Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on November 16, 2010, 09:19:33 PM

Title: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 16, 2010, 09:19:33 PM
Dear Assembled Sages,
I've mentioned this in a previous thread, I've been playing around in between practising tunes, with bass runs as in Stoney Steps HP, and on the 'B' music use the bass notes to run up from low G,A,B,C to get onto the D and E of the D row.
It's good exercise to get to know the bases and also getting my left hand working.
Apart from the painful stuttering of the left hand trying making it work, my ear's telling me something's not quite right on the basses.
Over the last couple of weeks, I've tried friends new Erica, and two oakwoods ( don't ask - yes they were nice! ) and I could hear the run up the bases and they sounded ok.

Tonight I was playing around whilst my daughter blew the notes on her flute, I squeezed the bass notes and she kept one eye on her flute tuner. She too was puzzled.
I'd squeeze, she'd blow... we were fine G,A,B, but C..???  her tuner was saying each bass note was spot on, but the C bass sounded strange though it said it was C.
Then we both twigged - bass notes G,A, and B were ascending, but the C was lower. A spot on good C, but an octave lower than the other basses.
Is this usual for Castagnari's?
yours somewhat puzzled
Q

Title: Re: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Anahata on November 17, 2010, 11:08:11 AM
Then we both twigged - bass notes G,A, and B were ascending, but the C was lower. A spot on good C, but an octave lower than the other basses.

There has to be an octave leap somewhere, on any accordion or melodeon bass.
I think it is common to make the break  between B and C because as it is only a semitone gap the ear tends to hear the small step up instead of the big step down.

Also as the basses usually have at least two reeds tuned an octave apart, there is actually a semitone step from the high reed on the B to the low reed on the C, which helps with the illusion of a semitone step. Some melodeons have three reeds per bass note, and I think the Castagnari Lilly has two reeds set two octaves apart per bass note, so you might well hear a jump there.
Title: Re: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 17, 2010, 09:40:00 PM
Thanks for the reassurance, I had no idea about the octave thing.
Tonight I've had a quick play comparing it with my Tenor Treble concertina. The C sounds more in keeping with a low C, an octave below middle C ( this low C is my concertina's lowest note ). There's also more than one reed in play, though I can't say if it's 2 or 3 reeds.
The same is true across the other bases, but the reeds do seem to be higher.
Well there you go - something else I've learnt!
thanks as ever....
Q

Title: Re: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Anahata on November 19, 2010, 02:27:06 PM
Just tried on my Saltarelle. I think the octave break comes between A and B. I guess it varies from box to box.
It's quite hard to hear because that box has reeds on three octave levels per bass note, so two are stepping up, while a high reed is vanishing and a low one appearing.

Title: Re: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 19, 2010, 05:54:18 PM
I've not yet picked up the courage to open up my Tommy yet, so not sure what's inside it.
As you say, there are 'more than 1' reeds playing on the bass note, with a range of pitch and it's difficult to worlk out what on earth's going on!
Hey ho.
All part of the fun.
Q
Title: Re: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Lester on November 19, 2010, 06:21:43 PM
The fact that the Tommy has shared reeds* in the bass end may be a reason for the pitching of the C bass.

*Shared reeds for beginners:
Rather than having a low and high bass reed and three reeds for the chord the high bass reeds is shared by the chord thus saving a reed - so my Tommy has 16 reeds in the bass end and my Erica, for instance, has 20.
Title: Re: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 19, 2010, 08:16:28 PM
Ahhh.... I'd vaguely heard about that.
I remember a friend going on about this before I took the plunge and bought a box, but I didn't understand or see the significance at the time
cheers
Q
Title: Re: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Theo on November 19, 2010, 08:28:02 PM
The fact that the Tommy has shared reeds* in the bass end may be a reason for the pitching of the C bass.


I don't see a particular reason why the requirements to share the higher tonic reed would make a difference to which bass reed was the lowest. 

Small format instruments have less space for the bass reeds than a full size box, so the small size of the reedblock and the chamber within it can set a lower limit on the pitch of bass reed that will perform properly.
Title: Re: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Lester on November 19, 2010, 09:36:35 PM
The fact that the Tommy has shared reeds* in the bass end may be a reason for the pitching of the C bass.


I don't see a particular reason why the requirements to share the higher tonic reed would make a difference to which bass reed was the lowest. 

Small format instruments have less space for the bass reeds than a full size box, so the small size of the reedblock and the chamber within it can set a lower limit on the pitch of bass reed that will perform properly.

My thought train was that the shared reed octave would be driven by the need to make the correct chord thus forcing the octave of the lower bass reed. May be I am just deluded   ???
Title: Re: Normal Bass set up on D/G?
Post by: Theo on November 20, 2010, 09:03:45 AM
Depends what you mean by the "correct" chord.   If you check the pitch of the chord reeds in most boxes you will find that the voicing varies from chord to chord.   Typically all the chord reeds are with a range of one octave,  some might have the tonic in root position, others will be first or second inversions.   Hohners typically have different inversions for the two D chords on a D/G.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal