Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ga on August 23, 2010, 09:49:30 AM

Title: What conversion to a C/C# Erica, assuming I'm too thick to learn Chromatic?
Post by: Ga on August 23, 2010, 09:49:30 AM
Hi all,

I picked up a C/C# Erica, at a car boot sale, which I don't particularly want to learn to play, as I play very little Irish-style.  It's in excellent condition though, and plays very nicely.   I already have a D/G pokerwork for Morris duties, so am thinking of having it converted, probably to C/F as, to my way of thinking, the D/G and C/F combo would be most useful for Morris and Ceilidh duties.  So, any other suggestions?   I'd like to keep the costs down on anything I have done to it, so if a particular conversion would be very expensive, I'll avoid that one.
I'm thinking of:-
1. simply flog it as is, and buy a C/F instead.
2. Have it converted to C/F. What might this cost - very roughly?
3. Convert it to D/G and tape off the thirds to open up more minor tunes to my repertoire.
4. Convert it to something else? A/D? Bb/Eb? (Something mainstream, not one of Squeezy's minor-tuned specials!)

I'd appreciate your thoughts, as I got it home, and thought to myself "Hmmmm....Now what?".
Title: Re: What conversion to a C/C# Erica, assuming I'm too thick to learn Chromatic?
Post by: rees on August 23, 2010, 02:37:30 PM
Learn to play it English style in C and grab the accidentals from the C# row. This is the quintessential English melodeon style and is played by very few people these days (Simon Ritchie being the notable exception on Font Whatling's old B/C box.).

C/C# along with B/C and C one-rows were very common in Southern England particularly East Anglia and were always played in C.

Basically any melodeon with a C row would do so music shops sold all three variants. G/C and C/F were not common and Percy Brown got his first D/G sometime around the late sixties (possibly early seventies, I'd have to check the recording dates - can't be arsed, you do it  ;)).
Several examples of C/C# being played English style on the Veteran CD "Pigeon on the Gate"
Dolly Curtis, Percy Brown, Font Whatling are all good.
Title: Re: What conversion to a C/C# Erica, assuming I'm too thick to learn Chromatic?
Post by: Ga on August 24, 2010, 12:07:48 PM
Thanks Rees - yeah, all good points.  I have the "Pigeon on..." CD and have admired Simon Ritchie's playing.   Interesting that Percy Brown's first box was a C/C#, as I was under the impression most of the East Anglian gang wore single rows - noted your point though, that "...any box, so long as it's got a C row...." .
I already have a single row in C, so I'm reasonably well served in the "C" East Anglian department, and if I'm honest, I find it nice, but not quite what I want from my melodeon playing.   I think I'd get more enjoyment out of the instrument if it was in a quint format.   I'll persevere with it for now, and keep an eye out for interesting reed block sets or someone with a full set of reeds from an Erica or Pokerwork.....



Title: Re: What conversion to a C/C# Erica, assuming I'm too thick to learn Chromatic?
Post by: rees on August 24, 2010, 01:59:14 PM
One-row boxes are the current East Anglian weapon of choice but it wasn't always so. Most of the old photos show two row boxes.
The influence of Oscar Woods and more recently, Katie Howson and Jeannie Harris, has played a large part in the current trend toward one-row boxes - plus, of course, most East Anglian tunes sound best on a one-row melodeon.
However, it's always refreshing to hear it played on a semi-tone box in C, with subtle use of the black notes.
Title: Re: What conversion to a C/C# Erica, assuming I'm too thick to learn Chromatic?
Post by: rees on August 24, 2010, 02:02:13 PM
If you're interested in new D/G reed blocks, I can probably get them from Hohner.
I'll have to check the price.
Title: Re: What conversion to a C/C# Erica, assuming I'm too thick to learn Chromatic?
Post by: Accordion Dave on August 24, 2010, 03:15:33 PM
I seems that the East Anglians and the Cajuns have similar weapons of choice.
Title: Re: What conversion to a C/C# Erica, assuming I'm too thick to learn Chromatic?
Post by: rees on August 24, 2010, 03:25:00 PM
I seems that the East Anglians and the Cajuns have similar weapons of choice.

Indeed, and the early Zydeco and neighbouring Tex-Mex musicians originally played on Hohner two-row quint boxes (usually G/C or Bb/Eb) until they moved on to the triple-row that they use today.
Title: Re: What conversion to a C/C# Erica, assuming I'm too thick to learn Chromatic?
Post by: Ga on August 25, 2010, 10:30:41 AM
Hi Rees,
thanks for the offer of finding the prices from Hohner, yes please, that would be good if you wouldn't mind - I have absolutley no idea of what the the cost would be, so even a rough idea at this stage would be fine, just to give me an idea.  I assume buying a full reed set would be a cheaper alternative than the assembled blocks?  This could also be an option if it turns out to be overly expensive.  Admittedly I'd lose the ability to realtively easily change it back to it's original tuning, but I could live with that. Feel free to drop me a PM if you're not comfortable putting Hohner's prices on the Worldwide Electric Interweb thingy.

I'm persevering with it for now, but find I mostly play it as a single row, which seems a shame - time to start stretching the repertoire and reaching for some of those accidentals!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal