Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: johnners on October 17, 2010, 10:43:27 AM
-
I play in a morris side with an Erica D/G - what key of one row do I buy to keep in tuning of G?
-
Erm ... that would be G ;)
-
So why do some sites say that you need a C one-row box to play in G - a D box to play in A and a G box to play in D?
And don't be so goddam glib with your answers, you 'experts'.
-
Irish and Cajun/Zydeco musicians often use a technique known as cross-key which is similar to blues harp playing. This involves playing in G on a C box, A on a D box, etc.
This does not apply to Morris music which is played in the home key of the instrument.
G box for tunes in G. D box for tunes in D, etc.
-
Ah, I see where this is coming from now. I thought it was an odd question since you already play a D/G for Morris and surely play on the G row when you're playing in G?
The difference is with Cajun boxes. Cajun players will be playing in G (well sort of) on a C box in the way that blues harmonica players will play in G on a C harmonica. the whole thing feels like playing "backwards" to an English style player, but it's an interesting thing to investigate. The Cajun boxes also have a slightly different tuning to accommodate this, to the extent that they will sound a little odd when played in their "natural" key.
G one row 4 stops are tuned an octave below the G row on a two row and so are deeper in tone and more hungry for air. I had a Hohner one row that I used for Morris (and ceilidhs) and it is hard work to get a good volume or lead the music ... however, they are good fun but try before you buy one as they are quite different beasts to two row boxes.
-
A C one row has all the notes of the key of G except for the F#, so it is quite possible to play a large number of G tunes on a C box. Many G tunes have no F#, and of those that do many can be omitted, or substituted with a different note.
The pattern of push and pull is different of course. If you want to try the fingering pattern for G on a C box, before you spend money then you can do it by playing tunes either in D using only the G row on your D/G, or in A using only the D row.
One disadvantage of a G one-row 4 stop is that the pitch is an octave below the G row of your D/G, so its very low, especially with the low reed in play.
-
Many thanks for the replies - it was just that I wanted to add a bit of weight to the Border tunes we play.
-
A C one row has all the notes of the key of G except for the F#, so it is quite possible to play a large number of G tunes on a C box. Many G tunes have no F#, and of those that do many can be omitted, or substituted with a different note.
The pattern of push and pull is different of course. If you want to try the fingering pattern for G on a C box, before you spend money then you can do it by playing tunes either in D using only the G row on your D/G, or in A using only the D row.
One disadvantage of a G one-row 4 stop is that the pitch is an octave below the G row of your D/G, so its very low, especially with the low reed in play.
All true, and actually I play quite a bit of stuff in G on my C box, but I get to choose the tunes and it does take a while to master the technique for an English style player who's been playing for a while.
A "proper" A minor is another good one, and C even works occasionally ;D
-
Many thanks for the replies - it was just that I wanted to add a bit of weight to the Border tunes we play.
Yes, I played mine for Border Morris, and it's a great addition to a band sound (:)
Edited to add: the G one row that is.
-
An aside on this issue - if I play my Trilly D/G with the border side, they prefer me to switch out the lower reed as it sounds too smooth. One of our past musicians used to play four stop Hohners with the side and they sounded great. It's the wet tuning and grunting basses that make all the difference. I have a HA114 in G and its hard work pumping enough air through it!
Rob.
-
To Rob2Hook - apologies for being previous; but I don't suppose you'd like to sell your H 114 in G?
Or would you know of anyone likely to sell a good one?
-
Sorry, Johnners. My affliction has so far prevented me from ever selling a box. I once traded one at a shop and have regretted it since... Mind you, my house has the look of a scrap yard! (:)
Rob.
-
I have a Hohner 1-row in G that I occasionally play for morris and I LOVE the sound of it, especially for Border; though I endorse everything that's been said about the air-hungry character of these beasts. My 1-row C box is far less work, so I tend to play that more - but of course I can only play it for morris if I'm the only musician or if any other players are happy in C - and that doesn't happen often in morris circles! I'm not so convinced about the G 1-row for Cotswold - it demands so much air it's difficult to keep under control and play successfully for the more lyrical traditions such as Field Town and Bledington. Great for Bucknell, though!
-
That's the trouble when playing boxes out. Unless your companions play boxes in the same key as yours, you're stuck! I rarely play my C one-row out for that reason. :'(
-
To Rob2Hook - apologies for being previous; but I don't suppose you'd like to sell your H 114 in G?
Or would you know of anyone likely to sell a good one?
I have one just arrived in part-ex. Externally it looks the business. Silver ends (the best), I haven't had a chance to check it over yet but will do so dreckly and let you know the price.
It must be a good one though as it has a Theo Gibb sticker on the back. ;D
-
@ Rees: I'm obliged, sir. I'll keep my ears on the rails.
-
I'll keep my ears on the rails.
Watch out for trains!
-
If coming from Rees' neck of the woods trains may not be fast, chuff and whistle to warn of their approach Jonners ;D
As to what proportion of their fuel derelict melodeon parts form, information is not yet available....
Richard - who has a silver ended HA114G and can confirm that they have a sound of their own, need plenty of bellows action to maintain wind availability and the left hand end may contribute to HAV as the bass reeds don't half make the presence felt as well as heard :)
-
OK, OK - I'm getting the drift of this now - in any case, what I should have said was that I'd keep ONE ear on the rails, as keeping two there would be a physical impossibility ('cept for HRH charlie boy, perhaps).
And I don't want to upset Rees by acknowledging that Wales is still in the steam era fuelled by melodeon parts (though I sometimes wish England still was…).
Ermm… I didn't realise that playing the HA114G carried a health warning - I don't like the possibility that I may contract HIV in the left hand. Surely there's a cure?
On a lighter note - does anyone know whether playing free reeds might help with Parkinson's?
-
Sorry Johnners, one of the conditions of playing here is you live with the humourous backchat and teasing ;)
If you play one of these in C and then one in G you really do feel the lower frequency bass reed vibration in the left hand but no not enough to result in real HAV, There is as yet no need for boxes to carry a health warning for either HAV or MAD, though there is a school of thought that they ought to contain a warning along the lines of 'may emit unmusical sounds in untrained operators hands'
The reed vibrations are probably too high to have any effect either way with Parkinsons, based on the practices of a couple of friends who are sufferers and have to 'sneak up' on an action by repeated movements in imitation of what they want to do to trick their system into not having a tremor before they complete the action there may be some effect with fingering the keys or operating the bellows but I have no idea if this would be good or bad if a sufferer were trying to play.
Richard
-
Hmmm - on the basis of what you say in your last sentence, it would seem that most Morris melodeon players might have the DTs anyway.
'Repeated movements in imitation what they want to do to trick their system' sounds like what happened to me at the Bury Day of Dance this year after too many Abbots.
Anyway; thanks for all the helpful advice, you lot.
A friendly site indeed.