Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Banjo Ray on September 11, 2010, 06:53:42 AM

Title: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Banjo Ray on September 11, 2010, 06:53:42 AM
I have a Hohner Pokerwork D/G which I love - unfortunately its so loud it can be heard in the next suburb.  My wife is keen that I get hold of a quieter or at least sweeter sounding instrument for practice at home.   I guess a Streb would be ideal but you cant get hold of them anymore, (not at a reasonable price).  Anybody care to recommend an instrument for those intimate indoor sessions.

Ray
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 11, 2010, 08:06:41 AM
Had the same problem m'self (when still had wife) so I'd warn you that 'those intimate indoor sessions' might be a thing of the past if you can't sort this.  ;)

   My own 'more gentle' boxes have been the more expensive ones, I'll let others  opine on that. As an interim measure try playing it under the duvet! If you shut the door as well the sound output is much reduced. It has the valuable spin off benefit of forcing you to play without looking at the buttons - certainly helped my technique.

(Incidentally the next event in this story will be that Wifey purchases a set of bagpipes)  :|glug
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Theo on September 11, 2010, 10:19:00 AM
I'll suggest a different answer. 

A box may have the potential to be loud, but it is the player who chooses how hard to work the bellows.  A pokerwork can be played quietly. It's just another aspect of playing technique, but like all technique it is something you have to learn to do.  Unfortunately there are many melodeonists who have of necessity learned to play loud, but have never explored the quieter possibilities of the instrument.

Of course there are some instruments that naturally not capable of the same maximum volume as a pokerwork,  but even with these one needs to adopt a different technique to really exploit the quieter dynamics.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Anahata on September 11, 2010, 12:31:34 PM
Theo has a good point, but quiet actually need a good melodeon with high quality reeds.
My Salterelle (I think it's a Connemara III) is excellent for playing quietly and I use it for song accompaniments. Apart from being responsive and even when played gently, I can select single reeds on the treble and cut out low basses and thirds on the bass side, and it's really sweet and quiet.

All the good Castagnaris can be played quietly. I have a Max (1 row) in D which has an amazing dynamic range - quiet and fast is possible even with all four reeds on, but squeeze it hard and it's deafening.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Steve C. on September 11, 2010, 01:53:03 PM
Not a perfect answer, but another way to go quieter is to move down in pitch to a GC box.  Not sure how it measures in db but it sounds quieter.

Another possibility, at least from experience with my DG Pokerwork, is to get it tuned and tuned a little drier.  First, I was AMAZED how out of tune it was (assumed it was the "hohner sound") but also, drying it out seems to produce less volume. And the volume it does produce is certainly sweeter.

Though you cannot kill a Pokerwork.  They are made to raise hell, and do it outdoors in a crowd, when necessary.

Also, not sure again about the db, but the bigger, heavier Hohners seem quieter, maybe try out a Corona and see
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: waltzman on September 11, 2010, 02:00:13 PM
Theo has a good point, but quiet actually need a good melodeon with high quality reeds

I think the biggest factor here is having the reeds set properly.  Hohner reeds are perfectly capable of playing quietly if properly set.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Theo on September 11, 2010, 02:15:46 PM
Two good points there from GCFMan/Steve , ie drier tuning, and bigger boxes being relatively quieter.  Strong tremolo is not actually any louder if you measure it with a sound meter, but it is perceived as louder by the human brain.  Its also true that Hohner factory tuning is very approximate which will also add to the perceived "annoyingness" of the sound.   My experience is that the reeds in Hohner pokerwork and Erica may be anything up to 10 cents different from what they should be, and getting them in tune, but with the same tremolo, makes for a much more musical sound, without loosing loudness.  And yes, getting them set properly will allow you to play at low volume.

Bigger boxes are always quieter than a similar box of smaller size, because the same force on a bigger box produces a smaller air pressure inside the box. Therefore for the same playing effort the reeds will be working at less volume.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Andy Simpson on September 11, 2010, 02:19:45 PM
Technique and tuning aside, the Castagnari Casta is probably the most naturally quiet and sweet sounding box I can think of but they're pretty rare and aren't made anymore so on the rare occaisions they do crop up secondhand they command quite high prices.

All other things being equal and if they're played the same way, something like a Castagnari or a Loffet will be quieter than a Pokerwork.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Accordion Dave on September 12, 2010, 02:35:58 AM
I have a couple of East German boxes that do not seem as loud as my various Hohners.

The Hohners seem to require less bellows effort than the boxes from the "German Democratic Republic" (GDR).

I have no problem playing the Hohners softly. The problem is being able to play the GDR boxes loudly.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Graham W on September 12, 2010, 01:35:55 PM
Technique and tuning aside, the Castagnari Casta is probably the most naturally quiet and sweet sounding box I can think of but they're pretty rare and aren't made anymore so on the rare occaisions they do crop up secondhand they command quite high prices.


I have a Casta and yes,  it can be played very softly with a lot less effort that some other boxes, and it has a nice 'gentle' bass to match too.

I might possibly be persuaded to part with it, too . . . . . . . .
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Nick Hudis on September 12, 2010, 10:28:46 PM
I've been experimenting.  My Casta does indeed play incredibly quietly and I agree with Graham that the bass is well balanced.  The Loffet is quiet too, but seem less so partly because the tone is brighter than the mellow Casta.  Neither of my boxes is a D/G and I for one would not part with the Casta for love nor money........

I'd have to say that neither box sounds at its best played at minimum volume.  It takes a bit more air for the sound quality to really develop.

Technically I wonder if it is easier to appear quiet when playing cross row style because there is less attack?
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Accordion Dave on September 17, 2010, 01:33:43 AM
I have too many accordions with "gentle bass".

Dear Santa: 

I would really like a box with HELIKON bass for Christmas.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Steve C. on September 17, 2010, 04:23:31 PM
Good advice, copied from Rod Stradling's page at mustrad.org

"Speed, Weight and apparent Volume:

Given similar build and reed quality, a 2-voice box will always be faster and often louder than a 3-row.  By faster I mean more responsive to button presses and changes in bellows direction.  This is because less air has to be moved to set 2 reeds vibrating than 3.  Also, a 3-voice box usually has its third voice an octave lower than the other two - lower means bigger; more mass to get vibrating, thus more air used and time spent.
It may seem strange for me to suggest that 3 reeds vibrating at the same time can be quieter than two, but it often sounds like that - for two very good reasons.  Firstly, because a 3-voice box usually has its third voice an octave lower than the other two, the big low reed uses about the same amount of air as the two smaller ones.  So, if you use the same amount of effort in playing, the high reeds (which are the ones you hear most readily) are only playing half as loud - the sound is obviously fuller, but quieter.

The second reason is the air pressure (which governs the volume of sound produced by the reeds), and is expressed in terms of force/area2, as in pounds per square inch.  If you put one pound pressure on a one square inch piston (like in a bicycle pump), you produce a pressure of 1 lb/in2.  But if you were to put the same pressure on one of those big pumps used to inflate air-beds having an effective piston size of maybe 10 square inches, then the pressure produced would be only 0.1 lb/in2.  One tenth as much!

So you'll see that the size of the bellows' cross-sectional area will affect the air pressure - and thus the volume of sound produced by the reeds.  Having an extra bank of large reeds, a typical 3-voice box uses a bellows with a c/c area around 20% greater than a typical 2-voice.  Thus it is around 20% quieter - or must be played with 20% more effort to produce equal volume, even when only using two voices.

Lastly, weight.  If you play standing up, a heavy instrument can be tiring to play - but since most people play sitting down, the actual weight is not usually too much of a problem.  What counts is how much weight you have to move about!  And what you have to move about is the bass end of the box - thus a 12-bass instrument is noticeably harder work and more tiring to play than an equivalent 8-bass one."
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: cool breeze on September 17, 2010, 07:51:54 PM
Would the loudness of the Pokerwork be similar to playing a upright piano in the house?
 :D
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Steve C. on September 17, 2010, 07:53:17 PM
As opposed to playing an upright piano in the yard?  (sorry could not resist)
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: acctech on September 18, 2010, 01:59:03 AM
It is a little unorthodox but you might glue some felt under the grill.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: sticky fingers on September 23, 2010, 05:05:03 PM
safety warning! dont glue felt under the grill, its a fire hazard! keep the grill free for toast and sausages.
or you could just try not to squeeze the bellows as hard, ( its a control thang ). sf.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: rees on September 23, 2010, 06:19:11 PM
Welcome to the forum, sticky fingers.
For your first posting you seem to have entered into the spirit of the thing nicely.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: sticky fingers on September 23, 2010, 07:49:30 PM
hello rees, met you at sidmouth a couple of times, all pros i know swear by your repair work, meant to catch up with you this year to replace a low c natural super durall but did not make it through work commitments, still i've got the same reed on the push so not an emergency!, thanks for the welcome, i am actually a previous incumbent of this parish, but occassionaly unsubscribe to defer contracting mad desease. god bless you, hope i will catch you next year. sf.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: acctech on September 24, 2010, 07:23:53 AM
safety warning! dont glue felt under the grill, its a fire hazard! keep the grill free for toast and sausages.
or you could just try not to squeeze the bellows as hard, ( its a control thang ). sf.

LOL, you made my day. The are some grills that are begging for some dogs and burgers. ie: Erica grill
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Kautilya on September 24, 2010, 11:26:09 AM
safety warning! dont glue felt under the grill, its a fire hazard! keep the grill free for toast and sausages.
or you could just try not to squeeze the bellows as hard, ( its a control thang ). sf.

LOL, you made my day. The are some grills that are begging for some dogs and burgers. ie: Erica grill
This is the cheapest solution to reduce noise; you won't hear any relatives or neighbours complaining and you will be near enough the box to hear everything. >:E
http://photos-a.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc3/hs417.snc3/25165_107158625976963_100000484794170_178907_5957155_s.jpg
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: naunton on October 04, 2010, 08:31:10 PM
The Castagnari Tommy is a great box for sessions (played quietly) and has a powerful voice when playing for a North West Morris Side... I love this little box
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: george garside on October 05, 2010, 10:47:12 AM
the quietest DG (or CF or BC or piano  accordion whatever) usually belongs to the individual who has developed a very fine degree of bellows control!

george ;)
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: stevejay on October 05, 2010, 04:04:00 PM
In some cases a "loud" instrument is a sign of quality or good set-up. Mandolins come to mind, one that has a bark is usually sought after, especially since it needs to compete. A quiet melodeon is still relatively loud I guess.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: george garside on October 05, 2010, 10:02:11 PM
In . A quiet melodeon is still relatively loud I guess.

disagree  - a quiet melodeon can be very quiet - its down to  getting away from the notion that the bellows ae just a bloody big air pump

george
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: stevejay on October 06, 2010, 05:17:03 PM
I meant capable of pretty good volume, not that it should always be played such.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: malcolmbebb on October 10, 2010, 08:22:49 PM
I have a lot of sympathy - I usually need to practice quietly, to date with a concertina.

But I do find that not all buttons sound nicely when played at low volume. On two boxes I get problems starting F# on the pull - not just my feeble pinkie since I can get the bellows from one end to t'other gently without a note.

A little perturbed by this thread, since I expect to have a DG Pokerwork on loan in a few weeks! (yes, and thinking about buying one)

Malcolm
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Rob2Hook on October 11, 2010, 12:34:26 AM
Yes, many free reed instruments are poorly set up for playing quietly, the reeds will not sound without a fair blast from the bellows.  There is also an issue with the quality of reeds, but this is not a simple high and low quality issue.  Some reeds are more mellow than others and when suitably set will play a delicate song accompaniament.  I admit to mostly choosing boxes for use for morris or ceilidh playing , so they're a bit on the loud side.  However, I have pre-war Hohner Club boxes which can be played very quietly after my self-imposed curfew (9pm - it's a terraced house), though not the Preciosa, which is happiest at medium to high volume.

I have always found Baffetti boxes to be loud, but remember the Delicia Popular as being quite mellow.  Castagnaris can be played quietly when new, but after a few years of playing at full volume will have lost the set and some notes no longer sound at lower volume levels.  So far this has not happened to my Trilly, hopefully the TAM reeds hold their set better for longer.

I have often lusted after an older German Pokerwork or Erica with a good dynamic range.  My Chinese PW is crudely set up and tuned - sounds fine for Border Morris, but not much else - and yet lacks the ultimate loudness a good German instrument can achieve.

Rob
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 11, 2010, 07:01:26 AM
Castagnaris can be played quietly when new, but after a few years of playing at full volume will have lost the set and some notes no longer sound at lower volume levels.  So far this has not happened to my Trilly, hopefully the TAM reeds hold their set better for longer.
As I'm sure you are aware, this is something which can be remedied by a good tuner.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Pat. on October 13, 2010, 06:22:46 PM
Thanks for the encouraging replys.B/C/C# Stradella boxes are a great challenge. Despite the look of them.they are are not so difficult to play if you have good bellows control ,wich is the same for any box ,and the possibilities are endless ,very glad I eventualy got one.
                                                                                                                                                              Pat.
Title: Re: Whats the quietest D/G
Post by: Pat. on October 13, 2010, 07:13:15 PM
Clearly  my earlier post is in the wrong section ,it should be under instrument makes and models.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal