Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: nemethmik on November 14, 2010, 07:20:14 AM

Title: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: nemethmik on November 14, 2010, 07:20:14 AM
The present D/G setup is a bit of a nonsence IMHO - keys that you never use  ???
I was about to place my order for 21+5 when I started thinking about Chris Ryall's comment. Why to have the high buttons that I never use? I found that Saltarelle has two 19+5 models and they seemed to be (much) smaller than the 21+5 models.
I am thinking of ordering a 19+5 D/G instead of a 21+5.
Here is a layout design I am thinking of for a 19+5. A new concept here is "high C#" accidental.
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: michik on November 14, 2010, 08:06:37 AM
Hm, I'm missing a row of lowest notes of on my 21+7 C/G  ... most of the 'large' C/G accordeons have 23+8 buttons

Maybe it depends on the tunes played and playing style (playing tunes in lower and upper ocatve).
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: nemethmik on November 15, 2010, 08:49:50 PM
Saltarelle Le Romane is a 19 + 5 button 3-voice, 12 bass accordion with "hand made" (a mano) reeds. It's only 4.2 kg. Have you seen or tried Le Romane?
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Microbot on November 15, 2010, 10:07:43 PM
Hi Miklos,

a couple of thoughts - I love the accidentals ... I'd go with that any day. For me, if you're having a 19 button melodeon, I'd want a 3rd button start. I do use the top end ... or at least as much as I use a low G...

I could live without the normal 10th button on the G row (F#/B) and similarly the 11th button on D row. But I wouldn't want to lose 2 off each row of the normal top buttons, which is in effect what you're proposing. The question is, how much would you actually use the very low G?

In short, I like and understand your layout and it might be good for you... But I would have a 3rd button start and regain the top G/E on G-row. I'd lose the bottom G (1st button) and have the C draw in place of the D(draw) you have on button 2, which would be button 1. Lots of people have this adjustment made...

On the D row, I like and would keep the low Eb/F but lose the normal low F#/A ... But I'd also order some additional reeds from Salterelle so I could change my mind and the set-up, If I wanted to!

but in the end its your layout to suit your style and the tunes you want to play ... I only suggest these ideas because you asked for comments! It certainly looks like a lovely box - I've not played or handled one.

cheers

Mike R
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: nemethmik on November 16, 2010, 01:27:35 PM
3rd button start. I do use the top end ... or at least as much as I use a low G...
Excellent comments, Mike!
The reason I killed the highest two buttons that on many traditional folk instruments (Irish pipes, (Hungarian) hurdy-gurdy, for example) the highest note is 3rd octave D; and they are very rarely used, in 99% of the Irish dance tunes the highest note is 2nd octave B. I am very much interested in what tunes/situation do you use 3rd octave G? Maybe you play G tunes in the upper register in "French" G/C style?
The low G might be useful when occasionally hacking out a tune in C on a "fully chromatic" D/G box with 5 accidentals.
I am especially interested in your and anyone else's opinion having an E bass on the push. I'd replace F# bass with E bass. What other bass would be a better option?
Here is a diagram with your (Microbot) recommendations.
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Theo on November 16, 2010, 01:39:32 PM
I find the low G useful in a number of tunes that I play.  It is the lowest note on a fiddle, so it does crop up reasonably often in fiddle tunes.  The low F# never does, though I can see that it would be useful for harmonies, or if you want a low voiced D or Bm chord.  For me the balance is clearly in favour of the low G,  but lit depends what you wNt to play.
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Clive Williams on November 16, 2010, 02:04:27 PM
I am especially interested in your and anyone else's opinion having an E bass on the push.

Yep, interesting that one - I think I've only ever met one tune where I went 'I wish I had Em bass on the push' - Markku Lepisto's Silta. I find F#m on the push *much* more useful... the G, F#, E, D run in tunes like Andy Cutting's In Continental Mood comes to mind, and there's a cracking Skolvan tune, The Gavotte Paths, that uses Em, F and F#m all in quick succession. But the biggest win for me is that you can play in D more or less anything you can play in G, with F#m being the equivalent of Bm in runs like 'D->F#m->G->A' which would be 'G->Bm->C->D' in G. This argument only makes sense if you also have G on the pull and A on the push too of course... which you do.

ChrisR will argue that F# should be on the pull, to facilitate playing in a F# blues scale mostly on the pull, Pignol/Milloret style, and while I've never tried that myself, that makes a lot of sense too.

But then I don't play in A much, and I expect E in both directions would be much more useful if you did.

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: nemethmik on November 16, 2010, 02:24:54 PM
But then I don't play in A much, and I expect E in both directions would be much more useful if you did.
Thank You for the comments, Clive!
The only reason I included E push bass instead of F# bass is that I am playing in A a lot and the G#'s accidentals are on the push. Does this make sense?
I play the regular English/Irish tunes in D/G.
The tunes I play in A are in major, minor (with F), dorian, in mixolydian and very often a combination of them: some bars are in minor other bars of the same tune are in mixolydian or major. Quite common to have D# here and there: that's the reason I'd prefer a 2.5 instead of a pure 3 row (ADG). BTW, the G#'s on an ADG are on the pull side and no need for an E push. Maybe I simply should reverse the G#/Bb accidentals to Bb/G#?

[modification: I play in A major, too]
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Owen Woods on November 16, 2010, 02:37:09 PM
I think that F#min is much, much more useful than E on the push. I am intending to reverse the G# plate so that it is on the pull, this will make runs easier as well. After that there really isn't much point in having it on the push. I would probably go for F# on the pull, but F# on the push would also be useful.
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 16, 2010, 02:37:59 PM
Could I invite you to try the layout on my scalefinder spreadsheet (needs MS Excel) to see how complete the scales you want o play in might be. For example it looks that you have complete Gm and Dm dorian harmonic and simple minors there on the pull. With a G bass. (I really should check though)

If you like minor key play (and it is lovely) - do consider getting 3rd stops on the left hand at design stage. Spreadsheet link in my sigfile below  Chris
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Clive Williams on November 16, 2010, 02:52:59 PM
Maybe I simply should reverse the G#/Bb accidentals to Bb/G#?

Tempting, isn't it? Yes... it *should* fit the chords better, but my experience of accidental using tunes like... La Chansonnette (Sansonette... what *is* this tune called?), Jump at the Sun, Pterodactyl 2 Step, Jiggery Pokerwork etc is that they all seem to prefer the Bb on the pull. Bottom line is that there's no perfect solution... what you go with will be heavily influenced by what you play, and if a chord to match G# is a priority, you're probably going to want to swap the G#/Bb over as you suggest. I keep changing my mind on this sort of thing, and none of my boxes have the same accidental layout as any other!

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 16, 2010, 03:07:54 PM
Sansonette (thrush). Dominique wrote the tune and wanted a name. Then he found a dying small bird on the road on his way home.

But I digress - I think these tunes are all in the 4th mode of B harmonic minor (as is Cliff Stapleton's superb Blue Sausage Island). I agree totally about the need to run that A# (a.k.a Bb) throughas a fluid 'pull' run. Dare I say it was originally in G  :|glug

This looks a super setup for minors - but let me check it  out at home
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Owen Woods on November 16, 2010, 06:56:28 PM
Maybe I simply should reverse the G#/Bb accidentals to Bb/G#?

Tempting, isn't it? Yes... it *should* fit the chords better, but my experience of accidental using tunes like... La Chansonnette (Sansonette... what *is* this tune called?), Jump at the Sun, Pterodactyl 2 Step, Jiggery Pokerwork etc is that they all seem to prefer the Bb on the pull. Bottom line is that there's no perfect solution... what you go with will be heavily influenced by what you play, and if a chord to match G# is a priority, you're probably going to want to swap the G#/Bb over as you suggest. I keep changing my mind on this sort of thing, and none of my boxes have the same accidental layout as any other!

Cheers,

Clive

I think that I could live with Bb on the push, although it would be slightly more inconvenient. I think that ideally you would have F on the push, Eb on the pull, Bb on push and pull and G# on the pull. Plus reversals for C, E and D :P
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Clive Williams on November 17, 2010, 05:00:15 PM
I think that I could live with Bb on the push, although it would be slightly more inconvenient. I think that ideally you would have F on the push, Eb on the pull, Bb on push and pull and G# on the pull. Plus reversals for C, E and D :P

I would certainly want Eb on the push; fits with the B chord (assuming no thirds), and critical in tunes such as Roslin Castle, where it's not a note you can fake/skip easily. F would have to be on the pull for me, assuming F#m is the push chord... which means the only slot left for a F chord on the bass is on the pull.

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: nemethmik on November 17, 2010, 06:23:59 PM
I would certainly want Eb on the push; fits with the B chord (assuming no thirds), and critical in tunes such as Roslin Castle, where it's not a note you can fake/skip easily. F would have to be on the pull for me, assuming F#m is the push chord... which means the only slot left for a F chord on the bass is on the pull.
Clive, what would be your current choice for the 12-bass and the 5 accidentals?
Thanks,
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Owen Woods on November 17, 2010, 06:53:30 PM
I think that I could live with Bb on the push, although it would be slightly more inconvenient. I think that ideally you would have F on the push, Eb on the pull, Bb on push and pull and G# on the pull. Plus reversals for C, E and D :P

I would certainly want Eb on the push; fits with the B chord (assuming no thirds), and critical in tunes such as Roslin Castle, where it's not a note you can fake/skip easily. F would have to be on the pull for me, assuming F#m is the push chord... which means the only slot left for a F chord on the bass is on the pull.

Cheers,

Clive

See I have never felt the need to play D# against a D chord. But F on the push is so convenient for D minor! And D minor is such a lovely key and with a half row it should be that difficult to play. Plus if you have a club bass, the F chord is on the push anyway. Then if you play in G minor it means that the runs down feel more "right", to me anyway.
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Clive Williams on November 18, 2010, 09:32:56 AM
Clive, what would be your current choice for the 12-bass and the 5 accidentals?
Thanks,

Blimey... that very much depends on the melodeon I think. For the one you're looking at, since it's 19+5, I think you need a 3rd button start. The preciosa is the latest box I've acquired, and it has a 3rd button start - this is how it's laid out in D/G speak, (it's 21+4 by the way):

The 1st button on the D row: F# low/ A low (I tend to play with several buttons pressed, and a button that doesn't clash with the rest of the row is a bigger win for me than a low G on the push)
The 1st button on the G row: B low / D low (I'm contradicting the above I guess, but instead of E on the pull I have a low D)
Accidental 1: G# / Bb (this is the opposite way to what the chords would suggest, but that Bb on the pull is just too useful to miss). I'm used to G# on the push from my Pokerwork anyway
Accidental 2:  Eb / F (the position of this button puts the F close-ish to E on the pull - ideally it should be on button 1 to be in the right place (i.e. between buttons 4 and 5 on the G row), but this is as close as I can get, so it's a compromise. The Eb *is* in precisely the right place (how it feels to me anyway) and is on the push to match with a thirds-out B chord (B major in reality)
Accidental 3: C / D (a reversals button)
Accidental 4: G# high / Bb high

If you have 5 buttons at your disposal, I'd probably mix them up slightly to put that D and F in slightly better position (1 to the left of where they are), though clearly this depends on where your 5 buttons start. Assuming they start so Accidental 1 is placed at the same point in the keyboard as button 4 on the D row:

Acc 1: G# / Bb
Acc 2: C   / F
Acc 3: Eb / D
Acc 4: C high / F high
Acc 5: G# high / Bb high

For basses, I'd go semi-unisonoric like this:

C/C   Bm/Em   F#m/F
G/G   D/D       A/A

but if you want something a little more conventional, then I think the Saltarelle bass layout is good:

C/C   Bm/Em   F#m/F
G/D   D/A       A/G

... but, as ever, it depends on what you want to play. I don't play in A much (I pick up an A/D box for that), or in Dm much (I have a C/F box for that) - I'm pretty lazy when it comes to playing in keys other than the 2 major/3 minor main ones. The Castagnari half row layout for example is completely different - it's optimised for playing in G minor I gather, which mine isn't, and the Castagnari bass layout has more chords available at the expense of those lovely reversals of the G and A chords.

So there you go - my opinion (only) on layout - good luck!

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Theo on November 18, 2010, 09:44:53 AM
I think there is a typo in the Saltarelle bass layout:  D/G should be D/A
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Clive Williams on November 18, 2010, 09:54:45 AM
I think there is a typo in the Saltarelle bass layout:  D/G should be D/A

Thank you! :|bl
Title: Re: Saltarelle 19+5 melodeons with 12 basses
Post by: Flanna on November 24, 2010, 04:59:22 PM
I've ordered a new box with a similar layout, it will be 19+6, from Yvus accordions in France. It took a lot of thinking about to get the layout that would be most suitable for the music that I will play on it. The music will be similar to what you (Miklos) play. So, although mine will have an extra button on the half row, perhaps it will give you some more ideas.

Here is the layout I have ordered:

--------------------------(D+/A+)----(D/A)----(G+/D+)----(G/D)--------------------------
--------------------------(B-/E-)------(B/E)----(C+/C+)-----(C/C)--------------------------
--------------------------(A+/G+)----(A/G)---(F#-/F+)----(F#-/F)-------------------------

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

---------------------(F/Eb)--(Bb/G#)--(C/D)---(E/F)----(F/Eb)---(Bb/G#)-------------------
------(B/E)----(D/F#)---(G/A)---(B/C)----(D/E)----(G/F#)----(B/A)----(D/C)---(G/E)-------
(G/C)---(A/C#)----(D/E)---(F#/G)---(A/B)---(D/C#)----(F#/E)---(A/G)----(D/B)---(F#/C#)

Hope it helps ;)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal