Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Graham Spencer on November 02, 2010, 04:23:43 PM
-
Cruising round the net earlier today I chanced on an accordion-related site (which shall remain nameless) on which the expert's advice was that a box should NEVER be stored or carried on its side, ALWAYS vertically oriented (ie in the playing position) because placing a box horizontally causes the valves to curl and distort. Is`there even a grain of truth in this theory, I wonder?
Graham
-
Well, I've never seen an accordion case that is designed to carry the instrument in the playing position. I would venture to say that it's the continual rotating of the acordion whilst hadling it that keeps the valves from sagging in one direction. When the accordion / melodeon or whatever is standing on its bass end, the bass valves are pointing upwards and the treble valves are hanging down, maybe the 'expert' was referring to the bass valves only? I suppose the best thing to do is not to store the instrument in the same orientation for too long.
-
Cruising round the net earlier today I chanced on an accordion-related site (which shall remain nameless) on which the expert's advice was that a box should NEVER be stored or carried on its side, ALWAYS vertically oriented (ie in the playing position) because placing a box horizontally causes the valves to curl and distort. Is`there even a grain of truth in this theory, I wonder?
Graham
Is there any chance he was meant the opposite by horizontally and vertically?
-
...... When the accordion / melodeon or whatever is standing on its bass end, the bass valves are pointing upwards and the treble valves are hanging down, maybe the 'expert' was referring to the bass valves only? I suppose the best thing to do is not to store the instrument in the same orientation for too long.
Many accordions/melodeons have boosters on the bass valves to help them remain flat, so that might not be a problem. Also evident are the "feet" on the bass end, which are provided to stand the instrument on. In addition, you will typically find that most shops and makers store and display the instruments parked this way.
-
I think that to do any internal damage, the box would have to be left in one position for a looooong time. I've had my present PA for around 40 years and I've always stored it on its feet. Sometimes it doesn't get played for weeks but it still works OK.
-
Will a given storage method really shorten the life of the valves to a point where they must be replaced or straightened before any expected tune-up/maintenance work is required? It seems like we're talking about geological time, when it comes to a piece of mylar that is so small actually bending under its own weight due to funny storage.
-
John McEnroe at Wimbledon "YOU CAN NOT BE SERIOUS!"
I agree with the expert - of course, more so with big heavy leather valves - but with any box - why give them a hard time - just keep them happy and laying flat.
-
The issue of curling leather valves seems to be real enough for concertinas which have been stored with their axis vertical instead of horizontal.
These are mostly old Lachenal concertinas which have been kept in those beautifully made, hexagonal, mahogany cases; often still seen. The valves on the concertina end which went in the lower part of the case droop downwards under gravity, eventually permanently. The recommendation, if you must have one of these cases, is to store the instrument and its case with their axis horizontal. Wheatstone, and all modern concertina cases are all made so that the instrument lies horizontally.
I've often wondered about whether this applied to melodeons. I've never had any gravity/storage-related valve curl problems. I always store mine so that they are upright, standing on their 'feet' inside the case. The exceptions are my one-row boxes, which, following the recommendation of a maker, I keep in their cases in the playing position. I think this is less to do with reducing the risk of valve curl, but more with reducing the risk of damage to the bass-end table (soundboard thingy) in the event of a sudden shock to the case (i.e. being dropped). Most one-row instruments don't have 'feet' and the left hand 'growl box' assembly, which stands proud of the bass-end table, could fracture the latter if the instrument was dropped even just a short distance.
-
Don't put your box down vertically/horizontally/diagonally inclined towards Mecca, the valves will curl up and if you're not careful then it will explode and people will die!!!. :o
What about all those French people who are adamant that you don't need, nay, shouldn't have bellows straps because when you're not playing it the box should always be stored standing up vertically?. Last time I checked there wasn't an epidemic of premature valve curling in Brittany.
Reminds me of the similar non-concern about supposedly damaging guitar necks if you hang them up by the headstock on wall hangers, complete piffle.
-
Well, I've no idea whether the "expert" knows what he's talking about or not, but as I've never experienced any concomitant problems over 30-odd years of playing I shall continue to carry my boxes in their appointed cases (horizontally) and store them when not in their cases whichever way up they fit the available space. Though actually, when a box is out its case I usually do stand it upright - but that's because it's ready to slip over my shoulder and play!
Graham
-
The issue of curling leather valves seems to be real enough for concertinas which have been stored with their axis vertical instead of horizontal.
These are mostly old Lachenal concertinas which have been kept in those beautifully made, hexagonal, mahogany cases;
Yes, but in that case gravity is pulling the valve directly away from the slot.
I've often wondered about whether this applied to melodeons.
The equivalent would be putting the melodeon on its back or front. I suppose in a hard case that means you shouldn't store or transport the case flat, but when I'm packing the car I put things however they'll fit...
The exceptions are my one-row boxes, which, following the recommendation of a maker, I keep in their cases in the playing position.
My one-row boxes differ in which way they will fit in the box. One has to sit on its feet on the bass end, one has to go in playing orientation, and the other lives in a padded gig bag...
TBH, I suspect that leather valves simply curl how they want to with age, and gravity doesn't make a lot of difference.
-
Apparently the buttons will wear out if you touch them :P
Longevity might be achieved by keeping the instrument in an vacuum in space, but entropy will always get you in the end :(
-
I think that to do any internal damage, the box would have to be left in one position for a looooong time. I've had my present PA for around 40 years and I've always stored it on its feet. Sometimes it doesn't get played for weeks but it still works OK.
Tom - did u see post-Ystrad PMessage from me? Ta (:) (:)
-
Blimey! I had better stop playing mine as the valves bend every time I squeeze a note out of it. ???
-
Longevity might be achieved by keeping the instrument in an vacuum in space, but entropy will always get you in the end :(
Then the reed plates will drop off as the wax de volatilises Andrew ;0
I spent some time in the AEA facility at Harwell as they were type examining a machine for us, this was done adjacent to one of the emptiest places in the universe, a road tanker sized vacuum chamber at incredibly low pressure where they were doing long term tests on componentry and materials like window seals and aerial feeder cables for the ISS, (during our sessions they were also firing the JET in the next building, my companion was very uneasy at being within spitting distance of probably the lowest pressure and highest temperature in the solar system and beyond !) I was not surprised that plastics etc degrade and boil off into space but the amount of degradation metals suffer was an eye opener - didn't see any bellows or reeds in evidence ;D
Richard
-
Apparently the buttons will wear out if you touch them
LOL :D
-
Bernard Loffet makes this suggestion, and I have always followed it. I remember Theo once saying to me that it was a valid point in theory but the risk could be very low in practice. Having spent £3,500 on an accordion with reeds that sound as if they were made in heaven,Ii am not going to take the chance. My accordion spends 22-23 hours a day in storage, so I want to know its happy.
May be its more of an issue for a LMM G/C which has a lot of big heavy reeds?
-
And most importantly, after a gig or session, when you get home, please remove your packet of uneaten sandwiches before storing the accordion for even a short length of time.
I give this advice after receiving an accordion through the post for repair a few weeks ago, and guess what I found inside the case???
By the smell, and the purple stain on the bellows, I'd guess egg and beetroot...
-
Just as with fine wine.. rotate your box.
-
I always rotate my wine box… :]
I'm ex-Navy, and one of the traditions handed down (since year dot, but no doubt applicable to damp wooden-hulled ships) was that flour and pulses, beans and other dried stuff had always to be rotated daily to kill the weevils and maggots which slowly worked their way to the top of the sack. Not sure how this killed them - maybe it was just to ensure they'd be at the bottom when a pest-free supply was needed.
-
Eggs, too. Rotate the eggs and they'll keep for a few weeks without refrigeration (so I'm told).
-
Even if stored with the bellows down is "better" I wouldn't. The little metal feet do their job just fine. I will admit, I wondered about this, and I believe the issue was one of my first posts.