Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: SamD on September 16, 2010, 12:38:45 PM

Title: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: SamD on September 16, 2010, 12:38:45 PM
Hi Guys - I'm new here, so sorry if this topic already exists somewhere...

I recently bought a B/C Black Dot Double Ray off ebay and have been enjoying it thoroughly.  It's a pretty beaten up but plays well on the treble side (except for the B in the middle of the B row - needs some attention). 

I was wondering if anyone could give me some more info on the box, re. age etc.  I can't get the pins out to have a look at the reeds - they're very stiff - however it does seem to have a couple of Swastikas on it either side of the bass buttons!  This would lead me to believe that it's fairly old - I can't see them printing Swastikas on products after the 40's.

Also, it has 12 basses arranged like the major buttons from a Stradella system (e.g. bisonoric) - this seems a bit limited to me.  Would it be worth my while replacing them with a normal (unisonoric) melodeon system?

Finally, where can I buy replacement reeds, and how easy is it to replace them?

Cheers
Sam

Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: SamD on September 16, 2010, 12:47:11 PM
PS the bass keys all sound HORRIBLE so will need replacing anyway. If you can still view it, ebay # 110572164768.  You can just make out the Swastikas in the photo of the bass buttons.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Theo on September 16, 2010, 01:15:00 PM
PS the bass keys all sound HORRIBLE so will need replacing anyway. If you can still view it, ebay # 110572164768.  You can just make out the Swastikas in the photo of the bass buttons.

Probably not that bad,  they will just need a full reed overhaul - cleaning, removing old wax and valves, fitting new valves, rewaxing and tuning.  The treble side will probably sound better after the full treatment too.

The only time a reed must be replaced is if it has snapped off, or is cracked and about to break when it can go progressively flatter until it fails completely.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: SamD on September 16, 2010, 01:49:35 PM
Thanks Theo, I'll have a look.  They do all sounds like an approaching freight train though.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on September 16, 2010, 02:27:29 PM
Sam, you often get that effect when the low bass reeds are out of tune with the baritone reeds, often caused by rust on the reed backs with this model and period. Throw in a bit of noise from the fibre flap valves which have probably gone stiff, plus a bit of vibration from reedplates loose in the wax and you end up with.......a freight train sounds about right.   ;D

Take Theo's advice; a full reed overhaul should fix it.   :||:
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: SamD on September 16, 2010, 02:32:17 PM
hokey dokey.... how do I do that?

 ;D
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Gandy on September 16, 2010, 04:18:29 PM
Also, it has 12 basses arranged like the major buttons from a Stradella system (e.g. bisonoric) - this seems a bit limited to me.  Would it be worth my while replacing them with a normal (unisonoric) melodeon system?

Do you mean the bass buttons play the same note or chord both in and out?   If so then that's quite a good system for a B/C.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 16, 2010, 04:50:36 PM
Quote
Also, it has 12 basses arranged like the major buttons from a Stradella system (e.g. bisonoric) - this seems a bit limited to me.  Would it be worth my while replacing them with a normal (unisonoric) melodeon system?
No way! If you've a min-stradella system on a B/C box you've got a really good and useful box there, and highly desirable. Can you post a piccy as the eBay link isn't working?
AL
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: SamD on September 16, 2010, 05:54:43 PM
Skipy's link should work - unfortunately I have no camera atm, so no pics.

To Gandy and HallelujahAl, yes the buttons make the same sound in and out, which I can see as being useful in a B/C box, plus I also play PA, so it's a setup I'm used to - however, there are no minor chords available :(
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: rees on September 16, 2010, 06:34:55 PM
Having just looked at the pictures, that box is definitely 1950s or early sixties, swastikas and all.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: SamD on September 16, 2010, 06:43:03 PM
yes, I thought it looked quite 50s in design! Naziism was still going strong in the Hohner factories then!
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on September 16, 2010, 11:38:57 PM
The other day, whilst walking through the ruins of the old Coventry Cathedral, I was looking at effigy of a former Bishop of Coventry, laid upon his tomb. The bronze likeness is in remarkable condition and doesn't seem to have suffered too much for having a great Cathedral burn and then fall down on top of it in 1941.

I noticed that there are two rather obvious swastikas on the Bishop's mitre ... better than on his butt I suppose   ;)

Germans tourists do get irony don't they?

I seem to remember swastikas being used on older Hohner instruments and they pop up all over the place in religion and popular culture ... though of course this has been rather tempered in many areas by the use that the Nazis made of the swastika.

I bet that the designs on those Hohners simply hadn't changed since the 20's or or earlier, and they're not exactly swastikas that are reminiscant of the Nazi usage anyway.

OK, I know you weren't actually implying that, it's just an excuse for me to mention the swastikas in Coventry's old Cathedral  ;D


edited: for spelling.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Andrew Culwell on September 17, 2010, 01:26:47 AM
I surmise that since the Hohners were made in Germany and the Swastikas appear on boxes made soon after WWII that we can be assured that the swastikas are directly related to the National Socialist German Workers' Party (Nazi's).  I wouldn't guess that the Hohner factory had a closet Hindu or Buddhist in the design department.  My Double Ray Deluxe has the same swastikas although they are quite faint.  Seems like those swastikas were present on the boxes before and after the war...can anyone confirm that?

By the SamD I almost bought that box.  I had one just like that played very sweetly and I sold it...I regret that!
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: SamD on September 17, 2010, 09:41:17 AM
The swastika was originally a Hindu symbol, but it was the other way round (as in the arms went anticlockwise).

To A.J. Culwell - yes it does play very nicely, except the bum B note - but as that is one of the buttons which is doubled in the C row anyway, I don't really need it.  Perhaps it would be different if it was a D or something...  I haven't really played many other boxes, but this does seem to have a well balanced tone - not too loud or harsh, but still bright and lively.  It has that mellowness you only get with old instruments.  I tried out a few brand new instruments in my local music shop, but even the Hohners sounded harsh and had an almost plastic-y quality to the sound - as mine was less than half the price of a new one, and sounds much nicer, I'm very pleased with my purchase. 

Sam
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 17, 2010, 10:04:15 AM
Apparently the old M. Hohner harmonicas were originally made with swastikas printed on them but when the Nazi pary got into power they told Hohner to remove them as they thought that a humble harmonica demeaned 'their' symbol.

Fact is the symbol was long in use before Hitler and his buddies decied to use it. Though it's well nigh impossible to separate the two things now.

Nonetheless the swastika has been around for millenia - though I believe that it's wrong to suggest that the hindu symbol is in reverse - there are example of it even in the British Museum going in either direction. And as Andrew says the symbols that Hohner used are quite different to the one's utilied by the Third Reich.
AL
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: rats on September 18, 2010, 07:09:18 AM
Not quarreling with your assertion that the Nazis thought the Hohner swastika trivialized their grand cause, but where in tarnation did you find that out?

It'd be nice to get past the association of the symbol with its evil but brief expropriation. Maybe not for another, what, 30 years? Ancient history then in the minds of most of the folks on earth.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on September 18, 2010, 12:00:45 PM
I've seen pictures of those Hohner mouth organs and in this case, sadly, it wasn't just a matter of a stray swastika like symbol, it was a fully fledged Nazi flag etc. that was emblazoned onto the harmonica and it's case.

I've seen the "Nazis didn't like it story" as well, but considering the number of things that the Nazi insignia got put on I do wonder about that.

In any case, it doesn't take away the fact that the swastika was surprisingly widely used in "western society" in a non-political context right up to it's appropriation by the Nazis.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on September 18, 2010, 12:02:34 PM
Oh, on the Double Ray, are those basses common on old Double Rays? From the pictures and comments it looks like a cut-down stradella system thingy.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: acctech on September 18, 2010, 02:21:49 PM
Some of the pre-war mouth harmonicas also had the star of David on them. As I understand it, it was not intentionally used because of this, but was just the choice of the artist. Who knows for sure, the answer to this is likely lost in time. Regardless, the political powers of the time forced it's removal. Hohner produced harmonicas that were used by both the German and Allied forces. There are two wonderful history books available from the Harmonika museum in Trossingin. They complement each other; one focuses on the harmonica and one on the accordion. They are hardcover's, with full color photos.
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: SamD on September 18, 2010, 06:00:20 PM
Oh, on the Double Ray, are those basses common on old Double Rays? From the pictures and comments it looks like a cut-down stradella system thingy.

it is a cut-down stradella system thingy.  Not sure how common they are though!
Title: Re: Hohner Double Ray
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 20, 2010, 08:25:06 PM
Oh, on the Double Ray, are those basses common on old Double Rays? From the pictures and comments it looks like a cut-down stradella system thingy.

it is a cut-down stradella system thingy.  Not sure how common they are though!

I had a grey Double-Ray for a time some years ago, and that definitely had a conventional melodeon bass.

Graham
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal