My GC has an Aminor chord and I use the G chord with E bass to get an Eminor chord when I need it.
Do the French G/C players have the 3rds removed from their basses as normal . They have a lot of minor tunes .
My GC has an Aminor chord and I use the G chord with E bass to get an Eminor chord when I need it.
It has an E major chord but I think that fits well with French A minor tunes which aren't always dorian or aeolian mode and as you say you can fake an E minor chord when you need one.
Don't think I've actually seen taping but the prevalence of Hohners and similar is much less.
The other 2 are quite dear , though
Worth every penny (or Euro) if you are into the continental style of playing. The scale exercises in Vol 2 are hard work though.Where these Diatonic Accordion Method Norbert Pignol & Stephane Milleret books can be bought in Europe?
Norbert Pignol and Stephane Milleret are strong advocates of thirdless chords. It opens up a lot of harmonic possibilities and the music in their diatonic accordion tutor which is written for thirdless chords is excellent. I think Chris Ryall would know better than me, but I have the impression they are a big influence on many French players.
| I'd not put it quite that way .. in practice les gars use really complex chords. eg Stéph's favourite would probably be A minor with a major 7th - this being the chord that arises from the harmonic or melodic minor scales. They are deeply into harmonic theory and teach it at "Stage Impro (http://www.mustradem.com/Formation/vogue2010.html)" every february (for well over 20 years now). The course pulls 30-50 people, about half playing accordéon. So yes, influential. Such jazz borderland chords are not even theoretically playable on our left end, as they commonly contain dominant tritone intervals. Their method is that one of them vamps right hand chords - while the other plays tune or improvises. Having your left end 'defined' by its third can be a bind in this - whereas {tonic+5} is such a neutral harmony - 2nd harmonic - that it often works. Try eg Pignol's (solo!) féline track 11 "Opulence" (http://chrisryall.net/felinetrack11.wma) - its scale is neither major or minor! I have to say he mostly does single basses against it though. As ever when I post these tracks - if you like it do please buy the CD from the mustradem.com site (http://boutique.mustradem.com/product_info.php?manufacturers_id=&products_id=41&osCsid=d3f05e4b8f63b1449b56ae05a3e74673) - these fellas live off their music (:) | (http://chrisryall.net/clips/pignol-milleret.jpg) |