Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Telemorris on November 30, 2010, 08:24:41 PM

Title: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Telemorris on November 30, 2010, 08:24:41 PM
I just picked up this Hohner from Fleabay. Still waiting for it to arrive. Given the damage to the bellows and the keyboard, I'll probably use it for a tuning table setup and keep the reeds for replacements along the way.

I'm wondering what model it is? It's a three row, 31 button, but it has 16 bass buttons. What are the likely tunings and given a tuning, how are the basses arranged? Any idea of possible age of the box?

Thanks,

Ed
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 30, 2010, 08:26:39 PM
Suspiciously like an early BCC# type box with a mini-stradella bass? Whereabouts does it come from?
AL
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Theo on November 30, 2010, 08:41:58 PM
And a bit too nice to scrap for parts I think.   
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 30, 2010, 08:49:46 PM
Agreed! It's got potential that box methinks - mind you, remember my last Hohner Horror?
It's certainly in better condition than that one! Shame to consign it to melodeon heaven.
 ;D
It may even be some sort of primitive CBA - are there any other name or number markings on it all?
AL
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Theo on November 30, 2010, 09:04:58 PM
With only 32 treble my guess is its diatonic,  could be GCF, a semitone system or a mixed system eg GCB, though I have only seen the latter on Italian makes.  It has the nice slightly curved shaping for the grill that only seem to be used on better quality boxes.
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: NeilA on November 30, 2010, 09:22:08 PM
Looks like it might be this model (although the description is wrong re the number of rows) the picture looks like it.

http://www.musicaviva.com/instruments/gallery/display.html?serienr=6908 (http://www.musicaviva.com/instruments/gallery/display.html?serienr=6908)
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: pgroff on November 30, 2010, 09:24:53 PM
Hi all,

I'm with Theo on this...

Hohner did advertise GCB and CFE boxes in one late 1920s catalog I have.  However, out of dozens of examples of 1920s - 1930s Hohners that look like the one pictured (3-rows with 31 melody keys and 16 basses) that I have seen in the US, *all* have been diatonics with the rows a fourth apart (FBbEb, F#BE [FisHE], GCF, ADG, BbEbAb etc.).

These were good models if you don't mind the small diameter buttons, but very heavy on the bass side (especially since the reeds are likely on zinc plates).

PG
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Theo on November 30, 2010, 09:32:15 PM
Given the damage to the bellows and the keyboard

I can see the keyboard is deficient, but the bellows look ok apart from some green corrosion on the corners, which will probably polish off.

If you want bellows and other parts i might be able to make a trade with you?
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Christopher K. on November 30, 2010, 09:41:09 PM
Funny, I was watching that one, too. Glad to know who got it!
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Telemorris on November 30, 2010, 10:04:47 PM
Here's the link to the Ebay auction. If you look at the other photos, you'll see that the first fold in the bellows on the treble side is ripped wide open on the underside. I'm assuming I'll need a new bellows for this instrument hence my thoughts about using the bellows for a tuning table.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rt=nc&nma=true&item=200545856116&si=8MJimc33MfmkTFZuU9xTkfwoGlg%253D&viewitem=&sspagename=STRK%3AMEWAX%3AIT

I have no idea about the condition other than the photos. The seller didn't have any idea what the tuning was, nor whether any of the reeds make a sound. I did pick it up for a good price given the condition. It should arrive in another day or two.

I can't afford to buy new bellows so I'll probably have to make a new set. Another thing to learn to do.
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Ziachmusi/Louise on December 01, 2010, 05:13:07 AM
the bellows might not be as bad as you think, looks to me as if they have just come away from the bellows frame. With a bit of  luck glue might do the job (:)
Hope the box exceeds your expectations - would be great if you could save it :||: :||:

Louise
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Telemorris on December 01, 2010, 05:16:49 PM
I'll see what I can do with it once it arrives. I'm looking forward to getting it in my hands. If I can repair the bellows, I'll still need a scrap bellows for a reed tuning setup. Maybe I'll need to do some bellows building after all.
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Theo on December 01, 2010, 05:26:52 PM
Just look for a scrap piano accordion.   Round here they are much more common,  and the extra size is an advantage too for more air volume.
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Telemorris on December 01, 2010, 07:13:51 PM
Theo,

 Thanks, that's very good advice. I'll see what I can find in a cheap or free piano accordion. I've got melodeon on the brain. MAD for sure. I've now got three, all in need of repairs. In the middle of a production of the Portland Christmas Revels and unable to put my hands on my melodeon. It's frustrating given that I've just discovered the joys of working on melodeons.

Thanks again!  ;D
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Clive Williams on December 02, 2010, 09:50:49 AM
A cracking example of this model came up on ebay (150526468311 if you're interested) last night; I was put off bidding mostly because I'm not sure about the internal construction of the model - and in particular, whether the reeds are on separate plates per button or one big plate per bank.

Once it turns up, I'd really appreciate it if you could let us know what you find inside about how these Hohners are put together...

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Telemorris on December 02, 2010, 04:25:18 PM
A cracking example of this model came up on ebay (150526468311 if you're interested) last night...

Once it turns up, I'd really appreciate it if you could let us know what you find inside about how these Hohners are put together...


I was also watching that auction. It's a beautiful instrument.

I'll do some documentation of my instrument once it arrives. I'm very curious about what I find. Sounds like you want photos of the reed blocks and the treble sound board arrangement. Let me know if you'd like any other photos.

Regards,

Ed

Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Clive Williams on December 02, 2010, 04:45:47 PM
I'll do some documentation of my instrument once it arrives. I'm very curious about what I find. Sounds like you want photos of the reed blocks and the treble sound board arrangement. Let me know if you'd like any other photos.

Yes please - that's exactly what I'm interested in.

Thanks,

Clive
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: pgroff on December 02, 2010, 05:30:05 PM
A cracking example of this model came up on ebay (150526468311 if you're interested) last night; I was put off bidding mostly because I'm not sure about the internal construction of the model - and in particular, whether the reeds are on separate plates per button or one big plate per bank.

Once it turns up, I'd really appreciate it if you could let us know what you find inside about how these Hohners are put together...

Cheers,

Clive

Clive,

Isn't that (#150526468311) the same instrument recently discussed here:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5260.0.html

I have seen a few similar Hoher 3-row instruments with that fancy grille and stepped keyboard -- and I still have a nice unrestored example with steel tongues on individual zinc plates. However in my experience, unless they are labeled "Steel Reeds," this body style usually contains brass tongues on individual zinc plates.  When I get a chance, I will look this model up in some of my old catalogs and edit the thread to add the model number(s) for this body style.

PG
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Clive Williams on December 03, 2010, 12:43:33 AM
Clive,

Isn't that (#150526468311) the same instrument recently discussed here:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5260.0.html

PG

Ah yes, so it is - a shame really - the body and reeds would seem to be in good restorable nick, but the bellows are shot. Doh!

Cheers,
Clive
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Theo on December 03, 2010, 09:27:43 AM
the bellows are shot.

New bellows can be made to the size, corner shape and colours required...
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: pgroff on December 03, 2010, 04:35:13 PM
Telemorris,

In answer to your first question, Hohner (US?) catalog No. 700, probably from the late 1920s, lists your ebay accordion (or one looking identical to me) as "No. 499/31/16."  The Musica Viva website link above is in error about the "31" part of the model number as well as in the description of number of rows.  Another catalog and playing guide I have from Hohner is dated 1929 and illustrates this same model on the cover, and inside the catalog section of that publication the model number is listed as "No. 499."  I have two unrestored but near-mint examples of this model, one in GCF and one in FBbEb.

Clive,

The accordion you mentioned, that sold to HarpDave, was evidently returned, and just sold again.  This has a 3-row open-action stepped keyboard, a complex wooden grille, and 16 basses. Though the body style is very different from the 499 as described above, and sales of the two body styles overlapped, this body style was also sometimes called the 499 in early years, but usually called the 498.  In my ca. 1907 Hohner catalog the same illustration of a 3 row, stepped keyboard, 16 bass box is listed as model 498 (with brass reeds?) or model 499 (with steel reeds); while similar to the ebay box, the one shown in that early catalog has a simpler wooden grille.  In the 1929 catalog, a box exactly like the recent ebay box (same complex wooden grille, but without the attached harmonica cover-plate) is listed as model 498 (evidently with brass reeds); in this catalog, the number 499 was used only for the closed action, flat metal keyboard version with metal grille and steel reeds (as above).  However I have seen a couple of examples of this "1929 type Model 498 body with stepped keyboard, and complex wooden grille" that did have steel reeds and were so labeled on the accordion.  I have a very good unrestored example of this latter body with steel reeds in GCF, probably needing a new bellows.


Will try to get up some pics of these.

PG
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Telemorris on December 05, 2010, 12:58:50 AM
I received the instrument last night. I've got other things going on today and won't be able to take pictures until tomorrow, I hope.

Preliminary inspection shows that it's probably an ADG (stamped on the keyboard end). I'll do some testing of the reeds tomorrow to verify the keys. I was able to pull only five of the eight bellows pins because of rust. Three pins sheared off in spite of the care with which I approached the task. Storage of the instrument must have been in a damp basement as there's failure of quite a few glue joints, rust in many places, verdigris on the bellows corners, and so forth.

The bellows are shot. Many holes in the leather gussets though the cardboard seems sound. The original seal of the bellows to the bellows frame must have failed a long time ago. It looks like the joint between paper and wood was starved for glue since there's little evidence that any glue was applied along a long and a short side of the bellows frame. I was able to get the bellows off, finally but both bellows frames came away in pieces and will need to be repaired before I can build a new bellows. I'll patch the old bellows to use for a tuning bench. 

It's a basic three row diatonic, two reeds per push and pull. I don't know yet if all the reeds work. The seating of the reed plates is the interesting/puzzling thing though. Either Hohner or a repair person used cork and leather with screws and right-angle brackets to seal the reed plates to the blocks rather than wax, a real surprise. Simple in the extreme to remove the reed plates. Both the treble and bass sides are sealed this way. The sound board has leather glued to it to provide a seal for the reed blocks rather than the felt I find glued to the reed blocks on my Presswood Pokerwork. Not the best of seals since the blocks were shifting as I turned the hold down bracket, both on the bass and treble sides. I don't know if the sound boards are flat yet; that could be the cause of the looseness of the reed blocks. 

Not sure what to do about the button board as one of the keys is broken. Yes, I can make a new key and create a relief for the two buttons that must pass through the shaft on either side. However, the keyboard design seems prone to failure, and has already done so. The longest keys have cut outs for the upper two rows buttons where a sizable section either side of the key shaft has been removed .The keys don't have continuous wood grain along the length of the shaft.

All reeds are H reeds. Some rust but a cursory inspection shows the rust is minimal, or seems so to my untrained eye. Of course the valves need replacement.

Will post more and put pictures up tomorrow. Can't remember the numbers written on the blocks and the sound board on the treble side.
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: syale on January 12, 2014, 04:07:29 AM
Ed, I bought one of these recently so trying to find out as much as i can about it! Mine is in relatively good condition. No broken pieces for the mechanics. The varnish on the outside is crackled (crazed). It needs work, tuning, valves and new pallet leathers etc but a keeper for sure. It is GCF (stamped on the keyboard).
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: syale on January 13, 2014, 04:56:40 AM
I have mapped the treble end and some chords. Still working on the mapping.

https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1MDap4PT9XxZv7dktqZbUs1CcN2sMNF0dH7x7seW6eHA/edit?usp=sharing (https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1MDap4PT9XxZv7dktqZbUs1CcN2sMNF0dH7x7seW6eHA/edit?usp=sharing)

Stephen
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: AlexCJones on January 18, 2014, 05:17:39 PM
I have mapped the treble end and some chords. Still working on the mapping.

https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1MDap4PT9XxZv7dktqZbUs1CcN2sMNF0dH7x7seW6eHA/edit?usp=sharing (https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1MDap4PT9XxZv7dktqZbUs1CcN2sMNF0dH7x7seW6eHA/edit?usp=sharing)

Stephen
I bought one of these years ago.  For the last year, mine was in the shop.  Anyway, when I first bought it, I scanned an image for a normal 12-bass GCF from a Hohner instruction book, and using Microsoft Paint, modified it to be my 16-bass GCF.  One version is the horizontal format, and the other is the typical vertical mirror format that is found in accordion instruction books, only this one I edited to have the additional buttons.

(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=5474.0;attach=12986)(http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=5474.0;attach=12988)
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: syale on January 18, 2014, 09:19:16 PM
Many thanks. This is truly wonderful!  :||:

Stephen
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: AlexCJones on January 18, 2014, 11:53:06 PM
I have higher resolution nad higher quality versions, but the forum has a file size limit, so I tried a few things to reduce the file size.  The best quality per file size ones were the .gif versions, but this forum would not allow me to upload in that format.

I just now tested pulling one of the high-quality versions into a Word document and saving it as .PDF, and I got that to work. The images are better quality while I reduced the file size for each to below the 256K limit, so I was able to successfully attach them to this reply.  So if anyone can use them, the pdfs on this reply look a lot like the ones in the previous one, only they are much clearer and in .pdf format.
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: syale on January 19, 2014, 02:19:18 AM
Let me start off by saying that musical theory is not my forte but I am becoming aware that I may need to read up on it. I see that the Chord/Bass arrangement for buttons 1 and 2 is D/A. For the bass reeds for D The notes on the staff are both B, 1 octave apart. Why are the notes B if the bass is called D?
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: AlexCJones on January 19, 2014, 03:17:27 AM
Let me start off by saying that musical theory is not my forte but I am becoming aware that I may need to read up on it. I see that the Chord/Bass arrangement for buttons 1 and 2 is D/A. For the bass reeds for D The notes on the staff are both B, 1 octave apart. Why are the notes B if the bass is called D?
What are you talking about?  Those are not Bs, they are Ds.  That is a BASS clef, not a treble clef.  It is also known as the "F" clef, because those 2 dots and the head of the curly-Q mark the second line from the top as being an F.  So the middle line in the bass clef is a D, not a B. The same is true for the spot below the first ledger line below the bass staff -- that is also a D.

The clef at the beginning of the staff is not just there to just look pretty, it actually determines which pitches are assigned to the lines.  If you don't believe me, read about it here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clef (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clef)


I take it that if you have ever sung in a choir, or performance, that you sing tenor.  Tenors!  They always get the babes!  And basses are always cast as villains.
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: syale on January 19, 2014, 04:03:24 AM
Whoops  :|bl

I play by ear and am trying to learn to read music albeit, it seems, very slowly  :(
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: AlexCJones on January 21, 2014, 04:01:50 AM
To come to think of it, showing the basses in standard staff notation is really unnecessary, and if little benefit--even to those of us who do read music.  The only reason why these diagrams are that way is that Hohner supplied the original ones that way in their instruction book, and I just did modifications with Microsoft Paint.  For the actual pieces in this instruction book, instead of just putting the chord names above the staff, they use a system usually used for piano accordion music, where the bass staff is used to indicate which chord to use, but not by showing all of the notes in the chord either.  But for diatonic accordion, I do not get accordion books--I get fiddle tune books, and they just show the one staff, and the chord names above.  (or often books that are instrument-neutral, which also do not use piano-accordion style).  My guess is that other melodeon players who read music find this the case too--that we read tunes meant for fiddle or instrument-neutral books, and not from books meant for piano accordion.


Back to the diagram: For the bass roots, I can just do Bb, F, D, A etc, and for the bass chords, just use the same way as for Guitar, mandolin, Autoharp etc, with assuming major, by default, and a lowercase "m" for minor, etc, where A = A major, Dm = D minor.

For the treble keyboard, there is still some value in showing it in standard notation, since that helps when reading the fiddle tunes, but I can make one that uses another system.  Diagrams should use a system that indicates the octaves of the pitches, so I am okay with Acoustical Society of America (C0-B0,C1-B1, etc, where C4 = middle C) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_pitch_notation (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_pitch_notation) or Helmholtz http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helmholtz_pitch_notation (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helmholtz_pitch_notation).  So, I can redo these diagrams so that the Basses just use letters and standard alphabetic chords (A,Dm, Am, E, Em, B), and the treble side in either ASA or Helmholtz.
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: syale on January 21, 2014, 05:52:24 AM
I have mapped the treble end and some chords. Still working on the mapping.

https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1MDap4PT9XxZv7dktqZbUs1CcN2sMNF0dH7x7seW6eHA/edit?usp=sharing (https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1MDap4PT9XxZv7dktqZbUs1CcN2sMNF0dH7x7seW6eHA/edit?usp=sharing)


 I have done that here...
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: squeezy on January 21, 2014, 10:03:30 AM
I am just guessing - but I reckon there's a fairly strong chance that your Bdim chord is a result of tuning issues and should be either a B major or possibly minor.  Taking it a step further - there's a fairly good chance that the D minor pull (paired with G major on the push) - should actually be a D major pull for playing along the inside G row.

My only reasoning for that is because every old Hohner left hand layout of that period has pretty much been set out in columns that correspond to the tuning of the diatonic rows on the right hand with a fairly predictable pattern.

I like the idea of a diminished chord on a melodeon - but it's definitely a luxury item!
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: Theo on January 21, 2014, 11:24:31 AM
I think that some of the reeds on buttons 9 and 10 have been flipped over.  Following the pattern as suggested by squeezy it would make more sense to have push B and pull E bass and chords there.  That also avoids the duplicated E/Em on push.  I'm still puzzled though because the extra note you need to make a Bdim is F which you would not get from the notes of the E chord.  It is also just possible that an incorrect note was fitted from new.
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: AlexCJones on January 27, 2014, 04:27:40 AM
On my 16 Bass GCF, I have a D major on the pull for the Bass button shown as #3 in syale's pdf.

Bass button #9 on mine is an E minor on the push and a B major on the pull.  Do what you want with the Bdim, but I would strongly suggest that you get your #3 bass button tuned to give a D major on the pull.  You already have a D minor on the pull with #13, and when playing in G, I would find it painful without a D major available on the pull

In a monthly Sea Shanty get-together, one guy plays Mingulay Boat Song accompanied by guitar, and he first plays a C major under a certain part of the melody, but then when those same notes are repeated, he plays an E minor, so having the E minor on the push is beneficial to me in that situation -- when an E minor is substituted for a C major.

[edited to correct "pfd" to "pdf"]
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: AlexCJones on February 01, 2014, 05:01:37 AM
Telemorris,

In answer to your first question, Hohner (US?) catalog No. 700, probably from the late 1920s, lists your ebay accordion (or one looking identical to me) as "No. 499/31/16."  The Musica Viva website link above is in error about the "31" part of the model number as well as in the description of number of rows.  Another catalog and playing guide I have from Hohner is dated 1929 and illustrates this same model on the cover, and inside the catalog section of that publication the model number is listed as "No. 499."  I have two unrestored but near-mint examples of this model, one in GCF and one in FBbEb.

Clive,

The accordion you mentioned, that sold to HarpDave, was evidently returned, and just sold again.  This has a 3-row open-action stepped keyboard, a complex wooden grille, and 16 basses. Though the body style is very different from the 499 as described above, and sales of the two body styles overlapped, this body style was also sometimes called the 499 in early years, but usually called the 498.  In my ca. 1907 Hohner catalog the same illustration of a 3 row, stepped keyboard, 16 bass box is listed as model 498 (with brass reeds?) or model 499 (with steel reeds); while similar to the ebay box, the one shown in that early catalog has a simpler wooden grille.  In the 1929 catalog, a box exactly like the recent ebay box (same complex wooden grille, but without the attached harmonica cover-plate) is listed as model 498 (evidently with brass reeds); in this catalog, the number 499 was used only for the closed action, flat metal keyboard version with metal grille and steel reeds (as above).  However I have seen a couple of examples of this "1929 type Model 498 body with stepped keyboard, and complex wooden grille" that did have steel reeds and were so labeled on the accordion.  I have a very good unrestored example of this latter body with steel reeds in GCF, probably needing a new bellows.


Will try to get up some pics of these.

PG
So what I have, (see my avatar) , my Hohner 31 button 16-bass steel-reeded GCF, is a 499/31/16 ?  At one point, someone asked for pictures, and I recently got it back from the shop.   So,  maybe this weekend, I will shoot a bunch more photos, with the bellows open too, and maybe some of the inside.

And do I understand you correctly that you have  an "unrestored but near-mint" example in FBbEb?  WHat are your plans for that one?  I like these 3-row 499s, because I like the sound of the basses (only diatonics have the "growl" or what someone else described as "like butter"), yet they have enough accidentals to do a more than you can with the 2-row diatonics, they smaller and are not as heavy as most of the modern 3-rows made today, so they seem to do bellows direction changes better (though not as nimble as a 2-row HA-2815 of course) and I really like the way they look!

I recently bought a small Venezia 3-row to get restored, but that was a miss.  There was too much is wrong with it on the inside.  Then most shops try to get me to consider a modern 3-row that looks like something that would land at an airport or something that should be whirling around in an amusement park with people inside it.  Those do have their charm, but I am thinking smaller and more wooden-looking -- just like the one in my avatar or what syale just bought. 

It seems that syale, and you and a few other folks here see the beauty in these 499s.  Would that be correct to start calling these the "499/31/16s" or just the "499s" for short?

[edited to change "32 button" to "31 button"]
Title: Re: What model is this Hohner.
Post by: AlexCJones on February 02, 2014, 05:17:16 PM
Someone once asked me to post photos of my own 16 bass, 31 button, which I now believe is a 499/31/16.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,14113.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,14113.0.html)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal