Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Steelarts on August 30, 2010, 07:59:58 PM
-
Geeze, this choosing a new box is really starting to make my head hurt! I've done so much research now that I'm starting to tie myself in knots. But I have been really hard on myself and boiled it down to 2 makes; it's Loffet Vs Saltarelle. The only thing that tends to put me off of Saltarelle is all the stuff I've read about some boxes not being consistently high quality, how true is this nowadays??? I really love the sound of these boxes and I can go and buy one off the shelf......BUT......
Someone (on another thread) mentioned having a Bernhard Loffet box made. It seems like if I don't mind waiting a month I can have a higher spec box made for a few hundred quid less than the Saltarelle! So now I'm in a quandry. Do I just go for a simple D/G Petit of a 2.5 row with 12 basses Graet e Breizh? From what I've heard I really like the sound of French boxes so think this is the way I'll end up going. This is going to be a purchase that will have to last many years (I cannot afford to catch a dose of MAD). Those of you who have Loffet boxes, is the process of buying for Mr Loffet an easy and pleasurable one and are you happy with your boxes?
Also can someone help me with this, please? ... If I go for a 2.5 row/ 12 bass, I take it that having more basses and accidentals will make the box more versatile, or will they just serve to confuse a beginner? I'd rather have the added bonus of more flexibility in the future rather than having to upgrade in a couple of years if you know what I mean. Also, what difference does having 2 or 3 voices make? It seems 2 voice boxes are cheaper and lighter but are they as loud as a 3 voice or as versatile. Thanks again for reading this and for all the help and advice you've given me so far.
-
What are you playing now?
-
OK, I see it on another thread.
-
From what I've heard I really like the sound of French boxes so think this is the way I'll end up going.
Saltarelle may be a French business but most, if not all of their boxes are made in Italy, so thinking of a "French sound as applied to one or two brands is probably not very helpful.
M Loffet only sells direct to UK customers, no middle man, so arguably you should get more for your money.
-
I take it that having more basses and accidentals will make the box more versatile or will they just serve to confuse a beginner? .
Yes, it will make the instrument more versatile - but only if you've got the mindset and approach to make use of it. Personally, I don't think I coule ever be happy with just a standard two row instrument, but many others obviously are. It clearly depends on the sort of music you want to play, whether you're happy playing in a 'cross row' style and whether you like to try out and explore different possibilities.
I don't really see why the extra half row would be confusing at all - you either use the extra notes or you don't. They won't get in the way of any regular two row playing you might be wanting to learn first. Personally, I find having accidentals positioned at the end of the standard rows to be much more confusing and illogical.
Also, what difference does having 2 or 3 voices make? It seems 2 voice boxes are cheaper and lighter but are they as loud as a 3 voice or as versatile. Thanks again for reading this and for all the help and advice you've given me so far.
Obviously, having 3 voices can give you a bigger, more complex, sound. If the instrument has switches for the reeds, there's also the option of selecting different combinations, to give you some different sound options, making it more versatile still. It doesn't necessarily seem true that more voices = louder, as far as I can tell.
If you're looking for a D/G instrument, then you need to think about the pitch of the reeds. The standard MM tuning will make your instrument sound very high, which might then mean that you don't enjoy playing in the top octave. If you want to play French style music, you might well see this as a problem. Alternatives would be to choose a two voice LM set-up (fine, if you like a 'dry' sound), or get a 3 voice instrument with at least one set of low reeds.
Hope this helps.
-
I have a Loffet P'tit DG. i love it dearly. It has a fantastic sweet sound. RIch basses. Smooth action. Fantastic. However, very soft spoken. It is certainly not an outdoor box at all, and definitely not loud enough for morris, for example. That isn't necessarily a problem of course. Paul Davenport, well known Sheffield folky and good chap also has one. His he uses largely for song accompaniment so he values the fact that it doesn't drown out his voice. A friend of mine has a Salterelle I play now and then which is again a great piece of kit. I prefer the Loffet, but if I owned the Salterelle and occasionally played the Loffet it could easily be the other way round.
There is no right answer, otherwise everyone would all play the same make and model of box.
Good luck.
G
-
Hi
I don't know where you are based but I've got a Saltarelle Nueilly for sale for a customer,2.5 row 3 voice,slide couplers under keyboard,12 base with 3 button couplers above,I'me in North Yorkshire but will be at Fylde Festival,Fleetwood next weekend,I will have a trade stand,you can try it if you wish.
hope this helps.
Pete
-
There are a few of us on Melnet with Loffet boxes. I think you'll find that most of us think his instruments are top quality. the Graet e Breizh are built by him in Brittany (with another craftsman doing the casework), the others including the 18 bass Pro I play, are built to his spec in Italy and finished by Bernard himself. Either way you have a great box and great customer service.
-
Hi
I don't know where you are based but I've got a Saltarelle Nueilly for sale for a customer,2.5 row 3 voice,slide couplers under keyboard,12 base with 3 button couplers above,I'me in North Yorkshire but will be at Fylde Festival,Fleetwood next weekend,I will have a trade stand,you can try it if you wish.
hope this helps.
Pete
Unfortunately I'm in Oxfordshire and will be heading to the south coast next weekend; it's probably out of my budget too as it's a lovely and very expensive instrument when new (but one can still dream.....).
I have a Loffet P'tit DG. i love it dearly. It has a fantastic sweet sound. RIch basses. Smooth action. Fantastic. However, very soft spoken. It is certainly not an outdoor box at all, and definitely not loud enough for morris, for example. .
Hmm, that's very good to know. Are all the Loffets on the quiet side? As my primary aim is for Morris it's got to have a bit of volume (imho). Do you know whether the "3 Voice" and Graet e Breizh are any louder?
-
Hi,
It is advertised in Buy and Sell,customer looking for 1850 ono
Pete
-
Two voice D/G with MM reeds..
as a two row for Morris, I think ok
But as 2 1/2 row D/G 2 reed....and for other than Morris and the 2 1/2 row's pote ntial.. I would personally not do it
I would opt for a 2 row three reed before a 2 1/2 row 2 reed
Ideally 3 reed 2 1/2 row or 2 row... and either good for more than Morris
Get a Hohner 2 row D/G for Morris.. a beater fro outdoor use and save up for a quality 2 1/2 row ( if you must) 3 reed unit.
As to Loffet's boxes... many satisfied customers and simple do a search for Saltarelle and the observations, reservations, and outride complaits are numerous...
Also, I prefer to deal directly with the guy whose name is on the box or with only a reputable dealer beteween us..
for the other side of the coins see posts on Saltarelle... too many fingers in the pie adding to profit and cost and complexity
-
I have a Loffet 2 1/2 row 3-voice Pro in DG, as does Ganderbox. It has plenty of stops at both ends so it's extremely versatile, and after a year or so mine is beginning to bed in and can now make a fair old noise if required. It's beautifully made, and was tuned exactly as I wanted it.
The only downside to using it for a Morris box on a long day out, mostly standing up, would be that it weighs 4.5 kilos.
I haven't run across anyone who has any of Bernard Loffet's boxes who isn't happy with it, and every aspect of buying one from him is entirely enjoyable. I can thoroughly recommend him.
-
"Get a Hohner 2 row D/G for Morris.. a beater fro outdoor use and save up for a quality 2 1/2 row ( if you must) 3 reed unit."
Strongly support Melodeon's recommendation here. Since its rare to be able to keep to one instrument only, the instrument you will never get rid of, even when acquiring successive boxes, is a DG Pokerwork, the pickup truck of melodeons.
-
"Get a Hohner 2 row D/G for Morris.. a beater fro outdoor use and save up for a quality 2 1/2 row ( if you must) 3 reed unit."
Strongly support Melodeon's recommendation here. Since its rare to be able to keep to one instrument only, the instrument you will never get rid of, even when acquiring successive boxes, is a DG Pokerwork, the pickup truck of melodeons.
I think this is sound advice and for now I might do just as you advise and keep the savings going into a melodeon fund for when my dream box comes along. I had a fear in the back of my head that finding a box that can do all things well might be difficult to find. Thanks for the advice.
-
There is no dream box in the real world of melodeons. It's a limited instrument that can't do everything, that is it's charm.
My dream box was a Castagnari Mory, I bought one, but now I play a Hohner.
-
"Get a Hohner 2 row D/G for Morris.. a beater fro outdoor use and save up for a quality 2 1/2 row ( if you must) 3 reed unit."
Strongly support Melodeon's recommendation here. Since its rare to be able to keep to one instrument only, the instrument you will never get rid of, even when acquiring successive boxes, is a DG Pokerwork, the pickup truck of melodeons.
I think this is sound advice and for now I might do just as you advise and keep the savings going into a melodeon fund for when my dream box comes along. I had a fear in the back of my head that finding a box that can do all things well might be difficult to find. Thanks for the advice.
Plus what you want/think is your dream box now might not be in the future. Once you've been playing a bit you'll know what it is you really need and what you like in a box so its easier to choose.
-
There is no dream box in the real world of melodeons. It's a limited instrument that can't do everything, that is it's charm.
My dream box was a Castagnari Mory, I bought one, but now I play a Hohner.
Never was a truer word spoke. I've always found that instrument A) had lots of good things about it, so when looking for the next, B), - my "dream", supposedly - I wanted those features plus something else. In practice, it works out that some features (both good and bad) cross over, some disappear and some new ones turn up. It's a bit like the "bells and whistles" on cameras, computers, phones, cars, cycles, workshop tools etc. etc. I suppose that's why some of us have more than one melodeon!
I like the "better" instruments that I've got a great deal, but I find my hands dropping on various Hohners about the place more often than not. My favourites among those are the Liliput and the Erica, with the latter being about as comfortable, versatile and useful as you'll get, in my humble opinion.
-
This talk of 'dream boxes' doesn't seem to me to be the main issue - the thing is, once you learn to play a box with certain characteristics as your main instrument, you're going to be stuck with it, because you won't want to relearn another system. So the point is really, 'Be careful what you wish for'! I think it's important to think carefully what sort of playing you're going to concentrate on, then get the best box for that, not the other way round.
That said, I've been interested recently to see what the top English-style players have been doing recently - there seems to be a noticeable move towards bigger three-rows, even for simple bashy dance tunes. I don't know what the reasoning is. Perhaps steady improvements in design or technique have brought back the appreciation of the undeniable benefits of more complexity?
-
There is no dream box in the real world of melodeons. It's a limited instrument that can't do everything, that is it's charm.
My dream box was a small 5-row continental/chromatic button accordion with hand made Italian reeds. Now I have one, and I still play and love my restored Hohner club boxes.
-
There is no dream box in the real world of melodeons. It's a limited instrument that can't do everything, that is it's charm.
My dream box was a small 5-row continental/chromatic button accordion with hand made Italian reeds. Now I have one, and I still play and love my restored Hohner club boxes.
There are all sorts of dream boxes out there....it's just that dreams keep changing.
-
Right on with the "dream box" thread. Dreams come and go.
Who knew that what I really, really, really needed was a Loffet Pro CF like DTN plays?
-
Would a dry tuned dream box be a "dry dream" ? And a w.... well you get the idea.
I too was smitten with the "idea" of a Mory.. So I pulled the trigger.
I was disappointed on many levels. I have owned 7 Castagnaris, one of them 3 times.
The Mory was a total dog from day one. very happy to off it.
If you get a a Hohner 2 row EWrica or Pokerwork in good nick ( would that be correct Limey Lingo)
you'll enjoy it an d never lose much on it, and they are easy to turn.
That is not so of a most "premium" accordions..
And you don;t have to be so damned careful with it that it would diminsh its value.. a fear I always have and it is uncomfortable.
Some suggest that if you feel that way about a box ( or anything) it wasn;t meant for you and you may have bought it for the
wrong reasons.
If you save up, something may just fall on you during that tiome period, and or your aspirations will change, or...
you may have the opportunity to play a similar model or something else...
What does it cost to get over to Brittany.. Can't be any farther than my nearest decent box shop which is a nine hour drive or 2 hrs by air... go visit Loffet.. hands on will tell you a lot.
Good luck
-
Theo is currently working on my latest dream box - an old Hohner Pokerwork in C/F - sad to report that the said dream is in fact a nightmare! But I'm assured by Theo that it'll all turn out ok in the end :D
Should you order a Loffet? Dunno - go look, see, try...I was impressed by the look and sound of DTN's Loffet at Whitby last week
-
I have a Loffet 2 1/2 row 3-voice Pro in DG, as does Ganderbox. It has plenty of stops at both ends so it's extremely versatile, and after a year or so mine is beginning to bed in and can now make a fair old noise if required. It's beautifully made, and was tuned exactly as I wanted it.
The only downside to using it for a Morris box on a long day out, mostly standing up, would be that it weighs 4.5 kilos.
I haven't run across anyone who has any of Bernard Loffet's boxes who isn't happy with it, and every aspect of buying one from him is entirely enjoyable. I can thoroughly recommend him.
Yes, I do have a Pro, and also a G/C 2 voice Graet e Breizh. I've also just bought a Saltarelle Pastourelle II, which jumped off the shelf at me in Sidmouth.
They are all fine boxes, and all very different. The Loffets, as has been said, give a lovely smooth, rich authentic French sound. In some ways I prefer the 2 voice GeB...I think it has more character.
The Saltarelle is much more in your face than the Loffets, but sounds great. I have to admit that since I got the Saltarelle, a lot of people have said (without necessarily knowing it was a new box, or anything about it) what a great sound it has.
It's not just sound,though. The three boxes are all different sizes in terms of height, depth and weight, and the button spacings, at both bass and treble ends, are all different. The action is different on all of them, as well. For purely ergonomic reasons, it really is a good idea to try before you buy, because the box must be comfortable for you to play.
I have heard, and believe it to be true, that Saltarelles are very variable in quality, and this was why I bought the one I found (or that found me) rather than getting one made to my own layout (despite the fact I'm making quite a lot of changes to it). With a Loffet, I don't think quality control would ever, ever be an issue, and he is really good to deal with, especially if you can make at least your initial approaches in French.
My Saltarelle is a much better outdoor box than the Loffets, though....you can hear it for miles!
-
........................... in good nick ( would that be correct Limey Lingo)
Blimey. guvnah, you're a right chip orf the ole block, an' no mistake, me ole cock sparrah, innit!
VAT paid, Purple Peril arriving tomorrow. I won't sleep tonight, too excited. :||:
Back on thread, TRY BEFORE YOU BUY.
-
I concur with Rees, if I ever end up spending that kind of money I'll be taking a holiday to Italy or to Brittany or wherever and trying out myself. My advice w/re: dream boxes is that since you dreams will change constantly, no matter what level you are at, best to find a reasonably good box, whether that's a refurbished Hohner or a second hand Italian box or whatever, say up to £1000 then this will do you well for a good few years and you can begin to think about things rationally.
I remember that before I got my Boeube (which was admittedly when I was quite young) I was lusting mightily after every box that I saw. Now I can be a trifle more reflective and reason to myself that I can buy lots of boxes as long as they are falling to pieces and cheap. How I got there I don't quite know.
-
The Saltarelle is much more in your face than the Loffets, but sounds great. I have to admit that since I got the Saltarelle, a lot of people have said (without necessarily knowing it was a new box, or anything about it) what a great sound it has.
Out of interest, when you got your new Saltarelle, how was the tuning described (if indeed it was)?
-
Out of interest, when you got your new Saltarelle, how was the tuning described (if indeed it was)?
It wasn't described as anything, but it's dry, the driest box I've got. Definitely not thin, dull, "brown", or any of the descriptions that sometimes get applied to dry boxes, though. One of the first times I took it out was in a session at the Ship in Sidmouth, and I was sitting next to a friend who plays concertina, and it struck me how alike they sounded.
Somehow it seems to suit all kinds of music, from morris to mazurkas, and it is the nearest I've got yet to the one box that does everything - and it's the lightest to carry.
-
It wasn't described as anything, but it's dry, the driest box I've got. Definitely not thin, dull, "brown", or any of the descriptions that sometimes get applied to dry boxes, though. One of the first times I took it out was in a session at the Ship in Sidmouth, and I was sitting next to a friend who plays concertina, and it struck me how alike they sounded.
Somehow it seems to suit all kinds of music, from morris to mazurkas, and it is the nearest I've got yet to the one box that does everything - and it's the lightest to carry.
Thanks, Pauline. I'm probably wildly wrong, but the more I hear about it, it seems to me that some or perhaps many dry 2-voice boxes with quality reeds sound a lot more lively than the same or even wetter tuning in 3-voice. That's even after fiddling around with treble stops on a 3-voice to try to mimic a 2v. Perhaps I've been looking in the wrong places for what I think I'm after.
Looks like you hit the jackpot with this one, though.
-
perhaps many dry 2-voice boxes with quality reeds sound a lot more lively than the same or even wetter tuning in 3-voice.
Interestly, it appears to have factory reeds, not TAMs!
-
perhaps many dry 2-voice boxes with quality reeds sound a lot more lively than the same or even wetter tuning in 3-voice.
Interestly, it appears to have factory reeds, not TAMs!
Crikey, it didn't take you long to have it to bits!
-
perhaps many dry 2-voice boxes with quality reeds sound a lot more lively than the same or even wetter tuning in 3-voice.
Interestly, it appears to have factory reeds, not TAMs!
Crikey, it didn't take you long to have it to bits!
......and moved some of the accidentals around! The rest of the layout changes will need the help of a certain person in St Ives (although he doesn't know it yet.....)
I suppose it's just what you are used to, and I'm used to the Castagnari layout, but I just can't see the logic of the Saltarelle half row and accidentals at all. Everything seems the wrong way round, at least for me.
-
Interestly, it appears to have factory reeds, not TAMs!
That's normal for Saltarelle. Nothing wrong with factory reeds anyway. It's only since the advent of Castagnari in the UK that the current fad for TAM reeds in melodeons has taken off.
-
Splendid.. VAT ? what ? VAT ? on the Purple Peril.. vat's dat all about ?
After you get said wondrous box.. let's settle up.. I think I'm gonna owe you, big time.
Hope the second package goes thru vat free
and dat it's not compromised in the long journey.
My Serenellinis had the typical Dural style reed and sounded and played fine.
I have heard Castagnaris with Dural reeds and they have an edge to them that's quite good.
I suspect gapping and tuning would have a good effect on a standard quality reed.
-
Ive always been pleased with the durals in my casta' Sander,powerful and stable, but I have a hohner now with more zing. The 1930s club X really sings in a way I never expected despite being unrestored. Aluminium front board and "hohner original" stamped reeds pinned on leather really rock. Once brought up to A440 this good really be the dream box.