Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: OwenG on November 09, 2010, 09:45:26 PM
-
The spring on the chord spoon of my hohner has gone. Any tips on replacing the spring or is a new spoon needed? Thanks in advance.
-
If the exterior of your failed spoon is all corroded/rusty and sad, you might want to replace both chord and fundamental units - that way, you'll have a spare spoon in your gig bag.
Have a look at these sites: http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html and http://www.peterunbehauen.de/p/07sparecatalogue.html
-
Springs can be replaced if the spoon is otherwise ok. you need some 0.8mm piano wire and follow the instructions here (http://diato.org/trucs/fabr_ressorts/image001.htm) to make your spring.
Fitting the spring is tricky. The most important thing is to devise a way to hold the spring compressed while you thread the rivet through two parts of the spoon and the spring and all without injuring your fingers if when the spring comes loose. The best method I've come up with is to stuff the legs of the spring into a piece of small diameter brass tubing. This hold the legs and provides a handle to manipulate the spring into the right place. Eye protection is recommended. If When the spring escapes form the tube it travels very fast.
-
What Theo said.
Please note that you will have to grind the head off the rivet in order to remove the old spring.
If you replace it with a split pin then the job is much easier if when the spring breaks again.
-
A chopped up safety pin will do for emergency repairs too.
-
Thanks for the advice.
I think I'll go for a new spoon and then try and fix the old one so that I've got a spare one if when another one goes.
I've noticed that some of the springs are quite creaky, is this a sign that they are nearing the end, or do they just need a drop of lubrication?
-
Creaky springs are an essential ingredient in The Sound of Hohner.
-
I've finally found time to change the spoon and one of the screws has sheared off in the hole. Any suggestions?
-
Whoops Owen, not a happy position :(
I assume from your using 'in' there is nothing above deck to grab with pliers ?
Do you have a 'Dremel' type grinder or similar ? if so you might just grind a slot in the end of the screw with a tiny abrasive disc, first off heat with a soldering iron until you can smell the wood beginning to cook, this may help loosen it enough to unscrew.
Failing that with a fine centre punch, punch the end so you can drill the screw out (in all cases trying to keep surface damage within the footprint of the hinge foot)
Failing that file up a tubular cutter from a bit of steel pipe or a bit of rod with a hole drilled up it, any sort of jagged end is likely to do as a one off but use a hand drill to drive it with and 'trepan' a hole in the wood around the screw and fit a plug with glue when removed.
Really desparate, try to knock it all the way through with a small punch then glue the splintered wood back together.
Acid - dissolve the screw out - lets not go there but have done it too many times myself in steel, particularly with small taps...........
Last resort of the handyman or first resort of the not so handy / confident, send to your Forum melodeon maintenance and repair depot of choice, they would probably prefer to get it out 'untinkered with' as putting right the damage done in failing to extract may be more difficult to disguise >:E
Any road, best of luck with it.
Richard - in the frozen East
BTW the 'heat the screw up with a soldering iron' is a useful tip for taking old steel screws out of wood when they feel tight and look like they may have rusted a bit.
-
Thanks for the suggestions Richard.
The head of the screw and the first couple of turns have come out leaving the rest firmly embedded. The screw is brass and showed no signs of wear and so I was surprised it snapped.
I think I'll take the low risk option and send it off for a professional fix.
Thanks again.
Owen - also in the frozen (but not yet snowy) East
-
If its brass then rust will not be an issue Owen, I would try to heat it up as suggested and then with a broken / ground down end of a junior hacksaw blade or craft knife, try to scrape a slot in the end for a small diameter screwdriver, this minimises 'collateral damage' and the cooking may just loosen it enough to remove, if the muses are with you, if they#re still agin yer, yup, probably need to go to someone more experienced.
Drilling out a brass screw without the drill drifting off is probably easier than a steel one but Sods law dictates this one will not play ball - its less risky under a drilling machine than by hand.
Richard - who cannot be bothered to return to the shed (0C and falling) to clear up the large box of small bits which crashed to the floor and spread everywhere as he was leaving it......