Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: westsider on September 26, 2010, 03:27:22 PM

Title: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: westsider on September 26, 2010, 03:27:22 PM
Hello to all.  I've been reading comments on this site for about a year and have decided that it is past time to register. I've been playing mostly Irish tunes on a 1 row Hohner HA-112 "D" for about months and want to start working w/a two row in the C#/D system.  Would one of the Weltmeisters a 406 or 511 be a good choice?  I will get the reeds upgraded because I've read that they can be a little weak; will the keyboard need to be blocked ala the Hohner 1 row (done myself, thanks for the great advice)?  I like the price point on the Weltys and the fact that, as best I can discern, they are still German made. Any suggestions?
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: melodeon on September 26, 2010, 08:26:08 PM
Depends...  a lot on the price

I found a new Weltmeister  at a small store in Oregon.. last year... $695  US...  to me, that was worth it..
more... not sure....

The problem with the C#/D is that it is uncommon to find an Erica/Black Dot in C#/D  which would be my choice before
a Weltmesiter and usually  modestly priced

Why not go with an upgraded 1 row in D....  here the Weltmeister/Gallota/Regal et al  are decent and fairly  priced.

Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: Theo on September 26, 2010, 09:09:02 PM
Would one of the Weltmeisters a 406 or 511 be a good choice?  I will get the reeds upgraded because I've read that they can be a little weak;

That or the 86W are all decent boxes.   Replacing the reeds will be a big extra cost though.  Much better value for money to buy a better quality box from the start, or buy an old Hohner two row in an unpopular tuning, and put a set of C#/D reeds  in.  In the UK you can get a set of Hohner C#/D reedblocks for a bit over £200.

The problem with the C#/D is that it is uncommon to find an Erica/Black Dot in C#/D  which would be my choice before
a Weltmesiter and usually  modestly priced

Hohner now sell the Double ray new in C#/D
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: westsider on September 27, 2010, 02:06:50 AM
Thanks for the suggestions.  I've found a 406 at a decent price that I'm interested in (less than half the cost of new) and I know the new reeds will make a big difference, but  I do have concerns; how would the keyboard compare to a Hohner 1040 or the HA series?  Even though I don't play fast, I hope to improve (eventually) in the speed department and would like the keyboard to be sufficient for  the next year at least.  Is the build quality at least as good as a Hohner Pokerwork or Double Ray? 
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: melodeon on September 27, 2010, 02:42:33 AM
I liked the keyboard action of the Weltie...
I liked the sound
I liked the price on the one I saw
I do not care for the usual retail price, even discounted

They do not sound as "harsh" as a Hohner
But keep in mind Hohners stock... "almost"  tuning
Hohners are greatly improved with tuning and of course padding the keyboard

The Weltie actually sounded in tune and cleaner.

I prefer Pokerworks and Ericas/Black Dots for their character and resale
ease of repair and parts/service availability

I would consider a new Hohner C#/D  not available (yet) in the US... over a Weltie if similarly priced.

Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: westsider on September 27, 2010, 01:04:43 PM
Thanks melodeon - I think that about answers all my questions.  I agree that pricing is the key based on what I've seen a heard from everyone.  If I can get the box for the price I think I can and rev up the reeds, should be perfect for now.  I appreciate the advise.
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: waltzman on September 27, 2010, 01:28:24 PM


I would consider a new Hohner C#/D  not available (yet) in the US... over a Weltie if similarly priced.



New Hohner Black Dot in C#/D is available through the Button Box
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: Don Roberts on September 27, 2010, 01:44:03 PM
I played a rented Weltmeister model 510 for a time while I had another box on order. I wish I would have bought the Weltmeister as well.
The 510 has three clarinet reeds which means one can have it tuned to any degree of true musette or dead dry if thats what you want. If I could find a used 510 I would probably buy it.
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: pgroff on September 27, 2010, 02:28:28 PM
http://www.elderly.com/vintage/items/160U-462.htm
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: westsider on September 27, 2010, 03:29:13 PM
That's the one.  Now purchased and off to Dancemaster Accordions for some zippy new reeds and hopefully not much else. 
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: melodeon on September 27, 2010, 03:31:31 PM
Good spotting Paul,


That's a recent listing... and
it seems someone at Elderly finally knows how to photograph an accordeon and provide a somewhat reasonable description.

That is a decent price and looks to be in good condition.
I would think at $525, could not go too far wrong and would not lose much on a resale.

I am not certain I would go the expensive of Italian reeds. 
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: tedrick on September 27, 2010, 06:14:22 PM
That's the one.  Now purchased and off to Dancemaster Accordions for some zippy new reeds and hopefully not much else. 

Hey Westsider - welcome to the world of mel.net -
I have been extremely pleased with the reeds and tuning Michael at Dancemaster did with my upgraded Paolo elite II - your Welti is going to sing -

Micheal is also very good at adjusting the keyboard to optimal action -
Title: Re: Weltmeister for Irish music?
Post by: westsider on September 27, 2010, 06:25:33 PM
Thanks Reeds,  that is what I'm hoping for.  Everything I've read about Michael has been very positive and melnet is the best music forum I've found.  Great environment.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal