Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tune of the Month => Topic started by: Clive Williams on August 31, 2010, 10:17:17 PM
-
The number of people posting recordings has really dropped off over the past couple of months, but oddly not the number of people voting in the polls. Certainly, holiday will be part of that, but I suspect not the entire story.
I'm open to all manner of options/suggestions as to what to do with TOTM going forward, and we'll have that discussion in the fullness of time I'm sure, but for now the first step is to find out what issues, if any, should be addressed by whatever we change!
So, to start my thought processes off, here's a question for you: if you've posted recordings before, but not got round to it over the past few months, can you think why? If you've fancied doing a recording, but never got round to it, what's put you off?
Cheers,
Clive
-
I was finding it a bit of a treadmill - learning a tune from scratch each month. Took a break and been learning other tunes over a longer period. Want to get back into TOTM but some of the choices have not been doing it for me. Maybe I should suggest one! How about Farewell to the Creeks (I wouldn't have to learn it from scratch)?
Neil
Good idea Clive - I'll make it my holiday tune.
-
I have to say when totm started I could keep up with the tunes, but lately a lot of the tunes are out of my ability level or they are tunes that will take ages to learn and never be used again. Id rather learn session useful tunes than spend a month learning a tune I dislike or that im not gonna play again. Especially as I have less time now ive taken up the fiddle.
-
So, to start my thought processes off, here's a question for you: if you've posted recordings before, but not got round to it over the past few months, can you think why?
That'd be me, then.
I've been fearfully busy, haven't felt like I had time. Didn't post anything for July, and no Nutting Girl for August. The studio (where I usually do recordings/videos) has been a mess (it's a conservatory and tends to get things dumped in it) but that's cleared up now so there's less excuse...
Possible explanations:
- General: The novelty's worn off?
- Cock of the North: didn't seem worth bothering with, other than a possible version in five different keys but that felt like gratuitous showing off for no good reason.
- Nutting Girl: didn't really know what I could do with it other that a fairly straight rendition of something that wasn't exactly the right tune from any of the collected traditions...
- Music you wouldn't expect on a melodeon I have an entry for this which I will submit late. I also have some ambitious possibilities which just aren't ready yet, but I might be able to hack the (3/2) Hornpipe from Handel's Water Music.
- Tunes from France: we did one, but I should really have a go at La Boîte à Frissons on my new G/C box. Again, it will have to be late, or it could double as a tune I learned this Summer.
-
Pretty much what Anahata said goes for me too.
Maybe it should be split between beginners/improvers and whizzfinger wizards.
I can certainly understand LDT's point.
-
The number of people posting recordings has really dropped off over the past couple of months, but oddly not the number of people voting in the polls. Certainly, holiday will be part of that, but I suspect not the entire story.
I'm open to all manner of options/suggestions as to what to do with TOTM going forward, and we'll have that discussion in the fullness of time I'm sure, but for now the first step is to find out what issues, if any, should be addressed by whatever we change!
So, to start my thought processes off, here's a question for you: if you've posted recordings before, but not got round to it over the past few months, can you think why? If you've fancied doing a recording, but never got round to it, what's put you off?
Cheers,
Clive
it;s partly the weather - really - all that rain Iam sure can provoke SAD* (not just MAD) as well as being the runaround outside season.
BUT BUT
I dont (can't) post. HOWEVER - watching these efforts and appreciating the pain folk put themselves through getting them ready generates much pleasure for the viewer.
They are a MASSIVE learning aid for those lower down the scale.
They can be good for showing technical tricks which will percolate into the brain and reappear in one's own efforts later.
Some are quite inspirational and set (me for one) some off in search of more of the same, new toons to listen to.
Maybe those who only watch (but also serve) such as myself, do not say thank you enough often enough. Sorry about that. I do PM players some times when they have knocked me out (you know who you are!) or for technical tips and the latter are much appreciated.
So there is a bigger picture in all this -- the debate over the Battle of the Somme proves the trigger effect - 10 pages of comments at least. And every time I go anywhere now I manage to get someone to strike it up on all kinds of instruments!!!
And TOTM online in your own time at your own pace should not be underrated as a driving dynamo for performance in those Village halls, camp gatherings, festival sessions and of course full blown stage gigs - All the World's a stage and one can see many TOTM players ending up on one at some stage or other.
The CLive IT dept must be able to tell us how many VIEWINGS there have been per toons played.... that would be a good indicator how much we concert goers appreciate the musicians.
You will be aware that TOTM is also raising thoughts elsewhere of having the same monthly operation.... imitation is the best form of flattery.
So, pray for more sun, wait patiently for newbies to coast in as and when they are ready and keep the door wide open not just for TOTM but other toon efforts. Some people prefer different types of music so the greater the variety (my preference for slow and haunting - aaagghhh, that word, that word) fast and furious etc. I am not a fan of "three old craws sitting on a branch" type stuff but I welcome the chance to hear folk playing/singing it!
So Clive - light up a Hamlet. sit back and have a glass of Lindisfarne oldeMeno Mead- you deserve it for leading by example (and playing some super toons while I smoke my King Edward Invincibles).
Now, instead of writing this note, which I do with unstinting gratitude for what has been graciously given by you all, if I had spent the time learning Sweet Thames flow softly I could have though about popping something up. :||: :||: :||:
-
Kautilya, my man. Your best (and most intelligible) post yet.
Sincere thanks. (:)
-
I do believe (hope) that with the nights getting longer people will close their curtains and return to the music and recording equipment.
As for myself I am afraid posting is a learning curve that I don't have time for at present. Probably have the basic equipment to post but lack, knowledge skill and patience at present time. During the little time that I have before lights out, I like to practice some tunes (read as: annoy the neighbours) including some TOTM tunes but I am know finding that although I can knock out a few tunes (not to high standard), I do not have a group of tunes that I can use as a set.
Would hate TOTM to stop as I have gained a lot from observing and listening to the box being played on its own as the sound is not masked by drums guitars etc.
John
-
Why? Holidays! ;D
-
holidays, beer, cider, moosics, mmmmm! festival food too, no sorry, had my goddam fill!
-
...wait patiently for newbies to coast in as and when they are ready...
We have had about 80 new members during August.
-
Oh I was gonna say I prefer theme of the months over tune of the month. That way there's more leeway for for the confident and less confident to choose a tune that suits the theme and their abilities.
-
Id rather learn session useful tunes than spend a month learning a tune I dislike or that im not gonna play again.
That pretty much echoes my own feelings.
I found/find TOTM a brilliant way to learn new tunes, with guidance from more experienced players where necessary (eg, with the basses). Having got my head round some of the more session-friendly TOTMs from the early days, I started going along to a local session, feeling that I could at least bash out Speed the Plough, Princess Royal and Michael Turner's Waltz without disgracing myself.
I'm now busily trying to learn as many of the regular session tunes as possible (especially as I play by ear, rather than from the dots).
I still think TOTM is great, and look at many of the posts, but I'm probably more likely to try and learn a new tune and post a recording/video if the chosen TOTM is something I think is likely to be useful for future sessions.
-
Id rather learn session useful tunes than spend a month learning a tune I dislike or that im not gonna play again.
That pretty much echoes my own feelings.
I found/find TOTM a brilliant way to learn new tunes, with guidance from more experienced players where necessary (eg, with the basses). Having got my head round some of the more session-friendly TOTMs from the early days, I started going along to a local session, feeling that I could at least bash out Speed the Plough, Princess Royal and Michael Turner's Waltz without disgracing myself.
I'm now busily trying to learn as many of the regular session tunes as possible (especially as I play by ear, rather than from the dots).
I still think TOTM is great, and look at many of the posts, but I'm probably more likely to try and learn a new tune and post a recording/video if the chosen TOTM is something I think is likely to be useful for future sessions.
Ditto, really. And I do think it would be a huge shame if TOTM were to disappear. It's potentially such a fantastic learning resource and has already proved to be so.
-
I'm with Anahata too. Some of the elected tunes I'd never bother to learn, though I have jammed along with most of them in a sessions. I had problems with my camera at first (also think the charger may still be in Suffolk) but the dedicated Olympus sound gadget is much easier to use and post process. Hence a few posts.
But it's time. I've three quite big extra projects in sway at present, 2 of which involve London meetings. Plus normal job. Also I'll never personally take to a new tune in a mere 31 days. I've always treated melodies like the more tannic and structured Bordeaux - they improve for some laying down as I hope anyone who got to the Welsh borders 'Gleanings' weekend might agree. Anything I might de-cork after just a month will still be a sulky little ditty with some rough edges. It's less technique than just learning/feeling/experimenting how I want to play it.
To those to who feel technique is a barrier - I'd say soldier on. None of the set so far has been a real finger twister, although they can be a challenge. Every little trick learned will pay off again later in some other tune. Having said that - I've no clue yet how to attempt Liberty Belle! But once you get at them they seem to find a way and then fall under the fingers.
I'd say soldier on but don't lose too much sleep re the numbers. Internet being internet it is developing into quite a nice little archive. Thanks to Lester for doing the indexing.
-
Oh I was gonna say I prefer theme of the months over tune of the month. That way there's more leeway for for the confident and less confident to choose a tune that suits the theme and their abilities.
That's pretty much the thinking behind ThOTM; it's very hard to come up with one TOTM nomination that pleases beginners and advanced players alike, and coming up with 12 per year is nigh on impossible. The ThOTM allows those that want to, but don't particularly fancy the month's TOTM, to have a go.
I'm not really thinking about dropping TOTM by the way, but am pondering ways it could be changed/updated so it doesn't become elitist - once it drops below a certain number, other new players will be discouraged from joining in, and it'll become stuck as the domain of a few. If we can keep it nice and healthy now, it'll be a lot easier to keep it rolling.
And no, I don't have any particular idea in mind; I'm just canvassing opinion at this stage, and waiting for inspiration to hit!
Cheers,
Clive
-
I think TOTM is great and have really enjoyed learning most of the tunes, I don't like Cock of the North much but was hoping to learn a A minor version but it turned out to much for me. I'm still working on The Nutting Girl so hope to do something at the weekend. For me as a lonesome beginner , no known Melodeon players locally TOTM is an essential learning tool. I must admit I much prefer the Videos to the audio files as I get to actually see what folks do - bass, bellow control etc. I really appreciated the tutorials videos that Clive, Chris and DTN did.
don't really see how it could be made better. I hope numbers improve in the autumn (which seems to be here (Bavaria) already!)
Louise
-
I'm encouraged to see posts saying how much people have learned from TOTM, and also preferring video for learning-related reasons. It's always nice to get feedback.
I may be arrogantly assuming that others have learned something from me, but even if that's true I have also learned a lot from other video and audio postings and from the discussions that ensued here.
-
I'm not really thinking about dropping TOTM by the way, but am pondering ways it could be changed/updated so it doesn't become elitist - once it drops below a certain number, other new players will be discouraged from joining in, and it'll become stuck as the domain of a few. If we can keep it nice and healthy now, it'll be a lot easier to keep it rolling.
There is no reason why the choice of tune has to be poll.
If the total vote is less than a large minority of members (30 to 50%???) then it counts for little, especially as many who vote for a tune don't contribute a recording. So Clive, you could simply act as a benevolent dictator, and receive suggestions and then choose the tune yourself using the suggestions as a source of inspiration.
-
If the total vote is less than a large minority of members (30 to 50%???) then it counts for little, especially as many who vote for a tune don't contribute a recording. So Clive, you could simply act as a benevolent dictator, and receive suggestions and then choose the tune yourself using the suggestions as a source of inspiration.
Well, I have been considering that; I thought I'd see how this thread goes, and indeed how Liberty Bell goes. But the thing is, it comes down to the impossibility of pleasing everyone all the time. You see, I could either pick deliberately easy ones to please learners; or I could pick more advanced ones to please those that are a little bored. Or I could alternate, so you get one easy one month, one moderate the next month, one fairly hard the next. Until I thought a bit and realised that was exactly what we've had recently courtesy of the poll - it's kind of a self limiting thing. If people are bored of easy stuff, harder stuff tends to win next time; if people thought something was too hard, easier stuff tends to win next time.
I also thought I'd see how many contributions Liberty Bell pulls in; if not many, then TOTM's should probably stay relatively easy choices. If it revitalises interest, and we see a few people back we haven't seen in a while, a mix of tune difficulty may be a way forward to keep a healthy turnover of players.
Cheers,
Clive
-
benevolent dictator,
pleasing everyone all the time.
Clive
Quick chance to slide in my technical hobbyhorse to help beginners to learn faster when copying the experienced.
The Chuff Trwll thinks my brain is addled because I cannot work out things backwards as easily ass him. BUT,
watching his fingering as HE sees and plays it (admittedly only right hand) as at Bradfield is much easier if the camera is viewing from the player's perspective. Face on it is "backwards" for the viewer so the brain has to do all kinds of mental acrobatics to get the fingers to play along.
At Bradfield I did as best I could and I was specifically trying to film his hands from the player's angle. Same with Yorkie (also below).
However as InsightandMind already presciently knew months ago that Clive was going to raise TOTM issues now, I was ccommissioned to film a clear example of how one might film as it is played. Yes, I know, this is on a whistle. Yes, it may be difficult to get bass and treble sides of a box in view. But at least one side can be shown by simply putting the camcorder on a tripod, positioning it to look down over the shoulder of the player.
The whistle shots were done for the learners to pratcise after the workshop.
I have also discovered a rotating software to flip the screen and I will try that on one of Clive's full frontals (battle of the somme http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnyLhVMUIkE&feature=related ) and see whether it helps ... I have to get my head round it by trying) irotate verrsion 1.37 www.entechtaiwan.com
It works!! Or have it got it all "esra over teet" as they say in Moscow?
It may give Clive a bloodrush to the head, but you will see that if he had also filmed right up on the box you would so easily be able to follow his fingering and TOTM dis-players would not have to worry about positioning the camera over their shoulders or above their heads. It also avoids folk seeing your unmade beds, saunas, washing machines and empty meths and absinthe bottles on the shelves.... Tracey Emin willl hate it.
So whaddya think? - be nice if someone can experiment.
Tks to Terry Coyne for:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IxPeAJKJiA
Rees at 2.36
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0SDZzKL_m5Q
Yorkie at 36"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xyN_g8U2ggc
and finally... if the dictator kindly agrees this could go into his tips for recording video and sound files (:) (:)
-
I like both TOTM and ThOTM, but for different reasons. ThOTM is usually more fun and more accessible, since it's most always possible to just choose something that you already like and that's within your comfort zone. TOTM, though, seems to have more educational worth, as it tends to involve tackling something that you ordinarily wouldn't have chosen, for whatever reason. I do think, though, that there's a difficulty in having both TOTM and ThOTM every month, as it can be a bit of a distraction to be preparing two entries so regularly.
I'm not a particularly big fan of the voting system. It's rare for me to know what more than one or two of the tunes actually are and it's not always obvious where to look them up. I know, in theory, it wouldn't do me any harm to persevere find them somehow, but in practice, it just doesn't happen. Also, it's not unusual to find, on first viewing, that there's already a run-away favourite (for some unknown reason) and that investigating the others isn't going to achieve much anyway. I'd be just as happy with a dictated choice, as, in effect, that's what it seems like anyway.
Personally, I think I've learned a great deal from TOTM/ThOTM. When watching better players, there's been the chance to see how they go about tackling the same source material, which is obviously very informative. Then there have been those occasions when 'beginner' players have posted simple, yet musically very effective, entries that tend to lead me to rethink my priorities. Also, there's the chance to consider entries that I don't enjoy so much - what is it about them that doesn't do it for me? How can I learn from that?
I guess another ongoing challenge of it, particularly with TOTM, is in finding ways of adding some sort of individuality to it. When everyone is attempting the same thing, I find it adds to the experience to try and think of something that might be a bit different from everyone else. Also, there's also the challenge of not just repeating the same style, techniques and tricks from one entry to the next, but to mix those up too.
-
I love Tune of the Month and would be very sad if it was discontinued. To be quite honest I mainly stopped posting because my playing is so poor and I felt embarrassed about inflicting it on people every month. I have learned such a lot from watching all the videos, and equally from reading the interesting comments on pieces of music and the way the players interpret them. Of course there is also the genuine enjoying of hearing people play their instruments and of feeling part of a real community of people sharing a great interest, although less so since I have stopped posting videos. I haven't read all the comments in this thread yet, but please, please keep TOTM happening! I adore my melodeons and still play them every day, so there is no lack of interest on my part, just a genuine concern about whether anyone else needs to hear me playing them :|bl
Cheers to everyone and thanks for all your great efforts.
-
Kautilya, my man. Your best (and most intelligible) post yet.
Sincere thanks. (:)
Hahaha! I agree Rees ;D And thanks Kautilya for articulating all that so well (:)
-
playing is so poor and I felt embarrassed about inflicting it on people every month
Know what you mean but not true. If you, LDT and other learners hadn't posted I'd never have had the courage to inflict my playing on others. I still tend to "hide" behind my hubby and prefer to post duets as that way the tune keeps going when I fall apart. But I think the beginner videos are also great encouragement for other learners.
Louise
-
Guilty - I often vote on TOTM if the tunes attract me, but I never post my efforts once I've learned the tune. I find the process of learning very rewarding, and am grateful for the TOTM format. Some months though, I just don't bother, if the tune doesn't do it for me. Some months I learn one of the short-listed tunes, instead of the poll winner. I rarely watch the videos or listen to the recordings of those who have cracked it, unless I need to know how the tune goes, or if there is a stream of admiring messages and a certain recording is obviously very impressive. This isn't from arrogance, just a lack of time, and also, if I want to hear someone's half-learned version, with no left hand, and several mistakes, then all I have to do is listen to my own efforts, I don't need to log on for that! I also don't have the recording kit, webcam, patience to learn yet another piece of recording software, or inclination to sign up for even more accounts with YouBook, FaceTube, etc etc etc.
I do like TOTM though, and find it very useful, and am glad some people can be bothered to put their efforts on line.
-
Time, Space & Technology - these are the mundane reasons (excuses?) that stop me posting ToTMs ;D
I keep meaning to set up one place where I can record but never get round to it. Partly cause I'm enjoying learning & practising the TotM! I may be one of many that learn it (mostly) every month but don't post. It's brilliant to see what others do, so I apologise for not contributing. The two ToTM that saw a big leap in my playing were Battle of the Somme and Schottische a Bethanie. a) I would never have learnt these tunes by myself, b) they add something different to my 'repetoire' and c) include technical stuff that stimulates further interest - e.g. time signatures & how to play things differently.
I'd be happy for benevolent dictator(s) to select tunes - I like the discipline of being told what to play!
-
My hunch is that the original rash of posted recordings was mainly a novelty factor thing, and I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of members are still actually having a bash at learning new tunes that they are interested in, but they now feel they have 'set out their stall', as it were, and now are being more selective about which tunes they wish to expose to public view, quite reasonably not wishing to be thought of as youtube hoggers. So, keep up both ToTM and ThoTM, I say, and don't worry if there are fewer responses. It ain't broke!
Something I've found is that I'm increasingly getting ideas of tunes I'd like to have a go at from other unrelated threads (such as Catharsis, Violet Tulloch Queen of Lerwick, Reel Eugène, and Hommage à Gilles Laprise), and I have wondered about trying to post my efforts too as recordings. I did wonder about suggesting that it might be an idea to have a sort of 'bin for non-recyclables' (except that it would never get emptied), so that anyone who wanted to contribute anything they liked could chuck it in, no pressure. Any mileage in that one, Clive? My thinking was that this might allow people with a new idea for playing something that otherwise wouldn't ever become a popular choice, to feel able to contribute it. Of course, they could always start a thread themselves, but that's a bit different.
-
As a beginner I think TOTM is great. I've learnt a few tunes from the old TOTMs and I'm working on The Nutting Girl but it's not quite ready yet. However, there's a big step between being able to play it OK and sitting down in front of a camera and playing it round twice without it falling apart.
Maybe it should be "three tunes of the three months"? There could be three tunes on the go at once giving a wider variety of tunes (i.e. allowing something for the beginners and something for the more experienced players) and more time for people to get round to learning and posting their tunes.
-
Maybe it should be "three tunes of the three months"?
Could be, but it's frequently made clear that anyone's welcome to post tunes of the previous or earlier months, which amounts to almost the same thing.
-
I did wonder about suggesting that it might be an idea to have a sort of 'bin for non-recyclables' (except that it would never get emptied), so that anyone who wanted to contribute anything they liked could chuck it in, no pressure. Any mileage in that one, Clive? My thinking was that this might allow people with a new idea for playing something that otherwise wouldn't ever become a popular choice, to feel able to contribute it.......
I like Chris's thinking here... a selection either voted for or dictated, and perhaps something broader than a Theme of the month, or an additional pot-luck category for tunes we have learned and wish to perform now, without waiting for the "correct" category to arrive.
I think the TotM is a wonderful medium to share knowledge and learn technique. I don't think it needs fixing. The summer has been a very busy time for myself, and I have not had much time to post, as it takes a bit of effort with my primitive setup. I have learned a couple of the tunes, though.
-
I did wonder about suggesting that it might be an idea to have a sort of 'bin for non-recyclables'
...
Of course, they could always start a thread themselves, but that's a bit different.
It it really? I'd have thought the "tunes" section was ideal for posting along the lines of "here's a YouTube of me playing this random tune I've just learnt and would like to share with the rest of you!"
I think the TotM is a wonderful medium to share knowledge and learn technique. I don't think it needs fixing.
Yep. One of the good self regulating things about it is that each month starts exactly one pair of new threads, so the number and size of the the threads is quite sensible and each one is focused on a clear topic.
-
Oh bother! I really am going to have to do Liberty Bell this month aren't I? I voted for it and when it was mooted before I was an advocate of it.
I haven't posted much recently due to pressure of work essentially. I will be back, honestly.
G
-
It it really? I'd have thought the "tunes" section was ideal for posting along the lines of "here's a YouTube of me playing this random tune I've just learnt and would like to share with the rest of you!"
I wondered if anyone would query that! The difference is a bit subtle, and it's an etiquette thing, I think. If I've learned a tune from somebody else's contribution or idea, for example, but wanted to do it in a new way, I might consider that starting my own thread about it might be thought of as just taking over someone else's good idea, and perhaps ruffle a few feathers. Whereas, if there were just a bin for such tunes, it could be more accepted as just a contribution to a general library of technique ideas. I know it's only a subtle difference. Do you see the point?
-
Ok, as a regular reader and Melnet follower but zero contributor to TOTM, what's my thoughts:
1. Technology is the excuse I can hide behind, or lack of, plus pressures of work - but got the Zoom H2 on loan to play with so.....that one's gone at least for this weekend!
2. Inspiration - I look forward to hearing how different people tackle the same chunk of ABC, particularly tunes already ingrained in my fingers. So thanks to Anahata, DTN, Graeme, GbH, LDT, Lester and all the other posters who have taken tunes in different directions. It makes me think - stop playing automatically and think again!
3. Motivation to learn new tunes - there have been some cracking tunes over the past year - Ashokan, Plane/ Bethanie, Rusty Gully. Tunes which I sort of knew but had never botherered to investigate. TOTM gave me that kick, particularly as you heard others have a go.
4. TTOTM - a good catch-all idea to run in parallel. It gives people a route to contribute, but not necessarily a reason to learn something new.
5. Future TOTM - I would favour some benign dictatorship steering choices occassionally to ensure there is a good mix of tunes. The challenge is that some great tunes get suggested, but often the majority of members don't know them so never vote for them. So perhaps we need 'help' to make the right decision sometimes :)
Summary - great idea - long may it continue. I am sure there are lots of people like me who follow it but have yet to upload a note.
And thank you Clive.
Enjoy the weekend
Andy
-
I agree with much of what Andy has said above.
I am a bit of a techno-numpty and don't know how to post a tune, but even if I did, I don't think I'd want to expose myself, so to speak. However, I'm very grateful for those who are prepared to do this and share their efforts. I always look at the TOTM thread and am often inspired to learn or re-visit the tune after hearing the discussions and seeing/hearing some of the examples that people have posted.
It's not just the playing of the tunes that's of interest - there is often some discussion about the origin of the tune, variations, speed, how it fits with dancing, etc. Please don't think of stopping TOTM just because there aren't dozens and dozens of sound/video files to see. There are some of us out here who get a lot out of it even if we don't seem to be contributing much.
-
I would offer two possible explanations as to why the number of posters for Tune of the Month has diminished, although I have no tangible evidence to support either of them. The first is based on the fact that Tune of the Month began last autumn and was quite well supproted during the winter months. However, during the spring and summer months many of us have been spending much of our spare time at festivals or at dance-outs with Morris sides for whom we play. This reduces the amount of time we can spend learning and practising tunes in order to post them on YouTube. My second point is that the number of posters has diminished since Theme of the Month was introduced. This would be entirely predictable because there are now not one, but at least two, tunes to practise and record each month, but only the same amount of time available in which to do so. No surprise, then, that the effect has been to reduce the number of postings.
If I am right (a big 'if'), then the number of Tune of the Month postings ought to increase again during the winter months, when there are likely to be fewer distractions. However, in order to encourage this, it might be worth considering an alteration to the system whereby, instead of having both a Tune of the Month and a Theme of the Month every month, they would alternate, so that one month there would be a Tune of the Month and for the next month there would be a Theme of the Month.
Are these thoughts in any way helpful or is this just drivel occasioned by alcohol deprivation, which I am now going to address?
-
Hope you don't mind me being honest! .... I love posting Tunes / Vids ... but due to the festival season pressures time is never been allocated ... but also the tunes in last couple of months just don't get my musical juices flowing! ... this months has got me interested again ... just need to find the time! ... then its the dark end of the year where everything becomes more possible!
I think this effect has been suggested .... I'm living it!.... I think TOTM is brilliant and i'm racked with a 'little' bit of guilt for not supporting it recently!
DTN
:o
-
have followed totm since speed the plough.
have learned some tunes.
can nearly play some of them.
however, the next one comes around before i am competent to publish.
currently i am enjoying learning the B section of nutting girl.
please continue. i may well catch up.
-
please continue. i may well catch up.
;D
-
I fully intend to start posting again, hopefully get this months in soon as I love the tune!
I could make my excuses but I've simply been too busy over the summer for anything internet related, let alone totm.
Don't change it, I think it's a great platform to see how we all play and the standard we are all at.
There are a few of us who like to show off our talents, and others who need the whole month to learn to play each tune. The vast contrast is brilliant and it's that which makes the wonderful material on this forum. What matters most is that the oppertunity is there for those want to post their totm,
I've also read that some people aren't keen on the last few tunes that have been winning the polls. I must admit I don't even know what they were I'll need to look them up. Playing music is hard to do if you don't like the tune. People often ask me to play my favourite piece, I simply reply, I like everything I play. If I don't like something, I don't play it. That may also reflect in the results of totm.
Apologies for my absence this summer. I can't promise better attendance but I'll do what I can.
-
Well said Graeme, I am looking forward to your next video!
-
I fully intend to start posting again, hopefully get this months in soon as I love the tune!
Please do! :P
-
Reading through this thread there seems to be a common theme of 'I like TotM but don't often post due to: time, comptence, digital savvy, etc@ which all seems to point towards a positive continuation.
Earlier in the thread its being discussed whether to make every TotM accessible (i.e easy) or to vary difficulty.
My request is for the latter. I can't play the harder pieces but really enjoy watching others do a great job which inspires me to carry on practising harder and longer. They serve the melodeon learning community well.
Then I appreciate the easy ones as something I can strive towards.
Long may it continue!
-
Equally, I love the challenge of the harder tunes, but the musical challenge of the easier ones. I agree with varying the difficulty.
-
In my other life as a clawhammer banjo player I hang out on a similar forum for players. They also have a "tune of the....." (there are more banjo players so they can do it weekly). However the format they pick is that the members volunteer in advance to "do" the tune for a particular week. When their time comes around they post a description of the tune, some history, links to available versions on youtube, amazon etc, tab or sheet music if available, hints for learners etc. This invites both discussion around the tune and for other players to post their versions. Works quite well for them although they struggle to fill in every week in advance. Not sure if this would be appropriate for us, although it may be easier than a poll.
Ray
-
I've been ill most of the summer so that's why I haven't posted (I think I did Cock of the north, though). Then there have been some tunes that I didn't like or felt were too advanced to learn (Rusty Gully, The Liberty bell) for my level.
I love TOTM, it has done a lot for my inspiration, motivation, and introduced me to English trad music. Very nice. I often find it hard to decide what tunes to work on, so something like TOTM is excellent for my learning and my discipline in learning to play. As someone pointed out, I sometimes feel ashamed to post because my playing is so poor. On the other hand, there is NOTHING as inspiring for me as seeing videos of other learners. Then I think "if they can do it, I can do it".
If you pros don't like tunes like Cock of the north or Nutting girl probably the idea of having a beginner section and an intermediate/anything above section is a good idea. I just wonder if that would increase the postings? We could have a test month maybe.
-
If you pros don't like tunes like Cock of the north or Nutting girl probably the idea of having a beginner section and an intermediate/anything above section is a good idea. I just wonder if that would increase the postings? We could have a test month maybe.
H'mm, I'm not entirely convinced by that (says he who hasn't posted anything to TOTM, partly because I've only recently returned to melnet but mainly because I don't have enough hours in the day as it is). I'd be wary of any system that led to a dichotomy between fellow squeezers or an elite group - we're all in the same relatively small boat, after all. OK, "Auntie Mary Had A Canary" may be musically extremely simple, but the challenge there surely lies in finding a new treatment for it; and "Nutting Girl" is a cracking tune anyway, and I can't see why anyone wouldn't like it. Anyway, I'm hoping to have a bit more available time after mid-October, so I should be able to have a crack at whatever comes up for that month......
Graham
-
Yeah, I do agree with you there, I wouldn't like it either. It was just an idea since several advanced players said that some tunes were too simple or possible too boring or how you would define Cock of the north... Well I hope it's mainly a matter of having the time, and that people have been busy with holidays and such.
-
Thanks for the discussion folks - I think the conclusion I've come to is that fundamentally there isn't anything particularly wrong with TOTM with a ThOTM running alongside; the only slight tweak I think I'll make is to lower the number of choices in the poll each month.
I like the poll as a concept; it adds a bit of drama to proceedings, and frees me from the responsibility of choosing the perfect tune each month to please everyone all of the time, which as we've proved here is quite an impossible task! The only real advantage not doing a poll is the ability to research it/possibly record a demo/tutorial of a tune before it's chosen, but let's face it, neither I, nor anyone else, is likely to find time to do that every month. And sometimes my knowledge of a tune and how it is usually played is just plain wrong (I had no idea Battle of the Somme was a Scottish pipe march, for example).
For what it's worth, I tend to prefer the simpler tunes when they win; it's more fun seeing what I and others can do with it to take the tunes into interesting direction - with more difficult stuff, I tend to spend too much time concentrating on playing the tune to be able to do anything creative with it. I do like taking a tune and playing it in 'my style' (which since you ask(!) is slow and using unisonoric basses heavily), and I think it's particularly nice when people take a tune and play it in their style, whatever that might be.
Cheers,
Clive
-
The only real advantage not doing a poll is the ability to research it/possibly record a demo/tutorial of a tune before it's chosen, but let's face it, neither I, nor anyone else, is likely to find time to do that every month.
Here is a suggestion that might do both. If the person who nominates a tune was responsible for providing background information, ABC/notation, and a sample performance, then the work of getting all that together would be spread round different people for each tune.
-
If the person who nominates a tune was responsible for providing background information, ABC/notation, and a sample performance, then the work of getting all that together would be spread round different people for each tune.
Not a bad idea. Sample performance not necessarily to be provided by nominator though, so that those who need and genuinely intend to spend time learning a tune can still nominate something new as long as they can find an example of it somewhere.
So maybe anyone can suggest a tune, but it doesn't get put on the voting list until someone (else or the same) does the above mentioned work. That in turn implies we need to be thinking rather further ahead...
-
I think the TOTM concept is a good one and doesn't need to be changed in any very big way.
What I would say, though, is that there's some value in encouraging the simpler tunes where possible, partly because more people can take part (both the less confident players and those of us who play one-rows), and partly because it's good to see more experienced players challenged to find ways of making the tunes their own.
TOTM is one of those things that benefits from being a habit - break the habit for someone, say by choosing an tune they haven't a chance of playing, and you break the monthly habit.
Gav
-
It's all been said in the above really.
Just too busy with other things. Golf included.
Autumn, Winter the best time available. Bit of the Spring too.
I'm with Anahata too. Some of the elected tunes I'd never bother to learn,
Others are inspirational. I've learnt a lot. Keep 'em coming.
Don't split it into grades Keep it all as one. Beginners and me will catch up.
The ThOTM is very good.
cheers Chas :|glug :|glug
PS. Hey we've been going for a year. Congratulations ! :|glug :|glug :|glug
-
I am extremely occupied with trying to get tenure at my university --- publishing and grant writing have taken up my entire summer. I do intend to start posting again soon. This will probably occur during the winter vacation when I am back in the US. I would like to get caught up on all the TOTM I have missed. I am happy to see it is still around!
-
I'd have to echo some of the above. As a new starter the opportunity to see so many different takes on the tunes by so many accomplished players has been invaluable, especially the videos of the players which help to give me some idea at least of what do do with the bass end! It's also been great to see the progress of other beginners and the encouragement you give them. As another ' newbie in isolation' ,I'd be sad to see TOTM go. Now back to 'L'inconnu de Limoise'.... (I've a bit of catching up to do!)
-
If I ever get a mic, I shall start 'contributing'. Until then, you've all been spared
-
Here we are again, autumn one year on. Both Tune of the Month and Theme of the Month continue to surprise, delight and educate me. The number of contributors does go down through the warmer months and that's hardly surprising taking festival/morris season into account. I remain disappointed at my own lack of output, but I'm really struggling to get to grips with a proper repertoire of morris tunes and fighting the terrible angst at performing in public that has become a relatively new and most unwelcome part of my life.
I've made a quantum leap on the concertina lately which has delighted me, only to find that my ability to play in front of others has declined in proportion which is quite distressing. I will beat it though so keep the TOTM and the ThOTM of going while I play catch up and learn a few tunes on the box (box playing has improved too but you might not notice ::) ).
-
... and fighting the terrible angst at performing in public ...
I finally submitted a tune to ThOTM and found it agonising to hear how I sounded playing on my own in front of a microphone. I guess the only way I'll overcome the nerves and improve is to keep persevering. I've played the box in bands, but putting my solo playing up for public scrutiny by fellow melodeon players feels far more intimidating.
-
Totally agree with tallship and dogbox. I actually practised quite a lot for Brighton Camp, but when I came to record it I almost died of nerves. The expletive laden results would made a good movie out-take segment. I suspect that my method of practice is somewhat to blame, as I dont seem to be able to play consistently enough to record a whole tune or play properly with others. I might do a late posting of Brighton Camp if I can be bothered editing it down to the only part which was semi-respectable.
-
It is daunting to play in front of a recording device of any sort - in a different but related way to how it feels performing in front of an audience. Both can be terribly nerve inducing. But it's worth remembering that nothing ever sounds as bad to anyone else as it does to you yourself. There are a few ways of 'sneaking up' on a recorded performance - maybe just leave a sound recorder running while you practice a tune a few times through, then if you end up with one decent take and would like to put it on YouTube you could add photos of you, your melodeon, Brighton or whatever. Keep trying, peops - your efforts are appreciated. :||: :|||: (:)
-
I don't find recording particularly nerve wracking, I just go wrong more. But then I can quite happily perform solo in front of people. What I can't do without feeling very nervous is start a set in a session. No idea why.
-
I'd love to join in as I've been an avid viewer/ listener since I started learning. Two things prevent me; 1, I don't have any recording equipment or a webcam. (or the spare cash to buy any at the mo') . 2, I don't have wifi on the boat and uploading files would take forever and clatter my data allowance. This said, I do take part at home and I take on board the advice and tips given to others and also inspiration from the more experienced members. One day I'll splash out and join in properly! I'd be very sad to see totm go. Bob.
-
I definitely think it would be wrong to separate tunes into "beginners" and "advanced". Simple tunes can also be good tunes, and in the hands of an expert player, a delight to listen to.
Some TOTM choices happen to be tunes I'm sick to death of, but that's just me and I'm sure there are plenty of people who enjoy them. Other tunes may seem deceptively simple but are tunes I never tire of. Complicated tunes needn't put people off - it's always interesting to hear how different players interpret them, and sometimes you come across a version that makes the tune seem more accessible than you thought it was.
So please do keep varying the mix. I continue to offer my apologies for non-appearance: I have no idea how to make or upload a recording and am too self-conscious to do so even if I could. I still enjoy seeing how other people play the tunes.
-
As i am new to this forum i havent gotten around to plunging into the TOTM recordings. I might at some point, but i have to find out all the hardware AND software requirements to do so. It's on my to-do-list, but it's somewhere at the bottom, heh....
W
-
I posted a lot in the winter -- all those French tunes -- but have backed off. This summer has been insanely busy because of grad school and work. My blog went from 14 posts in February to 2 in August! Also, though, I find the English tunes harder to get under my fingers, and don't -- as Anahata said -- have that much incentive to master them. I still love listening to them, though! Finally, even under the best of conditions, it takes me about a month to get a tune. I'm hardly ever concerned with "doing something new and interesting" with a tune, as I am in capturing the spirit of it. I find myself posting late ThOTM because I finally feel like I've pulled my idea together. I took a shot at Lemmy Brazil's #2, and only just feel that I can play it with ease, so you folks might be seeing that one soon.
-
For anyone put off by the cost/complexity of video why not start, like me, with sound only. I use a digital dictaphone that cost about £30 on ebay!
-
Just happened on this thread, and have skipped through the last 2 pages of chat.
I am aware I've never posted, though I came close with Lemmi Brazzle..... but nerves did kick in on attempt no.1 , followed by 'life' things simply getting in the way..... and I'd missed it!
I like TOTM for another reason - it highlights tunes and shows me alternative ways of playing and I've discovered cracking tunes I didn't know.
Recently, 'Scraping the mould off the marmalade', which accompanied Anahata's rendition of Lemmie, I think, has really caught my ear and i've got the dots.... so though I might not post on youtube, I appreciate listening to others; it heads me towards tunes I'm not familiar with, and all in all I think it's a good idea to continue it.
.... and as my typo's increase, I think it's time for bed!
night all
Q
zzzzzzzzzzzzz
-
I didn't dredge this thread from the depths in order to make individual contributors or non-contributors feel guilty. Far from it. It was much more a case of taking stock compared to where we were a year ago.. I think it's level pegging. Tune of the month works, so does theme of the month. Forum members contribute when they can / when the mood takes them, and it all adds to the musical experience that is melodeon.net. All is well. :D
-
I didn't dredge this thread from the depths in order to make individual contributors or non-contributors feel guilty.
but I do ::) Summer is difficult with festivals , holibobs and school children not at school ......which is lovely, but I'm now looking forward to a bit of mel.net time again and maybe a few hours playing when I don't feel too guilty. I don't think we should change TOTM....and would be a bit concerned if the numbers posting didn't fluctuate !
Does anyone not like TOTM ? I'd be surprised :o
cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
As someone who doesn't yet contribute to it, I don't feel I should comment. But I'm going to anyway! ;D
I love TOTM. Before I'd even bought my box- and never even held one in my arms - I'd scrutinised the postings and was bowled over by the music. A BIG THANK YOU to everyone who puts themselves forward and gets their music out there. It is such a brilliant learning tool for..well I was going to say beginners, but I think everyone benefits.
And it's particularly interesting and helpful to see (hear) what different people make of the same tune; the simpler versions have helped me learn some basic tunes, and the more experienced players show just what you can aspire to.
When I've conquered the 'performance nerves', and sussed how to use the darned equipment, I will put something up there. Til then, I'll continue to watch and listen and be thankful for those with more nerve and nous!
-
I very much enjoy looking and listening to TotM. I enjoy playing or trying to play some of these - still on Brighton Camp with reversions to Three Around Three.
Yet to be sorted with recording kit and technique.
This summer has not gone remotely as intended - assorted domestic and family emergencies, plus been ill the last fortnight and not actually had holiday.
Looking forward to trying yet again to get organised.
-
It is good to see this thread living on, with a very positive 'keep TOTM going' message. I have posted some videos (very determinedly for quite a while!) but have had my playing ( :|bl for what it's worth) directed in other ways recently. As with most things in life, it seems easier to jump off the merry go round than to get back on, but I love 'Oh Joe...' so am determined to post a vid this month. These tunes are all completely new to me of course, even the culture that produced them, and I don't get 'jigs' unfortunately (the rhythm totally eludes me) but I am making progress with 'The Kesh' ;D So keep it up, all you melnetters!!
-
I've only managed one video, but I do play lots of the tunes a bit, and I love watching the varied treatments on YouTube. I also like that ToTM has upped the overall range of melodeon videos available, and I think it's great that there's a tunebook etc.
So yes, it remains awesome.
-
To chip in my penn'orth, it's a great resource for the new player. You get a chance to actually look at where people's fingers are going, what basses they are using, and you get a feeling that it's OK to put your own stamp on a tune - your own ornaments or variations. And reading the constructive criticisms gives you food for thought for your own performances.
I can see the problems inherent though - new players want tunes they can learn for sessions, more experienced players want something new. But you're always going to have that problem, so the system of having Theme of the Month where people have a bit of freedom to pick something appropriate to them, and then Tune of the Month chosen to be something that's reasonably accessible to all. Perhaps those who are totally jaded by the thought of doing such a standard yet again could treat it as an opportunity to reinvent it somewhat?
-
I have to say that I did post once when TOTM started, and I have recorded since for it now and again, but one thing I find now is that by the time I get around to thinking about doing it, there are already so many really good versions already posted, I'm not sure what mine will contribute. So I end up not doing it. I guess that's the thing for me, it's a fantastic resource to see people actually playing something - example, Clive's wonderful version of Mominette where you have to see the bellows work to understand how the rhythm works - but I don't feel my posting another OK version of it is helping anyone...also I find the recording process with all the mistakes and rerecording a bit frustrating to be honest.
-
I like TOTM for another reason - it highlights tunes and shows me alternative ways of playing and I've discovered cracking tunes I didn't know.
yes I agree with that ... I enjoy seeing and listening many people playing the same tune, every time it's a snapshot of human diversity, people offering me a kind of mirror through which I can improve (sort of psycho-analysis ??? :D)
Think I should post more recordings, but you know it's quite a fulltime job :
1/ learn properly the TOTM
2/ record it (sometimes you must take several shots before having a correct one, sometimes you grin or slip one or 2 notes, sometimes the camera is not properly set etc .. )
I happened to get aware of Melodeon.net's existing only a few time ago and I do appreciate the way it gets on. It seems there is no equivalent anywhere else.
Please go on :|||:
-
Hi all,
Here is my response: i have put up only one video since I got started on ToTM about 6 months ago. I simply don't have time! I'm a full time masters student and that doesn't give me free time for anything, let alone the accordion. Also, as a new player, a month doesn't give me time to spice up a tune... i can get a good grip on it , but nothing special and that makes it hard to want to rush to learn it quickly. I like playing a tune, letting it be, and coming back to it a few months later.
But, the ToTM is great. As one of those people who has maybe voted a few times and then not put up a video, here is my why!!
-
It is certainly true, I've noticed from the numbers listening to my various contributions over the years it's been running, that interest has waned a huge amount. Mind you, being realistic, I've always put that down to people now knowing that my playing's c..p!
-
Really busy with lots of other stuff.
Have lots of new tunes to learn if I am to play with Sarum Morris next year.
Also as you all know I just moved back to England from Sweden. Dust hasn't settled yet.
Cheers Chas :|glug
-
I'm a newbie to the melodeon (and to playing music at all), so don't feel I've anything I've wanted to share just yet - however, I voted for The Sloe because I've been trying to make a reasonable stab at it and have found others' recordings really useful (thank you everyone - really useful for learning about the rhythm, the extra 'jauntiness' of the B music beyond the dots that I have for the piece, and about playing across the rows). I've also been able to use the youtube archive to go back and look at other tunes (after a great workshop with Julia Batters at Ingleton I've been playing La Marianne, and seeing how others experiment with the piece has given me inspiration).
I can't comment on what would make more people take part (although I hope I will be doing soon - mainly nerves and uncertainty about how to make the technology work probably stopping me at the moment, and that I'm already learning a tune a week at the More Music Morecambe session), but I'm glad people do!!!
-
Although I managed to post a recording of The Sloe last month, it has been impossible for me to learn Beatrice Hill's this month due to a combination of circumstances: learning tunes for Melodeons at Witney; learning four new Morris tunes that our foreman has just added to our repertoire; starting to learn a huge list of French tunes for the French music and dance group I have just joined; not to mention commitments that have nothing to do with music. I am sure that others are in a similar position.
Furthermore, a number of people who have not been playing very long have commented that a month is too short a time for them to learn a tune well enough for them to post a recording of it. However, there seems to be general acceptance that ToTM is a 'good thing' and many people who don't post recordings benefit from listening to the postings of others.
Soooooooo, might it be worth considering lengthening the time period of each tune from one month to two? This might enable less confident players to learn the tune well enough to post a recording and would allow those who are busy a bit more time to post a recording. If we were to run each ToTM and each ThoTM for two months, then there could still be a new one each month by introducing a new Tune one month and a new Theme the next month.
Just a thought!
-
I am finding the tunes are getting more difficult (and sometimes -to me- obscure) and so I can't manage to learn them to a standard good enough to record in the month time limit. Plus when it comes to winter time the lighting condition is rubbish so my videos turn out all shadowy and dark.
-
Although it's run as 'Tune of the Month', there is no stipulated time limit. As Clive has always said, submissions are welcomed at any time, and they can be well after the particular month concerned. Also, some months' selections will be more popular than others, for all sorts of reasons. That's OK too.
I post recordings to TotM only very occasionally, but I always like to hear/see what other people are doing. TotM is a great feature and long may it continue.
-
I am finding the tunes are getting more difficult (and sometimes -to me- obscure) and so I can't manage to learn them to a standard good enough to record in the month time limit.
That's an interesting observation, and certainly something to watch out for.
I'm not sure that I agree - last year we had The Liberty Bell which was a mountainous challenge, and The Cheshire Waltz which is long and not especially well known, whereas recently we've had The Sloe and Oh Joe The Boat is Going Over which I think of as quite easy and standard stuff, but maybe that's just because I've been playing them for a long time. Anyway we all vote for the tune, so if something really easy is in the list and it doesn't get a majority vote, I'm not sure what can be done, other than keeping all the tunes simple.
I suppose we could have a choice - easy TOTM and harder TOTM, but I really think that's just making things too complicated.
Plus when it comes to winter time the lighting condition is rubbish so my videos turn out all shadowy and dark.
My camcorder is quite good but low light is definitely one of its weaker areas. Apart from the rare occasions when I've done recordings in broad daylight, I use a lot of supplementary lighting to deal with this. Borrow a couple of desk lamps/reading lamps from somewhere in the house and point them at you. One on either side works well, and pointed at the melodeon if they are directional enough, and then you're not staring direct at the light and dazzling yourself.
Although it's run as 'Tune of the Month', there is no stipulated time limit. As Clive has always said, submissions are welcomed at any time, and they can be well after the particular month concerned.
Yes, I was going to make that point too. I'm not at all convinced that having a two month interval would actually increase the number of contributions.
-
I am finding the tunes are getting more difficult (and sometimes -to me- obscure) and so I can't manage to learn them to a standard good enough to record in the month time limit.
whereas recently we've had The Sloe and Oh Joe The Boat is Going Over which I think of as quite easy and standard stuff, but maybe that's just because I've been playing them for a long time.
Well ...
La Marianne (don't know it)
Dark girl dressed in blue (hard)
The cheshire waltz (hard)
LNB polka (don't know it)
Ash grove (don't know it)
Lemmie Brazils no2. (hard)
Three around three (Just about managed it)
Brighton Camp (did I miss that one?)
Oh, Joe (know that one - although quite slow)
The Sloe (Know it and got hang of it)
BH4HR (finding it really hard)
But that's just me others will have different POV. Its not a complaint just an observation.
-
I think I can honestly say that 99% of the TOTM tunes are new to me. A part from Folkcamp and Melnet I've no contact with english folk music, over here if it's folk it's usually Balfolk/ French.
So ToTM is great for learning new tunes, some I manage others I don't, but it's always fun.
-
Being a beginner with almost no control of the bass I find every tune a challenge, but no matter how hard the tune I shall try and post some sort of version of it (albeit slow and quite possible incorrect) towards the end of each month. This group is a great facility for learning, long may it continue.
-
I am finding the tunes are getting more difficult (and sometimes -to me- obscure) and so I can't manage to learn them to a standard good enough to record in the month time limit.
whereas recently we've had The Sloe and Oh Joe The Boat is Going Over which I think of as quite easy and standard stuff, but maybe that's just because I've been playing them for a long time.
Well ...
La Marianne (don't know it)
Dark girl dressed in blue (hard)
The cheshire waltz (hard)
LNB polka (don't know it)
Ash grove (don't know it)
Lemmie Brazils no2. (hard)
Three around three (Just about managed it)
Brighton Camp (did I miss that one?)
Oh, Joe (know that one - although quite slow)
The Sloe (Know it and got hang of it)
BH4HR (finding it really hard)
But that's just me others will have different POV. Its not a complaint just an observation.
That's really interesting, LDT; you're dead right when you say one player's nightmare is another's easy-peasy. Now I think of Dark Girl, Lemmie Brazil's No 2, 3 Around 3, The Sloe and B Hill's as a walk in the park, as I've been playing them for so many years; on the other hand, in December's poll there's only one tune I know and two I've never even heard of....(oh, and the other one I've heard of because it's been mentioned here, but I've never knowingly heard it and I've no idea how it goes!). No prizes for working out which is the one I know!
Graham
-
Re: difficulty; yes, good points by all. I try to set a mix of complexity when choosing the poll; some easy, some hard, but I appreciate that's my judgement at work and what I think of as easy is not necessarily the case to all. I do try and pick at least one or two tunes that would be session standards, so if you learn it you've got something that'll be useful, as well as one or two that *should* be session standards! And I also try and pick a range of different countries too (sometimes more successfully than other times, I grant you). And then the best bit, we let democracy rule! It has one or two unexpected effects, which to me adds to the charm of the thing.
Re: 2 months; well, I've always thought that it's impossible to get a performance perfect, and if you try, you're going to be waiting a long time. So I'd bet that those who struggle to learn a tune perfectly in a month would equally struggle to learn it in two. Better to simply put out a 'this is where I got to' recording at the end of the month and move on to the next. But as we've said, the tunes and themes are always left open so that anyone who runs out of time can still have a go... but very few do if you'll notice.
Cheers,
Clive
-
Re: 2 months; well, I've always thought that it's impossible to get a performance perfect, and if you try, you're going to be waiting a long time. So I'd bet that those who struggle to learn a tune perfectly in a month would equally struggle to learn it in two.
My reason for suggesting two months rather than one was not that performances would reach a higher standard (I'm not sure that they would). I am simply wondering whether some people might feel 'overfaced' - I know that I do. There is a new tune and a new theme each month and then there are those that I was too busy to get round to learning/recording last month or the month before. It leaves me feeling a bit overwhelmed. Yes, I could pick out one or two to learn and record and ignore the rest, but I tend to just throw my hands up in frustration and do nothing, whereas if they did not come quite so thick and fast I would probably feel more inclined to learn and record them.
However, judging from the posts since I raised this issue, others don't see it see it like that, so I shall say no more and leave it to others to contribute their recordings. Mine wouldn't have been that good anyway.
-
I managed a post for the first time last month with The Sloe, only because I'd just about got there playing it before it was voted ToTM.
As a relative beginner, I'm conscious of the time I take to learn a tune properly, especially as it would be a fair bit quicker to get it to stick on the EC so I know tunes can be got up to speed quickly. I find this time taken frustrating. Enjoyable but frustrating!
That said I feel I'm getting things a bit quicker now, but a month's pushing me.
Sometimes when I try and learn something, I find I bump into another tune and it is learnt more quickly thant the first tune, and realise some tunes don't stick in my brain. Not necessarily related to how hard it is, sometimes the simple ones won't stick, whether it be a month or a year, they don't go in and I let them drop. Time limits are not necessarily the restriction for me, some just don't go in.
I the mixture is important, like any 'club' thing, you have to cater for the beginner to get them involved, and also cater for the experienced player too or they get bored. I find the mix is reasonable, and even if I don't want to learn the tune, it's still good to see how others tackle things. It has also nudged me towards some tunes I didn't know, I'm currently getting to grips witht 'Scraping the mould off the marmalade' after listening to Anahata play it with Lemmie's. Cheshire Waltz wouldn't quite stick, but it's one of those I will come back to. Never heard it til I listened here.
I think ToTM is a broad church and caters for a range of abilities and objectives, some wanting to learn it and post, some learning it for later and others using it as brain fodder in some way.
I think it is A Good Idea!
Q
-
Learned melnet by ziachmusi. I love it. In my area Irish and bal folk is nthe normal folk music. So, I enjoy to speak with people who loves the same music as me and learn tunes together. Some months it is really hard and the others it is quite easy. But I enjoy the contact. This is the main point for me: to be the community of melodeon players. The difficulty or the standard on youtube etc. comes after this.
-
joreema: ' enjoying the contact..... a community of melodeon players...'
Well put - exactly!
Q
-
Sometimes when I try and learn something, I find I bump into another tune and it is learnt more quickly thant the first tune,
;D Same here, especially if there's a tune on Youtube I need to learn and make the mistake of following links to other tunes
..... some tunes don't stick in my brain. Not necessarily related to how hard it is, sometimes the simple ones won't stick, whether it be a month or a year, they don't go in and I let them drop. Time limits are not necessarily the restriction for me, some just don't go in. ....
:Ph thought I was on my own sometimes not being able to pick up some things everyone else seems to play ;D you're right, it's nothing to do with the difficulty of the tune, some are 'stayers', others go in one ear and straight out the other without leaving a trace ;D
ToTM is great for bringing up tunes I'd never come across before :D
-
Kautilya has it nailed down very well.
Many of you posters don't know how much your stuff is appreciated.
Unfortunately, some of us (me) are still back at Canal en Octobre and Orange in Bloom.
(though was inspired to learn "In a Garden Green" out of order, as the Anahata version was so nicely done that it just cried out "hey, you can do this one".
--Faithful lurker. :|bl
-
Almost everything that can be said about TOTM has been covered. I've just read the thread in one go and it amazes me that the same theme keeps cropping up, ie. you can post anytime, even after the month end. This gives perfectionists, beginners or busy people not just the opportunity to post but also to choose the level of tune they are comfortable with.
At first take this late posting may seem a little pointless but the second consistent message is just how much the postings are appreciated. I want to press the Youtube 'like' button to show my appreciation but if I do I'm then forced to fill in my details which I don't want to so I don't know how to give my support to those who have posted except by way of this thread.
The format is spot on as is the monthly choice. Encouragement and tweaks will hopefully restore the figures.
confession: I'm also guilty of voting and learning the tunes but not posting.
-
I want to press the Youtube 'like' button to show my appreciation but if I do I'm then forced to fill in my details which I don't want to so I don't know how to give my support to those who have posted except by way of this thread.
Many people post their appreciative comments directly on the individual TotM threads as they occur.
confession: I'm also guilty of voting and learning the tunes but not posting.
Don't worry, you're not the only one! ;)
-
I like TOTM...
It gives me a kick up the backside to look at new tunes.
It makes me rethink tunes I kind of know already.
And reminds me of tunes my fingers somehow remember but I've never known the name of - e.g. Beatrice Hill 3HR.
And the diversity of the videos inspires.
Andy
-
Speaking as a beginner, I tend to go through the Youtube listings & find a tune that I like, being played in a key I can accommodate (I currently have no D/G box). I'm not at the point that it makes sense to simply pick the current TOTM. BUT I do hugely appreciate the resource that TOTM has provided. Thank you all!
I've started making my own pitiful efforts to record something. It remains a salutary experience to realise just how big a gap there is between being able to play a tune reasonably competently, & being able to play it start-to-finish with absolutely NO screw-ups. :-[
-
TOTM is essential to my progress, I play by ear at the moment and seek out those in DG . All of you that contribute are helping those who often have no other contact on a regular basis with other box players in person. A big thanks is due for taking the time to share the tunes. I now have about 50 tunes on my U tube faves list and visit them often as part of my practice.
-
I just found this discussion was (almost) still alive. My own playing of music is just barely alive, and I'll yet again make an effort to revive it.
When thinking of my melodeon playing and totm, I realized I didn't really get going with my playing before I found totm. I remember sitting one entire evening with that French mazurka (never learned it) and then with Princess Royal, and later Bethanie. It's been a real challenge but totm has helped tremendously with learning to "hear" what chords to use, getting used to play on the inner row, and using the basses in more awkward phrases (because in many of the totm tunes there's a lot of pull-push and it's not always possible to cross rows to make it smoother). And playing whatever is possible (no typical Swedish melodeon player would ever even think of playing Ashokan farewell). I like that.
I've wanted to join in several times this year but never managed because of studies/too much work/similar. Now I feel that I HAVE to play more music for my own wellbeing and since I'm generally restless totm is a good thing and I'll try to join again.
I guess another problem I see (but that's probably just me, I'm always like that) is that recently it's almost only the top players who post something, which always intimidates me, and makes me feel that there's no point. But, I love seeing newbie recordings, it's extremely inspiring, and if I post maybe other newbies want to post.
I agree with Sarah that many of the recent tunes have at least seemed very difficult. But I'm not sure if it only seemed like that because I felt too stressed at the time to really sit down to learn a tune I've never heard, and that didn't seem easy enough.
-
Hi Susi - hope to hear you playing again soon then! I can relate to the 'too much work' thing; one of the things I do with TOTM is make time to play as a way of keeping myself sane, because otherwise work would take over completely (I'm crazy busy at the moment, mainly because I'm taking the step of growing what used to be a one man business as well as doing work that actually pays the bills).
I wouldn't say recent tunes have been too hard, but a few of them are obscure and not that well known I grant you. Inna Inna being a great example. No-one's heard it before, but it's really quite simple to play if you take a bit of time to go through it. I think there's a risk of being put off by something just because you *assume* it's going to be hard. For the most part, Liberty Bell apart, they're not... it just takes a bit of time, and a bit of confidence, and you'll be a slightly better player with a slightly bigger repertoire at the end of the month. Repeat for 12 months, and watch your skills grow.
Having said that, I'm surprised 'Rabbit Stew' is currently winning this month's poll; that's *hard*! If anyone wants a simpler tune, I'd suggest voting for something like the Bear Dance instead; a lovely tune with lots of possibility, but really very simple to learn. In rough order of decreasing hardness, I'd say Rabbit Stew is the hardest, Molly Oxford, 3 Sea Captains, Bear Dance.
Good luck!
Clive
-
I wouldn't say recent tunes have been too hard, but a few of them are obscure and not that well known I grant you. Inna Inna being a great example. No-one's heard it before, but it's really quite simple to play if you take a bit of time to go through it. I think there's a risk of being put off by something just because you *assume* it's going to be hard. For the most part, Liberty Bell apart, they're not... it just takes a bit of time, and a bit of confidence, and you'll be a slightly better player with a slightly bigger repertoire at the end of the month. Repeat for 12 months, and watch your skills grow.
Having said that, I'm surprised 'Rabbit Stew' is currently winning this month's poll; that's *hard*! If anyone wants a simpler tune, I'd suggest voting for something like the Bear Dance instead; a lovely tune with lots of possibility, but really very simple to learn. In rough order of decreasing hardness, I'd say Rabbit Stew is the hardest, Molly Oxford, 3 Sea Captains, Bear Dance.
Good luck!
Clive
I think you may be right, many tunes do sound hard, but probably aren't. It's just that my overstressed ears think they will take years to learn them and that there's no point. I just listened to Inna Inna again today, and it actually seemed quite easy. And I did learn a tune some month ago, just never had time to learn it well enough to be able to record it that month, and posting tunes after that month just doesn't seem to catch much interest anyway (other than having a nice recording up on You Tube, of course!).
I haven't yet listened to the poll tunes for next month.. a bit too late I suppose. But I'll go for the easy ones. Otherwise I may just record a Christmas tune or some old totm..
-
Also, TOTM often leads to other YouTubes or sites, where even more great tunes can be picked up.
Case in point (and a great tune it is) Weasel in the Grass (Lester's). :|glug
-
Has it been suggested before that we have an easy ToTM and a not-so easy ToTM, obviously with anybody entitled to post an entry for either or both?
Anything to encourage more activity...
-
Some melodeon workshops (e.g. those at Witney) are labelled for beginners, intermediates or experienced musicians and we choose the ones that suit our current levels of playing. However, it tends to be the case that almost all the tunes that win the TOTM poll fall into the beginner or intermediate category, although the Liberty Bell March was a notable exception. In many ways, it is good that nearly all winning tunes fall into the easier categories because that makes them more accessible to everyone: those who have not been playing long or lack confidence in their ability or tend to freeze in front of a webcam are more likely to attempt easier tunes, but more experienced musicians who want to challenge themselves can only really do so by adding embellishments or arranging the tunes in unusual time signatures or keys. One consequence of this is that interesting but challenging tunes are not going to win the poll very often because only a minority would feel confident about playing them, even though many more of us would benefit from pushing our boundaries by attempting them.
One way of addressing this might be to introduce a three monthly rotation in which all the options for the first month are simple tunes (e.g. Inna Inna, Bear Dance), those for the second month are of an intermediate standard (e.g. L'Inconnu de Limoise, Molly Oxford), those for the third month are more challenging (e.g. Liberty Bell March, Saut du Lapin/Rabbit Stew), and then we return to the simple tunes again for the fourth month. This way, everyone's needs/preferences would be addressed on a rotational basis and everyone would be able to push their limits from time to time.
Do others consider that it might be worth considering this suggestion or some variant of it?
-
With some obvious exceptions, I think it is difficult to designate what is difficult and what is not.
Some simple tunes I find difficult, and other 'tricky' tunes somehow appeal to my brain and get learnt, or are on the 'nearly there' list that means with peresverance I will get there with them.
Maybe a balance of tunes along the rotational approach as suggested by Bob might be an informal way forward?
just a thoughut...
Q
-
Yes, I accept that it is quite subjective as to which tunes might belong in each category. We would just have to accept Clive's judgment on this. Nevertheless, I think that many of us would accept some tunes as being fairly straightforward, others as being challenging and others as falling between those two categories. If Clive were to group together tunes that he regarded as being of a similar standard each month, then the winning tunes over each three-month period would be likely to include one fairly easy tune, one that was a bit more difficult and one that was of a more challenging nature. Would that not be an improvement?
-
For me it would be very motivating to hear the results of even beginners. There are alternatives to Youtube like soundcloud etc. We are a melodeon community with beginners and experts. It is good to hear everyone. It is not a competition. So, if we have tunes like "Inna Inna" or "Bear dance" - please make me happy and send your results, even with mistakes and slow tempo!
-
Right then! I have resolved to buy myself a cheap digital recorder and join in! I hope you'll all be kind! I'm kind of apprehensive but looking forward to it. Don't hold your collective breath though, I've got to buy the gizmo, learn a tune then learn how to put it on t'internet so it may be February by the time I sort it out! Bob.
-
I'm making it a resolution to learn the TOTM tunes to the best of my ability (and I am very much an 'lower end of intermediate' player!) - I'm going to be brave, but there is a bit of me that thinks 'why would people want to hear my substandard efforts' and I need to remember that this process is as much about the feedback that others who listen to our efforts give us - so I'm hoping that whatever I post will be commented on in a constructive way so that I can go away and improve my playing even more. It would give me much more courage to do this if some other 'beginner/intermediate' players posted on a regular basis.
As far as easy/hard tunes go - I find that if I click with a tune, even if it's a pretty hard one - then I have the stamina to keep plugging on at it - whereas if I'm not that interested in a tune, even if it's easier, I find it harder to learn...
So I'll give it a shot - although from the sounds of things Rabbit Stew may be a bit above my level... nothing ventured and all that.
Happy new year all! :|glug
Liz
-
Oh - looks like Bear Dance might pip Rabbit Stew to the post - in which case I would definitely post as I can play that and it would give me an excuse to try some different approaches to it.
L ;D
-
Right then! I have resolved to buy myself a cheap digital recorder and join in!
I can recommend a thing called an "UltraDisc DVR 7". A digital voice recorder with USB. I record tunes then tranfer to soundcloud. It cost about £30 on ebay! This is an example of the sound quality:
http://soundcloud.com/you/tracks
-
For me it would be very motivating to hear the results of even beginners. There are alternatives to Youtube like soundcloud etc. We are a melodeon community with beginners and experts. It is good to hear everyone. It is not a competition. So, if we have tunes like "Inna Inna" or "Bear dance" - please make me happy and send your results, even with mistakes and slow tempo!
I promise to show off my mistakes and stumbles! I agree, I also think it's extremely motivating to see/hear beginners.
Anahata, I know I once suggested a simpler totm vs a more advanced totm, but noone thought it was a good idea.
-
Thanks Tufty, that sounds great! I'll check it out. Bob.
-
Yes, I accept that it is quite subjective as to which tunes might belong in each category. We would just have to accept Clive's judgment on this. Nevertheless, I think that many of us would accept some tunes as being fairly straightforward, others as being challenging and others as falling between those two categories. If Clive were to group together tunes that he regarded as being of a similar standard each month, then the winning tunes over each three-month period would be likely to include one fairly easy tune, one that was a bit more difficult and one that was of a more challenging nature. Would that not be an improvement?
In the end it's always a judgement. and we must thank Clive for (usually) getting it about right. This month's 'mazurka' theme is going to get me out of my personal 'easy ' zone and I would commend Bob's 'easy', difficult', 'challenging' formula for the future.
-
So I'll give it a shot - although from the sounds of things Rabbit Stew may be a bit above my level... nothing ventured and all that.
OK, if you do it, so will I, without being embarrassed about the standard of my playing 4 years on... :|bl :|glug. Also, new camera should be able to record decent quality vid (I hope), which will help.
-
The number of people posting recordings has really dropped off over the past couple of months, but oddly not the number of people voting in the polls. Certainly, holiday will be part of that, but I suspect not the entire story.
So, to start my thought processes off, here's a question for you: if you've posted recordings before, but not got round to it over the past few months, can you think why? If you've fancied doing a recording, but never got round to it, what's put you off?
Cheers,
Clive
As for me, I'm spending time on Facebook, there are groups for melodeon players, maybe it's easier there to send videos ... ?
-
Yes, I accept that it is quite subjective as to which tunes might belong in each category. We would just have to accept Clive's judgment on this. Nevertheless, I think that many of us would accept some tunes as being fairly straightforward, others as being challenging and others as falling between those two categories. If Clive were to group together tunes that he regarded as being of a similar standard each month, then the winning tunes over each three-month period would be likely to include one fairly easy tune, one that was a bit more difficult and one that was of a more challenging nature. Would that not be an improvement?
Well, we could give it a go and see. Just out of curiosity though, if I were to run next month's poll (and I do like using a poll) of, say,
- Rabbit Stew
- Molly Oxford
- Sir Sidney Smith's March
- Mr Beveridge's Maggot
How many here think they would contribute if one of these won? How many of those are not planning to contribute to the Bear Dance TOTM? And how many are there who wouldn't contribute to that harder TOTM, but are planning to contribute to Bear Dance?
(Speaking as a player, I'd happily contribute to both hard and easy. My personal preference is the easier tunes since they're more open to interpretation and experimentation, something I particularly enjoy).
Cheers,
Clive
-
Well, we could give it a go and see. Just out of curiosity though, if I were to run next month's poll (and I do like using a poll) of, say,
- Rabbit Stew
- Molly Oxford
- Sir Sidney Smith's March
- Mr Beveridge's Maggot
How many here think they would contribute if one of these won? How many of those are not planning to contribute to the Bear Dance TOTM? And how many are there who wouldn't contribute to that harder TOTM, but are planning to contribute to Bear Dance?
(Speaking as a player, I'd happily contribute to both hard and easy. My personal preference is the easier tunes since they're more open to interpretation and experimentation, something I particularly enjoy).
Cheers,
Clive
Since I know two of them I would definitely post.
The problem I have with this discussion is that one mans easy is another mans hard (man being a non-gender specific word in this context). For insatance Old Molly Oxford is not a hard tune, is it ???
-
As an aside:
Somewhere here I've posted that in a moment of gross stupidity on my part, I've started to learn Rabbit stew as I thought it had won!
If you ignore my brainstorm, it does show up another facet of TOTM which in my opinion is really valuable.
I've started to learn it because
a. I like the tune
b. I've never heard it before.
Without TOTM I wouldn't have heard it or got the notation and converted it into dots to learn.
My point being it does highlight tunes and put them in the spotlight, making you listen to them and introduces tunes outside of your 'tune envelope'. I've done this previously by learning one of Anahata's tunes before he went into the TOTM for that month.
Perhaps the numbers of posters do not always reflect the true value of this monthly exercise.
Hope that's not broken the flow of current conversation too much.
carry on peeps!
Q
-
I would attempt to contribute if one of those more challenging tunes won. Two of them I have never attempted to play and Sir Sidney Smith's March always causes me problems. I have never yet managed to play it without the music because my mind gets confused about the B music! However, depending on which tune were to win, I would try to learn the tune, if it is one that is new to me, overcome my block over SSSM or post the version of Saut du Lapin I already know.
Bear Dance doesn't particularly inspire me in its basic form, probably because I am too familar with it, so I hope to find time to do something different with it, perhaps by playing it in unusual keys or learning the C music. I hope to post the results, however ropey they might be!
-
The problem I have with this discussion is that one mans easy is another mans hard (man being a non-gender specific word in this context). For insatance Old Molly Oxford is not a hard tune, is it ???
True, Lester, but I think that most of us would accept that some tunes are more difficult than others. I would be surprised if there was anyone, for instance, who thought Bear Dance was harder to play than Sir Sidney Smith's March, or even than Old Molly Oxford.
While there will undoubtedly be some variations in what people regard as more challenging tunes, I don't think that matters too much. What seems to be happening at the moment is that a fairly easy tune wins most months. I am merely suggesting a way in which a more challenging tune might win from time to time.
-
I have no idea what to do with Bear Dance at the moment, i didn't vote for it, but that is part of the fun. I suppose what I am saying is, no need to change the format as far as I'm concerned, I don't think it is failing, and if I don't contribute it's more to do with me than with the selection of tunes.
Hurrah! This is the conclusion I think we have already come to several times in this thread. We can't fix it because it really isn't broken 8)
-
What he said.
-
It has just occured to me to look back at the last few TOTM polls. It roughly works out that the winning tune only receives approx. one third of the votes whilst the other two thirds of voters are disappointed/ignored. Why are we having less posters = why are we ignoring the majority of voters?
TOTM, great idea, voting system, not so good.
-
It has just occured to me to look back at the last few TOTM polls. It roughly works out that the winning tune only receives approx. one third of the votes whilst the other two thirds of voters are disappointed/ignored. Why are we having less posters = why are we ignoring the majority of voters?
TOTM, great idea, voting system, not so good.
It's not the system's fault that votes are divided fairly evenly between the choices. A good way to handle that is to leave the other tunes that received significant votes in the list for the next month, and that's what Clive usually does. It's funny how the same tune can appear in the list for several months and not get to the top, though.
There's absolutely nothing to stop you learning, playing, recording and uploading any of the other tunes that you like in the list, or even not in the list, and posting them in the "tunes" or "recordings and videos" topic.
Also as others have said, playing the tune you've voted for isn't always what it's about...
-
There's an odd idea forming in my head and it's really not conducive to the rest of the debate. Is there room for a bit of 'None of this works for me this time around so here's what I wanted to play this month'?
COAT!!!!
-
There's an odd idea forming in my head and it's really not conducive to the rest of the debate. Is there room for a bit of 'None of this works for me this time around so here's what I wanted to play this month'?
COAT!!!!
I sort of see where you are coming from but that way may lie anarchy or at the very least people playing their favorite tune which they are already good at. Surely part of the idea of tune of the month is that people should learn something they may not otherwise have played, a piece that will extend them.
The rub is that by extension of my own argument we should learn the tune that got the least votes ???
-
There's an odd idea forming in my head and it's really not conducive to the rest of the debate. Is there room for a bit of 'None of this works for me this time around so here's what I wanted to play this month'?
COAT!!!!
I sort of see where you are coming from but that way may lie anarchy or at the very least people playing their favorite tune which they are already good at. Surely part of the idea of tune of the month is that people should learn something they may not otherwise have played, a piece that will extend them.
The rub is that by extension of my own argument we should learn the tune that got the least votes ???
But a poster may not want to learn that particular TOTM, therefor making this system counter productive. So what is wrong with people playing their favourite tune that they are already good at if it inspires other people to learn and play it, then it becomes productive.
-
Isn't that one of the things the 'Tunes' section is for? You can post away to your hearts content, no-one is imposing any restrictions! Bob.
-
So what is wrong with people playing their favourite tune that they are already good at if it inspires other people to learn and play it, then it becomes productive.
Nothing at all. That's (partly) what the "tunes" and "recording and videos" topics are for. (OK, Bob's just posted the same thing...) I have some more tunes I want to record and haven't done yet, and will link them there, possibly quite soon. Also Theme of the month gives frequent (for me) opportunities to do stuff I like and know anyway.
But TOTM will lose the plot if it becomes a monthly "post anything you like" topic, and the challenge of learning something you wouldn't have done otherwise is valuable, and so is the experience of learning what others do with the same tune.
-
So what is wrong with people playing their favourite tune that they are already good at if it inspires other people to learn and play it, then it becomes productive.
Nothing at all. That's (partly) what the "tunes" and "recording and videos" topics are for. (OK, Bob's just posted the same thing...) I have some more tunes I want to record and haven't done yet, and will link them there, possibly quite soon. Also Theme of the month gives frequent (for me) opportunities to do stuff I like and know anyway.
But TOTM will lose the plot if it becomes a monthly "post anything you like" topic, and the challenge of learning something you wouldn't have done otherwise is valuable, and so is the experience of learning what others do with the same tune.
Ditto, being presented with tunes I can't already play is why I joined this group in the first place. As a relative beginner (about 8 months of actuall trying to play) it is the challenge that I need to progress and the examples provided by more experienced players that I treasure. Previous posts have suggested that they are reluctant to upload files that are not as good as the experienced submissions. It is these examples (DTN , Clive, Anahata etc.) that inspire me to practice, my basses are still rudimentary and there is no ompah of note as yet, so I do my own version instead. Sooner or later when both hands do as they are told I'll upload a tune as written. :0) Why Change? Just practice everyone, don't be intimidated be inspired and share the learning curve. AND I would just like to say on my behalf that any constructive criticism of my playing is welcome, I will not take offence and I will take it onboard, that's what I'm on here for.
Happy new year everyone.
-
What he said.
-
I'll be honest. Usualy early on there is a version posted that I know I come nowhere near in standard and I just don't see the point in posting my lesser version to waste everyone's time on.
Steve
-
I joined this group when I began learning the melodeon about 12 weeks back. I will begin posting my interpretations of the TOTM selections in the future and paying increased attention on navagating this forum to obtain the selections early enough for me to learn and post. Thanks all for everything that has been posted and for melodeon.net
-
I'm a closeted TOTM player -- I have yet to get around to recording and posting anything. But I usually have a go at learning the tunes. It's a great way to expand the repertoire at a manageable pace, and it's a real education to see what different folks do with the tunes.
There are some great players contributing all sorts of interesting ideas to the music.
And my absolute favorite poster is LDT, who plays the tunes straight, rock-solid, and at a perfect speed to learn on the fly. Brilliant!
And thanks Clive: don't change a thing.
-
And my absolute favorite poster is LDT, who plays the tunes straight, rock-solid, and at a perfect speed to learn on the fly. Brilliant!
Awww...thanks. :|bl And there I was thinking my playing was dull boring and no use to anyone.
-
And my absolute favorite poster is LDT, who plays the tunes straight, rock-solid, and at a perfect speed to learn on the fly. Brilliant!
Awww...thanks. :|bl And there I was thinking my playing was dull boring and no use to anyone.
I agree with Matthew. Lots of times the more advanced recordings are blurry and too much ornaments to get the actual melody. I often learn from your recordings. And I say it again, you're one of the most inspiring people I know.
-
And my absolute favorite poster is LDT, who plays the tunes straight, rock-solid, and at a perfect speed to learn on the fly. Brilliant!
I do agree too ... playing slowly as she does is the most difficult thing and requires a lot of hability, sort of a way to perfection, isn't it ... ;-)
-
I think that the whole TOTM arrangement is fine as it is. As far as I'm aware, participation is voluntary, and if you don't like the current TOTM, then don't learn it. Being mostly an acolyte of English music in all of its forms, along with music from Brittany, the past TOTM list contains a few tunes that I don't take to, a lot that I adore, and one (Ashokan) that I detest beyond all reasoning.
I'm not a great fan of "home movies", so I don't have the sort of equipment needed to make videos; nor do I plan to get any. I could record on my trusty Zoom H2, and put it on a sound-only website, but somehow that seems like cheating! I'd also be depriving the forum, and the world of Youtube, of my special "concentrating" expression, which doesn't seem fair either. These excuses don't actually absolve me from a small guilty feeling for not participating.
One way or the other, TOTM enables me to see and hear some really cracking players, which I would go to many lengths to do likewise in the flesh. This sharpens up my aspirations, and also gives me the get-outs from some of the ruts that many years of box-playing make plentiful. The efforts of the newer players leave me green with envy, and wishing I could go back years and emulate them. I do however make a definite point of NOT coveting some of the beautiful boxes on show.
Don't change it or make it complicated i.e. it ain't broke, so don't fix it.
-
I could record on my trusty Zoom H2, and put it on a sound-only website, but somehow that seems like cheating!
There are several of us who have no video recording equipment (including myself - also with a trusty Zoom H2) so we do indeed put stuff on a sound-only website, like Soundcloud or Omnvoice. It's not cheating at all. Just different.
Don't change it or make it complicated i.e. it ain't broke, so don't fix it.
Hear hear! (literally ;D )