Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on August 31, 2010, 11:58:27 AM
-
I was asked to post this on behalf of someone else. ;)
Are there any tunes in C that can be played on a D/G melodeon?
-
Thanks!:)
What we need are well-known session friendly tunes -Railway Hotel (in G) works. Any other ideas?
-
I was asked to post this on behalf of someone else. ;)
Are there any tunes in C that can be played on a D/G melodeon?
It helps if your box has a F natural accidental; given that, you *should* be able to play most stuff with a C drone bass if necessary. If you've got a 12 bass, you've probably got a F bass/chord too, and if you're *really* lucky, it might even be in the same direction as the F accidental! :D
Bar Room Branle (http://www.ceilidhsoc.org/musictune.html?Tune=1444&_sps=10&_spt=40&_spc=0&_spd=0) is one of my favourites, and has a A part in D, and a B part in C (in complete contradiction of my 'I hate tunes that change key' rant)
Cheers,
Clive
-
It is certainly possible with standard accidentals, but you end up in the dusty end more than is pleasant often, using the F natural accidental with 4th button start is very annoying and without an F bass the best alternative is D with the thirds taken out, or C drone if you don't have that facility. A is much more satisfying to play in.
-
Are there any tunes in C that can be played on a D/G melodeon?
Lots, if you have an F natural accidental.
Nick Barber likes playing tunes in C - one of his favourite tricks in starting "Dr Fauster's Tumbler's" in C in a session and watching other player's faces when they can't work out what's happened.
Many simple tunes like Winster Gallop and Shepherd's Hey can be done in C when you get used to it.
Chords are a bit limited, but no worse than a 1-row, in fact better on average.
(I never got around to doing a recording of Cock o'the North when it was ToTM but the plan was to do it in 5 different keys on a D/G with end accidentals only. D and G are trivial, A is quite easy, C is a little more tricky, E major is HARD >:E )
A good use for playing in C is tunes that change key between sections. For example the "proper" Jimmy Shand version of Bluebell Polka goes G-D-G-C or D-A-D-G and both can be hacked on a D/G box. But if you try it in a session you'll be drowned out by everyone else playing in a different key...
The most utterly evil foreign key I've ever had to do (and in public!) was "Made Schottische" in C minor for Gog Magog Molly. I couldn't do it solo without gross comical effect, but joined in with a sax and a piano accordion that had no trouble with that key.
-
What if someone didn't have accidentals?
(I never got around to doing a recording of Cock o'the North when it was ToTM but the plan was to do it in 5 different keys on a D/G with end accidentals only. D and G are trivial, A is quite easy, C is a little more tricky, E major is HARD >:E )
you know now you've said that you are going to have to record it. ;) >:E
-
What if someone didn't have accidentals?
You'd couldn't play so many, but any pentatonic tune in C doesn't need an F natural.
There are MANY Scottish pentatonic tunes.
"Auld Lang Syne" is a simple example, "Spootiskerry" a little more advanced ;)
you know now you've said that you are going to have to record it. ;) >:E
Yes I knew that was coming... ask me for a demo on Saturday if there's time (:)
-
Bar Room Branle (http://www.ceilidhsoc.org/musictune.html?Tune=1444&_sps=10&_spt=40&_spc=0&_spd=0) is one of my favourites...
... as composed by Rob Kay (keyboards and assorted electro-wizardry for Tickled Pink). Check out Rob's MySpace (http://www.myspace.com/robkayrobkay)for some retro-techno trad tunes... Come Ashore, Jolly Tar is a cracker... 8)
Nick Barber likes playing tunes in C - one of his favourite tricks in starting "Dr Fauster's Tumbler's" in C in a session and watching other player's faces when they can't work out what's happened.
Yes, I remember Nick doing this a few times... and the look of collective bemusement from many melodeonists (as if it was close to rocket science)... some of us just carried on...
Remember - just 'cos it says D/G on the tin, doesn't mean that's all there is in there...
Ed J
-
Are there any tunes in C that can be played on a D/G melodeon?
Lots, if you have an F natural accidental.
Nick Barber likes playing tunes in C - one of his favourite tricks in starting "Dr Fauster's Tumbler's" in C in a session and watching other player's faces when they can't work out what's happened.
Many simple tunes like Winster Gallop and Shepherd's Hey can be done in C when you get used to it.
Chords are a bit limited, but no worse than a 1-row, in fact better on average.
(I never got around to doing a recording of Cock o'the North when it was ToTM but the plan was to do it in 5 different keys on a D/G with end accidentals only. D and G are trivial, A is quite easy, C is a little more tricky, E major is HARD >:E )
A good use for playing in C is tunes that change key between sections. For example the "proper" Jimmy Shand version of Bluebell Polka goes G-D-G-C or D-A-D-G and both can be hacked on a D/G box. But if you try it in a session you'll be drowned out by everyone else playing in a different key...
The most utterly evil foreign key I've ever had to do (and in public!) was "Made Schottische" in C minor for Gog Magog Molly. I couldn't do it solo without gross comical effect, but joined in with a sax and a piano accordion that had no trouble with that key.
F# major is pretty easy actually, for CotN, but you don't have the basses :(
-
What if someone didn't have accidentals?
I have a C on a low button on the G row instead of accidentals and play [with varying success] some tunes in C major without having an F natural. Sometimes you can play another note (e.g. D) as a substitute for the Fnat in the melody or just lean on an adjacent melody note while others play the tune 'straight'. One row melodeon players often use tricks like these.
here's a few irish tunes that I play in C on a D/G: The Steeplechase [reel], Devanney's Goat [reel], Graf Spee [reel], Bobby Casey's jig, The Cloone [reel]
-
I have a low C natural on the D row instead of a C# - which is pretty useful. Good for pipe tunes etc too!
-
you know now you've said that you are going to have to record it. ;) >:E
Yes I knew that was coming... ask me for a demo on Saturday if there's time (:)
I can bring my camera and record a 'live' version out and about at stowmarket if you feel brave. ;)
-
Remember - just 'cos it says D/G on the tin, doesn't mean that's all there is in there...
Nick Barber has put an interesting clip on youtube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLN-CqyFjhI) where he plays a phrase from Shepherd's Hey in all the major keys on a D/G box, in this order: G , D, A, E, B, F#, C#, Ab, Eb, Bb, F, C and then G to end!
-
Some people have entirely too much time on their hands...
-
If you can get that F ... I find "over the hills and far away" is a great C tune for a D/G box. Where you might need an F chord if you substitute a D bass instead hinting at a D minor it sounds lovely and is not so hard.
-
Remember - just 'cos it says D/G on the tin, doesn't mean that's all there is in there...
Nick Barber has put an interesting clip on youtube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLN-CqyFjhI) where he plays a phrase from Shepherd's Hey in all the major keys on a D/G box, in this order: G , D, A, E, B, F#, C#, Ab, Eb, Bb, F, C and then G to end!
Nick & Mary came to a session in Sheffield some time last year. Myself and Richard Arrowsmith had arranged before hand to bring our Bb/Eb boxes along to play some flat tunes. After playing one (Battle of the Somme), Nick launched into Dr Faustus' Tumblers... in Eb! C, on a D/G, I can cope with, but that really was witchcraft. :P
-
With Nick doing things like that, I'm not sure whether to prostrate myself on the floor muttering ' I am not worthy....' or get out the Garlic necklace and wave a cross in the air ;D
Tid'n natural, good will never come of it ;)
Q in utter disbelief ( and much respect! )
-
Witchcraft ? More like showing off. ;)
Stick to sensible keys on a D/G. Like A.....
>:E.
-
I've got a one row and I'm gonna use it... ;)
-
Hello!
I've recently learnt what I believe to be a molly dance tune, George Green's College Hornpipe in C on my DG. It fits onto the box rather nicely and you only need to use the F natural two or three times. There are a couple of places where it feels like you should play an F chord but playing a D bass is a good compromise and sounds rather pleasant.
I've only been able to find online sheet music for this tune in G but if you look inside Michael Raven's book One Thousand English Country Dance Tunes you'll be able to find a version in C.
Cheers,
Mark
-
Fendragon were playing a public ceilidh once when we decided to play a new set of tunes that we were planning to do in C. I was supposed to be using my C one-row, but I'd forgotten to bring it to the gig. "Oh no, we've only got the music in C, can't do it in G" - so I decided I'd busk it in C on my D/G box and the other three players would carry it if I missed the odd note. Half way though the set, the fiddler broke a string...
I don't think anyone noticed but it was a tense moment.
I've recently learnt what I believe to be a molly dance tune, George Green's College Hornpipe in C on my DG. It fits onto the box rather nicely and you only need to use the F natural two or three times. There are a couple of places where it feels like you should play an F chord but playing a D bass is a good compromise and sounds rather pleasant.
Yes, it is a molly dance tune.
If your F natural is a push note (it is on many D/G boxes) you can put a G under it to make a G7, and that's the chord you'd get anyway if you were playing on a one row as George Green himself did.
But with F on pull (as mine is now), D bass works well.
-
Mark - if you join the Dark Side and take up "abc", you'll find that it enables you to transpose very quickly, so if you find (eg George Green's Hornpipe) in G, you need have no fears. :||:
Don't try playing in third position on a Chanson though, as you soon run out of buttons at the top end! :|glug
-
Some slight thread drift:
Here's an example of some Zydeco-Reggae played in fourth position.
i.e. D on a C one-row accordion.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LvwOUsggNqE (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LvwOUsggNqE)
-
Interesting difference of terminology between instruments - playing in D on a C *mouth organ* would be called third position. (Fourth position would be playing a C harp in Am.)
Cheers
Steve
-
We picked up on that last year. Basically the two instruments have evolved different conventions. I suspect no amount of melnet pointing out they "ain't logical nohow" will change that ;)
:neigh: Always bear in mind that there are also two ways of thinking about "playing in X on an Y instrument"
1. "I only think in terms of major scales"
To play in C on a D/G you dot in an F "accidental" where needed, instead of F#. An "accidental" ;) C# is a killer!
It works, but IMHO a very stultifying way to play; the left end can be truly awkward as it's set up for D,G modes
2. "This is a diatonic melodeon, go with it"
D row is not to useful due to that C# :o but on G row you get C lydian scale with an F#, new to some ears but valid music,
used in folk in Auvergne and a few rarer places. Massive in jazz, and film music (eg all those David Attenborough repeats)!
I've gone with the posts above, but more folky examples ..
"Playing in E on a D/G" .. you get E dorian minor (D row) or E simple minor (G row)
"Playing in A on a D/G" .. you get A mixolyian (D row) or A dorian monos (G row)
.. all of which are "big" in folk sessions. So the tread title should be "Playing in C major scale on a D/G"?
-
It's simple, if you want to play English tunes in C, get a C box ! ;)
-
a lot to be said for a trichord FCGDAE with some bass and the rest treble only - and only the same size and weight as an ADG or GCF corona
George
-
I've just got back from a session I don't usually attend. I found myself playing, relatively easily, with my D/G box in C. It just depends on how desperate one is! :Ph :||: :|glug
-
It's simple, if you want to play English tunes in C, get a C box ! ;)
No, the whole issue is that it is not simple ::) People think in terms of "C" being the white notes on a piano, and in folk music (actually all music) that may not be the case. To pick a "well known English session tune at random" ;) here is Dark Girl Dressed in Blue played on a C box, and using the C row
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UmQM-Du-nHA (TOTM Feb 2011)
.. except it comes out in .. er .. G :o To play it in C you'd use an F box :P Why? I doesn't use the "C major" scale. It used one of the six "other" C scales. :Ph
-
Hi Chris and Pikey,
actually, to be fair, that You Tube video doesn't seem to me a fair comparison/example ... the video is Dark Girl Dressed in Blue played 'inside out' (on the draw) on the inner C row of a G/C ...and THAT is why it comes out in G! Which is exactly what you'd expect... OK Yes, it's being played on the inner 'C row' buttons, but playing on that row on the draw puts you in G.... And so far as I can work out the key is G myxolidian, using the F natural...
Having said that ... it's nice to see someone else using that 'inside out' technique ... I play a lot inside out ... on a D/G it means playing in D on the G-row and G on the D-row. Gives better rythm and some nice runs.
.... returning to the thread, what Pikey said about having a C box to play in C is basically true ... the thing about playing in C on a D/G box is the challenge to make it sound half-decent and fluent, and the relief in not carrying another instrument around!
Mike
-
OK - put it another way - and let's simplify completely to a Suffolk C one row to avoid quibbles about playing things "inside out"
o DGDiB "in C" is "simply" not playable on that instrument - it uses a Bb ???
o If you play same melody, same kit with G as its tone centre (ie "in G" ;)) it works! (:)
o If you really want DGDiB to "be in C" you'll need to find yourself an F box (try lower Saxony?)
I do believe that to simplify the glories of diatonic modes down to "it's in C" is to ignore the fact that even in Western folk genres there are (at least) two mainstream "major" and two mainstream minor scales in play. The others are, I accept, exotic.
Pikey .. I think knows this very well; to continually shoehorn all majors and all minors into 2 simplistic containers will forever leave anyone new to the instrument blinking at the different left end chords needed in each case.
As an analogy: It's about as valid as a Morris man saying .. "well, there's Cotswald, and there's Border .. that's all there to it really" :|glug
-
I didn't understand a word of that last post ..........
-
I didn't understand a word of that last post ..........
... I guess "DGDiB" means "Dark Girl Dressed in Blue" ... this helps with what Chris means!
OK - put it another way - and let's simplify completely to a Suffolk C one row to avoid quibbles about playing things "inside out"
o DGDiB "in C" is "simply" not playable on that instrument - it uses a Bb ???
o If you play same melody, same kit with G as its tone centre (ie "in G" ;)) it works! (:)
It doesn't work really, Chris ... I've just tried it! .... no F# ... have another look at the video you posted, which shows Howard Mitchell jumping across to the outer G-row to find F#... so if you play the tune on a C box in the 'G position' as you suggest, you've simply swapped one note you haven't got for another!!!
o If you really want DGDiB to "be in C" you'll need to find yourself an F box (try lower Saxony?)
well No ... for the same reason...... But to continue Pikey's common-sense approach) why not use a C/F box - Bb and B natural are both available... The tune can then be played completely, and played in exactly the same style as Howard Mitchell's video you posted ... and would come out in C (myxolidian). No need to go to lower Saxony!
An important part of what Pikey is saying is that playing in C on a C box gives you more chord/bass support. And on a C/F box you have even more chord/bass options ...
Surely, agreeing with Pikey's common-sense approach doesn't mean that our music has to be simplified.... in fact quite the opposite ... there are fewer options for diverse and inventive basses/chords and also fewer treble chords/runs/patterns when playing in C on a D/G box.
But it's still Fun !!!
Mike
-
It doesn't work really, Chris ... I've just tried it! .... no F#
Ooh-er, it needs an F nat and an F sharp, doesn't it? Chris would have done better to pick a pure Mixolydian tune as an example.
The only defence is that you need that F natural, whereas you can busk round the F♯ and get away with it.
to continue Pikey's common-sense approach) why not use a C/F box
That wasn't quite the point of the thread, though, was it? LdT was asking about tunes that could be played in C on a D/G box, and the answer is that there are many, especially if you're not too bothered about having all the right chords, just as there are also many tunes in A (especially Scottish pipe tunes that are really AMix) that can be played on a D/G box.
It's also worth mentioning that any pentatonic tune can be played in three different keys on a one row, and by obvious extension four keys on a two row.
-
Completely agree Anahata!
I'm not great in C on a D/G - especially fudging the basses effectively ... maybe we could have this as a 'theme of the month' and see what the Melnet Ensemble deliver ... that could be really interesting!
cheers!
Mike
-
Whoops, forgot that A/B variation in the tune :|bl I was actually trying to find video of an English tune actually "in C" (scarce) to avoid further side track issues!
There are however a shedload of tunes played in D mainly on G row, or for that matter in F on a mainly on a Bb row (mixolydian again, flat 7th note. Thanks Clive!) and my main point is that there's more to C row than playing in C major. Indeed that some "C" tunes don't really reside here.
Shall we call it a tie, or its it "Yours on points. Seconds out .. next round!" ? :|glug
-
Hi Chris,
A score draw for sure ... I only wanted to defend Pikey who gets a bit of stick from time to time ... whilst you were making an important point relating to the OP...
...for myself I doff my hat to your goodself for the creative way you approach the box ... I read your analysis and listen to your tunes and just wish I had the 'inner ear' you have to go hunting for those "tunes-not-played-by-Captain-Obvious" (regrettably the Captain has me by the short and curlies... ) ... in the way you do.
cheers!
Mike
-
Thanks Mike (:)
I have a thick skin !
I can play in C on the G row, but prefer not to as it's a) hard work and b) contrary to my natural style, which is more one row than two.
But to answer the original question, I agree with Mike. You can play almost any major tune in C on the G row, but with a lot of reliance on badly placed accidentals, and limited bass support - so why bother?
If the crowd you are with play a lot in C , then bring a C box with you. Or get one on C / D / G or D / G / C ! ;)
Now there's an idea for my next acquisition.......
>:E
-
Bring a C Box on Thursday? :|||:
-
I'm never without one .........
-
Thanks Mike (:)
I ?
If the crowd you are with play a lot in C , then bring a C box with you. Or get one on C / D / G or D / G / C ! ;)
>:E
or dare I mention it a BCC#. Even the little 12 bass trichord does C dead easily and is just as easy to play in F eliminating the need to cart around the heavier and more bulky combination of a DG and a CF! ( it will also do CDG or even DGC if you ask it nicely!)
george ;)
-
or dare I mention it a BCC#. Even the little 12 bass trichord does C dead easily and is just as easy to play in F eliminating the need to cart around the heavier and more bulky combination of a DG and a CF! ( it will also do CDG or even DGC if you ask it nicely!)
george ;)
But it would not sound like a melodeon :P
-
I am, as of this very morning, learning Naragonia's "Evening Glory" on my DG Mory. We tried it first in G , then in C and it was so much nicer in C. Admittedly I use a couple of extra accidentals on my half row.
-
Some years back I had a pupil, in Leeds, who had been bought a Hohner One Row in C as an Xmas present. In the couple of weeks prior to setting up our first lesson he had managed to work out a couple of Irish song melodies. I was greatly surprised to find that all three melodies were in the key of F. As followers of this thread will appreciate, this is the equivalent of playing C on the G row of a D/G instrument. Without preconditioning, unfettered by the restrictions of theoretical knowledge, there is no reason why these keys should not be practical, useful and accessible.