Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: BCC#er on October 25, 2010, 03:37:50 PM

Title: Mazurka
Post by: BCC#er on October 25, 2010, 03:37:50 PM
Hey,

while still polishing TOTM I decided to capture my favourite mazurkas La Guinguette and L'inconnu de Limoise.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kh0eAxwGLDg

Any feedback is more then welcome as usual (:) if you have anything to advise - please do I really need somebody to correct me.

Cheers,
Anatoly
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: BCC#er on October 26, 2010, 11:58:41 PM
Well it seems that I'm unpopular  (:) Or it's nothing to say about the record. Both are quite disappointing. Please mind I'm quite alone and there's nobody to ask for opinion but here. I don't complain but the feedback is very welcome (:)
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Theo on October 27, 2010, 12:17:51 AM
Hi Anatoly, there is a lot going on here ,  I think you have been overlooked.

Very nice playing, very danceable. Your bass line feels more like a waltz, especially when you take the tempo up int the second tune,  but I'm not sure what to suggest to make it more mazurka-like. 
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: accordion criminal on October 27, 2010, 12:29:17 AM
How sad you felt ignored. I posted a comment on your vid page. I'd like to know what about your playing you'd like to change. If you ask for a critique, perhaps you are suspecting certain aspects of your method. What might those be? :)
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: BCC#er on October 27, 2010, 12:32:54 AM
Thanks for the reply Theo! You've touched the point I've been most concerned of: how to make it sound like mazurka? There are a lot of examples on youtube but what to choose?
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: BCC#er on October 27, 2010, 12:42:55 AM
pontyrogof: The problem is I don't know whether I'm doing right or wrong. I play the tune as I feel it but there is a tradition that I'm not familiar with so I might do something inappropriate. I'd better avoid it on this stage as I discovered this type of music about 3 months ago and received my G/C just in August. Thanks for the feedback anyway!
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: accordion criminal on October 27, 2010, 02:25:21 AM
I like waltzes, so this thread is interesting to me.

I hunted on youtube and found what I think is an exemplary mazurka.

Mazurka compared to other waltzes have more emphasis on the third beat, giving them more swing. What do you think? I think also the tempo is for a shorter step. What do you think?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tR3oOmvx5ew (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tR3oOmvx5ew)

I think I will try to imitate this more emphatic three beat meter. Thanks for the inspiration.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: BCC#er on October 27, 2010, 02:36:22 AM
Well, thank you for an example but I stuck to another dance with it - Polonaise... Sounds pretty much like it.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: GuyWyatt on October 27, 2010, 07:14:22 AM
I have to say that I have a similar problem. I can listen to mazurkas and hear that they sound quite different to waltzes, but find it very difficult to decode how to get that mazurka sound.  Of course, the answer is probably "practice". it usually is.
G
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 27, 2010, 08:22:12 AM
Not counting the more 'choreographed' display form, which I would not regard as 'typical' (see example posted earlier here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tR3oOmvx5ew ), mazurkas tend to be dreamier, more laid back, more flowingly sensuous, than waltzes.

Mazurka compared to other waltzes have more emphasis on the third beat, giving them more swing. What do you think?
No, I disagree completely.
First, 'other waltzes' - no, although the mazurka is in 3/4 time, it is not a waltz.
Second: the essence of the mazurka is a weight (not a thump), or leaning, on the first two beats, the second slightly less so (like a slow heart-beat 'Lub-dub'). The third beat is the weakest and can sometimes almost be diminished to the extent of becoming a gap or silence in the music.  

Quote
I think I will try to imitate this more emphatic three beat meter.
No, please don't. You will end up with something very lumpy, wooden, and un-mazurka-like. See above.

Here's an absolutely lovely mazurka played by the mazurka master Stephane Delicq (now sadly no longer with us  :( ). In this clip you can also see couples dancing (they obscure the view sometimes!) and just demonstrating how smooth and smoochy the dance can be.
Nadiejda (= 'hope') (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnAB3sCm7Bg)

Edits:
Just found another one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XcNTVnAaEpA).

This one is slightly faster (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ttlpW1VY88E) and perhaps more typical of a French traditional Bal.

A final one from Stephane Delicq brilliantly played as a duo with a clarinettist (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJ1TLk6CYp4).



Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Theo on October 27, 2010, 09:38:04 AM
Excellent examples Steve.

Just though, another significant difference is that in the waltz the first beat is usually held slightly longer than the other two giving a feeling of falling into the second, and third.   In a mazurka the first beat may be emphasised by a push in volume but is definitely not lengthened.  It is pretty subtle stuff.

Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Simon on October 27, 2010, 10:57:26 AM
You've touched the point I've been most concerned of: how to make it sound like mazurka?
Lovely recordings, but I agree that they sound more like a waltz than a mazurka. For a start you could try playing a short chord on the 2nd beat and a longer one on the 3rd (Um-pah-paaah) [edit: for example septembre.mp3 (http://simonplantinga.nl/tmp/septembre.mp3)]. Also put on a good youtube video of a mazurka and turn off the sound. It helps to watch a mazurka and play along.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 27, 2010, 12:32:49 PM
while still polishing TOTM I decided to capture my favourite mazurkas La Guinguette and L'inconnu de Limoise.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kh0eAxwGLDg

Any feedback is more then welcome as usual (:) if you have anything to advise - please do I really need somebody to correct me.
I think your first tune La Guinuette has a very nice mazurka feel to it and you don't need to worry too much, but the second tune, as Theo has already commented, is too much waltz-like in my opinion. See other remarks on this thread.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 27, 2010, 12:36:46 PM
Lovely recordings, but I agree that they sound more like a waltz than a mazurka. For a start you could try playing a short chord on the 2nd beat and a longer one on the 3rd (Um-pah-paaah) [edit: for example septembre.mp3 (http://simonplantinga.nl/tmp/septembre.mp3)]. Also put on a good youtube video of a mazurka and turn off the sound. It helps to watch a mazurka and play along.
Hmmm... If you do play a longer chord on the 3rd beat, you've got to be very careful you don't make it become stronger than beats 1 and 2. In your example you manage to avoid this, and I think you do have a nice mazurka feel to your playing, mainly because you do have that gentle weight on beats 1 and 2. But a long (tenuto) chord on the 3rd beat isn't something I'd generally recommend.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: waltzman on October 27, 2010, 01:56:31 PM
Lovely recordings, but I agree that they sound more like a waltz than a mazurka. For a start you could try playing a short chord on the 2nd beat and a longer one on the 3rd (Um-pah-paaah) [edit: for example septembre.mp3 (http://simonplantinga.nl/tmp/septembre.mp3)]. Also put on a good youtube video of a mazurka and turn off the sound. It helps to watch a mazurka and play along.
Hmmm... If you do play a longer chord on the 3rd beat, you've got to be very careful you don't make it become stronger than beats 1 and 2. In your example you manage to avoid this, and I think you do have a nice mazurka feel to your playing, mainly because you do have that gentle weight on beats 1 and 2. But a long (tenuto) chord on the 3rd beat isn't something I'd generally recommend.

La Guinguette is in the method book by Milleret and Pignol and the long chord on the third beat is recommended throughout most of the tune.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: accordion criminal on October 27, 2010, 03:43:43 PM
Lovely recordings, but I agree that they sound more like a waltz than a mazurka. For a start you could try playing a short chord on the 2nd beat and a longer one on the 3rd (Um-pah-paaah) [edit: for example septembre.mp3 (http://simonplantinga.nl/tmp/septembre.mp3)]. Also put on a good youtube video of a mazurka and turn off the sound. It helps to watch a mazurka and play along.
Hmmm... If you do play a longer chord on the 3rd beat, you've got to be very careful you don't make it become stronger than beats 1 and 2. In your example you manage to avoid this, and I think you do have a nice mazurka feel to your playing, mainly because you do have that gentle weight on beats 1 and 2. But a long (tenuto) chord on the 3rd beat isn't something I'd generally recommend.

La Guinguette is in the method book by Milleret and Pignol and the long chord on the third beat is recommended throughout most of the tune.

So, the longer chord might be what I heard to make me think the third is somehow more emphatic than the first two? Please excuse my silly beginner comments. Just trying to wrap my brain around the subtleties. The comment about creating the feel of falling into other beats is helpful. In the Mazurka, which beat might we want to fall into?
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 27, 2010, 04:16:47 PM
So, the longer chord might be what I heard to make me think the third is somehow more emphatic than the first two? Please excuse my silly beginner comments. Just trying to wrap my brain around the subtleties. The comment about creating the feel of falling into other beats is helpful. In the Mazurka, which beat might we want to fall into?
Your comments are very pertinent, not those of a silly beginner at all. Stop trying to tell us that's what you are ;) . Sarah (LDT) used to do that. She's learned not to, now!

Think of the 3rd beat chord as not so much emphatic, but leading into the next bar, so that it helps put the weighty lean on to the first two beats (remember the heart beat analogy?).
So:
err-RUB-Dub, err-RUB-Dub, err-RUB-Dub, etc.

or, in terms of counting:
and | ONE Two (three)-and | ONE Two (three)-and | ONE Two (three)-and, etc.

Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: strad on October 27, 2010, 04:27:50 PM
Have just put one of my mazurkas in the Tunes section. It's very hard to play this tune in waltz time!

Nigel
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Simon on October 27, 2010, 04:51:13 PM
If you do play a longer chord on the 3rd beat, you've got to be very careful you don't make it become stronger than beats 1 and 2.
It's just one of the tricks to make a mazurka sound different from a waltz of course. I guess the longer 3rd kind of drags it towards the next measure. I'm not sure if it's really making the 3rd beat stronger.. perhaps the effect is to isolate the 2nd beat by making it more staccato.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: accordion criminal on October 27, 2010, 04:58:42 PM
So, the longer chord might be what I heard to make me think the third is somehow more emphatic than the first two? Please excuse my silly beginner comments. Just trying to wrap my brain around the subtleties. The comment about creating the feel of falling into other beats is helpful. In the Mazurka, which beat might we want to fall into?
Your comments are very pertinent, not those of a silly beginner at all. Stop trying to tell us that's what you are ;) . Sarah (LDT) used to do that. She's learned not to, now!

Think of the 3rd beat chord as not so much emphatic, but leading into the next bar, so that it helps put the weighty lean on to the first two beats (remember the heart beat analogy?).
So:
err-RUB-Dub, err-RUB-Dub, err-RUB-Dub, etc.

or, in terms of counting:
and | ONE Two (three)-and | ONE Two (three)-and | ONE Two (three)-and, etc.



Heehee, beginners don't know better than to dabble in Socratic irony. :)
I understand your "and" language, very helpful, thanks!
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: BCC#er on October 27, 2010, 05:32:06 PM
Thanks for your help everyone! :|glug

Speaking about Pignol/ Milleret books that's a great story I will write about as far as I receive it at last ;)
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: BCC#er on October 27, 2010, 05:41:34 PM
Here's an absolutely lovely mazurka played by the mazurka master Stephane Delicq (now sadly no longer with us  :( ). In this clip you can also see couples dancing (they obscure the view sometimes!) and just demonstrating how smooth and smoochy the dance can be.
Nadiejda (= 'peace') (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnAB3sCm7Bg)

Edits:
Just found another one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XcNTVnAaEpA).

This one is slightly faster (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ttlpW1VY88E) and perhaps more typical of a French traditional Bal.

A final one from Stephane Delicq brilliantly played as a duo with a clarinettist (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJ1TLk6CYp4).





Absolutely great! It seems I start to understand. But the emphasis seems to me more in the right hand rather then left. And Delicq plays bass-chord-bass most of the time

PS: Nadiejda means "hope"  ;)
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: waltzman on October 27, 2010, 06:52:20 PM



Absolutely great! It seems I start to understand. But the emphasis seems to me more in the right hand rather then left. And Delicq plays bass-chord-bass most of the time

PS: Nadiejda means "hope"  ;)
[/quote]

This is very true.  the subtle feel of a mazurka is communicated through the melody and the right hand not the left hand chords.  In my opinion, you can play a beautiful mazurka using the exact same left hand accompnaiment as a waltz.  The left hand can accent the mazurka feel but a straight bass, chord, chord doesn't really detract from it.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 27, 2010, 08:02:51 PM
PS: Nadiejda means "hope"  ;)
Ah, thank you! I stand corrected (:) .  I will alter my original link title.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: ganderbox on October 27, 2010, 10:16:28 PM

 the subtle feel of a mazurka is communicated through the melody and the right hand not the left hand chords.  In my opinion, you can play a beautiful mazurka using the exact same left hand accompnaiment as a waltz.  The left hand can accent the mazurka feel but a straight bass, chord, chord doesn't really detract from it.

Yes, I'd agree that the difference between a waltz and a mazurka originates in the structure of the tune rather than the bass rhythm. A mazurka tends to jump around a bit more than a waltz.
There are however plenty of mazurkas you can waltz to, and vice versa. Blowzabella know a thing or two about dance tunes, but at their LNE at Sidmouth they played what I seem to remember was a set of Andy Cutting's classics (like Flatworld etc), and the dancers were told that they could waltz or mazurka, as they wished.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: waltzman on October 28, 2010, 12:32:51 AM
Thanks for your help everyone! :|glug

Speaking about Pignol/ Milleret books that's a great story I will write about as far as I receive it at last ;)

La Guinguette is in the repertoire section of Volume two of Pignol/Millerett.  This volume also has a section about playing 9/8 rhythms.  Many mazurkas are written in 9/8 which more clearly conveys the compound rhythm found in many of the mazurka melodies.  I would try to copy the feel of the melody first with the right hand by listening to a recording you like.  Then you can add a simple light bass, chord, chord left hand rhythm and see what you get.  The compound rhythm of the melody plays off the simple bass quite nicely in most cases.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 01, 2010, 04:16:51 PM
At ceilidhs, I overruled the rest of the band and use the mazurka "The French Assembly" for the dance Rosa.  A somewhat smoochier dance than a straight waltz, it works very well and encourages more extravagant movement and gestures than one normally associates with a prim Victorian waltz.  Mind you, when the waltz was first brought to England, it was considered to be immoral!

To an English player, the mazurka is initially an unnatural mix of lightness of touch with a heavier and sustained emphasis.  For myself, I have to get in the mood by imagining I'm dancing with the partner of my choice - works every time so long as I don't get distracted by it!  Sometimes one is lucky enough to watch a couple dancing so well you just have to concentrate on accompanying them.

As a session tune it tends to get very muddy and loses all the characteristic lightness.

Rob.
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Fidjit on November 01, 2010, 04:35:33 PM
At ceilidhs, I overruled the rest of the band and use the mazurka "The French Assembly" for the dance Rosa.  A somewhat smoochier dance than a straight waltz, it works very well and encourages more extravagant movement and gestures than one normally associates with a prim Victorian waltz.  Mind you, when the waltz was first brought to England, it was considered to be immoral!


I think I'll try that on our dancers. Although I don't know that tune, but I think The Rosa danced to a Mazurka would be good.

Cheers
Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 01, 2010, 07:39:18 PM
Actually I think both work as mazurkas (even had I not known the tunes). The French Waltz style is 123 123 123 123 very smooth. They rurn continuously. The mazurka is an asymmetric dance and in particular you turn ¼ turn anticlockwise (seen from above) on bar 2, then release that in a 1¼ clockside turn on bar 4.

Bars 1 and 3 are just weight changes setting up the above movements.

So the dance has intrinsic physical swing and the music (as ever) should 'inform' that. You swung Guinguette  a little, but you could have dragged that bass bit a bit more, and then come in a tad late with the right hand. It was also a tad slow but never mind.

I thought your Inconnu started absolutely fine (though it accented how slow Guinguette had been)! Then you started dragging the bass chords and lost me I'm afraid. Mazurka is above all light.  A good way is to take the fingers off the chord before the end of the beat (stop chord is as much a rhythm even as start chord). It's subtle though. This youtube version is about right http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PpxfjUBjRhk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PpxfjUBjRhk)

Here's  early Pignol (Dédale) version http://chrisryall.net/Guinguette-Phyllis.mp3 (http://chrisryall.net/Guinguette-Phyllis.mp3) - The full Le Maître Dhû CD is available at Mustradem.com and not expensive.

I think Norbert plays Guinguette much more swung nowadays. But notice even 15 years ago how light it is. Nice improvised recorder 3rd time through from Christophe Saccatini .. and even nicer Pignol impro in Phyllis toward the end.  8)



Title: Re: Mazurka
Post by: BCC#er on November 10, 2010, 08:37:35 PM
Thank you very much Chris! It's even more to consider after the information you gave! BTW what box Norbert plays on this record? It sounds much sharper then tune is written. And if I remember right you've attended his workshop this year. Does he make it on the regular basis? It's easier to obtain some things in real conversation rather then from the records. Especially when it's lack of the records! (:)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal