Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tunes => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on October 03, 2010, 02:01:23 PM
-
Hi All,
Just started having a twiddle with it - as you do!
It's a tune I know well from other instruments, so thought I'd give it a go on the box.
Was amazed that the melody seemed to 'fall to the fingers' easily, then tried to work out some basses to it.
They *don't* seem to fall to the fingers as easily!!!!
....or perhaps it's just me.
Isn't it strange how some tunes appear difficult but once you get there they are actually easy, and vice versa, as in this case.
Ahhh he joys of learning!
Off for another try.
yours somewhat philosophically....
Q
where the sun's just come out and the deluge has hopefully moved up to you lot!
;D
-
. . . then tried to work out some basses to it.
They *don't* seem to fall to the fingers as easily!!!!
Don't know whether you've got Mally's tutor book, but I note that he uses this tune to introduce the idea of playing without using the basses at all.
Perhaps you've picked a challenging one.
Enjoy!
Tony M.
-
I've never played it with basses - always just play the RH on this lovely tune
-
I haven't yet learnt to play this properly, but the young lad in our side plays it beautifully along with another as yet unidentified makurka. He plays normal D row bass, I think, except for playing a G chord on the push against the high 'd's in bar 2 and 6 of the A part, and bars 3 and 7 of the B part, counting the lead in bar in the A and B as bar 0. This is from the dots on The Session (http://www.thesession.org/tunes/display/5476), which are not quite the same as what he plays.
-
Hi,
Try this:-
D/d/d B/d/a (cross to G row)G/g/d D/a/d
D/d/d B/d/a (cross to G row)G/g/d D/d/d
D/d/a A/a/d D/d/a A/a/d
D/d/a A/a/d D/d/a D/d/d
Roland
-
Hi again,
Sorry. Yes I agree with that. Go to G/g/d again in the B part for bars 3 and 7 ;o)
Roland
-
Thanks All for replying to my somewhat 'thinking aloud' post.
Yep I have got the Mally's book that recommends it without bases, but also know one player of note in the sessions I go to that has full basses. As the sesh in this thursday I haven't had time to watch or pick his brains yet!
In between various friends dropping in I've had a go today, after posting this first thing.
I seem to find the tune on mainly the D row, and as mentioned, pushing the G.
That means I'm probably on a similar vein to Bill and Roland.
Having discovered I'm really tired, ( falling asleep on the sofa was a clue!) I'll give up tonight, to keep going will only make me worse. I've discovered I reach a point when if I keep going I get worse! At the next opportunity I'll give the suggestions for basses a go.
Thanks Bill and Roland, I'll take note and give it a go
cheers
Q