Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Geoffleft on April 29, 2008, 02:07:52 PM
-
Some questions to all those brave souls who extend their passions to the insides of the 'Box'.
Who has tried tuning with these new little diamond files that are quite cheap these days? I couldn't resist the temptation when I saw a set of four for Au$8 the other day. This is the price of a four inch flat file of asian manufacture of the kind I find useful for tuning/sharpening reeds.
I'm a bit concerned that the way you would use them wouldn't be the same as the way a steel file is used, and so different techniques may have to be developed. I have been using little diamond points in the dremel for bits of tuning too, I fully realize that this is a loaded topic, but it is my most efficient way of staying in tune.
For flattening reeds Frank Romano (FRM Enterprises) in Montreal sold me some burins (Kind of gouging tools) which with a bit of practice are pretty efficient, and leave the long marks on the reeds we are used to seeing and wondering about.
Any comments freinds?
-
I think reeds are too valuable to choose a tuning tool only on the grounds of cost.
For files I've not found better than Swiss files made by Grobert/Vallorbe. They do a nice triangular file designed for sharpening saws. You can find them at Axminster tools (http://www.axminster.co.uk/product.asp?pf_id=22603&name=+file&user_search=1&sfile=1&jump=12&cid=SOVFD40DM08X3XB0JAWXFD5FZ45E3S4Z). And they aren't even expensive.
I have some cheap diamond files, but I don't use them on reeds, mainly because they are too coarse. Axminster also sell various diamond tools designed for sharpening blades. The have a nice fine texture, but they tend to be too wide to get good access to the smaller reeds.
Have you tried making your own 'sandpaper files'? Very simple to make with abrasive paper glued onto a stick. Very gentle, and with a fine grit you get a smooth finish.
-
(snip) Any comments freinds?
None other than I admire your spirit of adventure. In my mature years, I'm beginning to eschew adding other things to the list of things that I dabble at but never had the time to learn to do well so successfully taking such a job on is truly admirable. How do you measure the pitch of reeds to ascertain how they need to be sharpened or flattened?
-
How do you measure the pitch of reeds to ascertain how they need to be sharpened or flattened?
I have a Peterson Strobo-Flip (http://www.petersontuners.com/index.cfm?category=37) tuner. With this you can work out how many cents (cent=1/100 of a semitone) each note is out by and the rotation of the strobe display indicates if the note is sharp or flat. Offset the note reference value until the strobe rotation stops and read off how many cents +/- the note is.
I've just started looking into reed tuning and I'm about to have my first go at tuning a full instrument in the next few weeks. I might start a thread on the inevitable ups and downs to give you all a laugh. ::)
-
Theo. Thanks for the idea of a sandpaper file, it sounds good, with nice fine grit you could do really fine work. Yes I agree, good reeds aren't something you stuff around with! I did my learning on old hohner boxes mostly.
A spirit of adventure??! How many of us learn to swim by being pushed into the water? Quite a few I think.
If you ever have to find a reed rivet, it is a lot easier to turn one up using the head of a two inch nail in the collet chuck of your dremel! Neccesity has always been the mother of invention hasn't it? Just make sure you use your Vernier Calipers.
I would dearly love a Peterson strobe tuner, but how one can afford such things is a perpetual wonder to me. Where to put it is another thing to consider if you aren't lucky enough to have lots of space.
I have always used a Boss TU 100 tuner. I don't think theyr'e available any more, but I might be wrong. It has an easy to read needle gauge, and would obviously be totally inferior,as regards accuracy, but the big advantage to me is that it's mine! It isn't very big,and comes with me when I go to festivals. With it and a bit of help from my ear, I keep pretty happy.
-
Many people sure can "learn to swim" when pushed in the water, however it's a lot easier when someone can teach you the basics beforehand ;)
For the tuning, these hi-tech devices are surely very useful, but I can imagine how the tuning was done 50+ years ago when those electronic marvels weren't around and the craftspeople used their ears and simple reference tools (tuning forks?) to achieve the beautiful sound we still enjoy today on old recordings!
-
I've used these to tune concertinas with great success.......two grades available.
Lee Valley Tools is a Canadian Company .
Robin
http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=20187&cat=1,42500,42523 (http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=20187&cat=1,42500,42523)
-
I would dearly love a Peterson strobe tuner, but how one can afford such things is a perpetual wonder to me. Where to put it is another thing to consider if you aren't lucky enough to have lots of space.
Obviously you didn't follow the link and take a look. This is a small unit not one of the huge bench mounted jobbies and is a fraction of the price. At around £160 they're not exactly cheap but they do cost less than having one melodeon tuned. ;)
-
A spirit of adventure??! How many of us learn to swim by being pushed into the water? Quite a few I think.
__. Yes, I'm an admirer of that sort of thing. I had a neighbor who decided that if his children needed brain surgery he'd go on the internet and get a recommendation for the right chisel, saw, hammer, etc. He just jumped right in. It's kind of like tuning reeds, he'd probably "get the hang of it" after he'd ruined a few. ;D
-
Obviously you didn't follow the link and take a look. This is a small unit not one of the huge bench mounted jobbies and is a fraction of the price. At around £160 they're not exactly cheap but they do cost less than having one melodeon tuned. ;)
Hmm, clearly I'm charging far too little!
-
Yes I admit I didn't follow the link, Tallship. The Peterson Strobo-flip looks wonderful. And at that price it's a wonder good Accordion Techs aren't extinct.
Money and me have always had a troublesome relationship though, and this is why I started stuffing around with my own accordions. I couldn't afford, quite literally to get my Box tuned by a guy down the road who I discovered was grinding the reed plates of my Boxes as well as the reeds!! I had a feeling this wasn't correct, but I still had to pay for his work.
Time was also an issue, with a playing diary that didn't permit any downtime on my main instrument, this had the effect of ensuring that mistakes were not at the time an option, and so, I didn't make mistakes.
I have been lucky to sit next to a respected tuner, and watch the process that a Master used in tuning by ear, with a few reference tones. I consider that to have been a great honour, and one thing that guy showed me was that reed work was not a black, superstitious art that none but the divinely gifted were granted access to. If you respect the other musicians you play with, assuming you are lucky enough to play with others, never abuse the privilage by playing an out of tune instrument.
But then, I was just wondering about files.......
-
Guys and Gals,
Stay with your boxes and let others tune them. As you know, woodwinds and brass instruments are unable to be produced in tune with themselves, let alone others. They have to be lipped in and playing with a tuner attached is a very sobering experience and hard work. So stay with your melodeons and get them tuned yearly, not every bloody moment you are playing them. ;D
Old Bill.
-
But then, I was just wondering about files.......
Sorry about the tread drift, I was just trying to answer a question.
Theo: The box I was thinking of is a three voice and the estimate I got for tuning, re-valving and waxing the reeds back in was 'around £200'. In fairness this might have included a key change from C/C# to C#/D but I've deleted the email and can't check on that.
I don't think technological advances will ever threaten the skilled tuning technician's livelihood, a few people like me might have a dabble on a cheap old box out of interest without any intention of tuning for anyone else or indeed tuning their own best instrument. The old Hohner I have is just about scrap so I can't ruin anything precious or expensive to replace.
Back on topic, I have a set of diamond files but I'm not inclined to use them on reeds as a novice tuner. I liberated a couple of stirring sticks from a coffee shop that are around a quarter of an inch wide, glued them together and stuck very fine wet and dry paper on one side and a slightly coarser grade on the other. It may take me a long time to tune my first reed but I'll find out how much metal comes off to change the pitch by a couple of cents, lots of practice like this will lead to sufficient experience to judge when to use something more aggressive and for how long when making major adjustments like a key change.
-
Theo: The box I was thinking of is a three voice and the estimate I got for tuning, re-valving and waxing the reeds back in was 'around £200'. In fairness this might have included a key change from C/C# to C#/D but I've deleted the email and can't check on that.
That's more like it. I would describe that job as a reed overhaul, a much bigger task than just tuning.
Back on topic, I have a set of diamond files but I'm not inclined to use them on reeds as a novice tuner. I liberated a couple of stirring sticks from a coffee shop that are around a quarter of an inch wide, glued them together and stuck very fine wet and dry paper on one side and a slightly coarser grade on the other. It may take me a long time to tune my first reed but I'll find out how much metal comes off to change the pitch by a couple of cents, lots of practice like this will lead to sufficient experience to judge when to use something more aggressive and for how long when making major adjustments like a key change.
To my mind the big advantage of the abrasive paper tool over a file is that it is much more gentle and predictable. It is possible for a file (even a good one) to catch the edge of a reed and remove too much metal, or even bend a very fine reed, that sort of mishap is almost impossible with a sanding stick.
-
Just thought I'd check.
No. That favorite file of mine isn't even of asian manufacture at all. It's from a place called Portugal. Now that is a long way away, further even than Switzerland. Good file. Four inch flat. Probably a second cut by the looks of things. Not a Fine, and definitely not a Bastard. I hope you get my drift. It has lasted well too, although I've taken some care to keep it away from the other hard tools. Not Swiss though. Nor German. Nor Australian either, we used to make good files.
Guys, just be really carefull to use the right glue on your sandpaper sticks. The wrong glue could really set you off on the wrong tack. Heh. No, be sensible, don't go using something stupid like Milners. Maybe it'd be worth trying Hyde glue. It has a wonderous reputation.
-
one thing that guy showed me was that reed work was not a black, superstitious art that none but the divinely gifted were granted access to.
Too simplistic. A good artisan can make a very acceptable workmanlike job to a high degree of skill, consistently well executed and to a highly acceptable standard. I will guarantee that others will come along and lift the game way beyond that to an almost godlike status; they do this with an uncanny understanding of the task at hand, appreciated by many but truly defined by none. If you could explain and define genius then that knowledge would be available to all; all that is who were able to understand.
For that reason there will always be the mediocre, the good and the exceptional and long may it be so; otherwise the pretentious like me will have nothing to aim for and scientists will rule the world.
-
I've used these to tune concertinas with great success.......two grades available.
Lee Valley Tools is a Canadian Company .
Robin
http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=20187&cat=1,42500,42523 (http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=20187&cat=1,42500,42523)
Ah, Stick Sanders, I remember him well. They scoffed when he joined Fairport, y'know.
I've not used it but Dirk's Accordion Tuner program and a microphone is even cheaper than Peter's Son-Strober, and it monitors three reeds at once and keeps track of how your wetness varies with pitch.
I've thought about tuning my own reeds in the past but never got round to it. Perhaps being told by people who've never met me that I shouldn't is the impetus I'll need to get started...
-
Yes, the guy I sat and watched is revered in God like ways in his own community. He would be considered by all but the most brutish as high Folk Royalty. I do accept what you say 'Tallship', and generally I agree.
Definitely there exists a Divine spark, that glows in diverse ways in all of us. We of sensitivity can perceive and celebrate those who are blessed in specific areas, in this case accordion tuning. Some obviously can not.
I don't know what calibre of person, or musician you are. You may be a highly sensitive individual who is well qualified to be a judge of all things pertaining to every aspect of the Button Accordion. You may be a masterful player, a national treasure of long standing and priceless cultural value. Or you may not be.
And so might I be or not be.
However. I do like my accordions to feel just so. And if they don't feel right, and I can't make them speak what I want to say in my music, well then I feel, as the reason these instruments exist at all is so that I can play on them, that I should be able to correct them so that they do perform as I need them to....
And out come my trusty Portugese 4" second cut flat file, my dremel and little diamond point, my flattening burins, a half razor blade very well used and thin, a scalpel, a small screwdriver, masking tape, the old Boss TU100 chromatic tuner, tuning chart and pen. And I sit at my little kitchen table until Sparrows, Blackbirds and Thrushes, Indian Miners, Starlings,Silver Eyes, Wattle birds and Helmeted Honeyeaters start up their racket. And when I'm happy, I go to bed.
One of the nice things about a Forum such as this is that It's great to discover others from diverse places with whom you can share........ um, is'nt it.
-
However. I do like my accordions to feel just so. And if they don't feel right, and I can't make them speak what I want to say in my music, well then I feel, as the reason these instruments exist at all is so that I can play on them, that I should be able to correct them so that they do perform as I need them to....
Which is exactly how I got into this type of work, which has now become a full time occupation. I've enjoyed the challenge of acquiring skills where no textbook, apprenticeship or any other formal training is available. I've been assisted by many generous people who shared what they knew. It has also been a satisfying process to search for and find suppliers of some obscure materials and parts, and I have an excuse to visit Italy from time to time which is always a pleasure. And I'm still learning...
One of the nice things about a Forum such as this is that It's great to discover others from diverse places with whom you can share........ um, is'nt it.
Indeed it is, and in that spirit could I ask anyone who reads this make sure your profile includes your location, even if its just the name of your country. pushpullefty I guess from your bigpond email that you are in Australia
-
Yes Theo. I'm from Melbourne, Australia. A big Urban mess of a place.
And Theo. It is nice to communicate with a kindred spirit such as yourself..
My road has maybe been a little different than yours, as at every turn I have met with negitivity and challenges. In Australia we have a culture of cutting down the 'tall poppies'. This is especially apparent in 'Folk' circles. Still the process of learning about the accordion is a bit like a Bower bird building its fantastic nest out of all those especially selected bits of junk, all in blue. We get our information where we can and however it comes. As long as we eventually do get it.
And when I met the 'Box' for the first time, I had a feeling that this was my road. You get that feeling with people too don't you.
Thanks for a great forum.
-
I don't know what calibre of person, or musician you are. You may be a highly sensitive individual who is well qualified to be a judge of all things pertaining to every aspect of the Button Accordion. You may be a masterful player, a national treasure of long standing and priceless cultural value. Or you may not be.
As a person I'm an everyday working man, bright enough to get by and always have a job but not bright enough to make loads of money. :( As a musician I'm a fair guitarist but not more than that, I've always loved music but I'm not a natural musician at all, everything I've learned is through sheer dogged determination. I am very new to the melodeon so the standard of my playing would best be described as rank beginner. ;D
My comments weren't intended as a put down and I'm very sorry if they seemed so.
Pete.
-
Well now. I was the one who was appearing a little exaspirated.... sorry.
In all doctrines of worth, we usually come to the point of realizing that the more we know, the more we don't know.
And when there are real questions to be asked, and real facts to be communicated, It is sometimes sobering to realize that people who haven't come as far down the path as ourselves still need to have a voice. And we all need to be able to stand back and have a chuckle too.
I'm quite a mediocre player, but I do love all that there is about Button Accordion culture.
Tallship. You can play the guitar, you lucky barstard! All those chords and notes. We were just talking about it at the session last week. You've got it all over us single note players, and that includes the fiddlers. And I bet you have some great songs too. We'll just stop the tunes for a bit now, and let us dream off into some great song of old wonder.... ah
-
Well now. I was the one who was appearing a little exaspirated.... sorry.
No worries; funny old place t'internet, sometimes it's hard to get your point across without the possibility of misinterpretation.
In all doctrines of worth, we usually come to the point of realizing that the more we know, the more we don't know.
Quite so, I'm often alarmed by the degree of my own ignorance. ::)
Tallship. You can play the guitar, you lucky barstard! All those chords and notes. We were just talking about it at the session last week. You've got it all over us single note players, and that includes the fiddlers. And I bet you have some great songs too.
Oh, some of the songs are great, my voice leaves a little to be desired though! Finger picking gives a lot of options regarding the accompaniment style and texture. It strikes me that the melodeon should be great for song accompaniment, if you can keep the volume down a bit that is. I'm nowhere near good enough to control the instrument yet but I've only been playing for about six weeks. I play English concertina so on top of learning a new instrument I have to cope with the alien concept of two notes per button and constantly changing bellows direction. I'm a long way off figuring the keyboard out well enough to be crossing the rows to smooth things out a bit.
I keep toying with the idea of sticking a song up on youtube for a laugh but it would have to be something traditional to avoid copyright problems so maybe not.
*Back on topic* ( ;D) If you are determined to use the diamond files on reeds for goodness sake take it steady, ruining a reed is very, very easy. :o
-
*Back on topic* ( ;D) If you are determined to use the diamond files on reeds for goodness sake take it steady, ruining a reed is very, very easy. :o
Oh dear, is that a recent discovery?
-
Oh dear, is that a recent discovery?
More a case of accumulated knowledge Theo, I'm sad enough to have read every single thread in 'Instrument Construction and Repair' both on this board and at concertina.net and that's a fair amount of reading. Without exception, every time the subject of reed tinkering comes up the experts pile in with dire warnings about how easy it is to completely ruin a reed using the wrong tools that cut too quickly and too deep. I was surprised to read that cleaning a reed with a fiberglass pen can significantly alter the pitch and that's more like polishing than abrading. My conclusion is to work slowly and with extreme caution at first until I have some idea of what I'm doing.
-
In my experience the fibreglass pen has almost zero effect on steel reeds, though of course removing heavy dirt and rust with any tool will affect the pitch.
Incidentally I think the fibreglass pen is the best tool by far for tuning brass reeds.
-
Fibreglass Pen? What's that?
I know a guy who is seriously into Harmonica tuning. Great, great player but oh what a strange person. But this might be right down his alley. Imagine tuning a harp!! Carazy. But there is a whole bunch who are right into it.
I have a little jewellers screwdriver which has been sharpened that has always been fantastic for cutting the rust and dust off dirty reeds. A scalpel with a small curved blade is also good, and can cut away any burr from the side/tip of a reed after tuning with a file.
Has anybody tried using 'Cratex' rubberized abrasive rotary tools in their dremel for cleaning or tuning? They are available in a range of grits from jewellery suppliers. I don't use them. Just wondering if anybody else has.
-
Fibreglass Pen? What's that?
http://www.maplin.co.uk/Module.aspx?ModuleNo=3932&doy=4m5&C=SO&U=strat15 (http://www.maplin.co.uk/Module.aspx?ModuleNo=3932&doy=4m5&C=SO&U=strat15)
-
http://www.maplin.co.uk/Module.aspx?ModuleNo=3932&doy=4m5&C=SO&U=strat15 (http://www.maplin.co.uk/Module.aspx?ModuleNo=3932&doy=4m5&C=SO&U=strat15)
That's the one, and where I got mine from in fact. These are used by electronics types to clean up the tracks on printed circuit boards prior to soldering, I'm sure you'll find them somewhere in Oz at an electronics supply house or a well stocked hobbies shop. Do heed the health and safety warnings, nasty stuff fibreglass.
-
Has anybody tried using 'Cratex' rubberized abrasive rotary tools in their dremel for cleaning or tuning? They are available in a range of grits from jewellery suppliers. I don't use them. Just wondering if anybody else has.
Not tried that, in fact I dislike using power tools on reeds, not controllable enough for me. But Maplin also do this polishing block (http://www.maplin.co.uk/Search.aspx?criteria=polishing%20block&source=15&SD=Y), which is abrasive in a rubbery matrix that does a fine job of cleaning rust, though you sometimes need a scrape with an old screwdriver first if its really crusty rust.
-
One could use the 'cratex' wheels as a hand held abrasive too. They would be a bit more flexible than the rubber block from Maplins as they can be got in a range of sizes/shapes. I was just trying one out and for reed cleaning could be very good. Safer than a sanding stick. An old style ink eraser could work also.
I was once told a very convincing story about why serious instrument makers never but never used any machine tools (ranging from table/band saws through thicknessers/jointers to finishing tools) on wood that was to be used in a top grade instrument. Sandpaper was an absolute no no too.
Well the time came when I met some utterly top grade makers. One a famous bluegrass mandolin maker, the other a highly regarded violin maker for the classical musicians. I asked both if there was any truth in the story.. both regarded it as an hilarious piece of rubbish.
But Theo. I agree that you have much more control and feel if you are tuning reeds with a file. There is far less scope for a slip, or a bit too much grinding. As I mentioned, I had an accordion damaged by a careless tuner once, and he never got a second chance from me!
-
I don't know what the "why" was in that story, very possibly completely spurious, but there is a well documented and valid approach to violin making that uses no power tools and no abrasives either. Johnson & Courtnall's excellent book is based on a "no power tools" approach.
It's often repeated that makers in Stradivari's time simply didn't have abrasives. They "may" have used sharkskin but I've never some across any reference to whether the stuff actually works.
(I guess there's also the possibility that "sharkskin" was a name for something else, just as "moleskin" cloth has nothing to do with moles!)