Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: falcanary on November 05, 2010, 11:13:29 PM
-
http://www.heritageaccordions.com/ (http://www.heritageaccordions.com/)
-
Spam? Care to elaborate? :P Is this caveat emptor, a recommendation or a plug? :P
-
Not spam. Just a friend helping a friend. Rusty Sanner of Heritage accordions is a good guy, a great Cajun accordion player, and a budding builder. Falcanary just helping him out.
-
Not spam. Just a friend helping a friend. Rusty Sanner of Heritage accordions is a good guy, a great Cajun accordion player, and a budding builder. Falcanary just helping him out.
I agree with Ukebert. It would have been nice to have had this information on the original post. Just giving a website URL with no other explanation could have meant anything and is decidedly impolite. I guess it's the internet equivalent of having leaflets for double-glazing contractors dropping through your door. In my house these go straight in the paper recycling bin. >:(
-
Seconded to Steve_freereeder - 'stand up and be identified' is an unspoken tenet of internet sites these days.
A naked URL is immediately suspicious and deserves to be treated accordingly.
-
third,
This original post does not contribute to the forum.
Someone is after a FREE ad’
I, consider it spam
-
Looked like spam to me.
-
third,
This original post does not contribute to the forum.
Someone is after a FREE ad’
I, consider it spam
[[[ Admin hat on: No, the original post is absolutely fine. Musicians who want to advertise gigs or new CD's, or makers who want to let people know about their products are more than welcome to do so, just as long as it's melodeon related, which this clearly is. ]]]
-
Agreed Clive,
But if its done by just posting a link, with no explanation or introduction it risks being counterproductive, as appears to have been the case here.
-
well, at least people are talking about it, which is surely good news for soemone?
-
Not necessarily Al. If you saw how many spam membership applications I have to deal with every week! I've just rejected 5 spammers trying to get in this morning. My spam antennae are highly sensitised at present, and when I see a post from a recently joined member that is just a link to an external site, I am immediately suspicious.
Also its much more helpful to the cause that Falcanary is trying to promote now that there is some additional information, albeit a very small amount.
-
And to be fair, Falcanary is a friend of Rusty at Heritage accordions. He was just doing a probably unknown favor.
-
I'm sure that is so, but it is impolite according to the Rules Of The Internet. However, given that blafleur has posted in defence, all is well (:)
-
I have heard good things about his boxes
another good copy of a copy of a copy.
The world needs more copies
Can't tell if it's another butt box, the corners seem obscured.
Is there really anything distinctive about them that makes them worth consideration.
Is this any different than a Reed box or a number of others.
I suggest that someone rewrite his preamble on his web site..
clumsy and tacky and a bit too self aggrandizing;
and does he really say he does anything you do not expect to get?
Just an observation.
More Cajun builders are building more "Cajun" accordeons.
The pie is just so large. So each new maker is hoping to get a slice of the pie
diminishing the opportunity of another maker of another similar accordeon
selling his/her accordeon.
I suggest expanding outside the pie and offering something a little more
atrtractive ( not just beauty) rather than a low price..
though the Heritage is not low priced, seems right in there with many others.
When is someone down there going to build something of distinction rather than another
cookie cutter box....
Same look, same size, same reeds,same bellows, same iron holding it together same
tacky chrome on the flappers, etc.
I wish the builder success in his endeavor, to take a slice of the Cajun box pie.
-
"When is someone down there going to build something of distinction rather than another
cookie cutter box....
Same look, same size, same reeds,same bellows, same iron holding it together same
tacky chrome on the flappers, etc."
he he, if they did that, nobody down there would buy it. Ask me how I know. Rusty does miter his corners. The market for cajun accordions in south Louisiana is so big (and growing) that everyone building them can sell them as fast as they make them, that lowers the incentive for builders to pursue something to set them apart. I think people buying accordions in Louisiana have gotten so used to a certain look in accordions, anything changed tends to put them off, kinda of like someone taking your mom's favorite recipe and changing it, it might be good but most people just want mom's.
-
Interestingly the autobiographical link that someone posted about Marc Savoy said the same thing :P It said that when he started building everyone wanted a black shiny box and it took him some time to convince people to let him display the grain. It's common knowledge that most musicians are incredibly conservative.
-
Since someone posted this here I might as well put a plug in for Rusty. He is a top notch maker, learned from Randy Falcon. I owned one of his boxes in D(it's in one of the vids on the site), it was one of the best boxes I ever had. I still regret having to sell it to fund car repairs. I don't care about cosmetics so much, I want a box made for Cajun music, and Rusty will make you just that. I actually hope to get another box from him in the not so distant future.
-
I'm sure that is so, but it is impolite according to the Rules Of The Internet.
Blimey, I thought the internet was anarchistic at best, nihilistic at worst. Where's the rule book kept?
-
Blimey, I thought the internet was anarchistic at best, nihilistic at worst. Where's the rule book kept?
No rule book, just common sense. Order and purpose achieves more than chaos and anarchy.
-
Blimey, I thought the internet was anarchistic at best, nihilistic at worst. Where's the rule book kept?
No rule book, just common sense. Order and purpose achieves more than chaos and anarchy.
Not as much fun though. ;D
-
Now,now, children.
-
An "aha" moment
So the Cajun builders are making boxes as fast as they can to fill an expanding market..
no wonder they think that they can continue building with butt joints, amateurish finishes,
copies of copies of copies and slather them with Pledge...continue to raise prices without any discernable
improvement in design, materials or workmanship.
Self explanatory.
So what makes a Hertiage box worthy of consderation ,other than a connection with Falcon.
Certainly not the verbage on his web page.
What about... 30 day no questions asked return policy. No charge retuning and check up at 4 months.
Transferrable 5 year warranty. etc
-
slather them with Pledge
:D
What about... 30 day no questions asked return policy. No charge retuning and check up at 4 months. Transferrable 5 year warranty. etc
That's a fair.. the warranty would have to be more specific but if the market is truly expanding and business is booming, it shouldn't be too much of an expense for the builder? Moreover many players would not take advantage of it, lessening any burden.
Unfortunately, despite my pleas to the dealer, Kia has not started building melodeons.. not yet, anyway... when they do, all new boxes will come with additional features at no extra cost and have a reeds-for-life warranty, provided you get all tuneups done at the dealership. But of course there will be an annoying mix of standard and metric parts, and you'll have to remove the bellows and bass reedblock just to adjust the handstrap. We live in an imperfect world.
-
Wow guys I really appreciate the feedback. As mentioned above, it was unbeknownst to me that my link was published here. Like Bryan Lafleur, I would be happy to discuss what or how I construct my boxes or any other inquisition(s) that someone may have, just drop me a line. Just know that I'm not a butt however your feedback does mitre !
-
Wow guys I really appreciate the feedback. As mentioned above, it was unbeknownst to me that my link was published here. Like Bryan Lafleur, I would be happy to discuss what or how I construct my boxes or any other inquisition(s) that someone may have, just drop me a line. Just know that I'm not a butt however your feedback does mitre !
That was dreadful :D Brilliant.
-
Wow guys I really appreciate the feedback. As mentioned above, it was unbeknownst to me that my link was published here. Like Bryan Lafleur, I would be happy to discuss what or how I construct my boxes or any other inquisition(s) that someone may have, just drop me a line. Just know that I'm not a butt however your feedback does mitre !
Welcome to melnet, looks like you have made quite a vicarious impact already ;)
Careful analysis of the traffic here could provide more value than any business consultant - especially Melodeon's recent experiences :o
Attempting to follow all advice or satisfy all points of view may lead to the sanitorium!
Success in satisfying all points, well at the risk of upsetting Al, it would be nice to have been right in the midst of the second coming >:E
Richard - in the swamp country of England but not Cajun
-
Just know that I'm not a butt however your feedback does mitre !
Genius. Bienvenu mon ami.
-
On further anal ysis , I see that your corners are indeed mitred
Back to the web site....
I seriously suggest you re-write it. Pablum in my opinion,
little of substance that would cause someone to choose your
accordeon over another. Blather, at best.
I am serious about return policies, warranties and transferrable warrantees.
Also the question asked , and not answered...............
What is there about the Heritage accordeon that sets it apart from other
"Cajun" accordeons ?
-
clumsy and tacky and a bit too self aggrandizing;
Certainly not the verbage on his web page.
Pablum in my opinion,
Blather, at best.
:o
-
Still waiting...