Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: James Fitton on December 03, 2010, 08:20:14 AM
-
After a gig with our band tonight, some complicated logistics might mean leaving my boxes outside in a car overnight. Trouble is, it's forecast to fall to -15C or even lower tonight. Does this matter? How cold is too cold for a melodeon?
-
I once had a very nasty problem when all the reeds fell of my Castagnari Lilly turning it into a v expensive Italian shaky egg after the same scenario. Box left in car all day at work in cold, but no where near as cold as you are talking about, then into pub where it warmed up, then outside to play for Morris, one big draw chord and instant shaky egg!
Don't do it, find a way around the problem of at least let the box thoroughly warm up before playing it.
-
Never leave an instrument in the car over night, not just because of the temperature! If you are insured, you probably won't be for leaving them in an unattended car. If you can get inside, so can your box!
-
Mine survived playing at Whittlesea Straw Bear last year at -6C, and I didn't hear of any casualties with other boxes, so "too cold" is colder than that, for what it's worth.
-
Many years ago I left a melodeon in a car in freezing temperatures for several hours then took it in to a hot steamy house where we had all been partying. As soon as I opened the case the highly humid air hit the freezing cold instrument (Corona III) and it was immediately running with water, like I had put it under a tap! Stupidly, I still played it after several wiping downs, and it survived, but I remember when I got home after the party I pumped the bellows a good few times to try to get dry air in to the reeds (I should of course have unpinned the bellows and opened it up to dry, but we are talking about after a party).
No lasting damage apparently, but really not something to do to an instrument.
-
I recall a friend saying he once had a reed snap on his Hohner Atlantic accordion when his carol singing group were invited in to a warm house after having been playing/singing outside for some time. So if an instrument does get really cold take Lester's advice and make sure it is thoroughly warmed up before playing in a warm atmosphere.
But it would seem to be okay to play a cold instrument in a cold atmosphere, like lots of Morris people do over Christmas. But not a warm instrument in a cold atmosphere?
-
I recall a friend saying he once had a reed snap on his Hohner Atlantic accordion when his carol singing group were invited in to a warm house after having been playing/singing outside for some time.
I'm sure that was just an unfortunate coincidence.
If steel was as badly affected by that sort of temperature drop you would have to avoid all sorts of things made of steel in clod conditions.
-
Hmmm. Fears confirmed, I think. Trouble is, the car concerned may end up about 3/4 mile from the house concerned (as a result of a hill with too much snow), so I've the choice of lugging kit up and down said hill in the middle of the night, or just leaving it there until the morning. Sounds like I should at least prioritise the melodeon!
-
Wrap it in a duvet / sleeping bag?
-
I recall a friend saying he once had a reed snap on his Hohner Atlantic accordion when his carol singing group were invited in to a warm house after having been playing/singing outside for some time.
I'm sure that was just an unfortunate coincidence.
Err...d'oh! :D
-
Another thing you might think about it accumulated condensation on the reeds, over time, even when not faced with a cold weather disaster. Plenty of room inside most boxes to slap in a dehumidifier block. Every year or so replace or put in oven to redry.
-
Wrap it in a duvet / sleeping bag?
Insulation like this works for the human body by trapping air which insulates and retains the heat your body produces. As boxes don't produce heat there wont be much internal heat to trap in, but it might just keep off the worst of the temperature drop. Put a sledge in the car too and drag the boxes behind you?
-
Another thing you might think about it accumulated condensation on the reeds, over time, even when not faced with a cold weather disaster. Plenty of room inside most boxes to slap in a dehumidifier block. Every year or so replace or put in oven to redry.
[/quote
I'm not sure my Saltarelle will fit in the oven....... ;D]
-
Almost all materials become harder, more brittle (less ductile) as temperatures drop. Sudden changes in temperature exacerbate that, as do additional demands on the components. Significant changes in humidity will also affect certain materials.
As a general rule, squeezeboxes will survive low temperatures if they are in use (tends to put heat in through friction and vibration) or if they are allowed to cool down and warm back up very slowly, to minimise the potential for damage. The duvet idea is a good one to slow the chilling process, although after three/four hours the box will have reached thermal equilibrium with its surroundings. Letting it warm up very slowly would then be equally good - the duvet again, this time insulating the box from the heat - and don't take it into a warm house until it's approaching acceptable temperatures.
I don't know the specific thermal properties of the wax employed, but most adhesives retain minimal "stiction" even at such low temperatures that their adhesive properties have gone. For example, you can remove chewing gum from a surface by putting it in the freezer, but you have to knock the gum off the surface once frozen. As a result, keeping something still until it has warmed up and the adhesive's properties have been restored will generally avoid Lester's disaster scenario.
Hope that helps.
-
Wrap it in a duvet / sleeping bag?
That is exactly what we do with TSMB's hammer dulcimer with the hope that it remains in tune between nice centrally heated house and whatever venue we are playing at. Does seem to reduce he retune time :)
-
Forgive me for putting in my twopenneth as I am not an accordian player but the best advice I can give is seal the accordian in a plastic bag while it is in the cold ( the colder the air the drier it is) Move the accordian into a warm environment ( the sealed plastic bag should stop warm moist air from condensing on any cold parts, inside or outside the box.) When the box has reached ambient temperature it may be removed from the sealed bag and no condensation should form. I hope this is of help.
-
DANGER DANGER. :Ph
Did not mean to put the box in the oven, just the demhumidifier, until the the color changes back to blue.
(Not that some boxes might benefit from a little baking >:E
-
Wrap it in a duvet / sleeping bag?
Hmmm... I doubt that a duvet or sleeping bag would keep a poor little melodeon warm in a -15C environment !!!
I think the suggestion of the sealed bag to avoid condensation is the best so far.
-
My (limited) understanding is that, unless it is raining or you are underwater, you should never seal any instrument in plastic, you are just as likely to seal humidity in as well as out.
Not to say you shouldn't keep the instrument in a relatively tight fitting case. But the case lining usually helps control moisture, at least a little.
-
My (limited) understanding is that, unless it is raining or you are underwater, you should never seal any instrument in plastic, you are just as likely to seal humidity in as well as out.
If you read the original post it mentions "seal the accordian in a plastic bag while it is in the cold (the colder the air the drier it is)".
Of course, we are not talking of keeping it sealed for months, just a few hours until the ambient temperature rises again, to reduce the effects of condensation on reeds and other metal parts.
-
I'm not convinced that cold in itself (as opposed to hot sun) will damage reeds/wax etc - but the dynamics of ambient change certainly can. IME the enemy is condensation causing (I'm told) tiny rust spots in the steel killing them completely, or making them 'bark'.
I've had this trouble playing a cold box (ex car) inside and the sweatier the room the worse. But also simply playing outside at the time dew forms.
In the cold box instance I take the box inside and don't play while it feels cold. I exchange air into it for a few minutes using air valve only. Once it feels warm I'll play. Seems to work :|glug
-
After a gig with our band tonight, some complicated logistics might mean leaving my boxes outside in a car overnight. Trouble is, it's forecast to fall to -15C or even lower tonight. Does this matter? How cold is too cold for a melodeon?
wrap them in a duvet/s, sleeping bag and put a hot water bottle/2ltr drinks bottle with hot water in it on top. That may stop any damp inside the boxes freezing. If you also park up against wall (even better near a central heating outlet) that will reduce impact of frost - our last strawberries of the year and 'spring' onions have been outside in the frost covered with plastic bag and next to cheating outlet.............
-
Interesting discussion, about how to warm them up when they're too cold. The Germans had to build fires under their tanks on the Eastern Front just to turn over the engines! But after reading though the thread, it seems that the general wisdom for accordions in cold/hot weather is consistent across most types of musical instruments -
1. If you are uncomfortable because of the weather, the accordion is probably uncomfortable, too
2. Do not let the accordion become too hot or allow it to sit in direct sunlight for prolonged periods
3. Do not let the accordion become too cold and scold the postman when he leaves it outside your door in a snowstorm
4. If you take the accordion from one temperature extreme to another, allow it to acclimate before playing it
5. Do not expect the accordion in freezing or sweltering weather to perform as it does at room temperature
6. Do not allow the accordion to become wet and if it becomes wet, dry it thoroughly as soon as possible
7. If you spill a beer on the accordion, kindly apologize and offer to buy its next round
Most of it seems like common sense which is, of course, the first thing you forget when you're having a good time. (:)
-
cheating outlet.............
I'm looking for one of those - the last one got married! ;D
Anonymous.
-
cheating outlet.............
I'm looking for one of those - the last one got married! ;D
Anonymous.
;D ;D
-
I recall a friend saying he once had a reed snap on his Hohner Atlantic accordion when his carol singing group were invited in to a warm house after having been playing/singing outside for some time.
I'm sure that was just an unfortunate coincidence.
If steel was as badly affected by that sort of temperature drop you would have to avoid all sorts of things made of steel in clod conditions.
Hi Theo,
It might not be merely coincidence. When reed tongues get caught in the slot in the reedplate, attempts to sound them can cause breakage.
I have a feeling that (some alloys of) aluminum may shrink more in cold temperatures than does spring steel. I know that when I used to have a gig playing carols outdoors for hours on the concertina, cold temperatures could sometimes cause the brass frames of the concertina reeds to pinch the steel reed tongues. They would not sound until the instrument warmed up. I would have to switch from the Jeffries to a Lachenal where the reed clearances were more generous. If that differential is there between spring steel and reedplate aluminum also, then Sandy's anecdote could have had a similar cause.
PG
-
Hi Paul
I agree that differential contraction of brass or Al reedplates can result in a temporary pinching of a steel reed tongue. I've seen this once on a Wheatstone concertina where some notes would sound metallic when played at low temperature, but I still find it hard to believe that such an obstruction could cause an otherwise healthy reed to break. I can well believe that it could be the final insult to cause the failure of a reed that was already cracked.
-
Paul, I've noticed this differential contraction thing too. Some reeds will hang up, some will sound with a metallic sound, and the whole thing will sound out of tune until it warms up. This is with TAM Binci's. I had a Hohner 114 that did not do this, I'm assuming because the reed/slot fit was not as precise. I had meant to start a thread on this very thing to see what other folks did about it. For mine it is around the freezing mark.
-
Hi Theo,
I am pretty sure I have seen reed tongues break from getting hung up in the slot. At least that's the cause I inferred more than once (from evidence such as seeing a reed tongue that is cracked, and still hung up in a slot that is corroded). Maybe it is the tug on the bellows to free the reed that does it... Or maybe I was wrong to make that inference. You could well be right!
bafleur,
I'm not sure you want to do anything about it except let it warm up without introducing new moist air.... As both you and I concluded, this behavior is likely a necessary evil of very well-fitted reeds.
I'm not convinced that cold in itself (as opposed to hot sun) will damage reeds/wax etc - but the dynamics of ambient change certainly can. IME the enemy is condensation causing (I'm told) tiny rust spots in the steel killing them completely, or making them 'bark'.
I've had this trouble playing a cold box (ex car) inside and the sweatier the room the worse. But also simply playing outside at the time dew forms.
In the cold box instance I take the box inside and don't play while it feels cold. I exchange air into it for a few minutes using air valve only. Once it feels warm I'll play. Seems to work :|glug
Chris Ryall,
Re: cold accordion into a warm room (with higher relative humidity). I think even if you use the air button to bring warm air into an accordion with very cold reeds, you will risk condensation on the press reeds that are exposed to the main interior air volume of the instrument. If the warm room air is dry enough that this isn't a problem, then it also would not have been a condensation risk just to play the thing in that room.
I do use the air button sometimes in a different scenario -- if the inside of the accordion is full of very moist air, from playing in very humid conditions, when I bring it in to *dryer* air indoors (lower RH), I pump air into the box repeatedly using the air button and expel air repeatedly while playing every button, melody and bass sides. I am hoping that this will pump out the reservoirs of humid air that might linger inside the individual chambers of the reedblocks. Maybe overkill!
PG
-
I am pretty sure I have seen reed tongues break from getting hung up in the slot. At least that's the cause I inferred more than once (from evidence such as seeing a reed tongue that is cracked, and still hung up in a slot that is corroded). Maybe it is the tug on the bellows to free the reed that does it... Or maybe I was wrong to make that inference. You could well be right!
There is another possibility in this situation which I think is more likely. I've seen reed tongues which are cracked, and the crack is causing the reed tongue to no longer move perfectly vertically through the slot in the plate. In the rest position the reed appears to be nicely centred, but played hard it hits the plate and sounds bad. Eventually of course it breaks, but I'm convinced that it is the crack that has caused the reed to move slightly out of line. Reeds without cracks are pretty tough things, almost impossible to deliberately snap off. I've tried, they always take a permanent bend well before they break!
-
Hi Theo,
Good point!
PG
-
I've been playing my Luukinen box with binci reeds in around -10 C a couple of times, and usually put the melodeon back in the accordion box, (and some time the entire accordion box swept in blankets and plastic bags), before taking the box inside again.
I don't like doing this to the box, but the could dry air doesn't seem to have affected the reeds or box. But careful with the climate variations when you transport the box - especially cold to warm.