Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Telemorris on November 16, 2010, 04:54:12 PM

Title: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Telemorris on November 16, 2010, 04:54:12 PM
Hi,

I'm looking at some Ericas on Ebay. Some have wooden keyboards (evidenced by broken sections) and others have plastic keyboards.

Is it fair to say that the instruments with wood keyboards are older than those with plastic?

Does the inclusion of plastic date from the start of manufacturing the instruments in China?

Am I more likely to get an instrument made in Germany if I buy an instrument with a wooden keyboard?
 
I realize there's a maintenance benefit to the plastic, however, I prefer wood and am able to handle making a new keyboard, if necessary.

Thanks,

Ed
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Theo on November 16, 2010, 05:00:12 PM
Is it fair to say that the instruments with wood keyboards are older than those with plastic?
Yes, but you may find older instruments where the original wood one has been replaced with a later plastic one.

Quote
Does the inclusion of plastic date from the start of manufacturing the instruments in China?
No, the plastic keyboard was introduced many years before the shift to Chin around 2000
German made plastic keyboards are marked 'made in Germany' on the back, though this can wear off.

Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: waltzman on November 16, 2010, 05:46:35 PM
Just to confuse things a bit more, I have an Erica that was made in Switzerland that has a plastic keyboard.
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Ollie on November 16, 2010, 05:57:45 PM
I find I prefer the wooden keyboards... much nicer on the hands. But, personally, I've always been a more, y'know, hominid sort of person... but, whatever floats your boat.


 ;)
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Stiamh on November 16, 2010, 08:24:08 PM
I wish I'd known that a plastic or wooden keyboard might have helped me date some of the Erikas I've come across over the years.  :(  The made in Germany ones were definitely the best...
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 16, 2010, 08:47:09 PM
I have a Red Swiss made Erica, rounded body style that was quite different in construction internally than the german Hohners.  There seems to be no consistency between the swiss and german factories in my experience.  I have a black swiss made Hohner that looks to be made totally different than the red aforementioned Erica so seems like there isn't even consistency in the Swiss factories.  Were the Swiss made boxes just outsourced to Swiss factories?
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Telemorris on November 16, 2010, 08:51:03 PM
Does your Swiss made instrument have that provenance stamped on the underside? Given what I've read in the forum so far, I think I'd prefer an instrument made in Germany.

Ed
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: waltzman on November 16, 2010, 09:08:31 PM
Does your Swiss made instrument have that provenance stamped on the underside? Given what I've read in the forum so far, I think I'd prefer an instrument made in Germany.

Ed

Yes, it does.  It also has a different color red celluloid and silver lettering instead of the gold found on the german made ones.  They are quite rare, at least in the US.  You would have much better luck finding a German made one.  I only mentioned it because of the issue of dating Ericas.  I understand that Hohner started making accordions in Switzerland during the war but no one has been able to tell me how long they were manufactured there.
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Telemorris on November 16, 2010, 09:53:43 PM
I've been looking for information on how to date Hohner's especially Ericas. Haven't found anything much other than discussions of "T" and "H" reeds. Do you know where I can find more specific information? I have a presswood Pokerwork and would like to find a date. I need to look again, but I believe it was made in Germany.
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 16, 2010, 11:23:57 PM
Does your Swiss made instrument have that provenance stamped on the underside? Given what I've read in the forum so far, I think I'd prefer an instrument made in Germany.

Ed

Both Boxes keyboards are stamped made in Switzerland.  I'm led to believe that they are more desirable than german Hohners but I never learned why.   Rarity perhaps?
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Telemorris on November 16, 2010, 11:52:08 PM
Is there any difference in sound or function between the Swiss and German instruments? If so, please describe. Easier/harder to play, speaks quicker (though this may be due more to set up than the manufacturer). Thanks.
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 17, 2010, 12:18:11 AM
In my opinion it simply is the fact that they were made in Switzerland.  Maybe someone more knowledgeable about Hohner can pipe in here!
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: an bosca ceoil on November 17, 2010, 01:34:16 PM
The Erica was introduced in the mid-fifties with wooden keyboard, black bellows and a recessed grille. The keyboards changed to plastic first then the current grille, with raised edges, was introduced to simplify case construction.  (Same thing happened with the Corso and you will find some transitional ones with the casing machined out under a late style grille.) Anything with gold bellows is likely post 1970 and you will even find these marked Swiss, so it has no connection with wartime production.
Although the shapes are identical, reference to "presswood" Pokerworks is somewhat anomalous.
Prior to the modern floral "pokerwork" pattern that Hohner now call Goldbrand they produced a variety of models with  black and gold "sea-shell" decoration and the old Kalbe anchor, same as the "presswood" ones, which I am inclined to think are all post-war/ early fifties.
If your presswood has plastic valves and 880 tuning stamps it will probably be from that era and almost certainly from Trossingen, but I have yet to see one actually marked "Made in Germany".
(During the thirties they were making them with wide bellow frames and shallow case ends, embossed floral decoration but identical mechanics and keyboard)
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Bob Ellis on November 17, 2010, 05:38:00 PM
Yes, I used to date an Erica - nice Australian girl. I wonder what happened to her.  ;D ::)
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Graham Spencer on November 17, 2010, 10:07:32 PM
I seem to recall there was a fashion (maybe there still is!) for aftermarket replacement wooden keyboards for Ericas (Ericae?) and Pokerworks, so for the keyboard material to be useful in dating a box you'd have to know whether the keyboard was original or a retro-fitted modification.
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Telemorris on November 17, 2010, 11:33:25 PM
Sounds like dating might be more accurate by looking at the grille design. Recessed grilles might be a better indicator that the instrument was made in Germany, or Switzerland? I've been finding some instruments with recessed grilles and plastic keyboards with no "Made in Germany" engraved in the plastic.
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Theo on November 18, 2010, 08:27:46 AM
The trouble for all this is that both the various fingerboard and grill designs are interchangeable.  I have replaced many cracked and broken fingerboards, and badly corroded grills.  Bellows colour changed from black to gold at some point, but bellows can be replaced too. 

Does it really matter anyway?   

The design has remained essentially the same since the mid 50s so the age of the instrument is much less important than its condition and how well it plays.
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: rees on November 18, 2010, 11:35:39 AM
The trouble for all this is that both the various fingerboard and grill designs are interchangeable.  I have replaced many cracked and broken fingerboards, and badly corroded grills.  Bellows colour changed from black to gold at some point, but bellows can be replaced too. 

Does it really matter anyway?   

The design has remained essentially the same since the mid 50s so the age of the instrument is much less important than its condition and how well it plays.

Seconded.
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 18, 2010, 05:20:05 PM
Quote
The design has remained essentially the same since the mid 50s so the age of the instrument is much less important than its condition and how well it plays.

Yep! Here's an example (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkSVAHhFTVM) of a really grotty old box that Theo worked his magic on for me. Looks horrible, but plays like a dream, AND it has a new plastic keyboard. It's the old adage, 'it's what's on the inside that matters'.
AL
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 18, 2010, 06:39:25 PM
Al you had me singing the words to What a Friend We Have in Jesus...brought back many a Sunday morning worship...Bravo!
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 18, 2010, 06:46:00 PM
Quote
Al you had me singing the words
;)
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: an bosca ceoil on November 19, 2010, 12:53:37 AM
(  The made in Germany ones were definitely the best...

In what respect definitely?
I know that Hohner had a few problems while they were moving production but what is now so inferior about the Chinese made Erica, compared to the ones they were making in Germany?
Admittedly they are now a tad garish cosmetically and the tuning still "near enough", but they have improved the pallets and put sensible bass end on the Double-Rays.
Only thing I really do not like is the inferior finish of the buttons and keyboard but  these changes may well have taken place even if they were still home grown.

Sounds like dating might be more accurate by looking at the grille design. Recessed grilles might be a better indicator that the instrument was made in Germany, or Switzerland? I've been finding some instruments with recessed grilles and plastic keyboards with no "Made in Germany" engraved in the plastic.

As has been said, precise dating is pretty irrelevant because if you fit enough new bits to an early instrument you presumably wind up with a Chinese hybrid?
A recessed grille almost certainly indicates early German manufacture, because it cannot be fitted in place of a raised one (but an awful lot of those were fitted before Hohner upped sticks to the New World) and it is not very likely that old black and orange bellows will have been retro fitted to a recent instrument, in place of  gold and red ones.
The fact that "Made in Germany" is not visible means very little because it was often only printed, rather than engraved, and can wear off , some Swiss instruments only had  a label affixed to the body and an unmarked keyboard.
Given what I've read in the forum so far, I think I'd prefer an instrument made in Germany.
Ed
If you are buying at a distance and really do not want anything Chinese, avoid instruments with the HOHNER printed "vertically" in large letters (as opposed to parallel with the bellow folds)
Al you had me singing the words to What a Friend We Have in Jesus...brought back many a Sunday morning worship...Bravo!

And there was me thinking he was playing "Changes" , that plastic really conflicts with the "patina" ;)



Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Theo on November 19, 2010, 07:58:52 AM
(  The made in Germany ones were definitely the best...

In one other respect the Chinese ones are better than the later German made ones.   For some years before production moved to China they uses a black plastic end frame for the bellows.  These are less stiff than wood, and they are prone to damage around the pin holes.  Since the move to China they have reverted to wood end frames, a definite improvement.  Mind you the gold bellows tape is still a rubbishy paper which wears incredibly easily.
Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on November 19, 2010, 12:32:10 PM
Mind you the gold bellows tape is still a rubbishy paper which wears incredibly easily.

Wonder if they ever sacked whoever ordered 250 billion metres of the stuff?   :'(

I personally hate the vinyl bellows straps, wrist strap and thumbstrap they use. They last about 10 nano-seconds before either splitting, cracking or becoming just too hard to be of any use.

I had a pokerwork in for repair this week, purchased new a couple of months ago. All the bass buttons had become far too high and I had to do a bit of bending to get them back to a reasonable level. I was amazed just how easy they were to bend. The treble action was not as bad, but on its way to the same problem.

And, of course, I had to wear sunglasses while working on the thing....That gold paint is just too bright!    ;D

Title: Re: Dating Erica's with wood vs. plastic keyboards.
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 22, 2010, 04:10:11 PM
I'm assuming that gold bellows tape is simply just there for economical purposes, cheap!  They even offer it for sale on the spare parts list that Al just posted.  I wonder how much of that stuff they sell!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal