Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Dazbo on April 24, 2008, 01:10:09 PM

Title: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Dazbo on April 24, 2008, 01:10:09 PM
Why are the old Paulos so popular in Ireland?  I played a nice red one (4 voice in D/G) a few months ago and enjoyed the sound but it didn't seem that special to me and the box was, well, hernia inducing in its weight.

I presume it's partly (mainly?) due to the history of their use in Ireland (were they as popular elsewhere?) and therefore fashionable to have.  So why would you have (or not have) an old Paulo - grey, red or whatever?

Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: george garside on April 24, 2008, 02:33:04 PM
Why are the old Paulos so popular in Ireland?  I played a nice red one (4 voice in D/G) a few months ago and enjoyed the sound but it didn't seem that special to me and the box was, well, hernia inducing in its weight.

I presume it's partly (mainly?) due to the history of their use in Ireland (were they as popular elsewhere?) and therefore fashionable to have.  So why would you have (or not have) an old Paulo - grey, red or whatever?



possibly because in main they are  tuned BC or other semitone combination rather than Dg . The weight is much less of a problem as  many BC players use a fairly minimal amount of bellows opening (less being of course needed if bass not used much!) whereas many DG players use a of bellows movement and loud bass   resulting in greater physical effort being required.. Also most paolo's are played with 2 straps and often seated.& i personaly would find it very difficult to play with just one.  The older paolo's in particular were of superb quality and the tuning is  instantly recognisable, also the 4 voice & couplers can be another attraction.  I find it less physical effort to play 48 bass casali BCC# than a 2 row DG despite the extra weight & size. 
Maybe  its down to down to nothing more than that there was little available between the hohner double ray & the paolo untill all the wooden costalotties hit the market greatly increasing the choice.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Stiamh on April 24, 2008, 08:07:11 PM
God willing, I'm going to get the chance to play an old grey this weekend  :P So next week I'll give you my impressions, and ask the owner why he thinks it's so special (which I know he does).
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Stiamh on April 28, 2008, 02:38:24 PM
I did get a chance to play, at leisure, on an old grey this weekend. But I'm not sure it was a real "old grey" - the ones that people are asking $7K for on eBay, like the ones that Tony MacMahon, Billy McComiskey and others play. Those are said to have small treble buttons and a high action. This one, a 4-voice, had two couplers, standard sized buttons and was very similar to a red c. 1960 3 voice (with no couplers) that I also got a chance to play earlier the same day!

I didn't find either of them to be hernia-inducing at all - not that heavy to lift and quite easy to play. I wonder if the one you tried Darren was one of the later 9-coupler jobs? I think they were are quite a bit bulkier and heavier and AFAIK are not sought after by the Irish players.

So, even allowing for the fact that the "real" old greys might have something even more special than those that I tried this weekend, I think that they are probably sought after because of the sound they make. I suggest that the influence of the great players of past decades is such that players want not only to emulate their style but to sound like them.

Conversely if your idol on box is Sharon Shannon, you're probably not going to be in the market for an old Paolo, but for a dry-tuned Tommy or Cairdin or something like that sounds like that.

It's a bit like the old Generation whistles, which were all you could hear on Irish recordings of the 1970s for example. They defined the sound of the tin whistle for a whole generation (groan) of players, which is probably why I have gone back to them myself after trying lots of fancy new-fangled whistles - none of the latter have that characteristic sound and always leave me unsatisfied. Something indefinable is missing.

Back to Paolos: when I cut out the low voice on the old grey I was trying, I instantly heard the sound of Jackie Daly on his 1970s records - a lovely, soft and complex sound that I've never heard on anything else I've tried. So that's my guess - it's mainly a matter of timbre. Fashion probably does play a part though.

I really enjoyed playing the two I tried this weekend but I wouldn't go chasing after one. Especially not for $7K!

Cheers
Steve

PS the owner of the old grey described its appeal as "character." But interestingly he doesn't play it nearly as often as the 3-v Gaillard he has - now that was something special.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Theo on April 28, 2008, 05:07:40 PM
.... But I'm not sure it was a real "old grey" - the ones that people are asking $7K for on eBay,

Just to add a further complication, I'm told by people who ought to know that some of the grey coloured Paolos are actually red Paolos but with a grey pearloid finish!  Now that opinion could only come from the same culture where triplets can have two, three of four notes
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Quebecois on April 28, 2008, 06:20:15 PM
Then the current Jubilee model may not be "the grey" but at least it's guaranteed to be grey!
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: george garside on April 28, 2008, 06:44:47 PM
i once had a go on a genuine old grey paoli in immaculate condition - it was in a league of its own but unfortunately it was bought while I was  trying to make my mind up.  The older red ones are indeed good the genuine old grey ones (as opposed to ed ones in a grey skin!)  are indefinably better in every respect.
george
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Stiamh on April 28, 2008, 09:03:39 PM
Here's a photo of the one I tried. It must be one of those grey red ones that Theo has heard about!

My tuner was telling me the other day about a "genuine" old grey - identical in appearance to Billy McComiskey's - that someone brought in to have tuned. The owner had picked it up for $600 in a second-hand store in the US and apparently, not realizing its value, had hesitated before buying it... He (the tuner) said it was an exceedingly powerful machine - made his own Saltarelle sound dead by comparison.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: TomB-R on April 28, 2008, 11:25:57 PM
That's what Steve said it was, the rest of his post is about another one.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Lars on April 29, 2008, 11:22:19 AM
I'm into paolos myself. 3v C#/D red 50's, 4v 1960 D/D# and just picked up a 2v 60's (wooden soundboard, stepped keyboard) at a ridiculous low price this weekend, although in F/Bb (soon to be D/G).

I have played a number of both red and grey, and it's a matter of sound more than playability. The reds have a GREAT action (50's, that is), but the grey just have that certain sound to them. Tuned a bit on the wet side, they are just amazing. Give the bellows the slightest yank, and the machine will roar.

And yes, I would trady any of my red boxes for an old grey 3v. Without hesitation.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on April 29, 2008, 04:24:19 PM
Lars!Don't be so quick to retune your F/Bb.There's a vast repertoire of tunes for those keys.Most of the Tyneside hormpipes,many strathspeys and reels are in those keys.The low pitch will also give your ears a nice rest from all the D/G tunes.

Chris
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Lars on April 29, 2008, 08:17:55 PM
Well, make me an offer for the box, and it's yours! ;)

I have a repertoire of about 5 tunes in those keys that I play on regular basis... And a million in D/G-friendly keys!
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on April 30, 2008, 06:05:51 PM
Wish I could Lars.
Keep on buying those Paolos while you still can and keep them in a variety of colours too.When you're married and have kids it's not easy to sneak in a new box,but if you already have one that looks the same you can pretend that you've had it forever.Keep an old wood Hohner around too,you never know when a Gaillard or Costalotta might come along.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Lars on April 30, 2008, 07:39:12 PM
Well, if only I liked the sound of costalottis... I do, but I don't like playing them, actually.

Although the F/Bb paolo is GREAT, and really powerful, I'm still thinking about selling it again... In need of funds for restoring an old blast-from-the-past Irish-American box:) Alas! If only I had a grey, my search for new boxes could come to a halt...

/Lars
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: upmine3 on April 30, 2008, 10:44:15 PM
ROFL at sCANdanADIAN's comment about sneaking in boxes HA. That's exactly the mentality of us box players.  when you want to fork out for a new one and your missus is quick to point out the cost of bills. It's almost like being a junkie i suppose, you scrape enough money together for that fix of just one hit (new accordion) no ones looking you sneak up to your computer when every one's asleep and arrange a meet with your dealer. He tells you he's got the best gear going so you part with your cash and get your box. Only the next morning reality hits you hard when your wife is standing over you after an all nighter from playing your new fix. Your eyes are all glazed from looking at sheet music you can't explain where the funds have gone and your kids are crying Bah back to melodeon rehab.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: DaveCottrell on May 15, 2008, 09:57:33 PM
I think the popularity of Paolo Sopranis in Irish music is due to 1) economics -- they were the only BC's available in large numbers and attainable prices at a time when 2) popular artists were using them (nobody has mentioned Joe Burke or Paddy OBrien, two hugely talented accordion players who helped popularize the BC style).
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: rees on May 15, 2008, 11:38:55 PM
Bah back to melodeon rehab.

I've witnessed several of these domestic discussions over the purchase of a new melodeon. The partner always seems to prefer the new kitchen to the new Castagnari.
I've now taken to re-badging some of my stock. "New Kitchen" in D/G anyone? How about a Louisiana made "Water Bill" in B flat? Nice G/C "Stair Carpet" with stepped keyboard?
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: finnhorse on May 16, 2008, 06:03:17 PM
Quote
The partner always seems to prefer the new kitchen to the new Castagnari.
I've now taken to re-badging some of my stock. "New Kitchen" in D/G anyone? How about a Louisiana made "Water Bill" in B flat? Nice G/C "Stair Carpet" with stepped keyboard?

 ;D This practice should be encouraged in melodeon retailers everywhere  ;D
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Theo on May 16, 2008, 06:06:04 PM
Just don't ask me to put new valves in your dishwaser!
Title: Oldish grey Paolo on RTE website
Post by: Stiamh on June 29, 2008, 03:20:46 PM
Oldish grey Paolo on RTE website. I think it's a 3-v "grey red," similar to the 4-v one I tried above, rather than one of the hen's teeth models. Click the "web exclusive" link: http://www.rte.ie/tv/thefullset/prog6.html

(Edited to correct provenance of clip!)
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: rees on June 29, 2008, 06:03:53 PM
Fabulous playing to be sure, to be sure.

Did you notice his left-hand shoulder strap falls off during the last tune? Mine always does that if I try to use two!
..................... and I refuse to wear a back-strap, so uncool.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Lars on June 29, 2008, 07:16:45 PM
I use a backstrap when I play my paolo - but then again, I guess that just makes me way cooler than you, Rees:P
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: rees on June 29, 2008, 07:31:08 PM
Yes Lars, point taken.  :(
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: triskel on September 11, 2008, 01:48:38 AM
The partner always seems to prefer the new kitchen to the new Castagnari.
I've now taken to re-badging some of my stock. "New Kitchen" in D/G anyone? How about a Louisiana made "Water Bill" in B flat? Nice G/C "Stair Carpet" with stepped keyboard?

 ;D I'm reminded of a late 1940s "120-bass stair carpet" that's now in my possession.  ::)

It's a Hagstrom PA that belonged to the brother of our next-door neighbour (when I was a child) in Burton-on-Trent, a man called George Stiff who was a Midlands Champion player.

When he got married, after the War, everything was in short supply, but he needed a new accordion and (since nobody could get a Board of Trade license to import them) the only ones available at the time were made by Hagstrom in Darlington (who'd found it easier to export an accordion factory to England, than accordions - which is why the first D/Gs finished up being made by them). So using the money his father had given the newlyweds "for a new stair carpet", he and his brother took a trip down to London (the only place they were available) and bought the new PA instead.

Mind you, it got great use in the local accordion club band, and in a trio (with another PA and a drummer) that played for dances in halls all around the Burton area for many years.

His widow very kindly gave it to me six years ago, and it's the only PA I've got, but of great interest to me on several levels, including that my friend Nils Nielsen first came to England as a young factory-trained tuner with Hagstrom's at the time.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: triskel on September 11, 2008, 01:56:07 AM
I think the popularity of Paolo Sopranis in Irish music is due to 1) economics -- they were the only BC's available in large numbers and attainable prices at a time when 2) popular artists were using them (nobody has mentioned Joe Burke or Paddy OBrien, two hugely talented accordion players who helped popularize the BC style).

Actually, they were the most expensive (but best) B/C's available at the time, and there were various cheaper brands on the market. Indeed, just about all the old players I've ever spoken to about them (including one today, who paid £44.00 for his!) have told me that they had to buy them "on the old H.P." (in installments, by hire purchase agreement).
Title: Re: Oldish grey Paolo on RTE website
Post by: triskel on September 11, 2008, 02:19:07 AM
Oldish grey Paolo on RTE website. I think it's a 3-v "grey red," similar to the 4-v one I tried above, rather than one of the hen's teeth models.

No, that's a "proper" grey box, but one of the light-grey ones from around 1953-4, like the one Joe Cooley is playing on the album cover photo:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/cooley_cd.jpg)

They'd be less strident than the dark-grey ones with the metal grilles, but still a lovely box.
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: triskel on September 11, 2008, 02:27:56 AM
Here's a photo of the one I tried. It must be one of those grey red ones that Theo has heard about!

That is one of the grey "red boxes", from around 1955-6. It's basically the same model as this one:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/PaoloSopranired1955.jpg)

Quote
My tuner was telling me the other day about a "genuine" old grey - identical in appearance to Billy McComiskey's - that someone brought in to have tuned. The owner had picked it up for $600 in a second-hand store in the US and apparently, not realizing its value, had hesitated before buying it...

The last one of those I had cost me £65 from an East London junk shop ;D , but that was a good few years ago...  :(
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on September 11, 2008, 09:26:11 AM


That is one of the grey "red boxes", from around 1955-6. It's basically the same model as this one:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/PaoloSopranired1955.jpg)


I have one identical to this currently in my workshop. Unfortunately the couplers are missing and I've been trying to obtain something suitable for a while, but with no success from other local repairers (and a few from overseas).

Not that I expect any one to be scrapping a Paolo of this type, but any one know of anything suitable about?

No doubt I shall eventually find a scrap piano accordion with suitable parts, but any help in the meantime would be much appreciated.

MC
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Lars on September 11, 2008, 03:51:04 PM
Malcolm,

Are you missing the buttons, the levers, the slides, or the whole thing?

If it's just a matter of buttons, it should not be that hard to fix - if you find some buttons of the right type/size. If it's the same as on my 1960 red 4v (that I play without grill) it's "just" two buttons pivotting on a pin with a stick that moves the lever coming through the soundboard.

Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on September 11, 2008, 05:56:21 PM
Lars,
 
It's just the switches and their backing blocks I'm missing. I can make and fit the lifters from brass. The butterfly and the slides are all there, as are the axle pin and the surround.

Trouble is that all the switches I've tried so far are slightly too wide and I'd rather not butcher the grill.

I've done the same job before on similar accordions, having obtained the switches from  scrapped piano accordions, but these days even really badly damaged scrappers are selling for silly prices over here....
Title: Re: What's so special about Paulo's?
Post by: triskel on September 11, 2008, 06:45:56 PM
No doubt I shall eventually find a scrap piano accordion with suitable parts ...

Let me know if you do, will you Malcolm - I could do with a couple of them myself!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal