Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: mikesamwild on April 23, 2008, 05:59:37 PM
-
Hi
I am trying to free the reeds on an old Hohner with zinc plates beeswaxed onto a wooden reed block, at the high end. Where is the best place to get some info to understand how reeds actually work? I use feeler gauges, razor blades and very fine abrasive paper but have no very fine files. What is the principle and are there any good books or web pages? Or is this arcane knowledge only available to the cognoscenti?
I haven't got time to go for an initiation ceremony
I still work on the assumption that reeds twang like a ruler trapped in a desk and that is what makes the noise . I did see a web page by Wim Wakkers on the physics but couldn't understand it . Can anyone help?
In hope
Mike in Sheffield
-
Mike there is a good description on concertinaconnection.com, though last time I tried the site was down.
There is also a little info in Dave Elliott's Cancertina maintainance handbook. I believe there is also quite a lot of written material in German. I don't read german so I've not looked into that.
Do you want to understand how reeds work, ie the physics, or just how to fix them when they stop working?
Most of what stops old reeds working is (a) dirt, rust, wax and other foreign material getting in the way of the reed tongue, or (b) reed tongue out of line with its slot.
You can make a very nice gentle file with abrasive paper glued to a stick.
-
I believe there is also quite a lot of written material in German. I don't read german so I've not looked into that.
Yep - There is a lot good info in German books. Also in Italian and in French (some books). If you can read french, so I would suggest a book "L'Accordéon & sa diversite sonore". The book tells everything basic info and some more good stuff with ~200 pictures. And it includes a dvd... Price 49 €.
-
I still work on the assumption that reeds twang like a ruler trapped in a desk and that is what makes the noise . I did see a web page by Wim Wakkers on the physics but couldn't understand it . Can anyone help?
In hope
Mike in Sheffield
Hi Mike, I'll try and help to describe the action of a reed as I understand it and hope that if I make any errors someone will correct me. Firstly the analogy to a ruler trapped in a desk is completely wrong, the reeds themselves make no sound at all, here's how it works.
The reed is mounted over a slot in a plate (accordion or melodeon) or reed shoe (concertina); the slot is minutely larger than the reed, such that the reed is free to swing into the slot without fouling the sides. Bellows air pressure draws the reed into the slot until the spring of the reed overcomes the pressure and it swings back, when the spring effect runs out the reed is drawn back into the slot again and so on. The reeds swinging back and forth 'chops up' the flow of air rushing through the slot and it's this that makes the sound you hear. The volume of air passing through the slot and the frequency of the reed's swing cycle determines the pitch of the sound.
Wim Wakker's site is back on line now so if what I've said made sense to you go back and read the article again for a more accurate and detailed description than I could ever give. If you saw a reed playing on a tuning rig I think you would be surprised at the distance it swings back and forth, fascinating to watch. If anyone spots an obvious flaw in my description please feel free to jump in and give the proper information.
Hope that helps,
Pete.
-
Thanks eveyone for such a quick response
All info will be gratefully received. I wish I'd paid attention in A level Physics in the 50s but they made it so mathematical with no good analogies. Did Sir Charles Wheatstone explain it clearly?
Mike
-
The reeds swinging back and forth 'chops up' the flow of air rushing through the slot and it's this that makes the sound you hear. The volume of air passing through the slot and the frequency of the reed's swing cycle determines the pitch of the sound.
one significant error - its only the frequency of the reed's swing cycle that determines the pitch of the note. The volume of air passing through the slot only affects the loudness. If it were otherwise then the pitch of our instruments could be changed by altering the pressure on the bellows.
Otherwise a good clear explanation. Less detailed than Wim's but possibly easier to understand.
-
Thanks all
I found an interesting website for pat Missin harmonica guru. He has some interesting stuff on the history in Asia of the free reed.The original looks like a V slot cut in a flat plate of what looks like thin bamboo. This would play same on the suck and blow. I'm going to make one and see if it works just for interest. maybe you could do it with a stiff leaf a bit like we did with privet leaves between the thumbs?
I agree that Wim's is a bit complex for an old 'un. But he certainly knows his stuff. I'll give it my son who has a PhD in Physics from Cambridge, see what he makes of it all!
By the way, how does the old school ruler work? Is it like a bass with the desk as a resonator?
-
one significant error - its only the frequency of the reed's swing cycle that determines the pitch of the note. The volume of air passing through the slot only affects the loudness. If it were otherwise then the pitch of our instruments could be changed by altering the pressure on the bellows.
How about the note bending with a harmonica? Perhaps we cannot do the same with a bellows, but I think that past a certain pressure threshold the volume of air affects the pitch produced by the reed.
-
I'm not a harmonica player, but I'm pretty sure that bending notes is not just a matter of blowing harder. I believe its more to do with the player altering the volume of the nearby space by moving the mouth and tongue, and possibly by moving the hands closer to enclose the harmonica.
And yes it is possible (though difficult) to bend notes on a melodeon.
-
One effect is to press a button down a very small amount and press very hard.
As for the more general pitch shift with pressure I think this has been researched by the reed organ people it is a small but real effect, it should be on the net somewhere.
-
It seems to me the melodeon community is falling behind a bit by not doing this http://tinyurl.com/59rqxd (http://tinyurl.com/59rqxd) kind of research.
-
It seems to me the melodeon community is falling behind a bit by not doing this http://tinyurl.com/59rqxd (http://tinyurl.com/59rqxd) kind of research.
Actually the thing is that melodeons and cromatics are very well examined. And there is no need for an x-ray research because the instruments can be made with transparent plastic. So while somebody is playing accordion others can see what is happening inside the accordion. At least one plastic bandoneon can be found in Klingenthal and one piano accordion in Castelfidardo (this is made in 1976 by Brandoni.)
However, it is another issue what accordion manufactures says to public.
-
That was an interesting comment on bending notes. I tend to agree with Theo , on a harmonica it is something to do with twisting the reed, I have always found that sucking on a harmonica gives more 'wah wah', bluesy notes. Normal blow/suck gives the steady English sound . I do better in sessions in Ireland with a suzuki or lee oscar than a tremolo Liebchen etc, but that's maybe a function of dsingle reeds rather than 2 'wet tuned' reeds
Could this aslo be why Cajun music on a C box played in G gives that wailing sound or was it just a result of having to play along with fiddlers in G on easily availble C boxes. I remember when R Cajun came to Bromyard in the 80s I only had a D/G melodeon and found a C harmonica allowed me to play along in sessions better in the key of G on the box.
I also find the pull notes on a C/G Anglo have a more 'lonesome' sound when playing with uillean pipers than when played on the push.
On the D/G melodeon I get the same feeling when playing an A tune
Any comments?
Mike
-
Ive just been experimenting with a straw in a glass of water and you can blow bubbles on the blow but without too much control and it burbles; but on the suck you can get much finer control . I find I whistle to the dog in the high frequencies on the suck not the blow when I make dog friendly poacher's noises. You can control the gap between the lips to get the narrow slit.
I kicked off as a kid in the 40s making music with anything to hand and graduated to reeds so I suppose I evolved an 'intuitive' approach. We made them from battery terminals and watch springs as war babies to mend mouth organs. I even won a talent contest at the local Co-op gala on a Spear and Jackson saw playing an air. What is the science behind that?
Or is this getting a bit weird, please tell me and I'll leave this site or go on to a more accomodating oldtimer's site?
Mike son of Aelfroth the Incontinent
-
How about the note bending with a harmonica? Perhaps we cannot do the same with a bellows, but I think that past a certain pressure threshold the volume of air affects the pitch produced by the reed.
Hi All,
I only recently came across this interesting forum and would like to point out here that the technology for pitchbending on melodeons and other free reed instruments is something I've been working on for many years now. Interested readers can find more information and sound files at www.bluesbox.biz .
The main obstacle I currently face is not so much developing a dependable, robust instrument, but rather more one of developing the market. Considering the vast number of different kinds of free reed instruments and associated music genres, it's not easy to identify those in which to first introduce the technology. I find that the technology is not a trivial expansion of the musical dimension of these instruments. I'm looking for suggestions, and I'd be interested in what members of this forum think about it.
Best regards,
Tom
www.bluesbox.biz
-
Hi Tom
Thanks for the info Your site is very interesting.
I'm going to a festival this weekend where Jody Kruskal from New York will be talking and demonstrating bending effects on Anglo concertina. I'll report back on discussions
Mike
-
Hi
I missed Jody's talk, got stuck a session! Sorry, I'll meet him at Whitby and ask him.
-
Chris Parkinson was doing some interesting bending on a pokerwork during the 'Hohner night' at Sidmouth. I've no idea how, but he produced the effect several times during the night.
-
I know Chris from way back in Sheffield and will be going to his workshop/sessions at Whitby. I'll ask him. I know he started as a kid , like me, on mouth organs in talent contests!
What a box player!!!