Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: dave t on October 27, 2010, 08:04:23 AM

Title: Taping up the third
Post by: dave t on October 27, 2010, 08:04:23 AM
I have a borrowed E. German pokerwork copy and I would like to remove the third from the B major chord. Could someone please tell me how it's done? Is it something that somebody who has never opened up a melodeon before can attempt? Finally, is it easy to undo as I want to make sure that I can return the instrument in the same condition it was in when it was loaned to me?

Thanks.
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: Theo on October 27, 2010, 09:09:21 AM
This thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4218.0.html) covers the same topic.

Always a good idea to use the search before asking a question.    (:)
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: Lester on October 27, 2010, 09:37:01 AM
I have produced some drawings of the bass end of Hohner Pokerwork/Ericas which show which reeds are where.
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 27, 2010, 09:58:49 AM
I have produced some drawings of the bass end of Hohner Pokerwork/Ericas which show which reeds are where.
Excellent work Lester! Thanks.

Dave T:
The key diagram of Lester's is the Pokerwork Chord Block.
Assuming your Pokerwork copy is the same as this (and this is something you will need to check), to remove the third from the B major chord, refer to the small blue circles in the upper part of the diagram. The reed you need to tape up is the D# on the push, located at the single blue circle at the right of the diagram.

You will need to tape up the individual D# reed tongue to stop it sounding. You can't just tape up the reed block port (like you can on many Italian boxes), as the airway is still needed for the pull E on the pull Em chord. Fortunately, being a push note, the D# reed is the uppermost on the reed plate. You need to cut a small strip of adhesive tape and stick it directly over the reed tongue and the adjacent face of the reed plate. But make sure you don't cover up the valve and slot for the underneath reed.

You could use sellotape or masking tape, but these tend to leave gunge on the reed if/when the tape is removed at some point in the future. So it is best to use 3M Scotch Magic Tape or equivalent which should not leave a residue on removal.
http://www.ryman.co.uk/0605023343/3M-Scotch-Magic-Tape-19mm-x-25m-Pack-of-3/Product

Edited to add tips for removal of the tape:
When removing the tape from the reed plate/tongue, take care not to peel off the tape in such a direction (i.e. at right-angles to the reed plate surface) that the reed tongue is also pulled up excessively out of position. Start at the rivet end of the reed plate and peel the tape off progressively along the surface of the reed plate rather than upwards. When the remaining tape is approaching the thin end of the reed tongue, support the reed tongue (hold it down!) to stop it being lifted too much out of position by the last section of adhering tape. You might need to remove traces of adhesive from the reed tongue/plate using a cotton bud sparingly moistened with white spirit or nail varnish remover. Take care not to get it on the valve or wax. It will dissolve the latter and possibly affect plastic valves too.
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: rees on October 27, 2010, 12:58:36 PM
Superb advice from Steve as always.
An alternative is to tune the D# reed to D. This will give a B minor chord instead of the B major.
Of course, unless you are very brave, this modification is best left to an "accordion engineer".
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: Ollie on October 27, 2010, 01:43:00 PM
If you want to play a B minor chord, you can cheat a bit and play the B bass with the D chord, thus producing an (almost) B minor chord. I asked a similar question when I started out, but use my Bmaj chord quite a lot when playing in E minor.
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 27, 2010, 01:53:57 PM
Just to head off the usual confusion


The harmonic minor is the one prevalent in gypsy, klesmer, russian, flamenco, swing, much jazz, and most classical music. We folkies use the other two.  If you tape out that third - the remaining 1st+5th B chord works for either.

Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: dave t on October 30, 2010, 06:00:50 PM
Thanks to Lester and Steve, and some help from my father-in-law with the disassembly, the job has now been successfully completed!

Cheers,

Dave
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 14, 2013, 03:09:40 PM
Just a footnote here to thank Steve (5 posts up) for some spot-on advice on how to do this little trick. My habitual box doesn't have thirds, but the old 1990 Lilly does, and we using it for chording.  Its Gmaj7 sounds much better  8) after the "treatment",  and it's no longer bothered what variety of B chord is in play.  Thanks  :D
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: pikey on March 14, 2013, 09:22:38 PM
If you want to play a B minor chord, you can cheat a bit and play the B bass with the D chord, thus producing an (almost) B minor chord. I asked a similar question when I started out, but use my Bmaj chord quite a lot when playing in E minor.

And you need Bmaj to play Delilah  ;)
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 15, 2013, 11:00:25 AM
He's misread it again ..

   "you need to Be A major" to play Delilah 

.. stupid boy  ::)

Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: playandteach on March 15, 2013, 01:05:26 PM
Just to head off the usual confusion

  • Em - either dorian C# or aolian C and both all there on the D/G keyboard - harmonises to a B minor chord
  • E harmonic minor scale (contains C and that D#) - harmonises to B major

The harmonic minor is the one prevalent in gypsy, klesmer, russian, flamenco, swing, much jazz, and most classical music. We folkies use the other two. 
This is probably a can of worms, but that isn't the full picture on the minor scales. Yes modal music will often  have flattened 7ths (the 3rd of the dominant that you want to shut off), but to get perfect cadences (the chord 5, chord 1 full stop phrase endings) you don't want to have a minor chord 5 (an open bare 5th will be fine). This is more complicated than attributing this need to the use of harmonic minors (which are not that common in classical music - though I am aware of exceptions before the flood gates open). Harmonic minors get their flavour from both the flattened 6th and the sharpened 7th - only a limited number of styles use that - hence the identifiable nature.
The only relevant fact in this post is that not having the third might lose something in the fullness of that cadence, but having the wrong third will be a bigger issue.
I'm not used to using forums, so if this counts as a thread drift - let me know.
Thanks
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 15, 2013, 03:42:26 PM
Definitely a can of worms, and I'd point out that I penned that 2½ years ago! As you say, minors are a bit complex but the main "E" minor ones on our box for occidental folk music are the three I alluded to. I'll say little more.  I got shot down only yesterday for being geeky about scales and chords.

Suffice it to say that when Theo fettled the box into "4th button start" it still kept the choice of C or C♯ pull for the main 'folk' Em's and he also left me  the D♯ push there. I can add it to my B chord if I choose, or not  8). Please don't downplay harmonic too much - French Balkan and Baltic music is full of it!

Oh :o just noticed that guitarists have a specific name for this - a tonic+5 is a "power" chord! What d'you know! Presumably something that came with electrification? 
Title: Re: Taping up the third
Post by: Lester on March 15, 2013, 03:54:14 PM
Power Chord 101 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_chord)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal