Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: tostean on August 22, 2010, 09:51:45 PM
-
Anybody here who plays a DG Beltuna Sara 3? I'm thinking mostly of the new model, but probably old and new are much alike in spite of the changed design. I tried a GC and AD Sara 2 today - quite impressing.
If you play Sara 3 I would like to hear your opinion, and would like too a comparison to other brands and models in the same categori - DG 2rows with 3 set of reeds in the right. I'm looking for a melodeon suited for playing dancemusic with 2-3 violins and a bass, but also suited for at bit of 'lyrical and reflective' solo now and then. And that it's not too expensive of course :-)
tostean
-
There is ahuge variety of boxes that will do those two things, it's much more down to the player than the box to fit in with others.
-
I am looking for opinions about Sara 3 compared to similar types - could be for ex. Hascy, Saltarelle Nuage, Loffet graet a breiz. I played a Sara2 g/c for the first time a few days ago. It impressed me and I now wonder how a Sara 3 d/g is judged by those who play it. Playing d/g you often need the lower 3. choir, in my opinion, and therefore Sara3 is interesting. But since it's not played by anyone i Denmark I have no possiblity of trying it right away.
Thanks for your answer, Theo. I quite agree that the player is far more important than the box, that the way of working together in a group is the important thing, not the names of the instruments.
Hope to hear from Sara3 players.
-
I'm also interested in the Sara 3. Seems like Hobgoblin no longer have any left in stock. Does anyone else supply Beltuna?
-
On the same note...
Are there any Beltuna Sara 3 owners out there who can PM me some pictures of the internals - particularly the bass/ treble mechanisms?
Just curious... wondering about the technical aspect of the thing... :|glug
Ed J
-
I have a feeling Dave Jolly has/plays one.
Someone from this parish also has one see here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nCibzEmJroA&feature=channel
Martyn
-
Just been talking to someone who works for Hobgoblin, apparently they are not importing any more Beltunas
-
Just been talking to someone who works for Hobgoblin, apparently they are not importing any more Beltunas
I e-mailed Beltuna about 18 months back for a catalogue, and asked about direct imports - on chromatics and melodeons. They wrote back, willing to to supply chromatics... but directed me to Gremlin/Hobgoblin for melodeon enquiries - quoted to me as the exclusive importer.
I've every reason to believe the exclusive import deal is over - in as much as this place (http://www.accordioncentre.co.uk/) will import Beltuna melodeons (did when I asked last month)... as will probably Dave Jolly, or others... :|glug
Ed J
-
Just been talking to someone who works for Hobgoblin, apparently they are not importing any more Beltunas
That's a real shame. They are really very very nice boxes indeed.
-
I e-mailed Beltuna about 18 months back for a catalogue, and asked about direct imports - on chromatics and melodeons. They wrote back, willing to to supply chromatics... but directed me to Gremlin/Hobgoblin for melodeon enquiries - quoted to me as the exclusive importer.
I've every reason to believe the exclusive import deal is over - in as much as this place (http://www.accordioncentre.co.uk/) will import Beltuna melodeons (did when I asked last month)... as will probably Dave Jolly, or others... :|glug
Ed J
I've never had much luck trying to buy anything from Hobgoblin. Last year I wanted to buy a Beltuna Alex 3 (not exactly a cheap instrument), but after a lot of mucking about on their part (didn't know where it was after Sidmouth/Whitby/whatever) I gave up. Bought a Loffet instead - he set it up as I wanted and was keen to advise and to have my business.
I don't know whether he now "does" Beltuna, but I bought a Serenellini from Dave Jolly a couple of years ago, and it was a really good experience. His other preferred make is Mengascini, and I know he has (had) one of these in I think CF for his own instrument. He rates them highly. I think, but may be quite wrong, that GbH's Mengascini came from Dave.
I do get the notion that some of these "exclusive/sole distributor" arrangements, with Italian makers especially, are an obstacle to buying the instrument of one's choice in the UK. My problem is that it's still fairly easy to find something else as good or desirable and blow the money on that.
-
I don't know whether he now "does" Beltuna, but I bought a Serenellini from Dave Jolly a couple of years ago, and it was a really good experience. His other preferred make is Mengascini, and I know he has (had) one of these in I think CF for his own instrument. He rates them highly. I think, but may be quite wrong, that GbH's Mengascini came from Dave.
Indeed, mine was also from Dave. I was very happy with the service - particularly so, given that I hadn't actually seen such an instrument previously and I didn't entirely know what I needed or what I might be getting. The box was ordered, custom built and delivered within a matter of weeks - certainly nothing like the extended lead times associated with better known manufacturers. Also, as I'm sure you've noticed, I was given the chance to specify not just the tuning and keyboard layout, but also had options on case colour (choice of two), button colour (black/white/mixed) and the opportunity to design my own bellows decoration, just as part of the standard service.
-
I've never had much luck trying to buy anything from Hobgoblin... Bought a Loffet instead - he set it up as I wanted and was keen to advise and to have my business.
Only ever bought a couple of boxes off Hobgoblin... both 'stock' (one S/H, t'other clearance - both since sold). Gone direct to a maker for my 'big guns' since... pretty painless process... and I get one heck of a squeezebox for not that many beans... 8)
I don't know whether he now "does" Beltuna... other preferred make is Mengascini...
As far as I am aware, there is a connection between Beltuna and Mengascini... think they're owned by two brothers... :-\
... fairly easy to find something else as good or desirable and blow the money on that.
Indeed. I see a lot more Loffets about these days... and other obscure makes... :|glug
Ed J
-
Only ever bought a couple of boxes off Hobgoblin... both 'stock' (one S/H, t'other clearance - both since sold). Gone direct to a maker for my 'big guns' since... pretty painless process... and I get one heck of a squeezebox for not that many beans... 8)
How do you even start a process like going direct to the maker to buy a box? Judging by my past experiences of Italy, not many of them speak English it seems. Is it an easy process and what sort of lead times (if any) are involved?
-
How do you even start a process like going direct to the maker to buy a box? Judging by my past experiences of Italy, not many of them speak English it seems. Is it an easy process and what sort of lead times (if any) are involved?
My experience, albeit limited, is that the whole thing is wildly variable when dealing in Italy. The first hurdle seems to be getting a response to the initial enquiry (either for language or technological reasons). After that, just about anything can happen (good and bad!), depending on the maker you're dealing with.
I expect that, as well as EeeJay, the maestro Rees Wesson can shed a good bit of light on this.
By contrast, I bought my Loffet Pro direct from Bernard in Brittany, using a mix of French and English in the correspondence, and the whole process from start to delivery could not have been more straightforward or satisfactory. I was also fortunate in knowing what I would get from a brief acquaintance with someone else's instrument.
That raises the old question about being able to try before you buy if you want to, which means foreign travel, unless you can have a go on the same or similar where you are.
Personally, I'm not keen on the angst involved in some of these transactions for Italian boxes, and if at all possible would prefer to go through one of the select group of UK specialists like Rees or Dave Jolly, or a larger dealer like The Music Room. That way, I feel that I'm going to get good advice, the box I want, and the after-sales backup. Unless there's a huge disparity, those advantages outweigh any price differences.
That's not by way of discouraging you from having a go-just my own view on it!
-
My Beltuna Sara II came from Hobgoblin at Nottingham - which is no longer trading, which is a shame as they were very good, helpful and generally bothered about their customers. I have contacted Beltuna directly with questions in the past and they have responded promptly, they seem to be very helpful. They seem willing to supply directly to individuals - they have supplied me with quotes. I think upgrading to a Sara III would be a good idea. There is one used to play at least one TOTM which sounds fantastic.
-
Up until recently when I sold it to a forum member I had a beltuna sara2 which I originally bought from Dave Jolly.
Everyone who had a go at playing it told me how nice it was....it did have a nice sound but just didn't suit me and the way I play.
-
I played Sarah's Sara when she first had it, and very nice it was too.
I also had a good play on a Sara 3 when Hobgoblin had a trade stand at Melodeons at Witney a few years back. I was very impressed. Much nicer to play than a Saltarelle Nuage (though less versatile in terms of choices of voices) and a serious contender to a Castagnari Hascy, I think.
-
I played Sarah's Sara when she first had it, and very nice it was too.
indeed you did
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xE9Q8duhM_o
-
How do you even start a process like going direct to the maker to buy a box? Judging by my past experiences of Italy, not many of them speak English it seems. Is it an easy process and what sort of lead times (if any) are involved?
Who said anything about Italy?
Although there are various folks on the forum who've dealt direct with Italian factories, I haven't... yet... main point of contact for me has been this guy... (http://www.accordionmaker.com/) whose English is good...
Apart from Bernard Loffet, there are other European makers who prefer to deal direct - Bertrand Gaillard (http://www.accordeonsgaillard.fr/), Aaro Luukinen (http://www.f-aw.net/)... various other good makers too...
I also had a good play on a Sara 3 when Hobgoblin had a trade stand at Melodeons at Witney a few years back. I was very impressed. Much nicer to play than a Saltarelle Nuage (though less versatile in terms of choices of voices) and a serious contender to a Castagnari Hascy, I think.
Erring towards a 3+2... (http://www.beltuna.com/alpstar/small/sara3+2ciliegio.jpg) 8) much as I like multi row contraptions, there's just something so 'right' about the format to me... Another thing I like (in pref. to the Hascy) is is the closed keyboard... and the cutouts in the back to give a bit of foldback...
...it did have a nice sound but just didn't suit me and the way I play.
Yes... much as I've toyed with the idea of small Castagnaris over time (and having owned/sold two), I think I'm more comfortable with 'mid size' things. I think it's the only way to find out really... live with an instrument for a while to get it out of your system...
Ed J
-
Hi Tostean,
Perhaps try talking to:
http://www.rudisblueladybirds.dk/
I've never met them, don't know who they are, but they play Beltuna Sara, and are based in Denmark. It might be worth a shot, in case www.accordionhouse.dk don't have any Saras in for you to try.
Lars / København
-
Hi Lars
Thanks for your reply - and of course thanks also to others who have posted remarks and replies.
In fact the shop you mention is just where I lately had the opportunity to play Beltuna :-) Right now they have two Sara 2 g/c and one a/d in stock. But unfortunately not a Sara3 d/g which is the most interesting to compare to other brands for me.
Quite surprising to meet another dane at melnet, think I'll drop you a PM in our own much more understandable language.
.
-
think I'll drop you a PM in our own much more understandable language.
Yeah, right! ;)
-
Let's not get started on Welsh, Rees!! Admit it, you owe all your culture to the brave Danish settlers who brought civilisazion to your neck of the woods ;)
-
Let's not get started on Welsh, Rees!! Admit it, you owe all your culture to the brave Danish settlers who brought civilisazion to your neck of the woods ;)
........... and bacon!
-
Let's not get started on Welsh, Rees!! Admit it, you owe all your culture to the brave Danish settlers who brought civilisazion to your neck of the woods
No way! I'm descended from the ancient britons and owe what little culture I possess to the fact that my ancestors managed to flee to the extremities of these islands to escape from marauding hordes of vikings who raped our villages and pillaged our womenfolk! The language across these islands at that time was what is now known as...wait for it...WELSH!!! So - Croeso y Cymru!
;D
-
Let's not get started on Welsh, Rees!! Admit it, you owe all your culture to the brave Danish settlers who brought civilisazion to your neck of the woods
No way! I'm descended from the ancient britons and owe what little culture I possess to the fact that my ancestors managed to flee to the extremities of these islands to escape from marauding hordes of vikings who raped our villages and pillaged our womenfolk! The language across these islands at that time was what is now known as...wait for it...WELSH!!! So - Croeso y Cymru!
;D
Yes indeed, you tell 'em Al.
I live in the upper Severn valley, 20 miles West of Shrewsbury. This is some of the most fertile land in the UK and has been raped and pillaged by all and sundry. A kind of Shropshire English is spoken here.
You only have to travel 10 miles to the West and the Welsh language reigns supreme. Needless to say, the invaders never really ventured into this land. Too steep and mucky for them. Wimps! ;)
-
Oddly enough, I've just been talking to the boss about getting some other brands in - It seems we can get Beltuna instruments to order, so getting you a Sara should be no problem.
Cheers,
Jon
(Music Room hat on)
-
I, too, have Sara 2s on order. >:E
-
Let's not get started on Welsh, Rees!! Admit it, you owe all your culture to the brave Danish settlers who brought civilisazion to your neck of the woods
No way! I'm descended from the ancient britons and owe what little culture I possess to the fact that my ancestors managed to flee to the extremities of these islands to escape from marauding hordes of vikings who raped our villages and pillaged our womenfolk! The language across these islands at that time was what is now known as...wait for it...WELSH!!! So - Croeso y Cymru!
;D
Or preferably, as we say in real Welsh, Croeso i Gymru!
-
Dim bwys.
-
A kind of Shropshire English is spoken here.
Time for a Shropshire Shouting workshop, perhaps....
Baz
who inner daft, inner drunk...
-
and dunner come from Clun!