Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: blackbush on October 10, 2010, 06:45:59 PM
-
My wife just purchased a Hohner Double Ray B/C, the first time she played the box it became apparent she had a natural ability to quickly play any tune she hears, and within a few hours she was able to play half a dozen tunes. (Irish music )
I'm jealous! I have never played any music before but I'm determined to give it my best shot. My wife is able to write down the button numbers with a + or – sign for push or pull and a circle for the outside row and I am able to play if I know the tune.
So I was wondering if this is a good way to learn or am I learning bad habits as I think I am learning to play by memorizing the buttons rather than the notes. Can’t read music.
Also; Is it easier to learn on a single row box?
If so Could someone please tell what box would be compatible with the Hohner Double Ray B/C
Any advice would be appreciated. -- Jim
-
Welcome to the mad house Jim!
Many learn the melodeon using button numbers and it seems to suit them ok. As you can't read music it sounds to me to a perfect way to learn.
ps. Don't kill your wife >:E
-
whilst there is absolutely no doubt that many learn to play quite well using button numbers I would recommend learning to play scales on the BC box sssart with C (on the row) then G,D & A. Work out the scales from a keyboard chart.
The ability to play scales on auto pilot facilitates playing by ear just as well as it does playing from the dots in that you will, all being well, be able to 'pick out' tunes you know as you will know how to play the next but one note higher or 3 notes lower or whatever . Knowing where each note is also enables you to slowly work from dots if only to establish which note is next i.e. if you just use the written music to provide the names of notes.
george
-
When I bought a BC box last year for a course up on Skye I worked from button numbers but wrote them beneath the relevant dots on the sheet music...
Now I know which notes are under which buttons (mostly ;D), I have also improved on my ability to make sense of the dots... and I can now play a couple of tunes from memory...
Do whatever works for you at this stage if it lets you make music and enjoy it 8)
(Rather than deprive the wife maybe you should get one for yourself... just so happens that I have one for sale...less than £200 including a hard case ;)) [I now have a BCC# ;D]
-
Thank you, this has been very encouraging. And Lester I think I got my answer about a single row of buttons being easier to learn on from your web site ;)
Graham, what kind of box do you have for sale? My wife has told me to get my own melodeon! I don't get no respect.
-
email on its way Jim
-
I should probably have started a new thread for this question, oh well.
Does anyone have any experience or advice on this box: Beltuna Sara 3 in B/C, 3 voice? I know it is quite extravagant but I was thinking I could buy it as a present for my wife and then I can steal her Double Ray. I just noticed that Hobgoblin have it marked down quite a bit.
-
Why not a second double ray if you both like them?
-
Yes, I thought of that, but isn't that a wee bit too practical for this MAD thing?
However, 2 Double Rays makes the most sense, there is one on eBay so I will keep my eye on it.-- Thanks
-
What could be better than Double Double Rays...Except for three of them like me!
-
Sextuple Rays? :-*
-
I believe that Mr. Blackbush is displaying the most aggressive case of MAD I have seen in my not quite couple of years on Melnet. After he has been at this for a while, where will the family find a place to sleep?
-
Can he be cured by giving them away to deserving individuals? I unselfishly volunteer to be one of them.
-
What could be better than Double Double Rays...Except for three of them like me!
Just wear a pair of Ray Ban while you play to eliminate the doubles...