Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on October 14, 2010, 04:45:33 PM
-
I have lifted the following quote from the "Hohner reeds on Hohner reedblocks, inside a modern/Italian melodeon body":
The title of this thread sounds like a description of the Morgane, Merlin, Galaad series.
How do these sound compared with the likes of Hohner Pokerwork, Erica, Corona II - same characteristic resonant Hohner sound or "cleaner/purer" sound of the similar-bodied models from Castagnari, Saltarelle, Dino Baffetti, etc?
How does the quality of components/construction, speed/smoothness of action, etc, of these compare with likes of Castagnari, Saltarelle, Dino Baffetti models?
Any views/reviews from owners, or anyone who has been impressed/not impressed?
-
I've played a few Morganes in various festival stalls, I think that it is the best value first hand box on the market, with the possible exception of the Sandpiper. I was tempted by one before buying my Bouebe, which I got second hand.
-
I've played a BC morgane at Eagle musics shop and it was really quiet nice, a bit like a boube with metal corners. The one Id really like to try is the Hohner Valparaiso G/C/acc but they seem to only exist in a french mail order shops and Id prefer to try before I buy.
-
This previous thread on these melodeons - http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=4238.0 - has given me a feel for the quality of the instrument.
So the most important part of my question now is - how do these sound compared with the likes of Hohner Pokerwork, Erica, Corona II - same characteristic resonant Hohner sound or "cleaner/purer" sound of the similar-bodied models from Castagnari, Saltarelle, Dino Baffetti, etc?
-
Main difference in the sound is that the factory tuning has very little tremolo so direct comparison with a pokerwork/erica is not possible.
The main improvement to my mind is the treble buttons which are mushroom shaped and have a positive stop. There is also an adjuster on the bass strap. The keyboard has some rather hard edges which make it less comfortable, and close up the finish is not as good as it looks from a distance. The case is veneered plywood. If I wanted that sort of sound I would get a pokerwork or Erica and modify the tuning, that is only a personal opinion.
-
The one Id really like to try is the Hohner Valparaiso G/C/acc but they seem to only exist in a french mail order shops and Id prefer to try before I buy.
I'd love to see one of these too! Apparently they're made specially for Hohner France by Victoria accordions.
Cheers,
Jon
-
The one Id really like to try is the Hohner Valparaiso G/C/acc but they seem to only exist in a french mail order shops and Id prefer to try before I buy.
I'd love to see one of these too! Apparently they're made specially for Hohner France by Victoria accordions.
Cheers,
Jon
They also have italian reeds, I believe, so they are Hohners in name only.
-
I have had a Merlin D/G for a few months now and am very pleased with it. They are available in UK. Worth shopping around. I thought I'd had a great deal until I came across a techie/small reseller in the SW - he beat the price by loads. On the other hand I bought from a shop that I've been v happy with for some years now.
I haven't played a Costalotti for years so can't compare. Also I'm no techie.
I came to melodeons from a Crabb 40 key C/G octagonal bought new about 1970.
I bought a Corona 2II A/D/G in 1976 in France. This was because I was particulaly interested in the extra options across the box rather than the addition of the A row. I later had it drier tuned - by a Mr Hohner in Paris at Hohner's (No relation, he had moved there in the late 40s.) He said the main sound differences were due to the lower quality of reeds compared to the Italian ones. As an illustration he showed me what I think was called an Atlantic G/C which did sound and feel a lot more like the higher quality boxes you see around. It was out of my price range then. I kept the Corona II for about 25 years.
Bear in mind a box sounds v different from the player's position. The Merlin I would say had a harder edge to the sound - some would accuse the Pokerwork/Corona of being "mushy" both in sound and action. I read often that The Merlin etc are Chinese - mine came in a packaging labelled Made in Indonesia which is a puzzle. Maybe the cardboard box was made there! Do ask if you think I can add to this.
-
Along with the Valpo, another to add to the series is the Cap Horn. Both are hard to find away from the Continent.
-
Main difference in the sound is that the factory tuning has very little tremolo so direct comparison with a pokerwork/erica is not possible.
The main improvement to my mind is the treble buttons which are mushroom shaped and have a positive stop. There is also an adjuster on the bass strap. The keyboard has some rather hard edges which make it less comfortable, and close up the finish is not as good as it looks from a distance. The case is veneered plywood. If I wanted that sort of sound I would get a pokerwork or Erica and modify the tuning, that is only a personal opinion.
I've got a DG Morgane, and what Theo says is spot on. I've done some mods to get the sharp bits off, but it's not the most comfortable thing to hold and play. It's quite heavy for what it is, and the length and quality of the shoulder straps provided leave a lot to be desired.
A decent workhorse at a sensible price, but I like my German Ericas better.
-
So the most important part of my question now is - how do these sound compared with the likes of Hohner Pokerwork, Erica, Corona II - same characteristic resonant Hohner sound or "cleaner/purer" sound of the similar-bodied models from Castagnari, Saltarelle, Dino Baffetti, etc?
I have a G/C Morgane. I would say that its sound on the bass side is very Hohner, in the spirit of the Pokerwork and Erica. (Bass action is a little stiff, though.) On the treble side (great action by the way), it sounds less characteristically resonant than the Pokerwork or Erica and more like the similar-bodied models you mentioned. Then again, it may seem this way due to it being swing-tuned. (Actually, according to Hohner's Morgane/Merlin/Galaad spec sheet, it's demi-swing. To my ears, it sounds about what Bernard Loffet describes as "demi-swing attenuated".)
I have found my Morgane to be very good value for the money and am happy with my purchase. Recommended.