Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Chris Cartwright on August 29, 2010, 07:22:01 PM

Title: In search of the perfect Bass setup
Post by: Chris Cartwright on August 29, 2010, 07:22:01 PM
Hello all

I’m into crossrow playing, and interesting chords, and am trying to figure out a good bass end for a G/C/Heim melodeon.

Several people on this site seem to like Bernard Loffet’s setup, but it (and all others I’ve looked at) seems to miss what seem to me important chords.
I’d love to hear from people with a view on this, and am very happy to be told that my analysis is wrong, as I’m new at this.

My logic is as follows:

Stage 1
Principal keys (in approx order of playability) G, Am, C, Bm, D, Em
Major modes typically require (using C tonic) C G F Em Dm (Am)
Minor modes typically require (using A tonic) Am Em Dm G F C (B) (E)
A bass end having the following: [C G D F (A) Am Dm Em Bm] meets all/most requirements for the principal keys mentioned above. This is 8 chords (or 7 if you drop 3rds)
Restricting requirement to G and Am doesn’t cut this down, but restricting to C+Am only limits it to [C G F Am Em Dm] which is 6 chords (hurrah!)

So my first question is “why don’t boxes intended to play mostly on the pull have these 6 chords on the pull?” Why do they rather feature things like E, G#??? Eb??? (B. Loffet) Instead on Em Dm and Am

Stage 2
What “Interesting chords” (xM7, xm7, x7, x9) would we like to be able to play?

A brief analysis of some favourite tunes indicates the following:
Major tunes benefit from (using G tonic) G6 D6 and C9
Minor tunes benefit from (using A tonic) C6 G6 A6 and E7 A7 D7
So on same logic of focussing on the principal keys of G and Cm, this means we would need:
Basses: E B A F# D G C – so additional B and F#
Chords:  G D A C – just need to reinstate A

So the perfect box now looks like (on the pull):
Basses:  C G D F A E B F#
Chords: C G D=Dm F A=Am Em Bm
Which for a 16 bass leaves one button spare  (:)

So my second question is – in the light of this additional analysis, I still can’t see why (say) Loffet’s bass is as it is – no Em at all;  no minor chords on the pull; G#?? no F# on pull etc etc.
I’m sure I’m fundamentally missing something, and would love someone to tell me what it is

Thanks in advance, Chris


Title: Re: In search of the perfect Bass setup
Post by: waltzman on August 29, 2010, 08:15:36 PM

So the perfect box now looks like (on the pull):


I’m sure I’m fundamentally missing something, and would love someone to tell me what it is

Thanks in advance, Chris

Fundamentally, there is no perfect box....they are all compromises.

Mr. Loffet is a fine player in addition to being a builder.  I'm sure his bass recommendations are based on his experience in playing french tunes.  If your repertoire is different then you may want something different.
Title: Re: In search of the perfect Bass setup
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 30, 2010, 07:22:07 AM
i've got the 'standard French' G/C 18 bass and having at least a bass note for all 12 in both directions solves a multitude of problems as well as giving me nice crossed chords such as E/C and A/C  - due to my C both ways.

Lofflet's 18'er seems more toward playing useful straight chords, and when we last looked at it I thought it was pretty clever. Now you don't get all the notes both ways but there will of course be useful crossed bass possibilities. Anything but a PA bass involves choice and compromise. Perfection will depend on what you play.

Of course one of the beuties of the instrument is that you may commonly 'extend' any chord by dropping a finger onto a right end note!
Title: Re: In search of the perfect Bass setup
Post by: NeilA on August 30, 2010, 07:29:36 PM
Anyone see merit in what Rick Mohr has done with his basses? See his website http://rickmohr.net/Music/Melodeon.asp (http://rickmohr.net/Music/Melodeon.asp) Interesting to see how he arrived at his layout.

There's some nice tunes on the site as well.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal