a trichord for sale up here in Inverness which might be worth adapting...would then only have to change the colour...TomC
Tom,
I did a writeup on it at the time. The thread is at http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1686.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1686.0.html), and there's some info further down on the adapter to fit the La Divina bass end to the Trichord bellows. They weren't an exact fit, but the final result didn't look too bad.

The original post refers to a wire lever operating the air valve. I subsequently improved the action, fitting a wooden lever.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: squeezenplease on August 23, 2010, 04:46:23 PM
Many thanks Bill...will now do my homework...read your writeup...and hopefully come to the right decision...TomC
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: squeezebox63 on August 23, 2010, 05:09:45 PM
I agree withnfldbox , stradella 12 bass on a b/c doubleray deluxe does it for me also. really easy for anyone whos played a piano acc.
a chromatic box with a stradella bass, what more can you ask for. { a bbc# box maybe}.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Owen Woods on August 24, 2010, 12:00:01 AM
Many good points have been brought up, I will work on the project in September.
It must be small, light and a dream to play and not cost the earth.
Many thanks for all suggestions so far Robert

Isn't that true of every accordion? :P

My Trichord has 12 strad basses and I would love to have a row of counters too - then the minors woiuld be good, so dream of a 4x12.

I have one, hee hee hee :P

Sorry :|bl
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Nick Hudis on August 24, 2010, 01:06:50 PM
As someone who plays with the 3rds switched off a lot of the time, I'd find a stradella would limit playing to conventional triadic harmonies.  But a free bass preferably unisoric would open up a lot of potential. With 18 basses you would have a decent chromatic free bass. 24 basses and you'd be flying.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Accordion Dave on August 24, 2010, 03:06:20 PM
I am a bit confused and some questions come to mind.

If a melodeon is so great, why would it need modification?
 
If you are going to go to the trouble of learning the Stradella bass, why not just learn the piano accordion or unisonoric chromatic?

It seems that those types of accordions were developed because of the limitations of the early models that you folks call melodeons.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: rees on August 24, 2010, 03:15:51 PM
I am a bit confused and some questions come to mind.

If a melodeon is so great, why would it need modification?
 
If you are going to go to the trouble of learning the Stradella bass, why not just learn the piano accordion or unisonoric chromatic?

It seems that those types of accordions were developed because of the limitations of the early models that you folks call melodeons.

Mel.net is a broad church but I know what you mean.
When I think melodeon, I think 10 treble and 2 bass. Anything with more buttons is approaching a musical instrument and there lie dragons.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Quebecois on August 24, 2010, 03:28:12 PM
...there is a real need and no one seems to be listening out there in accordionland.
Many good points have been brought up, I will work on the project in September.
Al, it seems someone has answered your prayers...
 
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 24, 2010, 05:24:20 PM
Quote
Al, it seems someone has answered your prayers...
;D

Just gotta start saving up my pennies now  :P

Quote
When I think melodeon, I think 10 treble and 2 bass. Anything with more buttons is approaching a musical instrument and there lie dragons.
LOL! Yes, I was under the misapprehension for quite some time that a melodeon was a musical instrument...I know better now of course  ;)
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: nfldbox on August 24, 2010, 07:50:26 PM
Quote
When I think melodeon, I think 10 treble and 2 bass. Anything with more buttons is approaching a musical instrument and there lie dragons.
All "folk" instruments are caught between tradition and improvement.
Don't knock it: there are many doctoral dissertations in them there hills.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Owen Woods on August 26, 2010, 12:59:48 AM
I am a bit confused and some questions come to mind.

If a melodeon is so great, why would it need modification?
 
If you are going to go to the trouble of learning the Stradella bass, why not just learn the piano accordion or unisonoric chromatic?

It seems that those types of accordions were developed because of the limitations of the early models that you folks call melodeons.

Come now Dave, don't be facetious :P

The melodeon is a fantastic instrument (and it is an instrument ;)) but like every instrument, even the best instrument in the world (the piano), it has limitations. The trick is to try and reduce the limitations whilst still retaining what makes the instrument great, which of course may well be different for each player.

I think that the Stradella Bass system is really suitable for "chromatic" melodeons, otherwise standard 12 or 18 bass is probably sufficient, although depending on the type of music that you wish to play then a 32 bass might be a good idea. There is a great danger of course in relying too much on the three chord trick, but then there is the danger of relying on the two chord trick with melodeon bass.

For a BCC# of course, Stradella Bass is pretty much essential and I would add that it would be a good idea for BC, C#D or any of the hybrids, C#DG, F#GC, GCC#, BCE etc.

There are reasons why a lot of us do not play unisonoric accordions, because we think that melodeons are better. They are generally lighter, more responsive, less cumbersome and easier to play with bounce and energy. Crucially they are more fun than unisonoric accordions and have greater charm. This is my own opinion of course, you may differ.

As someone who plays with the 3rds switched off a lot of the time, I'd find a stradella would limit playing to conventional triadic harmonies.  But a free bass preferably unisoric would open up a lot of potential. With 18 basses you would have a decent chromatic free bass. 24 basses and you'd be flying.

There is always the open stradella, but yes, I know what you mean. A free bass would be ideal, but I think that having 24 bass would be worth it. I however would retain the original stradella cycle of fifths counterbass bass, as then you could retain playing bass and then chord without having to unduly move your hand. So that would be 48 bass and you could arrange them in the same way as you would nomally. If it wasn't such a nightmare I would be tempted to modify an accordion myself.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: waldoB on August 30, 2010, 04:13:50 PM
As is ever the case someone has been there before. An extra counterbass type row between the fundamental and the dominant is a standard tuning. 12 by 4 or five works so  well with melodeon players who would be accordionists with a BCA coz of the waggling weight. There's a lifetime of harmony and bass lines to explore with just that. DB
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: GbH on August 30, 2010, 05:05:19 PM
Another alternative to conventional melodeon basses or stradella seems to be the Darwin system.  On the surface, it would seem to offer a lot more flexibility than a conventional melodeon, having, as it does, fully chromatic unisonic bass notes alongside a system of bisonic third-less 'chords'.  Personally, I really like the idea of this approach, but would instinctively worry that I'd forget how to play a conventional instrument.  Also, without knowing more about it, I have no idea how well the system actually works in practice.  I assume that there must be at least some disadvantages too - surely no system is ever going to be perfect.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2010, 05:25:36 PM
I had a chance to try, well look at, a Darwin bass when its inventor Marc Serafini was in Stowmarket this spring on the melodeon building course.  In Marc's hands it is a great system so the potential is definitely there for someone who wants to learn it.  I seem to remember that both the bass and chords play the same in and out.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: GbH on August 30, 2010, 05:40:22 PM
I had a chance to try, well look at, a Darwin bass when its inventor Marc Serafini was in Stowmarket this spring on the melodeon building course.  In Marc's hands it is a great system so the potential is definitely there for someone who wants to learn it.  I seem to remember that both the bass and chords play the same in and out.

Going by the diagram on his site, if I've understood it correctly, the 'chord' buttons all play different notes depending on bellows direction - although most chords are duplicated on other buttons, but in the other direction.  Obviously, I've no idea whether you saw something different to this again and whether the system is still developing.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2010, 06:20:10 PM
It was a prototype I saw, so there may well be changes. 
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 30, 2010, 06:42:46 PM
have only just read this lot as aaway at whitby last week.  Very much agree with most of what has been said. It seems to me that perhaps 3 & at least 2 sizes are needed to make the system affordable and also suit differing requirements as to weight, bulk ;& portability as well oas of course sound.

A Bc 23 button & BCC# 31 button  both with minimum 12 stradella a la trichord & double ray delux, preferably with 3 voice mmm treble or really strong 2 voice mm. more bass if can be fitted withour enlarging averall dimensions.  The lightweight portable session box

 a lightweight 2 or 3 voice 3 row with 12x4  bass  - counterbass, bass, major & minor
this to be reasonably cheap in relation to reasonable quality - the main starter box
 
a 60 bass mmml 4 voice perhaps higher qulity box  for them who can afford one!

george
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Graeme on August 30, 2010, 07:37:17 PM
What's the consensus on this one?

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=120614181384&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Anahata on August 30, 2010, 08:14:48 PM
What's the consensus on this one?

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=120614181384&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT

If the basses are fundamental, major and minor I think I'd miss the counterbasses.
In my PA and B/C/C# days I liked the melodic possibilities in the LH.
For only 36 buttons I'd be a lot happier with 4 x 9. Your mileage may vary.

Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2010, 08:22:46 PM
Bass button spacing looks wide.  Borsini have a good reputation for their piano boxes.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Accordion Dave on August 31, 2010, 01:49:39 AM
To Ukebert who wrote...Come now "Dave, don't be facetious :P
The melodeon is a fantastic instrument (and it is an instrument ;)) but like every instrument, even the best instrument in the world (the piano), it has limitations. The trick is to try and reduce the limitations whilst still retaining what makes the instrument great, which of course may well be different for each player."

I have grown to love the melodeon after many years of playing the piano accordion. In fact in another post I made a few minutes ago, Melodeon Acquisition Delight has struck again. I now have a great 1-row that only needs a couple of leather straps. No other repairs are needed. That's a first.

I think that it is fun to learn to play as many different types of accordions as possible. I never thought I would get the "ins and outs" of the bisonoric accordion, but I am doing quite well after a couple of years.

A lot of guys have the souped up electronic accordions with Musical Instrument Digital Interface. So far I am doing the poor man's version of that. I carry along an inexpensive electronic keyboard, to get piano, organ, marimba, steel drum, vibraphone and other effects for variety. It worked for Frankie Yankovic when he pioneered the use of the Hammond Solovox in polka music.

When I play at various events I bring along several different accordions for variety.

Recently I have been playing my piano accordion along with another fellow who plays Steirische Harmonika. He likes his "flats box" the best so I have had to transpose songs that I originally learned in G, C, and F into A-flat, E-flat and B-Flat.

There is another guy who has a 2-row Hohner in G and C. I have an East German 2-row in those keys. So I may play a button box duet with him at our next event.

The piano accordion is compatable with whatever keys I need to play in. The button box players need to plan ahead.   
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 31, 2010, 09:41:11 AM
unless they have a BCC#!

george
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: graememackay on August 31, 2010, 10:03:30 AM
Hello all, sorry for my absence, summer time beckoned and I am only coming up for air now.  I'm probably just going to repeat what most folk have said anyway but will say my bit.

It seems that everyone wants something a bit different from their box but the stradella is the one common factor.  There is no reason why it can't be matched up with other tunings than the semitone system and could compliment the music a lot better than the current melodeon basses.  Simply by changing the reed blocks this can be achieved.

I think everyone agrees that there is a distinct lack of b/c/c# boxes with decent bass ends, especially if there is to be anyone wanting to learn to play.

After playing with a 60 bass box on my converted morino club, I can say now that it's not quite enough. I miss the c# row at the top and although its at the bottom, it's a big jump to find it when I want it. I think for someone to buy a reasonably priced b/c/c# box that is going to get them through the learning curves of learning how to play various keys etc, 80 basses are needed.  counters, fundemantals, majors, minors & 7ths with c# at the bottom row and g# at the top.  This would also reflect good value for money as when the owner progresses on with their ability, there will be less need to upgrade prematurley.

As for the treble end, I reckon that middle C should be on the 3rd button on the middle row, not the 4th as it is on jks layout.  If the notes were shifted down it would give more essential notes at the top of the keyboard instead of low ones that don't get used much.  We don't often go lower than low G, neither do our pals on fiddles.

As George pointed out, there's no real need to have a van load of boxes, just a b/c/c# with all the keys buit in already.  The only planning ahead to be done is learning the how to    play
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Sandy Flett on August 31, 2010, 10:17:48 AM
After playing with a 60 bass box on my converted morino club, I can say now that it's not quite enough. I miss the c# row at the top and although its at the bottom, it's a big jump to find it when I want it.

Charlie Watkins and Emilio Allodi have been offering the option of C# at the chin end on new 72 and 60 bass boxes for some time. I have always thought this was a good solution, rather than go up in overall number of buttons.

How easy would it be to convert an existing 60 or 72 bass - ie move the C# to the chin end and shuffle all the others down one? Would there be any chamber work to do, or re-tuning?
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Theo on August 31, 2010, 11:20:56 AM

How easy would it be to convert an existing 60 or 72 bass - ie move the C# to the chin end and shuffle all the others down one? Would there be any chamber work to do, or re-tuning?

It would just mean shifting all the reeds one position along the blocks, 48 reeds for a 4 voice bass setup.   The chambers are usually all the same size on bass and chord blocks.   Tuning would need to be checked, but unlikely to need much alteration.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Accordion Dave on August 31, 2010, 01:21:41 PM
Can a B/C/C# box play with a Steirische Harmonika in Bb/Eb/Ab?
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: LDbosca on August 31, 2010, 01:50:51 PM
Can a B/C/C# box play with a Steirische Harmonika in Bb/Eb/Ab?

A B/C/C# box is fully chromatic so I can't see why not.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Gandy on August 31, 2010, 02:33:57 PM
As for the treble end, I reckon that middle C should be on the 3rd button on the middle row, not the 4th as it is on jks layout.  If the notes were shifted down it would give more essential notes at the top of the keyboard instead of low ones that don't get used much.  We don't often go lower than low G, neither do our pals on fiddles.

That's interesting, because I have a box with that 34 key layout, C on the fourth button.   The top notes on that layout are seriously squeeky, I don't know how much use I'd find anything higher up than the top G.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 31, 2010, 02:37:31 PM
Can a B/C/C# box play with a Steirische Harmonika in Bb/Eb/Ab?
 

 do you mean all by itself while the owner is elsewhere doing the same thing? :o
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Mike Averill on August 31, 2010, 07:22:47 PM
As George pointed out, there's no real need to have a van load of boxes, just a b/c/c# with all the keys buit in already.  The only planning ahead to be done is learning the how to    play
Thats the theory but in practice every one has there favoured fingerings. I seem to remember that even Jimmy Shand carried a second box in c#/d for such occasions.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 31, 2010, 07:44:48 PM
Quote
Can a B/C/C# box play with a Steirische Harmonika in Bb/Eb/Ab?
No probs!
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 31, 2010, 09:30:28 PM
As George pointed out, there's no real need to have a van load of boxes, just a b/c/c# with all the keys buit in already.  The only planning ahead to be done is learning the how to    play
Thats the theory but in practice every one has there favoured fingerings. I seem to remember that even Jimmy Shand carried a second box in c#/d for such occasions.

I find this difficult to believe as it would have been most unlikely that he would have put down the shand morino & picked up a 2 row just to play in the flat keys which are readily available on the BCC#.. He  recorded  a number of 'melodeon' solo's on a CC# erica  some of which may well have been in the flat keys to which that tuning ( which is part of a BCC# anyway) is well suited. Can anybody confirm his use of a C#D for " such occasions"



george

george
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: acctech on August 31, 2010, 11:50:59 PM
The Hohner Nova 48 three row chromatic treble reed blocks are onterchangable with blocks from a Corona.  Just replace the stock chromatic blocks with GCF or other arrangement. BCC# is possible, but is not currently a stock setup available.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 01, 2010, 09:28:45 AM
Quote
The Hohner Nova 48 three row chromatic treble reed blocks are onterchangable with blocks from a Corona.  Just replace the stock chromatic blocks with GCF or other arrangement. BCC# is possible, but is not currently a stock setup available.
True - but it'd still be not a very good box I'm afraid, and the Nova buttons are renowned for falling off.
AL
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: Sandy Flett on September 01, 2010, 09:55:13 AM
Quote
The Hohner Nova 48 three row chromatic treble reed blocks are onterchangable with blocks from a Corona.  Just replace the stock chromatic blocks with GCF or other arrangement. BCC# is possible, but is not currently a stock setup available.
True - but it'd still be not a very good box I'm afraid, and the Nova buttons are renowned for falling off.
AL

I confirm it is a poor quality of box, having briefly owned and got rid of one (there is a separate melnet thread on this). There is also the issue of needing to modify the air button for diatonic use.
Title: Re: Stradella bass on a Diatonic
Post by: george garside on September 01, 2010, 10:05:21 AM
the best course of action then is to let somebody else  be first owner!, discover its weeknesses and hopefully sell it  cheaply having copped for a huge chunk of depreciation.  Suitably but economically fettled one   it would have possibilities as an inexpensive BCC# with stradella bass.

george
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal