Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on November 02, 2010, 09:32:52 PM
-
Hi All,
I've been having another thinking session evolving around my 21 button Tommy in G/D with accidentals and a 3 button key note start.
I've been looking at 'Stoney Steps' with a run up from low G upwards, except there isn't a low G on my box!
It seems to get round this is to use the bass notes for the G,A,B,C and then the next note, D is on the D row and upwards as the tune progresses. I've only got an A below the D on the D row, so it's basses or whistling!
As far as playing the tune goes, I'm using it as a learning aid to simply learn what's around the box, and using basses, it'll be a while before i get to grips with the tune properly. It is an excellent way to find it's outer limits of a box though, just as some tunes with Bb are teaching me where the accidentals are.
Back to the plot - But....why is a standard box built like it is?
It seems there's a lot of notes at the other end nearest your knees which as someone says, is only really useful for calling on the dogs. Why all the notes up that end that to me seem of little use, when I could use a few under my chin?
I suppose ( assume ) those with a 4 button start have the lows built in?
Can you convert a 3 button start to a 4 button?
...and what would that mean?
questions...questions.....
I think I need to go and lie down
Q in a pickle.
-
I think it is that way simply. Because lower pitch boxes such as GC, and CF are that way, and DG when was invented in the 50s nobody thought about the lack of low notes.
My personal opinion is that DG boxes should have the scale starting on the 4th button, especially when there are accidentals, then it is possible to arrange for a complete scale starting from low fiddle G.
-
My Tommy has been converted to 4th button start and had low notes and accidentals and is very useful for some tunes. I am about to convert an Erica as well. The main downside is the additional stretch to the accidentals but you soon get used to it.
As to why, I kind of guess that as the melodeon in D/G is a relatively new layout therefore playing in the chinmost octave is also and thus the low note/accidental problem. With C/F and G/C it is more normal to play in the kneemost octave where the problem does not exist
Looks as if Theo beat me to it but at least we agree ;D
-
That's ok Lester, I'll let you have the last word :)
-
Apologies for my delay in replying - work!
I didn't realise the D/G was a 'new' invention, but I suppose I had no idea of history here. I'm aware older anglo's are G/C but newer ones G/D so it all makes sense, sort of!
It seems obvious from both your reactions that this isn't a particularly odd thing to do.
Please can I ask you both how the keyboard is actually laid out, note for note on your box ( Lester ) or your advised modification ( Theo )?
I'd like to try and get my head around how it would leave the keyboard, and what happens to the knee end if you squeeze something in under your chin!
Theo: Could you PM me how long would this rearrangement would take to do, and an approximate costs involved?
....cos I simply have no idea!
It's something that I'd like to think about, as it seems to be a good idea - but I'd like to see exactly how it will change the lyout.
thanks both for replying
cheers
Q
-
G row acc/acc B/C D/F# etc
D row acc/acc G/A A/C# D/E etc
the rest of the layout as normal but with the top two buttons missing.
-
As requested my layout is on the end of the link below. Not a lot of thought went into it ie I just had the standard low notes with the standard accidentals. The only oddity is the kneemost button on the D row is reversed to give me the F#' in the G row direction so I can play Mrs Saggs without thinking too hard :P
https://docs.google.com/drawings/pub?id=1fA_pcI-SYWzQNbXSicKJg8_ql7vYJmQeZP8tQx39wEU&w=960&h=720 (https://docs.google.com/drawings/pub?id=1fA_pcI-SYWzQNbXSicKJg8_ql7vYJmQeZP8tQx39wEU&w=960&h=720)
-
Ok, many thanks for this.
Will sit down with a nice cup of tea in front of the woodburner and think.....
and try desperately not to fall asleep!
cheers
-
My Tommy has been converted to 4th button start and had low notes and accidentals and is very useful for some tunes. I am about to convert an Erica as well. The main downside is the additional stretch to the accidentals but you soon get used to it.
As to why, I kind of guess that as the melodeon in D/G is a relatively new layout therefore playing in the chinmost octave is also and thus the low note/accidental problem. With C/F and G/C it is more normal to play in the kneemost octave where the problem does not exist
Looks as if Theo beat me to it but at least we agree ;D
Low notes and accidentals does mean a stretch, it's OK on boxes with smaller pitch between the buttons like a Tommy (or the Oakwood Model 4 where I got Martyn to reduce the spacing a bit for precisely this reason) but it's not easy on boxes with standard spacing.
Ian
-
I suppose ( assume ) those with a 4 button start have the lows built in?
They go down to G if they have extra low notes instead of accidentals, but with accidentals the remaining low notes don't go down the scale to G on most default setups.
My Oakwood (I've said this before, I'm going to make a diagram and put it on my web site for next time...) has had two low notes changed* to give me a complete G scale, at my request when I ordered the box new. I'm completely delighted with the result and Stoney Steps was one of the first tunes I learnt on it. There's some great other tunes down there too: Sadlers Wells Hornpipe, Butchers Hornpipe, Charming Maid... now there's an idea for the "local sessions" ThOTM thread as we play all those...
* G row: D on draw changed to C natural
D row: F# on press changed to G
Low G scale switches between rows a bit but isn't hard to play.
-
Here ya go. This is the low end of my Oakwood. Notes in red are the ones that were changed from what you usually get:
(http://treewind.co.uk/images/lownotes.png)
-
Thanks to everyone for taking the trouble to reply.
Ian: I can imagine what you mean about stretch.
I've currently been messing about with 'Jiggery Pokerwork' simply to sus out how to include an accidental (Bb). It's getting a lot better, but in my first attempts I'd often miss the B button. On a push on G row I end up playing D instead of B by mistake, so stretching even a bit more! If it was a 4 button start that would be the strech, which I can do. I discovered the odd noise is the tendons creaking!!!!
( by the way, nice to catch up when you were down for the Committee Band ceilidh, even though it was a bit of a rushed conversation in between the GW dance spot )
Anahata:
I did originally check the low note layout on the website's home page, and as you say, I found it odd the way it didn't go down to low G as a matter of course.
I've not tried Charming Maid yet, but do give it a good thrashing on my tenor Treble concertina, and absolutely love the repitition of the opening phrase lower down the register. Cracking tune!
I suppose having to try and play lows on the bases on Stoney Steps ( another good learning exercise, which gets easier with practise ) and thinking about other tunes such as Charming Maid has prompted this whole thread.
Thanks for your keyboard layout, it certainly makes sense. I'm playing across the rows so having the notes to hand as opposed to resorting to the basses would be good.
OK. My only hesitation is that I need to talk to my daughter, as it's a 'shared box' and I don't want to upset her learning.
It might mean I have to leave it until later on, when she's got to grips with it a little bit more ( or given up altogether! )
Thanks all for the info.
cheers
Q
-
Just converted a strange "Hohner copy" I own to the fingering described by Anahata. Yes, it makes lots of sense for playing in G, which is what I tend to play on a D/G box. (If I'm playing in D, I tend to favour an A/D).
Incidentally, the "fake Hohner" is obviously of Klingenthal construction, but with Hohner reeds and a Hohner badge. Plays quite well though....
-
Ahhh another Converter!
In my limited experience i had no idea how common it obviously is. I will sit and cogitate!
Nice coliour scheme, looks very 'Christmassie'!
cheers
Q
-
"Just converted" - don't these genii make ti sound easy! :'(
-
Yes I know what you mean......
coming from the concertina world, it's really blowing my mind!
The idea of simply altering a tuning to suit is just.....phew!
Mind you, my English's ability to grind out a tune in any key does make the melodeon seem limited beyond belief. I've never had to add/take away reeds cos i've already got them all!!!!!!
Still it's limited ability is the attraction.
It matches my limited ability........ :(
hey ho.
cheers
Q
-
I play a G/C and recently I've been learning some tunes in the low octave, also relearning others across the rows down there. I could just play them along the row in the lower octave, but I like learning the two-row approach to facilitate playing different basses. So the fingering is only off by a button and it's been quite easy to hammer them out. I think the lower octave has a wonderful tone, although now that my box has accidentals, I wish I had my old box with low notes instead!
-
Being a beginner, but having been 'around' melodeons and players for a long time, I've sort of picked up on odd conversations and discussions over the years. I'm now starting to realise what they were all about.
Consequently I've tried the cross row approach right from the word go. I think it allows you to have a more fluid style as opposed to frantic thrashing along the rows. I now only frantically thrash around C's and E's....errr I think! The ones that don't have an alternative easily available, if you know what I mean.
Until I decide one way or t'other, I'm using the bass notes, which is a good exercise in using them in itself. As you say, the tones of the lower notes are far nicer than at the dusty knee end.
Stops the local dogs congregating outside the window too!!!!!!!!!!
cheers
Q
-
Consequently I've tried the cross row approach right from the word go. I think it allows you to have a more fluid style as opposed to frantic thrashing along the rows.
Beware that it doesn't get too fluid. When you need articulation, your RH fingers have to do more work (instead of your left biceps), and also if you learn to play whole runs of notes all in the same direction you can end up holding the basses and chords down solidly through a whole bar or more at a time. If you do that you'll sound like the worst sort of piano accordion player (an instrument where it's really easy to do that), and there are melodeon players who have managed that.
It's good to be able to play a given sequence of notes either way, and make the choice between crossing rows and push-pull based on what suits the music best.
-
Hmmmmm.... that's got me thinking!
I see what you mean.....and I am tending to look for runs in one direction. I hadn't thought about the possible effect on basses, such as you describe.
OK....thank you for that thought. Yet another thing to think about whilst rubbing my tum and patting my head!
thanks for the tip
cheers
Q
-
Beware that it doesn't get too fluid. When you need articulation, your RH fingers have to do more work (instead of your left biceps), and also if you learn to play whole runs of notes all in the same direction you can end up holding the basses and chords down solidly through a whole bar or more at a time. If you do that you'll sound like the worst sort of piano accordion player (an instrument where it's really easy to do that), and there are melodeon players who have managed that.
It's good to be able to play a given sequence of notes either way, and make the choice between crossing rows and push-pull based on what suits the music best.
Spot-on advice from Anahata, as usual (:)
-
It's good to be able to play a given sequence of notes either way, and make the choice between crossing rows and push-pull based on what suits the music best.
Spot-on advice from Anahata, as usual (:)
[/quote]
Its good advice that applies to other aspects of playing too: its good to be able to choose to play quiet/loud staccato/legato fast/slow dancy/lyrical ornamented/plain etc by choice rather than just the same every time.
-
Absolutely, Anahat's hit it on the nail, and I agree totally with Theo too.
I remember having concertina workshops with Ali Anderson a long time ago, who made the point about varying your playing very clear.
It's so true. As Theo says, occasionally try a tune a different way. You learn so much.
I also find that if I can't play a tune slowly and steadily, I'm not in control of it and don't *really* know it.
I have been reminded of this resently when trying to teach something to my daughters some morris tunes ( they play flute and concertina ) that if I slow it down for a note-to-note run through, I actually have to know each note! At a slow speed you can't fluff or rely on speed to blur or skip through the bits you don't really know.
As ever, all good advice.
thanks all
Q
-
It's good to be able to play a given sequence of notes either way, and make the choice between crossing rows and push-pull based on what suits the music best.
Spot-on advice from Anahata, as usual (:)
Its good advice that applies to other aspects of playing too: its good to be able to choose to play quiet/loud staccato/legato fast/slow dancy/lyrical ornamented/plain etc by choice rather than just the same every time.
[/quote]
Agreed, and I'd add: when to play vs. when not to play at all!
:|bl
-
Andy - oh so true!!!!!!!!!!
but don't get me going on that one....!
Q
-
This is the low end of my Oakwood. Notes in red are the ones that were changed from what you usually get:
(http://treewind.co.uk/images/lownotes.png)
I am about to place an order for 2.5-row D/G box and I am thinking of asking the maker to apply Anahata's layout for the low notes.
How painfull is the loss of the low D on the pull?
I think I'm not crying for not having the low F#.
Thank You for your help.
-
This is the low end of my Oakwood. Notes in red are the ones that were changed from what you usually get:
(http://treewind.co.uk/images/lownotes.png)
I am about to place an order for 2.5-row D/G box and I am thinking of asking the maker to apply Anahata's layout for the low notes.
How painfull is the loss of the low D on the pull?
I think I'm not crying for not having the low F#.
Thank You for your help.
If its a 2.5 row then you might want to rethink, because you will have accidentals on the half row. Therefore at the start of the D and G rows you have some more choices. You could include a low D on pull and a low C, a low F, or other low accidentals. I agree about the low F#, it would not pay its rent.
-
I am about to place an order for 2.5-row D/G box
If its a 2.5 row then you might want to rethink, because you will have accidentals on the half row.
Here is what I was thinking of.
Any comments and recommendations are welcome.
-
I think I might consider a E1/D1 reversal instead of the low G#/Bb
And I would have the low F/Eb reversed to Eb/F so the F matches the pull F on the bass
-
I think it is that way simply. Because lower pitch boxes such as GC, and CF are that way, and DG when was invented in the 50s nobody thought about the lack of low notes. My personal opinion is that DG boxes should have the scale starting on the 4th button, especially when there are accidentals, then it is possible to arrange for a complete scale starting from low fiddle G.
I suspect there is a real market for 'low start' D/G's and that makers should specifically make such a box rather than it have to be a special order as now. After all - those e reed chambers are supposed to be tuned too. Does any maker do this? Does any dealer have it as a standard part of the range?
The present D/G setup is a bit of a nonsence IMHO - keys that you never use ???
-
After all - those e reed chambers are supposed to be tuned too.
From the boxes I've looked at I don't think any alleged "tuning" of reed chambers is a significant consideration. Hohner reed blocks all seem to be the same size whether for G/C of D/G. Same applies to most Italian makes. Its quite common to see a strip of wood under the reed plates of D/G s to lift the reed plates so they reach the top of the chamber, in better boxes the top of the chamber is filled with a small wooden packing piece.
-
I think I might consider a E1/D1 reversal instead of the low G#/Bb
And I would have the low F/Eb reversed to Eb/F so the F matches the pull F on the bass
Excellent comments! Thank You, Theo! I wonder why Saltarelle's factory tuning has F bass on pull and most F's on the push?
Anyhow, I rearranged a bit the accidentals. Since playing in A in my area is paramount, I've included a C# reversal either.
More comments are very welcome.
-
The next version is (5) "E,D,C# reversals; F’s on pull; low G,C in G row".
-
Version 6: E,D,C# reversals; F’s on pull; low G,C in D row. The advantage is that the "sterch" for the low Eb/F accidentals is better.
-
Version 7: E,D,C# reversals; F’s on pull; low G,C in D row; G#’s on pull.
Having seen Steve Freereeder layout
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/mory_steve_fr_layout.jpg
I found that G# on the pull is more meaningful for a an E bass on the pull.
I have to send my layout design to the maker in a couple of days, any comments are highly appreciated.
Thanks for Anahata's and Theo's contribution.
I play tunes with this box in G, D, A and their modal keys (E dor, A dor, A min, Bm, A mix, etc).
If you have a 2.5-row D/G what would you change?
Thank You!
-
Returning to Chris's point about D/G's standatd tunings being not so good -
Not only would it require a sea change from the melodoen makers, but also a significant knock on effect for those teaching and producing manuals too.
This is my main worry about changing. Currently my daughter is used to it 'as is' with a 3rd button being the key note.
If I change it this will mess up the tutor book she is using as they all refer to using a melodeon with this 3rd button 'standard' setup. If, like me, you tend towards reading music as opposed to the 'tabulature' fingering in most tutors, then the affect is reduced.
cheers
Q
-
simplest way of making 4th button do box compatible with tutor books is to put ;masking tape over chinmost button on each row so that effectively it becomes a 3rd button do box, albeit with the accidentals masked off. This is not a problem in the early stages as they are rarely used. Once the new player is able to proceed without looking at push/pull & buttons signals the masking tape can be removed to give access to the accidentals.
george
-
George - that's brilliant!
Good tip. Now I have no excuse. Better start saving for a conversion!
cheers
Q
-
I always have a role of masking tape handy when running beginners workshops just in case anybody with a 4th button do box turns up- fast conversion to 3rd button do so the notation I provide will work .
having said that I have always been puzled by the 3rd button do being more or less the norm on DG boxes as at the manufacturing stage it would cost very little to put in the extra button & reeds. The really daft thing is that the scarlatti rosso BC is 23 button 4th button do whilst its 21 buttonDg equivelent is only about £30 cheaper - same goes for other sellers clones.
george
-
George: As said above, the layout seems to be brought over from earlier incaranations, but curiously never tweaked or modified by the makers. That is interesting, as most other makers of anything normally get feedback from users of their products as to how the product works or modifications the makers can make to improve their product.
Either they haven't listened or we haven't shouted loud enough!
Q
-
in between the maker & us the players there is likely to be in some cases an importer, + possibly a wholesaler and a retailer. None of these are necessarily good players of both semi tone & 4th apart boxes and of the various 3 row setups including BCC#. It is therefore quite unlikely that any constructive comments we make to the seller, who may not even be a box player, wll be ACCURATELY transmitted to the maker. In my opinion the only way to get it right would be for the makers to put out their prototypes to really experienced players of the particular type of ;box for extended trial & comment. In other words it is not much good ,say, an experienced piano accordion player on a makers staff commenting on a melodeon prototype as he may well not even notice some of the things that we would see as less than desirable. It is for these reasons that the small n;umber of top class lyrs who make small numbers of top class boxes usually get it right.
george
-
Yes, I see your point and agree.
There are similar comparisons with mountain bikes ( my other hobby ). There's the mass market producers who make the bikes *they* think we will like, and recently a small number of independant designers who are making bikes that *we* want to ride!
i.e. they have ironed out the mass market cock ups and got it right for the actual riders.
Interesting.
Still.....never tried playing a tune on my bike ;)
..... and no I won't try to ride my meloeon through muddy puddles :o
cheers
Q
-
Yes, I see your point and agree.
There are similar comparisons with mountain bikes ( my other hobby ). There's the mass market producers who make the bikes *they* think we will like, and recently a small number of independant designers who are making bikes that *we* want to ride!
i.e. they have ironed out the mass market cock ups and got it right for the actual riders.
Interesting.
Still.....never tried playing a tune on my bike ;)
..... and no I won't try to ride my meloeon through muddy puddles :o
cheers
Q
The problem is that the people who are making the things right charge (justifiably) high prices, it takes a long time for it all to percolate down to the rest of us :(
-
this is fine on a handmaade top calss box where the craafastman has haad to put in many hours work & use skills & knowledge accumuklated over a lifetime . It should not however apply to a mass produced just about aadequate quality box where the maker gets very little of the eventual retail price.
There is no more complication to factory producing 8 bass 21 button melodeons thatn to producing piano accordions with complicated bass mechanism and a lot more reeeds, and dfor that matter a lot more casing - but - we are being ripped off somewhere along the line if you consider retail pri;ce in relation to size . (amount of materials)number of reeds , couplers or whatever in piano accordions.An example of this is scarlatti 48bass 2 voice 3 coupler piano accordion £ 349.against £299 for 8 bass 21 button melodeon with no couplers, much less materials and a mere handful of reeds.
george :(
-
Having just spent more time than I thought I needed too tuning the high reeds on a Pokerwork G row that will probably never ever be played I wish to vote for at least a fourth button start if not a fifth ;)
-
There is no more complication to factory producing 8 bass 21 button melodeons thatn to producing piano accordions with complicated bass mechanism and a lot more reeeds, and dfor that matter a lot more casing - but - we are being ripped off somewhere along the line if you consider retail pri;ce in relation to size . (amount of materials)number of reeds , couplers or whatever in piano accordions.An example of this is scarlatti 48bass 2 voice 3 coupler piano accordion £ 349.against £299 for 8 bass 21 button melodeon with no couplers, much less materials and a mere handful of reeds.
george :(
Supply and demand and the economics of running a production line. PAs far outsell melodeons so you change your line over (dead time) and start producing PAs. All that changeover time and the line and company overhead gets split between a lot of accordions. You change over to making melodeons, there's a lot less instruments to split the overheads between. Whilst the cost of the parts may be less that is but a small part of the final cost.
Steve
-
Supply and demand and the economics of running a production line. PAs far outsell melodeons so you change your line over (dead time) and start producing PAs. All that changeover time and the line and company overhead gets split between a lot of accordions. You change over to making melodeons, there's a lot less instruments to split the overheads between. Whilst the cost of the parts may be less that is but a small part of the final cost.
Steve
Not only that, but all PA's of a give size use exactly the same reeds set. We want a choice of D/G, B/C, G/C, C/F, C#/D and more each of which requires a completely different reed set.
-
Having just spent more time than I thought I needed too tuning the high reeds on a Pokerwork G row that will probably never ever be played I wish to vote for at least a fourth button start if not a fifth ;)
Why not just keep the third button layout start but drop the reeds an octave?
-
I wish to vote for at least a fourth button start if not a fifth ;)
Why not just keep the third button layout start but drop the reeds an octave?
That would need half a new set of reeds, go too low and you would run out of high notes.
Also the fingering changes in the high octave, so everything would be different to play.
This is a bit like what happens with G/C boxes. They are always third button start, but it doesn't matter because you don't go that low and most of the action is at the high-notes end of the keyboard. It's a very different box to play.
-
Having just spent more time than I thought I needed too tuning the high reeds on a Pokerwork G row that will probably never ever be played I wish to vote for at least a fourth button start if not a fifth ;)
Why not just keep the third button layout start but drop the reeds an octave?
Or drop only one set an octave.
Bandoneon, anyone????
-
For english music an octave dropped G row works great. Take the hohner 4 stop G box as an example octave lower on the MM reeds AND has L reed octave below that. So reeds 2 octaves below a pokerwork DG G row.
They sound great played in either octave and all buttons from 1 upwards are utilised.
Fingerings change slightly between octaves but thats life, at least for a melodeon and anglo players. Octave transposition is a fairly basic and essential skill soon learned.
A pokerwork tuned LM could be a good alternative to a dry tuned costaloti
-
A pokerwork tuned LM could be a good alternative to a dry tuned costaloti
IMHO almost anything is a good alternative to a dry tuned box of any provenance......... :D
-
One way to go that has interesting possibilities would be to play a G/C box and put some time and energy into getting fluent at playing in D ( just like playing in A on a D/G). This opens up the possibility of playing the English repertoire in familiar keys but also exploring continental music. It gets a lot easier with a 2.5 or 3 row and at least 12 basses and a 3rds stop. E minor can be a bit of a challenge at times with this approach but works OK if you are not too fussed by the bass end.
I sense that with my G/C+ the limitation as far as keys is concerned, is my skill level, not the box.
-
That's more or less what I started doing earlier this year when I got my Baffetti G/C and was hoping to expand on when I got my C/F Dony that I intended to convert to G/C but financial considerations intervened and it had sadly had to go.
Everything, including English, sounds better on a G/C. ;D
-
One way to go that has interesting possibilities would be to play a G/C box and put some time and energy into getting fluent at playing in D ( just like playing in A on a D/G). This opens up the possibility of playing the English repertoire in familiar keys but also exploring continental music. It gets a lot easier with a 2.5 or 3 row and at least 12 basses and a 3rds stop.
Nick, what an excellent comment! I've just read mamy of your earlier posts and I am sure I am going to rethink completely what layout shall I go for. The G/C system seems to have a number of advantages http://diato.org/pdf/2+5r12b.pdf
-
one of the problems that occurs with 4th apart boxes (8 bass) is that once you start to depart from the 'home' keys' you become bassically! challenged so to speak as well as being somewhat short in the accidental department.
Under these circumstances a BC starts to make sense as on the treble end not only are F,C,G,D,A,E all there but more importantly they are easier(or certainly no more difficult) to play than are 'foreign' keys on a 4th apart box. As far as being bassically challenged there may be a fairly simple answer to this!
george ;)
-
play a G/C box and put some time and energy into getting fluent at playing in D ( just like playing in A on a D/G)
I've just asked my friend, an excellent G/C/# player from Belgium, and he said that the right hand part of any G/C/# accordion is perfect for playing tunes in D and A. But, his 12-bass layout is exectly like Loffet's, and the problem with that is that both D and A basses are on the pull, and this bass layout is not really good for playing in D. That is, for playing in D on a G/C/# 18-basses are required.
-
play a G/C box and put some time and energy into getting fluent at playing in D ( just like playing in A on a D/G)
I've just asked my friend, an excellent G/C/# player from Belgium, and he said that the right hand part of any G/C/# accordion is perfect for playing tunes in D and A. But, his 12-bass layout is exectly like Loffet's, and the problem with that is that both D and A basses are on the pull, and this bass layout is not really good for playing in D. That is, for playing in D on a G/C/# 18-basses are required.
to a simple soul like me this sounds horendously complicated - thank goodness for the simplicity (in comparison) of a BCC# with same both ways stradella bbass!
george ;D
-
I had my new Baffetti Binci set up with 4th button start plus accidentals. I was a bit concerned that I would run out of notes at the top end as it's only a 19 button keyboard, but so far the only tune which has caused a problem is Stoney Steps Hornpipe (I play that on my C/F Pokerwork anyway as it's far too squeaky on a D/G). Agree about the stretch to the accidentals, but you do get used to it, and it's satisfying to realise that you are using all of the buttons at some point!
-
I had my new Baffetti Binci set up with 4th button start plus accidentals. I was a bit concerned that I would run out of notes at the top end as it's only a 19 button keyboard, but so far the only tune which has caused a problem is Stoney Steps Hornpipe (I play that on my C/F Pokerwork anyway as it's far too squeaky on a D/G)
???
The version I play (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MJLh_Wzh9E) doesn't go higher than the usual top G. What key are you playing it in?
-
OK David, thanks for the reassurance!
I think in my own mind I'm convinced it's the way to go for me, but it's getting round to it.
thanks
Q