Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Telemorris on November 05, 2010, 05:02:47 PM

Title: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Telemorris on November 05, 2010, 05:02:47 PM
Hi,

How do I identify the different Hohner reed types? I've seen references to "T", and "H" reeds. Does this identify the reeds or the reed plate? How and where are they marked? Are there other types that could show up in a Hohner Erica depending on the age?

Are there differences in the sound each type of reed makes?

And finally, If I need to buy new reed banks from Hohner to change the keys the instrument plays, what reed type will I get by default?

Thanks.

Ed
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Andy Simpson on November 05, 2010, 05:26:25 PM
Firstly, "reeds" and "reedplates" are pretty much interchangeable and usually refer to the whole assembly of the reed tongue, (the strip of metal that moves and makes the sound), and the plate it's mounted on.

H and T reeds get their names because they're marked with either an easily noticeable H or a T on the upward facing part of the plate.

H reeds are generally considered better, (sweeter sounding, more responsive), by most people but they're only found in very old boxes and haven't been made for decades when they were replaced by T reeds, which is the only type Hohner offers and has offered for years. There seems to have been a bit of a transition period and some boxes have H reeds for the treble and T for the bass.
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on November 05, 2010, 10:27:59 PM
Oh! That's all it is. Thank you!  :Ph ;D (Relief!)
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Christopher K. on November 06, 2010, 11:20:25 PM
Andy made a very nice summary of it. I have a borderline Club (no wax, just leather and pins) where only two or three reeds show the H stamp, while the others are marked with a strike through the corner and the bass reeds have no mark at all. I remember reading somewhere that this is because some of the plates may have been flipped over but I once removed a few reeds and didn't see this was true.

The tonal differences between H and T are quite striking and instantly recognizable. It boils down to a matter of personal preference. I've found that I can get better dynamics and volume control from H reeds and they play sweetly with less pressure, but the high notes are weak. The T reeds are louder and brighter throughout the range.
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Telemorris on November 07, 2010, 12:42:34 AM
Thank you very much for the information.

I'd like to know more about the differences between the H and T reeds.

Are they made of the same or different metals?

Are the tongues shaped to the same dimensions - either thickness or the shape of the opening in the reedplate: Longer and thinner for a given note vs. shorter and fatter?

Are there other differences that can make a difference in the sound? I've read about the rivets that hold the tongue to the reedplate making some contribution to the quality of the sound.

I've also been finding instruments on Ebay advertised as having "Bell metal" for the tongues. Can anyone enlighten me as to the sound qualities of bell metal?

Thanks
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Christopher K. on November 07, 2010, 03:49:58 AM
Bell metal means bronze reed tongues (like a harmonica), which in accordions was phased out a long time ago. Bronze has a very pleasing tone but it takes a lot more wind to make the reed speak. I think there are some members who have experience modern boxes that have steel tongues on bronze plates.

The hardness of the material that makes the plate (shoe, frame, plate, box.. whatever you call it) and the method of attachment makes a big difference in the final tone. Same tongue on different plates will not sound the same. Some old H reeds have zinc plates, some do not.

That's the extent of my knowledge. The rest is witchcraft.  (:) :||: :||:
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Telemorris on December 06, 2010, 09:30:50 PM
I ran into a third type of Hohner reed plate while reading through the archivess. Yes, there's the "H" and "T" reeds but there's also a reed plate with Hohner stamped down one side of the plate.

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4975.0.html

When were these types of reed plates made? Are they of a better quality? If they are of a better quality, what makes for the quality, and which model instruments were likely to have them? Would they have been put into a two row diatonic of higher quality? I've seen the standard Pokerwork, Erica models, but I'm also discovering Hohners with more attention to detail like this one:

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=320627275003&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT#ht_9848wt_1141

Is this model more likely to have the higher grade reeds? I'm not bidding on it, but it may be a good benchmark for a future purchase.

Thanks,

Ed

Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Telemorris on December 10, 2010, 07:31:33 PM
I took receipt of my black Erica this week and find "T." stamped reeds in it. See the photo.

What is the difference between "T." and "T" reeds? Does anyone know? PGroff???

Thanks
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Theo on December 10, 2010, 07:53:45 PM
There are numerous variants of H reedplates too!  I think it is mainly a reflection of different sets of tooling that were used as production methods were refined.  I'm sure there were also deliberate steps taken to manufacture different qualities of reed.   The type with "Hohner made in Germany" stamped on every reedplate for example must have been a better quality reed, they certainly show signs of different manufacturing processes, the most obvious being that the grinding marks run along the length of the reed, instead of at right angles that is the norm for T and H reeds.
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Telemorris on December 10, 2010, 08:50:31 PM
So you're thinking these "T dot" reeds may be a cut above the standard "T" reed?

I do wish there were a Hohner catalog with all the different types/models of reeds and reed plates used over the years so we'd know what we're looking at when one of us opens up an older instrument.
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Theo on December 11, 2010, 01:03:47 AM
So you're thinking these "T dot" reeds may be a cut above the standard "T" reed?

No I don't think so.
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Prestidigitator on December 11, 2010, 09:19:26 AM
In the run-up to trying to emulate Lester and Ukebert (et al) and revive an old Hohner Victoria box (H reeds), I've been scouring all possible sources in the hope of finding out enough to avoid a massive disaster. One has been the "HATools-Katalog", in which it seems to suggest that "T-Mensur" implies "economy class reeds". This catalogue also describes TAM and A Mano reeds as 2 classes of reeds which are "Handarbeit 1(and 2) Mensur". Is it perhaps possible that the H on Hohner reeds is H for Handarbeit i.e. hand-worked,hand finished or similar?

All pretty academic, as I'll be glad to get even a squeak out of my restoration box.

By the way, Lester's photo gallery is a tremendous help as well. My only complaint is that it miffs me to see how untidy and uncleanly my workshop is compared to his.
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Theo on December 11, 2010, 09:33:31 AM
I don't think its likely that the H stands for anything other that Hohner,  and I've heard it suggested that T is for Trossingen, where the Hohner factory is located.
Another reaason I think this is that the preoccupation with reed types among players is a comparatively new phenomenon.   In the small number of older catalogues I've read I've never seen a mention of it.   

I also firmly believe that the description of reeds as hand made or a mano is no guarantee that the box they are in will play well.   I have worked on modern Italian boxes where the reeds have the visible signs of being a mano - cone of hammer marks on the rivet, and blue edges to the head of the reed - but the box was dull to play, even after I'd done my best to get the reed set and tuning right. 
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Lester on December 11, 2010, 09:53:44 AM
By the way, Lester's photo gallery is a tremendous help as well. My only complaint is that it miffs me to see how untidy and uncleanly my workshop is compared to his.

;D

I'm sure there aught to be an old adage about clean workshops and poor workmen
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Prestidigitator on December 11, 2010, 11:02:35 AM
I don't think its likely that the H stands for anything other that Hohner,  and I've heard it suggested that T is for Trossingen, where the Hohner factory is located.
Another reaason I think this is that the preoccupation with reed types among players is a comparatively new phenomenon.   In the small number of older catalogues I've read I've never seen a mention of it.   

I also firmly believe that the description of reeds as hand made or a mano is no guarantee that the box they are in will play well.   I have worked on modern Italian boxes where the reeds have the visible signs of being a mano - cone of hammer marks on the rivet, and blue edges to the head of the reed - but the box was dull to play, even after I'd done my best to get the reed set and tuning right. 
I guess that, as with many other things, increased knowledge today means that people tend to have more views about such things as reed types; whilst in the past no-one knew or bothered. I certainly recall that when I got my hands on my first melodeon upwards of 40 years ago, I had no great idea how it worked or what was in it, nor yet did I care. The aim of the moment was to get some sort of recognisable tune out of it; I'm still trying.

A few years ago, I bought a new Serenellini Cherry 98 with Dural reeds and was, frankly, disappointed at how "brown" it sounded. Oh dear, should have bought TAM version and so forth. In fact, all it needed was a lot more playing to get some life into it. I don't have the sound recordings to prove it, but I have a sneaky suspicion that no instrument I've had (new, secondhand, high spec, low spec, whatever) sounds the same now as when I first had it. I don't mean that they're all out of tune, either.

Any box is a "living" thing, and how we (and others before) play it and treat it means that each gets its own character. So really I don't suppose it matters a HooT about the reed types.
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Prestidigitator on December 11, 2010, 11:14:38 AM


I'm sure there aught to be an old adage about clean workshops and poor workmen


There ain't!
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: TomB on December 11, 2010, 12:46:54 PM
My old boss was fond of telling us that a clean workbench meant no work was being done  ;D
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: waltzman on December 11, 2010, 02:27:50 PM
I don't think its likely that the H stands for anything other that Hohner,  and I've heard it suggested that T is for Trossingen, where the Hohner factory is located.
Another reaason I think this is that the preoccupation with reed types among players is a comparatively new phenomenon.   In the small number of older catalogues I've read I've never seen a mention of it.   

I also firmly believe that the description of reeds as hand made or a mano is no guarantee that the box they are in will play well.   I have worked on modern Italian boxes where the reeds have the visible signs of being a mano - cone of hammer marks on the rivet, and blue edges to the head of the reed - but the box was dull to play, even after I'd done my best to get the reed set and tuning right. 

That's a little disheartening.  Any thoughts on the reason for this?
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Owen Woods on December 11, 2010, 02:53:42 PM
In the run-up to trying to emulate Lester and Ukebert (et al) and revive an old Hohner Victoria box (H reeds), I've been scouring all possible sources in the hope of finding out enough to avoid a massive disaster. One has been the "HATools-Katalog", in which it seems to suggest that "T-Mensur" implies "economy class reeds". This catalogue also describes TAM and A Mano reeds as 2 classes of reeds which are "Handarbeit 1(and 2) Mensur". Is it perhaps possible that the H on Hohner reeds is H for Handarbeit i.e. hand-worked,hand finished or similar?

All pretty academic, as I'll be glad to get even a squeak out of my restoration box.

By the way, Lester's photo gallery is a tremendous help as well. My only complaint is that it miffs me to see how untidy and uncleanly my workshop is compared to his.

Don't emulate me, I'm making it up as I go along ;D

And my workshop is my room. I do most of my work on a coffee table in the corner, but switched to my desk for a bit once term had finished. This is why I have little bits of valves EVERYWHERE. I found one in my bed the other day.
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Theo on December 11, 2010, 04:17:55 PM
Quote
I also firmly believe that the description of reeds as hand made or a mano is no guarantee that the box they are in will play well.   I have worked on modern Italian boxes where the reeds have the visible signs of being a mano - cone of hammer marks on the rivet, and blue edges to the head of the reed - but the box was dull to play, even after I'd done my best to get the reed set and tuning right. 

That's a little disheartening.  Any thoughts on the reason for this?

Largely I believe because many of us have paid too much attention to the descriptions of boxes, and not put enough trust in our own ability to judge a box by playing it.  I've certainly been guilty of this myself. I recall John Turner from The Music Room advising me years ago not to worry about whether a box hand hand made reeds, but to base my choice on the playing qualities of an individual box.  It was advice I ignored at the time, but have now taken on board.
Title: Re: Identifying Hohner reed plate types
Post by: Telemorris on December 11, 2010, 07:02:42 PM
[snip]
A few years ago, I bought a new Serenellini Cherry 98 with Dural reeds and was, frankly, disappointed at how "brown" it sounded. Oh dear, should have bought TAM version and so forth. In fact, all it needed was a lot more playing to get some life into it. I don't have the sound recordings to prove it, but I have a sneaky suspicion that no instrument I've had (new, secondhand, high spec, low spec, whatever) sounds the same now as when I first had it. I don't mean that they're all out of tune, either.

Any box is a "living" thing, and how we (and others before) play it and treat it means that each gets its own character. So really I don't suppose it matters a HooT about the reed types.

I agree. Musical instruments made from wood tend to take a great deal of playing  to reach their full potential for sound, volume, overtones. Stradivarius violins didn't become the incredible instruments they are today until decades of playing had opened them up. Guitars, pianos, most wooden instruments take a long time to become themselves. The varnish needs to craze and crack over time to allow the wood to vibrate more openly, increasing the available volume and refining the overtones.

Some of the changes in the instrument my also have to do with you, the player, getting accustomed to the sounds the instrument makes. An instrument can "grow" on you over time.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal