Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on September 28, 2010, 09:02:56 AM
-
Changing rhythms...
So how do you do it?
And do certain rhythms suit being changed to particular other ones? (I'm talking about using same tune)
Like can you go from a waltz to a hornpipe? etc.
-
not quite sure what you are asking? Do you mean playhing a tune written & norally played as eg a 4/4 as a 3/4 or changing from a hornpipe into a waltz without stopping?
If the former t;here are many 4/4's that work very well s 3/4s provided either you make the change entirely by ear (preferable) or if you can only work from dots you ignore note length, timing etc & only read the name of the notes eg BF#cg etcetc. The easiest way if to play a tune you know as a walatz & then go straight into the wasa 4/4 but playing it to fit the waltz you have just played - then go straight back into the waltz & practise this technique untill you get the tunes fitting seemlessly together.
The Rowan Tree 4/4 works equally well as a waltz3/4, Loch Lomond 4/4 makes a good waltz but it could be a bit of o bugger to sing to in waltz form as you have to lengthen some notes considerably. Most 6/68stuff is easy to cut in half & play as a 3/4 eg Bonny Dundee. Even winster gallop can be played as a waltz ( I once ran a aworkshop doing just that!) but it doesnt sound particularly good!!
changing tunes to other time signatures can be fun/interesting & requires absolutely no knowledge of musical theory - just bugger about with it untill it sounds right.
george ;)
-
Do you mean playhing a tune written & norally played as eg a 4/4 as a 3/4
that one....I was trying to 'do a clive' ;) play speed the plough in different rhythms last night...and struggled with changing it to a waltz....maybe it would help if I could play waltzes properly first.
-
....maybe it would help if I could play waltzes properly first.
I think that is a vital first step!
-
Practice...
Many tunes can be relaxed into a hornpipe - otherwise Border Morris would have died out for lack of suitable music! Occasionally you can take the essence of a tune into waltz time, or more likely a mazurka which seems to accomodate more of the left over notes.
Rob.
P.S. actually, I wish more morris bands could decide which rythm they are supposed to be playing...
-
I find turning waltzes to jigs and 4/4 or 2/4 to hornpipes okay...I struggle a bit with the others.
-
I find turning waltzes to jigs and 4/4 or 2/4 to hornpipes okay...I struggle a bit with the others.
It usually is ! It can help to play the bass very pedantically as a solid UM PA PA & to start the bass rhythm before the tune if trying the 'conversion' in isolation. It is for this reasson that i suggest going from a known waltz into thee 'conversion' as you have already established a solid waltz rhythm. Dont try to convert a whole tune all at once, just concentrate on go;ing from the known waltz & getting the first few bars of the next tune converted.
george
-
Depending on the melody you can often change 3/4 to 5/4 by changing every second bar into two notes (either replace a half note by a quarter one or just delete a quarter note). Also works for 6/8. Bellowhead's Fakenham Fair is a great example and the Liberty Bell makes a nice 5/4 tune as well.
-
what would you use a 5/4 for?
george
-
what would you use a 5/4 for?
george
There's a few French Waltzes in 5/4.
Steve
-
Princess Royal makes a nice waltz and Planxty Irwin becomes Planxty William Kimber when played as a polka!
-
6/8 to 3/4 is cheating. There are some real tunes that exist in both forms - try playing The Perfect Cure really slowly so each half bar is a bar in waltz time, then play The Rope Waltz...
(or start with the Rope Waltz and speed it up)
Anyway, I think LDT was talking about the type of transformation that turns The Plane Tree into Schottische à Bethanie.
It's quite fun to do, but if you can't play waltzes easily, trying to turn a hornpipe into a Waltz isn't going to help ;D
Some tunes are more amenable than others to such conversions.
I recycled one of my own Molly tunes into a jig once - it's a good way of composing a new tune if you are in a hurry and can't think of anything completely original.
5/4 ? There are a few 5/4 hornpipes, such as John Kirkpatrick's The Gas Almost Works and incidentally he recycled that into/from Fulham by Gas Light which is the same tune in waltz time... and Greg Trice's Moulsham Street Hornpipe which was inspired by and written to go with The Gas Almost Works. (Does anyone else in the world play that?)
I don't know what dances would work with them - you'd have to invent one. What do Seven Champs do with Take Five?
Hey - idea for theme of the month: tunes in irregular time signatures!
(no 2/4, 4/4, 6/8, 9/8 or 3/2 unless perhaps they change metre mid tune)
-
Dennington Bell makes a great jig, (much to the amusement of Katie Howson!)
-
Princess Royal makes a nice waltz
might try that one.
Anyway, I think LDT was talking about the type of transformation that turns The Plane Tree into Schottische à Bethanie.
It's quite fun to do, but if you can't play waltzes easily, trying to turn a hornpipe into a Waltz isn't going to help ;D
that's exactly what I meant.
-
Well you see. I can only 'memorize' a finite number of tunes so instead of getting bored with the ones I've already 'learnt' and moving on and forgetting them. I thought I would try just paying the 4 tunes I do know off by heart in different ways.
-
I don't know what dances would work with them - you'd have to invent one. What do Seven Champs do with Take Five?
I think it's more common in Eastern European dance music - i.e. Bulgarian dances that make use of the "limping" rhythms, (5/4, 11/8) . I think this one is in 5/4, or some more exotic uneven rhythm.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fmn5_L-u8sY
-
5/4 ? I don't know what dances would work with them - you'd have to invent one.
How about the 5/4 waltz like this one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fC6FWy7fr0w) or this one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-RhuMuKFbYE)? ;) Another reason to use 5/4 is that it can be a great variation (see Bellowhead).
-
I think it's more common in Eastern European dance music - i.e. Bulgarian dances that make use of the "limping" rhythms, (5/4, 11/8) . I think this one is in 5/4, or some more exotic uneven rhythm.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fmn5_L-u8sY
I can't listen to it now (I'm at work - sssh!) but it's allegedly in 5/8, probably a Pajduško (sp?) Horo and like all Balkan rhythms the bar is divided up into 3's and 2's i.e. long and short beats.
So 11/8 is usually 2+2+3+2+2 or short-short-long-short-short
The long is 50% longer than the short. You soon get used to it.
We went to a French Bal on Saturday but they didn't play any 5/4 waltzes :(
-
French 5/4's or 5/8sare actually pretty rare. I used to hear perhaps 2-3 in a St Chartier festival, the Allier/Chavanée lot don't do 5/8s at all. Nor the Bretons I've seen and I used to be a regular at Paris's Mission Bretonne (http://tav.trad.org/). The Grenoble group have a couple - but they are pretty eclectic people. Didn't see any last summer in Basque counry. I'm not actually sure where this style originated, but suspect the German border.
IME of Balkan (and I did long ago found Anahata's local club!) the 'limping' rhythms tend to be Serbain/Macadonian with more brisk stuff from Central Bulgaria and espcially Rumania. but Balkan dance is a vast, specialised and fascinating subject (again the Grenoble people are in to it++).
Actually because Balkan tunes are still very much tied to their source dances - they are almost the antithesis of this thread's title. As said before I personally think rhythm changing is naff. One might break rhythm - but that's another matter (and far more fun IMHO) :|glug
-
<snip/>
One might break rhythm - but that's another matter (and far more fun IMHO) :|glug
What does the term 'break rhythm' actually mean? I assume it's something more specific than just changing an expected rhythm to something else?
I must admit that I find being able and prepared to change a rhythmic pattern within isolated bars or phrases to be generally more useful and interesting than changing the entire tune. Although the individual changes might seem inconsequential on thier own, it's those sort of touches that, to me, make one performance stand out from another.
-
I looked on Youtube for a decent rendition of the set: Full Rigged Ship/New Rigged Ship
without luck. I wanted to post a link. However, this was the 3/4 to 4/4 example that helped me understand that kind of transformation.
I'll tell you about an exercise that I currently do on low whistle, the relatively easiest instrument for me, and will transfer to melodeon when I get my new straps from the Button Box.
First, I play an easy waltz that I can play smoothly at a decent speed on automatic pilot, such as Planxty Hewlett. I tap my foot very emphatically on every downbeat: 1 2 3 1 2 3. Then, just solo with my foot, I tap a bit faster and count to myself 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4. When I feel myself well-absorbed in this counting, I hum that waltz melody in time to my foot tapping and notice where I drag some notes out to keep time with my foot. Then, I try playing my instrument in place of my humming. Finally, I decide what extra notes to play in those places that got dragged out for the extra beat. That part takes some brain gymnastics for me! But, it's fun. I don't speed up my 4/4 from march to reel tempo until I'm really confident with my new version of the tune. Hmm, video camera time again?
-
Princess Royal works well in 4/4, 7/8, 6/8, and 3/4. Now just need to work out a 5/4 version. >:E
-
some tunes make nice slow airs, e.g. hundred pipers or waiting for the federals,
i like to play hundred pipers slow and soulfull with some ornamentation, as an intro, then play it bright and punchy with straight notes
-
what would you use a 5/4 for?
george
There's a few French Waltzes in 5/4.
Steve
Er ....as the definition of a waltz is a dance tune in triple time, how can there be waltzes in 5/4? Polskas, maybe, but waltzes?
Here in Cyprus traditional tunes come in all kinds of multiple time signatures - a nice straightforward 5/4 would be a pleasant bit of relaxation! I have a book of Cypriot tunes, one of which is is in a combination of 3/8, 5/8, 7/8 and 11/8 - and not in any discernible order!!
Me - I'll stick to playing polkas, waltzes & hornpipes......
Graham
-
What does the term 'break rhythm' actually mean? I assume it's something more specific than just changing an expected rhythm to something else?
Say you are in a waltz playing - one two three -one two three - to 'break ' you instead play some variation that is strongly structured in twos. This might be done with repeated note groups, or by the way you use the bellows on existing notes. In the first case you can keep the 3/4 on left end. (In the latter it's useful to have another player). The 2/4 goes out of phase with the 3/4 after one bar, then falls back in at the second. Cutting/Eaton used to do a fair bit of this - it's invigorating to dance against .
Similarly you can break to a 3/4 across a 4/4 tune - in this case resolution takes 4 bars. Some band arrangers do this too (especially if they have a brass section). Trickier on solo melodeon, and I'm not personally good at it.
Er ....as the definition of a waltz is a dance tune in triple time, how can there be waltzes in 5/4? Polskas, maybe, but waltzes?
See http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I31q5UhzfX4
In a 5/4 basically you do 3 steps of waltz man| left right left .. followed by a little two-step right left | The next bar is the same but led with the other foot. One's partner does mirrored feet as usual.
The dances are quite fast. Some couples step out the whole thing which I'm not fond of - think it looks a bit Pinocchio actually.
I do the lazier version waltzing the three and simply weight change the two. Quite fun but hard not to spent the dance counting steps! There seems to be a relationship to the German 'zwiefacher'
Dots - http://www.stammtischmusik.at/noten/boxhamerisch.htm
Wacky video, with rhythm breaks on Tuba! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TV0uUVuH8p4
-
Yes, I follow the mechanics of tune & dance in 5/4; my only quibble was with calling it a "waltz", which is by definition in triple time. Do the French (erroneously) call it a "valse", or do they have another local name for it, I wonder........
Graham
-
They call it a 'five-time waltz' so there is no ambiguity, and the step goes 1-2-3, 1-2; 1-2-3, 1-2,
There is also an eight time waltz which goes 1-2-3, 1-2-3, 1-2; 1-2-3, 1-2-3, 1-2;
I can get my feet round either!
-
There are zweifachers that consistnently alternate measures of 3/4 and 2/4 which would be equivalent to the french 'five time waltz' and it is danced the same way also. The thing about zweifachers is that many of them vary the mix of 3/4 and 2/4 measures so they are even more tricky to play and to dance to than the five time and eight time waltzes which have a regular pattern.
-
Changing rhythms...
So how do you do it?
And do certain rhythms suit being changed to particular other ones? (I'm talking about using same tune)
Like can you go from a waltz to a hornpipe? etc.
Why do you want to do that?!?
-
Changing rhythms...
So how do you do it?
And do certain rhythms suit being changed to particular other ones? (I'm talking about using same tune)
Like can you go from a waltz to a hornpipe? etc.
Why do you want to do that?!?
Because we can; it's fun to do; it is a form of improvisation and experimentation, and therefore a learning experience; it stops us getting stuck in a groove of only playing tunes in one way only. Is that enough for starters?
-
Swedish Masquerade is a good place to start. Slow March, Waltz, Polka. The march is a distinct tune but the waltz and polka are the same tune with a different rhythm.