Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: accordion criminal on October 14, 2010, 07:09:37 PM

Title: My Video Version of Kitty Come Down to Limerick
Post by: accordion criminal on October 14, 2010, 07:09:37 PM
I don't get in best touch with the tune until the last third of the video, but my facial expressions in the first two thirds were too hilarious to cut.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=katySPhGoVo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=katySPhGoVo)
Title: Re: My Video Version of Kitty Come Down to Limerick
Post by: rees on October 15, 2010, 02:25:51 AM
Wow, great playing!

melodeon gurning suprema! thank you.
Title: Re: My Video Version of Kitty Come Down to Limerick
Post by: Stiamh on October 15, 2010, 07:23:43 PM
Apologies for my facetious earlier post, which I just removed. I couldn't believe how slowly you took the piece, which is a slip jig after all. I presume you got the tune Martin Hayes, who turned it into a slip dirge, and then decided to take it at a more, er, leisurely clip.

That aside, agree with Rees - a very intense performance, and the expressions add to the brooding, dramatic quality. Tony MacMahon couldn't have squeezed more passion out of it  (:)

 
Title: Re: My Video Version of Kitty Come Down to Limerick
Post by: accordion criminal on October 16, 2010, 03:25:13 PM
Rees, thanks. :)

Steve, thanks for the explanation for your earlier post. I thought I would be "safe" sharing a video like this on this teaching and learning forum because members talk so much about what to do to make practice count. I don't always play so slowly, but I am a beginner, having started daily practice only since this past May, and I've read and found that slowing a tune down to try to "mean" every note is just challenging enough that I must work hard for success, but not so challenging that most of the notes go by without any particular quality, right or wrong. My spontaneous facial expressions reveal this, don't they? I'm getting acquainted with the instrument, listening intently to how my use of it effects it, both the right and left hands. The happy result is that it feels so much more familiar in my hands now! My video reveals to me how in the first two thirds, my upper octave part lacked personality, but by the last go around, that part finally sounded like it was making a statement, a real pay-off for me. I did get the idea from Martin Hayes to play this slip jig slowly, but like an air, not a dirge. :) Most of all, I just like to share my passion for this instrument with people who are more likely to understand.
Title: Re: My Video Version of Kitty Come Down to Limerick
Post by: Stiamh on October 16, 2010, 06:57:01 PM
I don't know whether I failed to understand, or whether my judgment was clouded by my own understanding of the piece in question. Both probably. Anyway, I take all your points, pontyrogof: please accept my apologies for my ill-chosen comments (all of them  ;)  ) and keep at it with undiminished passion.
Title: Re: My Video Version of Kitty Come Down to Limerick
Post by: John C on October 16, 2010, 10:45:58 PM
I find your approach to music very interesting as I have just watched a TV programme (in Canada) about the plasticity of the brain.   Apparently recent research has shown that people suffering with schizophrenia can "turn on" certain parts of the brain with aural and visual exercises (on the computer) and thereby reduce the effects of their illness.    What your are doing seems similar to that.

I assume you are trying to learn this tune by playing very slowly and with great concentration so as to develop new neural pathways and "mentally absorb" the music and vibration.

Have you memorized the piece and do you feel this approach has been helpful.   


Title: Re: My Video Version of Kitty Come Down to Limerick
Post by: accordion criminal on October 16, 2010, 11:44:39 PM
Steve, your initial reaction may have come from the passion you have for musical tradition. I risked stepping on the toes of tradition when I posted this video. :)

John, I'm lucky not to have a distinctly dissociative mental disorder, but I bet like many, I do hear voices in my head that disturb me and interfere with a positive flow. I hear constant criticisms of my playing. Gee, I wonder where those voices came from? ;) Anyway, I can relate to the remedy you describe. I think what happens is that if I play a tune at a pace that is natural and relaxed enough for me that I feel no anxiety about where to place my fingers next or what to do with too much or too little bellows, the sound of what I'm playing at the time and what I imagine I want to play next totally drowns out those annoying voices. I'm so absorbed by the beauty of what I can do at the proper pace for myself, that I must be creating new neural pathways from such a pleasant experience. To answer your question, I memorize a tune first on tinwhistle, an instrument that allows me to play more automatically. Then I find the notes by ear on the accordion. Finally, I spend a lot of time playing the tune at the pace natural for me to play it fullest of meaning, not according to how it is traditionally played. This is a new process I stumbled upon just a few months ago. I never approached learning to play an instrument this way before, but I never tried such an enchanting instrument as button accordion before. :)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal