Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: stevejay on November 04, 2010, 09:20:14 PM

Title: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: stevejay on November 04, 2010, 09:20:14 PM
Key of A on a D/G.

Any good youtube examples for inspiration? I'm curious to hear some, I am trying to play more in A and might gain inspirAtion.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Theo on November 04, 2010, 10:19:44 PM
Sorry I don't know of any vids, but I like these tunes in A:
Britches full of Stitches
Athol Highlanders
Stool of Repentence
Bill Malleys Schottische
and Sidlaw Hills goes well in G and A

Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Lester on November 04, 2010, 11:49:40 PM
Old Joe Clark is great in A
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: george garside on November 05, 2010, 09:27:52 AM
100 pipers
cock of the north
lilly the pink
72 highlanders farewell to gibralter

all G#less so no problem

why not try winster gallop or the rowan tree  either can be played faking the G# or if you have one at the chin end  it falls easily under the thumb. (if using two straps!)

george
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: george garside on November 05, 2010, 09:37:32 AM
for anybody that hasn't thought of it  - once you can play a DG in A you will also be able to play a BC in G  BUT will  have the F#  readily to hand.

The similarity between A on a DG & G on a BC  is a very useful starting point for anybody wishing to play both systems  ( and if required it also gives free entry from BC to BCC#)  Looked at it this way the two systems are in fact very similar   & not poles aprt as many think they are

george
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Theo on November 05, 2010, 10:18:01 AM
  Looked at it this way the two systems are in fact very similar   & not poles aprt as many think they are


Yes indeed,  once you have internalised the A fingering on a D row the connection is obvious.   

The problem for very many DG players is that key of A can seem to be a strange and foreign territory.  Often this is because 'on the row' fingering is the starting point of most of the published DG tutor books.   It took me a long time to get over that hangup myself, which is one of the reasons that when teaching complete beginners I teach A very early on.  The second tune I usually teach is Britches Full of Stitches in A.  It's not any harder than playing in G if you haven't spent all your time hammering up and down the G row and belting out oom-pah on the D/G and C basses. >:E
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Tony M on November 05, 2010, 01:09:34 PM
either can be played faking the G# .  .  . 

I'm curious - and always keen to learn something new:

Sitting at work, so haven't got any music to hand to understand the context of the G# in the tunes you suggested - but how do you set about "faking" it?

I should say that my accordions have the accidentals anyway, but if there's a way to extend my (fairly limited) capabilities, I'd be interested to know.

Cheers,

Tony M.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: george garside on November 05, 2010, 01:47:58 PM
an an example easy tune to fake the G#' (iat only has one G# & thats in the top octave) is Scott Skinners  'the cradle song' which can be played either as  slow air in 4/4 or as a waltz changing it to 3/4 on the hoof so to speak.  The G# is followed bu a high A- instead of the missing G# I play two high A's.
faking is a fascinating art form  & can take the form of an aural illusion, the simplest of which ( partiularly if playing with others who are the proud posessors of ,say, a G#) is simply to miss the note out all together w;hile otheres get on with it.  As a general rulle the faster the tune the easier the faking is as in terms of absolute time the note you havn't got is not goi;ng to be around for long enough to be missed!
Sometimes  a right hand chord will cover the gap or a triplet on the note above or below may do the trick. If all else fails a big handful of bass may create a suitable diversion to take the punters mind of things  and sometimes  a bass note can fill the gap eg using the bass B note to substitute if you havn't got a low B on the treble.

Is all a question of experimenting  and not worrying about  the rights and wrongs  buried in the depths of musical theory that  is so loved by some!

george ;)
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Fidjit on November 05, 2010, 02:45:52 PM
Well I'm going to a "Same row different key" course at Witney in a weeks time. Looking forward to that complicated experience. :|bl  :|bl

Chas
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Theo on November 05, 2010, 03:38:13 PM
Is all a question of experimenting  and not worrying about  the rights and wrongs  buried in the depths of musical theory that  is so loved by some!

george ;)

Exactly, the G#s are not really the problem, though in theory they seem to be. The real difference, if you have been happily playing up and down one row in G or D, is that you have to learn a completely different pattern of pushes and pulls, and if you want to be able to use the A and E basses you have to choose to play on the pull quite a lot.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: GbH on November 05, 2010, 03:40:16 PM
I don't have perfect pitch and, ordinarily, find it difficult to distinguish between different keys, much less choose a favourite.  However, on the melodeon, the instrument's limitations do seem to force different keys to have distinct feels, just because the available harmonies differ for each key.  I find playing in A to be a very obvious example of that.  It does seem to be quite an easy way to change the ultimate nature of the tune.  Of the tunes I've tried myself, my attempt at Michael Turner's waltz (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jTEJp1cokUk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jTEJp1cokUk)), in A, seems to demonstrate this.  If I'd tried the same tune in G, I think it would have turned out very differently.  Certainly, when moving something to A major, I don't worry about transposing chords as they would be in another key - I just use whatever seems to be easily at hand.

Obviously, accessing the G# is no issue for my instrument, so, for me, that helps things along a bit.  But even without that, the A mixolydian option is always there.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: george garside on November 05, 2010, 03:54:51 PM
Quote
Exactly, the G#s are not really the problem, though in theory they seem to be. The real difference, if you have been happily playing up and down one row in G or D, is that you have to learn a completely different pattern of pushes and pulls, and if you want to be able to use the A and E basses you have to choose to play on the pull quite a lot.

not altogether a different pattern of pushs & pulls as provided you can play a scale in D through both octaves on the D row playing a scale in G sharpless A is  simply using exactly the same pushes & pulls but starting  part way along the D  scale (or do it on the G row & out pops D - very handy for eg the B part of La Russe)) Same goes for BC - learn C scale full length of box &GDAEF   consist of a portion of the C scale with a prod at 1 or more accidentals which are always to hand.

george

george
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Tony M on November 05, 2010, 03:55:58 PM
Is all a question of experimenting  and not worrying about  the rights and wrongs  buried in the depths of musical theory that  is so loved by some!

Many thanks, George - a little light is now shining in the darkness!

I'll need to experiment with a few tunes and see what I can do.

Cheers,

Tony M
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Fidjit on November 05, 2010, 05:32:56 PM
I need to find the scale first I think.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: george garside on November 05, 2010, 08:03:39 PM
I need to find the scale first I think.

start on button 6 note A push(assuming 3rd button do)  push pull seqence is then  blow/suck, s/b, s/b, ?/b

? +missing G#  which can either be faked or plaued on button 1 blow

george
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Fidjit on November 05, 2010, 09:55:08 PM
I need to find the scale first I think.

start on button 6 note A push(assuming 3rd button do)  push pull sequence is then  blow/suck, s/b, s/b, ?/b

? +missing G#  which can either be faked or played on button 1 blow

george
Didn't sound right  :|bl  :|bl Then I got it.
Thanks. :|glug  Well that's a start anyway.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Andy in Vermont on November 14, 2010, 10:15:59 PM
Key of A on a D/G.

Any good youtube examples for inspiration? I'm curious to hear some, I am trying to play more in A and might gain inspirAtion.

I couldn't find it on YouTube, but the (French Canadian) Reel St-Paul in A is excellent on a one-row in D, so you can certainly play it on a D/G box.
McKenzie's March is in A mixolydian, and also sounds great on the D row.
I hope that I got the names of these tunes right.
-Andy
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 15, 2010, 07:05:26 AM
Anything 'mixolydian' - a.k.a playing in 'A' on the D row (as per Liam's Witney class), a.k.a an 'A' scale with a Gnatural.

Bluesey stuff, Apalation, County/Western (sorry), Rock'n'Roll are classical examples but there are quite a few in the English/Scottish tradition too. And French ..

   Fred Paris's Retour de Montaignac  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I447q4C3Kpk

While it is possible to play fluently in A 'accidentally' - I feel it's sort of fighting the box and the chords aren't all there. I'll let others deal with 'A' When I had an F/C I'd use it in preference for any 'G' mixolydian tune. A bonus was that G minor was there too on the F row,  some tunes even move between the two!
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Howard Jones on November 15, 2010, 08:22:21 AM
Sportsman's Hornpipe is another good tune.

I usually start and finish the scale using the pull As on the G row, which allows you to play the A chord.

The biggest problem I have with playing in A is air control.  Usually I'm constantly dabbing at the air button in order to keep the bellows balanced.  In A, I find I'm mainly playing on the pull, with few opportunities to dump air on the push to recover the bellows.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: george garside on November 15, 2010, 09:28:03 AM
I usually play in A (on DG box) on the row for two reasons

1. there are no air problems

2. the fingering & bellowing is exactly the same as G on a BC ( provided you don't need/can manage without G#

3  using the  BC fingering avoids nasty accidents as I am  used to doing it on BC & BCC# bpxes.

george
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Anahata on November 15, 2010, 09:52:10 AM
Sportsman's Hornpipe is another good tune.

I usually start and finish the scale using the pull As on the G row, which allows you to play the A chord.

But Sportsman's is A Dorian, a minor mode. You'd expect to play that on the G row anyway. You do have a point though, that even if you play as much of an A major scale as you can on the D row, you need to use the A on the G row (pull) to get an A chord to go with it.

Most of this thread seems to be about A major tunes, which you'd play on the A row if your box had one. Many of those mentioned above are A mixolydian, of which there are many because they have their origins in Scottish pipe music, and pentatonic tunes are easy to do in A on a D/G box because they don't have any G#s either.

As well as the comparison with playing in G on a B/C or B/C/C# box, nobody's mentioned that the same push-pull sequence is common in Cajun box playing, and also known as cross-harp in blues harmonica playing, where the flattened 7th and extensive use of the subdominant chord are characteristic of the music.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: LJC on November 15, 2010, 10:40:16 AM
Hesleyside Reel is good in A, as is Speed the Plough (excelent for confusing fiddlers who don't think you can play A on the box). Both have G#s.

The Sportsmans Hornpipe is in the dorian mode - there is a huge difference between playing A dorian and A major.

edit: didn't read Anahata's post, obviously.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Owen Woods on November 15, 2010, 02:24:35 PM
Sportsman's Hornpipe is another good tune.

I usually start and finish the scale using the pull As on the G row, which allows you to play the A chord.

The biggest problem I have with playing in A is air control.  Usually I'm constantly dabbing at the air button in order to keep the bellows balanced.  In A, I find I'm mainly playing on the pull, with few opportunities to dump air on the push to recover the bellows.

Try playing a BCC#, it's even worse!
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Quebecois on November 15, 2010, 03:23:57 PM
So much easier to play on a A/D/G box  ;D
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: george garside on November 15, 2010, 03:33:28 PM
?? on a 4 voice paulo soprani 80 bass cock of the north, 100 pipers, lamb skinnet etc etc can be played  in A using 4 voices & bass with not moe than 3 or 4 inches of bellwos open.  Speed the plough max 5 inches.My home  & the cradle song  not more than 5 inches.  On 2 voice a bc ,not using the bass, 23 or 4 inches will suffice for most of the above.(in A)


george
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Owen Woods on November 15, 2010, 05:51:36 PM
?? on a 4 voice paulo soprani 80 bass cock of the north, 100 pipers, lamb skinnet etc etc can be played  in A using 4 voices & bass with not moe than 3 or 4 inches of bellwos open.  Speed the plough max 5 inches.My home  & the cradle song  not more than 5 inches.  On 2 voice a bc ,not using the bass, 23 or 4 inches will suffice for most of the above.(in A)


george

I'm sure it will, but I'm still getting the hang of the reversals in A :P Most keys are OK, but Bb and A are giving me trouble.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: george garside on November 15, 2010, 06:49:08 PM
use the push E middle row & push B outside row as much as possible push C# inside row aslo handy.  Bonny Dundee provides very good practice using these reversals


george
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Owen Woods on November 16, 2010, 01:07:39 AM
use the push E middle row & push B outside row as much as possible push C# inside row aslo handy.  Bonny Dundee provides very good practice using these reversals


george

Thanks, I'll try that tune (:) The problem is that a) the reversals seem to be in odd places, not particularly intuitive and for odd notes. That's probably DG bias coming through. The other is that I haven't really got to liking switching between innermost and outermost row. I play most stuff on the BC row, occasionally switching to CC# for a nice reversal run. If I'm in a flat key then it's the other way around. But switching from the B row to the C#row needs more practice. It is possible, I'm sure.
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: george garside on November 16, 2010, 10:46:39 AM
 george
[/quote]

Thanks, I'll try that tune (:) The problem is that a) the reversals seem to be in odd places, not particularly intuitive and for odd notes. That's probably DG bias coming through. The other is that I haven't really got to liking switching between innermost and outermost row. I play most stuff on the BC row, occasionally switching to CC# for a nice reversal run. If I'm in a flat key then it's the other way around. But switching from the B row to the C#row needs more practice. It is possible, I'm sure.
[/quote]

possibly the simplest way to get used to the choice of notes on the 3 row is to introduce them into tunes you are alaready playing - but only one at a time- eg if you are using the pull E on the outside row try substituting the push E on the middle rowand then consider which is best for the particular bit of the partic;ular tune, bearing in mind  the two main functions of the 'alternatives' i.e. to prevent over extension of the bellows ( I find it very satisfying to bring the bell owsback without much use of the air button) or to ease difficult bits of fingering  or rapid repeated reversals - eg use the pull F# inside row for the DF#A sequence in soldiers joy rather than reversing for the F# on the outside row.  The EF#EEC#E in bonny dundee  (key A) is easyest played all on the push using the 'diagonal' C#inside row,E middle row.F# outside row.


avoid the temptation to play long runs in same direction unless you know you have a following run in the opposite directionto bring the bellows back to where ;you started - otherewise its a question  of 'ever outwards'!

hope this helps

george
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Anahata on November 16, 2010, 01:23:32 PM
eg use the pull F# inside row for the DF#A sequence in soldiers joy rather than reversing for the F# on the outside row.
...
avoid the temptation to play long runs in same direction unless you know you have a following run in the opposite directionto bring the bellows back to where ;you started

If you do the pull F# you might also want to do the push C# and B to avoid breaking the second rule  (:)
Title: Re: A on a DG, G on a CF etc,,
Post by: Owen Woods on November 16, 2010, 01:48:59 PM
You've got too good, lad - the main row fingering has become automatic.  If you think back a while, those reversals in D and G were not intuitive, once.  :|glug

I know, I know :P

possibly the simplest way to get used to the choice of notes on the 3 row is to introduce them into tunes you are alaready playing - but only one at a time- eg if you are using the pull E on the outside row try substituting the push E on the middle rowand then consider which is best for the particular bit of the partic;ular tune, bearing in mind  the two main functions of the 'alternatives' i.e. to prevent over extension of the bellows ( I find it very satisfying to bring the bell owsback without much use of the air button) or to ease difficult bits of fingering  or rapid repeated reversals - eg use the pull F# inside row for the DF#A sequence in soldiers joy rather than reversing for the F# on the outside row.  The EF#EEC#E in bonny dundee  (key A) is easyest played all on the push using the 'diagonal' C#inside row,E middle row.F# outside row.

avoid the temptation to play long runs in same direction unless you know you have a following run in the opposite directionto bring the bellows back to where ;you started - otherewise its a question  of 'ever outwards'!

Aye, that's what I've been doing. A lot more practice needed methinks :P
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal