Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Noodle on December 02, 2010, 12:10:42 PM

Title: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Noodle on December 02, 2010, 12:10:42 PM
I quite like the look of metal and it doesn't usually take e long to start imagining what things would look like if they were made from it.

The only times I've seen metal on sqeezeboxs are grilles and the odd fingerboard. How feasible is it to construct a melodeon, for example, entirely out of it (bellows obviously won't be :P)? What potential problems could there be? Has it actually been done?
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Graham W on December 02, 2010, 12:57:28 PM
It's entirely feasible in that any suitably skilled engineer / toolmaker would be able to make and assemble the components. After all, a melodeon is much, much simpler than many other mechanical assemblies that are made in vast quantities every day.

Whether it would be a worthwile exercise is another thing, interesting though . . . go for it ;D
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Malcolm Austen on December 02, 2010, 01:36:55 PM
Condensation?
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Noodle on December 02, 2010, 01:39:52 PM
Condensation?
Silica gel?
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Owen Woods on December 02, 2010, 01:42:43 PM
Soundboards are often made of metal anyway. As are fingerboards. Acoustics would be interesting.

A brushed aluminium box would be quite cool I have to admit. Or a polished brass one for that matter.

Hmm, I wonder whether they would let me do that as a fourth year project? :P

EDIT: I think that the biggest problem might be the reedblocks. I'm not sure that metal reedblocks would work particularly well. Dunno about metal pallets either.
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Quebecois on December 02, 2010, 02:58:33 PM
I think that the biggest problem might be the reedblocks. I'm not sure that metal reedblocks would work particularly well.
They would probably work but their fabrication might be tricky! Also the weight factor.

Besides, metal conducts heat and cold in a very different way than wood!

How about a "Vistalite" or acrylic melodeon instead? Or carbon fibre?
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Broadland Boy on December 02, 2010, 03:31:27 PM
Condensation?
Silica gel?

Silica gel only absorbs a certain amount of moisture some of which it can release again if temp rises, it periodically needs a session in the oven to drive off the water and allowing it to start absorbing it again.

A carbon fibre box might have interesting acoustics.......

Richard
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 02, 2010, 03:55:42 PM
How about a "Vistalite" or acrylic melodeon instead?

The idea of a clear acrylic box really appeals to me (yes, I know I'm a bit weird!); see-through bellows could be a bit of a challenge, but I like the idea of being able to see all the mechanical gubbins working while the box is being played.  It's been done with the violin family, and I guess probably with woodwind as well, so..............
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Quebecois on December 02, 2010, 04:27:14 PM
Yeah, a see-through melodeon would definitely be a head turner! Plus the fact that it would be more "acceptable" to use keys with wooden palettes, etc.

In fact, the casings of the treble and bass sides could be made of transparent acrylic while using wooden reedblocks, regular cardboard bellows, etc. and the whole thing would become an educational instrument!  
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Owen Woods on December 02, 2010, 04:50:08 PM
The idea of a clear acrylic box really appeals to me (yes, I know I'm a bit weird!); see-through bellows could be a bit of a challenge, but I like the idea of being able to see all the mechanical gubbins working while the box is being played.  It's been done with the violin family, and I guess probably with woodwind as well, so..............

Yes, you can get clear clarinets I know.

Yeah, a see-through melodeon would definitely be a head turner! Plus the fact that it would be more "acceptable" to use keys with wooden palettes, etc.

In fact, the casings of the treble and bass sides could be made of transparent acrylic while using wooden reedblocks, regular cardboard bellows, etc. and the whole thing would become an educational instrument!  

And it wouldn't be too tricky to make, perhaps easier than with wood. The fingerboard would be tricky though.
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 02, 2010, 04:58:35 PM
Yes, you can get clear clarinets I know.
Which allow all the dribble, spit and condensation to be clearly visible running down the bore as you play. I speak from experience!  :o  :|bl
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Christopher K. on December 02, 2010, 05:01:08 PM
There is a company in Germany that makes a carbon fiber Steirische accordion. I don't know if their reedblocks are carbon fiber, or just the casework. The paintjobs were more like something you'd expect from Mexico rather than Germany.
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: diatonix on December 02, 2010, 06:10:14 PM
I remember visiting a small German melodeon factory near Klingenthal back in 1994 that manufactured "Glas-Harmonikas" or see through melodeons, I think they used some sort of fiber or plexi glass. Also the bellows were transparent. But they had to learn the hard way that what potential customers find interesting is not necessarily what they end up buying... Today they are no longer in business. (I played several of them but don't recall any special acoustic effect or benefits).
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: phkrh on December 02, 2010, 09:54:18 PM
I quite like the look of metal and it doesn't usually take e long to start imagining what things would look like if they were made from it.

The only times I've seen metal on sqeezeboxs are grilles and the odd fingerboard. How feasible is it to construct a melodeon, for example, entirely out of it (bellows obviously won't be :P)? What potential problems could there be? Has it actually been done?

Edge-welded stainless steel bellows could be arranged...

http://www.metalflexbellows.com/assets/images/capabilities/custom_bellows_large.jpg

Keith
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: melodeon on December 03, 2010, 01:55:17 AM
I have considered and messed with a pop riveted aluminum chassis

Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Keithypete. on December 05, 2010, 02:08:13 PM
A melodeon doesn't need bellows at all. A telescopic metal ( or plastic)  tube arrangement with an O ring set  up would do the trick. It would take some getting used to and would be less than pleasing to the eye. The different rates of thermal expansivity could be problematical too.
   Remember the aborted attempts to develop an  aluminum cricket bat? :|glug
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Falseknight on December 05, 2010, 11:57:19 PM
You can machine and bond acrylic in the same way that you can machine wood.

Acrylic guitars and basses are great fun - and work much like wood.

Bellows are good - sliding seals would be a nightmare - they are only used in 'industry' if there is no alternative.
Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: dahlberg on December 29, 2010, 07:46:58 PM
Offcause it`s possible to build an accordion out of metal.
The now defunct swedish company SAM did cromatic accordions,both piano and buttton;of aluminium.
(http://www.beltrami.se/large-S6003152.jpg)
Never played one by myself but i heard they are very comfortable.


Title: Re: How feasible is an all metal box?
Post by: Theo on December 29, 2010, 11:00:19 PM
And the Hohner Atlantic series PAs are all metal.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal